6 ms·
Is the World Making You Sick?
- Kenji 12y agoWhat makes me sick is this fear-mongering. Go back to the industrialization in England if you want to see real pollution. We have made astonishing advances when it comes to increasing air quality. Catalysts in cars, all kinds of regulations about emissions. We are constantly trying to remove harmful substances from our lives - but that requires evidence, we can't just randomly blame 'chemicals'. It's far from perfect, I know that. But the average lifespan of humans has steadily gone up.
- vixen99 12y agoDreadful fear-mongering? Plenty to monger! Good gracious -we are even told to watch and limit the amount of fish we eat thanks to its mercury content. And mercury (horribly toxic) is only one of many substances that we should get concerned about. "The researchers, led by scientists from Harvard University and the U.S. Geological Survey, found that the ocean’s mercury levels have already risen about 30% over the last 20 years. Combined, the findings mean the Pacific Ocean will be twice as contaminated with mercury in 2050 as it was in 1995 if the emission rates continue."
- awinder 12y agoThe author isn't really arguing for widespread policy changes, that would be for society to decide and like you said, in total maybe the chemical exposure has a net benefit in avg lifespan anyways. But there is a classification of health issues that is not explained by traditional medical views, other than to say that it's a neurological issue. If there is a physiological component at play, research in that area could really help treat suffering patients, or provide opportunities for them to manage their illness. I don't know whats considered fear mongering about that.
- noonespecial 12y agoThere is room for improvement in the modern world. But you know what could be making us sick in our everyday lives? Cholera. Makes bpa a little less scary after all.
- nitrogen 12y agoLet's not resort to the appeal to worse problems as a reason to give up on solving problems closer to home.
- wdewind 12y ago> There are several types of proof. Nick Ashford and I observed the same patterns of inexplicable new-onset intolerances across very different toxic exposures in over a dozen countries. Sheep dippers using organophosphate pesticides in rural areas of Europe, radiology workers inhaling chemicals while developing films in New Zealand, Gulf War veterans, EPA workers in a remodeled and poorly ventilated office building in 1987, cleanup crews breathing fumes after oil spills. Many would get ill, and a small percentage never recovered. They became exquisitely sensitized, as well as disabled. This doesn't really sound that crazy to me. People working with industrial chemicals need protection. This is a widely known and accepted fact. It doesn't point to the entire population getting sick from small doses of chemicals in their day to day lives, like the flame-retardants in their mattresses, as the article opens up claiming.
- Scoundreller 12y agoI see similar complaints about risk to health and personal safety from emergency services personnel, but their life expectancies suggest otherwise. What I would really like to see is an estimation of the life-expectancy of the workers in these industries. Is it actually lower than average, or does it appear that the exposure has a minimal effect on health? Do the benefits of working in the industry out-weigh the risks (e.g. good health insurance benefits for treating other diseases out-weigh harms from exposure)? Are life insurance companies requiring higher premiums?
- DanBC 12y agoFarmers dipping sheep in organophosphates may have many years of reduced quality life before dying at about the same age as other people. Farm workers are traditionally poor so that might be a confounding factor.
- mod 12y agoI worked in lawn/pest control and my boss said that after a time, some guys take a hit from the chemicals, and become 'exquisitely sensitized' as is referenced here. Chemicals that had no noticeable effect previously, suddenly have immediate consequences, like rashes or illness.
- michaelochurch 12y agoThe reflexive lay dislike for "chemicals" is a bit weird to me, because everything in this world is made up of chemicals. If anything, the ostensibly healthy foods like fruits and vegetables probably have more chemical complexity and heterogeneity than processed foods. In terms of pollution and the presence of bad chemicals, it's nothing new. Burning any organic matter releases thousands of chemicals, and for all the romance around wood fires and stoves, those are much more polluting than most industrial processes today. This isn't to invalidate the core concept of the article, which I can't really evaluate. It seems likely that some of the irritating illnesses people get are due to hypersensitivity to certain chemical agents that, in low doses, most people can tolerate. I just doubt that this is a new problem, given that we've always lived in somewhat of a chemical stew and our air and water have always harbored things that can kill us.
- lukifer 12y agoHonest question: given the incredible variety of chemical compounds in nature, if one wants to describe specifically those that are directly harmful to health, or that trigger an immune response in some persons, what is the optimal umbrella term? ("Toxin" is every bit as overloaded and fuzzy as "chemical" in common parlance.)
- o_____________o 12y agoThat's the problem, isn't it? What is directly harmful to health? Beyond those agents we've universally codified as people poison, "harmful" is a constantly shifting designation that will always be misappropriated by those with a cross to bear over their pet subject. Health is such a complex, nuanced subject that its hard to imagine anything different than the messy passions we're describing.
