6 ms·
Bitcoin revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth
- jrochkind1 12y agoThis is a much better article than you'd expect from the clickbaity title, seriously, take a look.
- ingler 12y agoIt's a crap article. I'm an early adopter and I've never bought drugs with btc, contrary to the article's unfounded claims. Whoever created Bitcoin solved a problem: how is something of value sent from person A to person B across the internet. It might not be an elegant solution or a readily apparent one to the less tech savvy, but it's a solution that's been proven to work. The price is immaterial. What matters is the blockchain technology and its underlying ramifications.
- minimaxir 12y agoThe Washington Post has posted articles with even more clickbaity titles very recently. http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/01/13/is-this-the-single-most-important-trick-to-going-viral/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-intersect/wp/2015/01/... :P
- chkuendig 12y agoto be fair. that's actually an article about linkbait :P
- juliangoldsmith 12y agoHow many deaths of Bitcoin are we on now? I can remember 3, at least, the first of which was when it came down from its peak of $30/btc. Personally, I hope this drives out most of the speculators. They have, in my opinion, done little for Bitcoin except make it difficult to use as an actual currency.
- haakon 12y agoBitcoin has died 33 deaths so far. Source: http://bitcoinobituaries.com/ http://bitcoinobituaries.com/
- sosborn 12y agoIs this the new Apple Death Knell? http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/death_knell http://www.macobserver.com/tmo/death_knell
- Dylan16807 12y ago"Is doomed" is not a supposed death. Four articles on the same day claiming death do not constitute four supposed deaths.
- jrochkind1 12y agoThe speculation has created a LOT more attention from bitcoin; it's possible speculation is the majority of bitcoin use, in which case hardly anyone would be paying attention to bitcoin without it. Which might be just fine, of course, it's just another thing the speculation has done for bitcoin. I think the interesting thing the article points out is that bitcoin mining itself is inherently a form of speculation though -- you are counting on the value of the bitcoins you mine being at least as high as the money you had to expend to mine the bitcoins (hardwar, power, network access), or mining is a losing proposition.
- juliangoldsmith 12y agoThe problem is that speculation created a lot of attention for Bitcoin as a get-rich-quick scheme, not as an actual utility. And that's not necessarily true. It assumes that everyone mines bitcoin for the purpose of obtaining bitcoin, not to support the network.
- jrochkind1 12y ago> And that's not necessarily true. It assumes that everyone mines bitcoin for the purpose of obtaining bitcoin, not to support the network. Like someone is intentionally donating money in hardware and electricity in order to support the project? How many dollars a month would you personally spend to do this? Maybe there's some rich people involved who have the money to spare? At the current cost of mining, how many dollars a month are are required to keep the economy going (I have no idea), and would it be possible to get that much as "charity" donations to support the bitcoin project (I have no idea either)?
- bramgg 12y agoThe current price of Bitcoin is irrelevant to its long term success.
- jacquesm 12y agoAnd is still extremely high compared to where it was not all that long ago. If bitcoin would have gone on a monotonic increase from < $1 to where it is today everybody would be speaking about a miracle. We'll see where it goes in the long run, so far if anything bitcoin has been one of the most interesting things happening in this new millenium and I'm very curious where it is headed in the longer term, but I won't make bets either way.
- ssharp 12y agoI also find BitCoin to be interesting but I'm not sure if that interest has really spread that far from tech-oriented audiences. The people who really support BitCoin can be rather fanatical in their expectations of what BitCoin will become and I don't see its current growth coinciding with those expectations. It would be interesting to see how many people are using BitCoin as a daily currency, and what the changes to that number have been over time. We see lots of places accepting BitCoin (and using services that instantly convert that to USD so they don't actually hold the BTC) but is there the similar growth on the buying side? Who's buying BitCoin and why? If BitCoins growth has largely come from people who are speculating / investing, or are doing illegal things with it, then growth rates aren't sustainable and these crashes become more and more likely. As for the miracle, I don't think it's that out of the ordinary. Apple went from being worth $0 dollars to being worth over $600 billion. Being on the ground floor of either would have been nice, but when BitCoins were < $1, they were still more likely to be worth < $1 today than being worth $200. I can say one thing for certain: BitCoin's price chart since it's high over a year ago does not give me any confidence it in. I have no desire to hold onto something like that in the hopes that it becomes worth more. It just seems like a ridiculous thing to do. I see no value in using it transactionally and negative value in holding it and I don't really see either changing. I don't wish BitCoin to be a failure, I just don't see it being the kind of success that so many people have bet on it being.
