7 ms·
Rapere Intercept Drone
- pronoiac 12y agoWhoa, that's an unfortunate name.
- dcre 12y agoI can't think of many that would be worse.
- KaiserPro 12y agoI assume its named after the sword
- oldmanjay 12y agoThat's the same strange attitude that got a man fired from DC gov't for using the word "niggardly." If your sensitivity is such that you can't handle similarities in word sounds I recommend you lock yourself indoors cause it's a tough world out there.
- comex 12y agoI don't know where this name came from, but it made me think of Latin rapere, "to snatch/grab/carry off", which is the etymological source of "rape" and, while a common word, was also used for somewhat related purposes in Roman times (namely, kidnapping women). This is unlike niggardly, which is etymologically unrelated to nigger. However, rapere is also the source for innocuous English terms like rapt and rapture.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoThe word "rape" didn't even remotely cross my mind until you mentioned it here. The name actually reminded me of a rapier, a kind of weapon.
- cheald 12y ago"rapier" is what I thought, as well; the rapier is a light thrusting sword, which is intended to deliver a quick wounding strike to the target. Seemed perfectly on-point for this drone.
- pronoiac 12y agoTo be perfectly clear, I did a double-take because I mis-read it the first time, I'm probably not alone on this, and I'd consider it an ill-advised name. You could consider me oversensitive, but would you choose Niggardly for a brand name?
- classicsnoot 12y agoNiggard Systems: a company devoted to conserving capital resources through a proactive approach towards analytics and trends in money markets.
- USAnum1 12y agoI understand you may disagree with them, but there's no need for an ad-hominem attack. I like to believe our community is above that, even as a lurker. Instead, why do you disagree with the assertion that its an unfortunate name? (It appears @comex gave a pretty convincing argument for why it is at this level in the thread, and I know I read the name wrong at first!) quick edit: http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/rapere http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/rapere isn't looking too good, either.
- classicsnoot 12y agoThat was actually what the F22 was going to be named.
- bdg 12y agoIt's "Rap er uh", not "rape er e".
- DanAndersen 12y agoI wonder if projects like this will trigger the development of drone countermeasures, leading to an interesting arms race and regular battles in the skies above us.
- KaiserPro 12y agowe are here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_in_World_War_I#The_dawn_of_air_combat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aviation_in_World_War_I#The_daw...
- Morphling 12y agoI wonder if you could just create some kind of roof over the rotors, thus negating the "attack".
- superuser2 12y agoWhat exactly do you think is the point of helicopter rotors?
- ceejayoz 12y agoTo generate lift. It's most certainly not to shield the helicopter from attacks from above.
- superuser2 12y agoExactly. How do you imagine rotors generating lift when enclosed by a roof?
- sandworm 12y agoIs this a joke? There have to easier ways than physically dropping a string into a rotor. They are radio controlled. A handful of parts from radioshack, or even just an injection-capable wifi dongle, and they will drop from the sky without you leaving the ground.
- pervycreeper 12y agoThat strategy almost certainly has a vastly different legal status compared to the original article's.
- dexen 12y ago> A handful of parts from radioshack, or even just an injection-capable wifi dongle, and they will drop from the sky without you leaving the ground. Jamming RC control is not that straightforward, and for good reasons: it's common for several pilots to operate RC-controlled vehicles from single airfield simultaneously, thus RC radios evolved to avoid interference with one another. While modern RC radios indeed usually operate on 2.4GHz band common with WiFi, they typically employ frequency-hopping spread-spectrum communications[1] that has nothing to do with WiFi and is designed with degree of robustness against interference. Secondly, many `drones' (in this context, quad-rotors and multi-rotors) are catable of semi-autonomous operations, such as position holding, following a pre-planned flight path, and automatic return-to-base, as both aide to pilot and a natural protection against losing radio contact with the remote control. To combat those capabilities you would have to jam GPS signal too, and most probably the end result would be drone simply drifting with wind and slowly changing altitude, instead of dropping out of the sky right away. Not to mention jamming nearby neighbours and motorists, and illegality of such jamming [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio-controlled_aircraft#Frequencies_and_sub-channels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radio-controlled_aircraft#Freq... [2] http://www.gps.gov/spectrum/jamming/ http://www.gps.gov/spectrum/jamming/
- andygates 12y agoIndeed, my Parrot has a preprogrammed behaviour in case of loss of signal: cease lateral movement and descend to hover until signal is reacquired (or the battery runs low, in which case land). If it were flying waypoints, it'd ignore the jamming as it ignores signal loss - and part of the fun flying waypoints is sending Mr Crashy out of direct control for a short time. Jamming's a fantasy attack just like shotguns are.
- wavefunction 12y agoI thought about making an anti-drone drone that would basically fly in front of another drone and release a fine spray of some sort of air-hardening resin which should foul control surfaces and mechanical parts. Haven't done it yet.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- bdg 12y agoI'm curious if a microwave's magnetron strapped to the pursuit drone could act as a poor man's Active Denial System and fry the other drone.
- gvb 12y agoSerious practical problems: 1. Weight of the magetron, battery, and power supply to power the magnetron. 2. Shielding required on the aggressor drone to prevent it from frying itself.
- downandout 12y agoDestruction of property is destruction of property. The logic behind this seems to imply that you could legally take steps to crash a manned helicopter merely because it was flying over your property. That is almost certainly not the case. Another example: Some of the wealthiest people in California live on a street called La Jolla Farms Rd. (supermarket magnate Ron Burkle owns a 58,000 sq ft home there). One of the hallmarks of living on this street is that hang and paragliders taking off from the La Jolla Gliderport fly over these homes constantly during the day - many with cameras. Would it be legal to take any of them down? My guess is you would be charged with attempted murder.
- cge 12y agoHot air balloons frequently fly over Rancho Santa Fe nearby, as well. Local ordinances are such that most if not all of them are doing so illegally, if I recall correctly, but that still doesn't mean shooting them down would be legal.
- niels_olson 12y agoPrivate property owners generally only have airspace rights in so far as "enjoyment". That, is they can shoot fireworks, have balloons, loft their own drones, etc. Unless a pilot of an aircaft (including balloons, etc) is somehow being intentionally disruptive (e.g., hovering their helicopter over an ex-girlfriend's birthday party), they have a higher obligation to safe flight. And if that means overflying Coral Reef Ranch, Gwendolyn Sontheim Meyer's show ponies are just going to have to deal with it.
- girvo 12y agoI feel there is a large difference between disabling a drone, and killing a human being. That's a bit of a disingenuous argument in my opinion.
- downandout 12y agoMy point was that I can guarantee that the law doesn't make that distinction - maybe it will in the future, but not today. Taking out flying objects is illegal.