- lukifer 12y agoThat doesn't address the question. To most people, peanuts aren't harmful, but a small number of people can die due to exposure. A laundry detergent with no effect on most people may cause some to break out in hives. What do you call these substances, whether natural or man-made?
- monochr 12y agoI have a new law based on Betteridge's law of headlines: Any scientist who claims to have produced a paradigm shift hasn't. You're welcome to call it Monochr Law of Paradigms.
- mcmancini 12y agoMancini's corollary: the robustness of the scientific foundation of an article is inversely proportional to the frequency of the word "chemicals" in the article
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 12y agoThis is why I do not shed any tears for the decline of most newspapers and TV news. Even the "good" ones tend to be hit or miss, or not call out BS when it is so obvious. The Economist seems to be one of few publications that I can consistently read without getting frustrated by emotional journalism or poor logic.
- abandonliberty 12y agoIt doesn't matter, new media is just as bad. Similar pressures exist, so we get similar results.
- stolio 12y ago> In 1962, physicist and historian Thomas Kuhn proposed that science makes progress not just through the gradual accumulation and analysis of knowledge, but also through periodic revolutions in perspective. Kuhn is almost always referred to as a philosopher because he left physics to be a "philosopher of science". In a nutshell I see an article about a scientist who worships a philosopher, believes she's the leader of the third major revolution in understanding human illness, and has a theory that's plausible yet difficult to test. Doesn't make the idea wrong, but these are not good signs. In her defense she's published a few times on the subject* still something about the article's rubbing me the wrong way. * - http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=claudia+miller http://scholar.google.com/scholar?hl=en&q=claudia+miller
- enziobodoni 12y agoI run a hospital lab, and I see requests for testing for all sorts of bizarre things, largely by naturopaths, deriving from the "philosophy" expressed here. We refer to people who believe this stuff as being on the "Quest for Purity", a quixotic drive to remove all "toxins" from their bodies. Regardless of whether or not there are substantiated examples of low doses of chemicals causing effects, the worry about this problem being widespread is a very common delusion that consumes an enormous amount of attention and money, is preyed upon by charlatan doctors (or naturopaths, who call themselves doctors), and is incredibly confounding. The rub in these potential illnesses is that you can never actually remove any of these exposures completely, and thus you are required to continue to purchase diagnostics, cures, and consultations forever. If there is a true toxicobiologic effect in here, it will be essentially impossible to discern from the obvious and overriding psychiatric issues and financial conflicts at play.
- jpmattia 12y ago> and I see requests for testing for all sorts of bizarre things It would be interesting: Can you list a bunch?
- enziobodoni 12y agoMicronutrients, even in hair. Trace metals, especially after chelation therapy, when the results are definitely misleading. Labs that associate Candida with everything. "Stealth" virus testing. Quack Lyme disease serology labs that always give positive results. Anti-malignin antibodies. Multi variate index assays predicting irritable bowel disease. IgG food allergies. Outrageously large (>50-100 component) IgE allergy tests.
- jpmattia 12y agoA bit of a wild guess, but many of those look like self-diagnosing or "fringe" from folks dealing with autoimmunity issues. Is that right?
- 12y ago
- claar 12y agoI predict many of the additives in our food and other products will be dimly viewed in retrospective, similar to how we view asbestos & lead paint today. The preservatives, anti-caking agents, food colorings and other profit-enhancing additives are basically used with an "innocent until proven guilty" mindset. As usual, you need only follow the money; who profits from adding these things to our food? Pretty much everyone. There's much less profit motivation for pure food, so it simply won't happen until there's conclusive proof that the additives are bad. And who's going to pay for that proof -- enough that those profiting from them can't squash it?
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoBecause of market forces and some of the documentation regimes, the end cost to the consumer is higher without these things. One might think it's because the-products-without are less mainstream and less subject to economy of scale, or just because shopping at Whole Foods signals caring. That does not make Whole Foods a scam; it's complicated. Not picking on Whole Foods ( I've never even been there ) - they're just a visible metaphor for this phenomenon. There's something in our Values Map that seems to put profit at cross purposes to "human values" or "caring". It may also be that food "made by hand" is actually of higher quality since the producers have more control and are interested in it more as an... art statement(?). Maybe it is profit; maybe it ain't.
- intopieces 12y agoIf this topic interests you, you might enjoy the Todd Haynes movie [SAFE] (1995).
- claar 12y agoAlso related is Katie Couric's Fed Up (2014).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]