- patrickgokey 12y ago"...despite companies trying to get free PR by saying they'll accept it, almost nobody uses it to buy anything other than drugs." I stopped reading right there.
- ssharp 12y agoI don't really want this type of drive-by snark from a newspaper, but I think there is some truth to what was written. It's seems like any time a merchant announces they'll accept BitCoins, it will get pushed to the front page of /r/bitcoin and probably drum up some business because of it. I know of some local businesses who got online and print coverage for announcing that they're accepting BitCoin have hardly had any actual BitCoin activity. I'd be interested to see if any of the big companies, e.g. NewEgg, Overstock, etc., have seen sustained business increases from accepting BitCoins.
- jkyle 12y agoThe overwhelming majority of those companies also don't actually accept bitcoin. They've brokered a deal with an exchange. Bitcoin payments are made to the exchange and the exchange pays the vendor in U.S. currency. So, the company isn't actually transacting in bitcoins.
- drinkzima 12y agoBy that token most companies do not take anything but their own currency. Currency hedging is something corporations do to align costs and revenues - companies generally are not trying to make money wagering on currency positions.
- ssharp 12y agoAbsolutely. They are accepting BitCoin for the convenience of customers, not because they hold a positive opinion of it.
- Igglyboo 12y agoIt's hyperbole but it has some truth to it. Why would you go through the hassle and possibly loss of money to convert fiat to bitcoins then purchase things with bitcoins instead of just buying with fiat? You wouldn't, except that bitcoin is anonymous so you can use it to buy things privately. Most people really don't care enough about the privacy of an average amazon purchase to go through all this hassle. When you're buying illegal goods, however, privacy is #1. And what is the most popular item on the most popular illegal goods marketplaces? Drugs. Almost everyone I know that uses bitcoin is either speculating to make a quick buck, or using it to buy something on a darknet market. I'm sure there are people using it for everyday goods but it really doesn't make much sense to do that now unless you value your privacy very highly.
- jacquesm 12y agoDoes the bitcoin protocol foresee in a situation where the hashing capacity is drastically reduced? (It has admirably adjusted to the increase in hashing power but it is not unthinkable that a few very large miner farms going out of business would actually reduce the hashrate of the network to the point where the transaction speed would slow down so much that the whole institution becomes un-usable.)
- juliangoldsmith 12y agoThe difficulty will be adjusted. I doubt any single large mining farm going out of business will be enough to have much of an effect on transaction speed, and it's unlikely that enough mining farms will go out of business within two weeks[0] to cause problems with the network. [0] Two weeks is about the time for difficulty to be adjusted.
- deeviant 12y agoYes, part of the plan is for miners to transition from mining-based activity to focusing on transaction fees. This would probably mean transaction fees will trend upward. I think it remains to be seen if this will be a profitable enterprise. Certainly, bitcoin trade volume will be a very important part of this equation, if it does not really take off as an actual currency, but remain as instrument to store wealth, that could spell disaster for bit coin. If miners do turn away from bitcoin, the capacity will be drastically reduce which makes a 51% attack much more feasible, threatening bitcoin's existence. This is much more worrisome than transaction speed slow-down and in fact, as long as there is heavy volume, miners could make money off transaction fees so they are almost mutually exclusive events. Despite all this, I think bitcoin is pioneering the field, and regardless of it lives or dies, it will have impacts in various facets of the future.
- jacquesm 12y agoI think you mis-understood the question.
- wmf 12y agoIn some cases, a dramatic drop in hashing can cause "programmed self-destruction". http://arxiv.org/abs/1405.0534 http://arxiv.org/abs/1405.0534
- tlrobinson 12y ago"Bitcoin prices are so low, you see, that miners are spending more money running their supercomputers than they're making from new coins. So why are they still going? Well, they have dollar debts that they need to pay back, and where else are they going to get the money? They're stuck, in other words, in a catch-22: they can't afford to keep mining, but they can't afford to stop mining, either." Huh? If miners are spending more on electricity than the Bitcoins they mine are worth then they should immediately stop mining (unless they are engaging in speculation)
- Dylan16807 12y agoIf they weren't engaging in speculation they wouldn't have bought mining equipment in the first place.
