4 ms·
What exactly are the accomplishments of philosophy, aside from logic which is better studied by mathematicians and computer scientists?
by amichail 17y ago
What exactly are the accomplishments of philosophy, aside from logic which is better studied by mathematicians and computer scientists?
- khafra 17y agoPhilosophy is sometimes considered the parent of the sciences--just about every pursuit of knowledge used to be philosophy. Once they were systematized, testable, and useful enough to stand on their own, they became sciences.
- amichail 17y agoThat's like saying that the major accomplishment of religion is that it led to science.
- khafra 17y agoI don't disagree with that by much. Religious institutions in the past have preserved or advanced scientific discovery at times. The difference is that Philosophy consists of seeking the truth, institutionalized religion usually consists of defending the truth. Religions may spawn some scientific inquiry, but they have a lot of trouble letting their children go off and live their own lives, so to speak.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoSuppose you discover that you can get nasty illnesses from being exposed to other peoples germs which are spread in their bodily emissions, indeed some of those illnesses can kill. You then have kids. Do you defend that truth by instructing them to wash their hands, cover their mouths when they cough, avoid contact with faeces, etc., to stop germs spreading? Or, do you have to wait until that child is old enough to discover germs for themselves? The Church has always sponsored scientific enquiry as Christians believe that knowing more about the created enables us to know more about the creator.
- khafra 17y agoE pur si muove.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoGalileo was educated in part in a monastery and at the Uni of Pisa (founded by a pope). He was sponsored by the Church to do his studies; when he wished to publish his pamphlet the authorities urged caution and refused to state outright that heliocentrism were true wishing instead to gather more evidence. Galileo went ahead pissed off the papacy and was censured. Indeed if we consider Einsteins relativity then we might argue that the anti's were right to hold reservations as without an ether it is no more correct to say that the Earth revolves around the Sun than it is to say the Earth is static. I doubt they had this in mind though.
- danek 17y ago>> The Church has always sponsored scientific enquiry lol
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoMany universities (in Europe) grew out of monastic study and mediaeval universities were founded both by the wealth of princes and by papal bull. Individual scientists, Roger Bacon say, were provided a living by the church others, Copernicus springs to mind, were sponsored in their studies by particular bishops or similar Church luminaries. The Catholic Church still operates at least one observatory which has been going since the 16 Century. As highlighted in the Merton-Weber thesis scientific enquiry in the 17, 18 Century appears to have been pushed on by Protestant philosophy.
- dantheman 17y agoPhilosophy has had many accomplishments, it's where the questions first get asked. In general it's where ideas get refined and understood enough to go out and be acted upon -- before it can be science it needs to through it's philosophical stages. Heidegger, an amazing existentialist, laid out a lot of problems that AI was going to have in the 50s. http://www.amazon.com/What-Computers-Still-Cant-Artificial/dp/0262540673/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1200063500&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/What-Computers-Still-Cant-Artificial/d... The study of philosophy for most undergraduates taking a few classes can be thought of as the history of human thought.
- amichail 17y agoThe assumption here is that asking questions divorced from scientific training is a reasonable thing to do. What makes you think that philosophers are any better at asking questions than scientists?
- foldr 17y ago>The assumption here is that asking questions divorced from scientific training is a reasonable thing to do. Of course it is a reasonable thing to do, e.g. "Is there any milk left in the fridge?" I suppose you're asking whether it's reasonable to ask "deep" questions without scientific training. I think that it is -- moral questions are an obvious example -- but in any case, bear in mind that most philosophers whose work touches on scientific issues _do_ have some scientific training. It's really not possible to consider all this at such an abstract level. If you have something against philosophy or philosophers, you'd do well to point out some concrete examples of what you're talking about, instead of engaging in this sort of generic scientistic whining. The biggest irony here is that your views are taken almost verbatim from a philosophical movement of the early 20th century (logical positivism). One benefit of reading some philosophy is coming to a realization of how unoriginal virtually all of your ideas are, and how much they owe to the intellectual culture you were brought up in.
- dantheman 17y agoWhat is scientific training? Logic & Mathematics? I was having a discussion in another thread about the demarcation of science and pseudoscience, and despite decades of trying the only definition is that works is consensus of other scientists. Most scientists believe physics is science while astrology is not. I'd say that I don't hold philosophers or scientists or mathematicians as the ultimate questioner. I believe that they are each skilled in different areas, and are probably best at asking questions in those areas.
- fnid 17y agoI would say Questions are the greatest accomplishments of philosophy. There are many questions out there, the meaning of life, where we came from, what happens when we die. These are philosophical questions in origin. Philosophy is the birth of inquiry. Science is the attempt to find the rational answer.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoAnd when we show there is no rational answer that is discoverable ...
- foldr 17y agoTo which questions?
- unalone 17y agoI know, right? Like when we know there was no rational answer for the weather so we said gods did it. Silly scientists not realizing we haven't learned anything in the last five thousand years. They refuse to admit that it's impossible to find new answers to questions.
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoI was thinking more about application of Godels Incompleteness Theorem or the Church-Turing Hypothesis or even to take a more basic consideration Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle. Based on the standard scientific and logical axioms the cause of the progression of weather is quite discoverable except that the chaotic nature makes it practically (at present at least) unpredictable. Perhaps you believe the world is entirely Newtonian?? I await your answer with baited breath.
- foldr 17y ago>Philosophy is the birth of inquiry. Science is the attempt to find the rational answer. I think that's a little harsh on philosophy. Scientists don't have a monopoly on rationality. There are many areas of philosophy (e.g. moral philosophy) where scientific methods are far from sufficient (though useful), but where we still benefit from clear and rational thinking.
- foldr 17y agoOk, before answering that question, I'd like to ask you the following question: How much philosophy have you read? If the answer is "none" or "very little", don't ask people here what the accomplishments of philosophy are, but go and actually _read some_ and find out for yourself.
- unalone 17y agoLogic came originally from philosophy. Your question's like asking why we ever bothered with the Model T when Porsche is such a better vehicle. Modern philosophy is important because it targets common assumptions and attempts to debate and verify them. The whole point of common assumption is that if you believe something that's wrong, you don't necessarily realize it without a lot of work. Philosophy attempts to shine light in those unknown recesses. But "accomplishments"? I'd say the biggest casual accomplishment is that it serves as a great topic of discussion for people, gets people thinking together, and as a result brings them closer together. Might as well ask what accomplishments Shakespeare gave us, or Hitchcock. Not everything can be verified with an award and a metric.