- emmett 12y agoYou don't need to spend a bunch of capital on mining equipment to speculate. You can just buy Bitcoin. Usually you buy mining equipment because you think you can make BC cheaper than everyone else with operational efficiency.
- Dylan16807 12y agoIn practice I think mining equipment has rarely been able to pay for itself without speculation because of so much demand to be a miner.
- savanaly 12y agoHe's probably referring to the fact that marginal cost is still below marginal revenue, but long-run average cost is above marginal revenue. This situation is often covered in introductory microeconomics and the conclusion is that they will continue to operate in the short run but shut down in the long run.
- eof 12y agoEven if they are engaging in speculation, it would be more rational for them to quit mining and spend the money they would spend on electricity to buy bitcoin on the open market.
- rboling91 12y agoMiners don't necessarily need supercomputers to mine. Sure, perhaps miners who set up huge operations might be in trouble, but anyone with access to moderately strong computational power, including basic laptops or even cheap SoCs, can mine. It might be beneficial to have mining spread out among those running less powerful computers, assuming that the miners act independently, for then the risk of a single mining firm/group controlling a dangerously large percentage of computational power would decrease substantially. The author also doesn't mention tipping, which will eventually be the dominant source of mining fees. In a drastic case, Bitcoin users could provide tips substantially larger than the current reward for block discovery/vetting. Should this be the case, the system could be self-correcting, and if the Bitcoin network is too dependent on large miners, the tipping system could act as a "bail out" in the near-term.
- danbruc 12y agoMiners need expensive and energy hungry equipment because this is what protects the Bitcoin network.
- querulous 12y agoWhat tip volume and value do you envision that tipping fees will make up the main source of income for miners?
- rboling91 12y agoThe volume of tips would have to increase drastically. In any case, the volume would depend on the price. Slightly off point, it might not be completely unrealistic to imagine a world in which miners do not derive their main source of income from mining. Perhaps miners could running mining programs on SoCs during the day while the miners themselves work other/additional jobs. While the number of miners mining in this way would have to be very large in order for this configuration to be possible, should this be the case, miners wouldn't be nearly as financially dependent on mining, and they could be more immune to fluctuations in the price
- gus_massa 12y agoIf you have to pay for the electricity, it's only economical to mine (Bitcoins) with an ASIC. The CPU and GPU mining is now so slow that you will get very few Bitcoins in average, and the cost of the electricity to run it will be grater than the money you can get from the Bitcoins. (To get a smooth outcome you should probably mine in a pool, but this decrease the expected average result only little.)
- throw7 12y agoOil drilling revealed: a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth (washingtonpost.com)
- jrochkind1 12y agoI think there is actually some profound truth to your intended sarcastic comment, although you didn't intend it. There is an aspect of that in oil drilling. But the difference is that, in the end, there are consumers who want oil for doing something with it (generating electricity and other work; making plastic), not just for trading for other commodities. The only thing you want bitcoin for is trading for other currency or commodities, it has no use value in itself.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gesman 12y agoThat's an interesting perspective on why bitcoin price is falling, or rather why the fall is accelerated, but I don't see anything Ponzi about it. In fact it might be a good time to buy bitcoin.
- jfmercer 12y agoThe writer seems to have no understanding whatsoever of either Bitcoin or economics. Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme only in an imaginary world.
- TehCorwiz 12y agoFrom the article: "But in the long run, we're all dead, and Bitcoin might be too." Google "bitcoin is dead". Go on, I'll wait. Here I'll make it easy: http://lmgtfy.com/?q=bitcoin+is+dead http://lmgtfy.com/?q=bitcoin+is+dead They've been claiming that since at least 2011. The fact is that it isn't dead or dying. It's still 10x what is was worth in 2012. Currency markets move and when you have to trade one currency for another. We just saw the first real bitcoin xmas last month. With some big names accepting btc for the first time. Those vendors want their fiat and have to sell it on the market to cash out. That's one of many factors right now which includes government auctions of seized bitcoins. As adoption increases and more can be done within the bitcoin ecosystem it will stabilize.
- bdcravens 12y agoBitcoin itself isn't dead, but for some it is, if your play was to get wealthy off of it. For those who haven't been following it long, but who saw the rocket ship of 2013 and wanted a ride, it may be dead for them. I'm perfectly okay with that, as speculation usurped what it can really accomplish.
- abotsis 12y agoIt's an ok article, though technically inaccurate on a few fronts: The difficulty of mining is related to the number of coins mined (not the number of miners). The miners aren't the "central repo" of the ledger (it's distributed and anyone can download it). shrug
- kordless 12y agoThe claim that most people buy drugs with it is flat out WRONG.
- msie 12y ago"Ponzi scheme" and "redistributing wealth" in the same headline? Wow, that is a sure warning sign for the quality of the article.
- nether 12y agoA year ago people were saying it could go to $10,000/btc if it became widespread in China. Then China banned it.
- robsears 12y agoThat article was terribly written, and snarky lines about libertarians and "It's too bad Bitcoin doesn't have a central bank to help stabilize its value" don't add humor or insight. He brushed over the importance of the underlying technology so he could assault it for being a representative currency. I get the sense the author doesn't know any more about economics than he does about bitcoin. He basically just stated the differences between bitcoin and fiat currencies with a smug undertone of blind faith in Keynesianism, then concluded only a government is fit to regulate transactions between private parties.
- turnersd 12y agoThe content of this piece presents nothing new, and has absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with "Ponzi schemes" or "redistributing wealth."
- mrb 12y agoI was a co-founder of TAV (we built and sold 3 TH/s of ASIC miners in Sept 2013). This journalist, Matt O'Brien, clearly has done little research on Bitcoin and is not familiar with mining operations. His article contains lies, fallacies, and personal opinions that do not reflect reality. "What are [venture capitalists] supposed to say, though, when they've bet hundreds of millions of dollars on it?" Fallacy number one. If VCs were merely praising Bitcoin with no (or very few) investments, the journalist would say "well why don't they put their money where their mouths are?". Now they do put their money on it, but he says "well what else are they supposed to say?". "It's fallen 36 percent the past two days, as you can see below, with a 24 percent decline the past 24 hours." This is hardly newsworthy. What he seems to forget or point out is that Bitcoin is and has always been volatile --no one denies it. There has been dozens of instances where BTC lost (or gained) 20% or more in a span of 24 hours. Today's drop is no different than the other ones. "It's too bad Bitcoin doesn't have a central bank to help stabilize its value." This is very ironic to write 2 days after the Swiss central bank themselves caused an appreciation of the CHF of 30% in mere hours, hurting Swiss exports badly. "It has no inherent value" Another journalist who fails to realize no fiat currency has any inherent value either. Currencies (whether fiat or crypto) have value because people demand/accept them (whether it is the IRS asking to pay your taxes in dollars or Newegg accepting Bitcoin). This is it. Nothing gives them "inherent" value. "almost nobody uses it to buy anything other than drugs" Utterly false. The journalist has no data, no source, nothing to back up this claim. This claim used to be made 4 years ago when Bitcoin was barely starting to get in the public eye, when the top exchange (MtGox) barely had a few thousand users, when there was no payment processors to help businesses accept Bitcoin, etc. But the reality is that the Bitcoin economy has grown very quickly over the last 4 years: today 82,000 merchants accept Bitcoin [1], numerous processors exist (Bitpay, Coinbase, etc), merchants like Newegg and Gyft experienced their best Bitcoin Black Friday sales ever [2], etc. "Bitcoin prices are so low, you see, that miners are spending more money running their supercomputers than they're making from new coins." This is not true at all. There is zero reason for a miner to, say, spend $50,000 on electricity a month to mine X bitcoins when he could simply buy these bitcoins from the market for, say, $25,000. So if this was the case, it would make sense financially and logically for the miner to stop mining and buy the coins from the market. At the very least they would suspend mining activities. In fact this is precisely what happened to CEX.io [3] (they were likely inefficient and overspent in some areas, compared to other miners who continue operating because they are still profitable). Nowadays any large smart professional miner does not have high fixed recurring monthly costs like colocation in a data center (these are very cost-ineffective facilities to run mining operations). Instead they set up shop somewhere, eg. in a warehouse retrofitted for cooling and power, see [4]. This makes electricity their highest recurring cost, so they can in theory stop mining any time and it would significantly reduce their operating cost on the spot. [1] http://www.coindesk.com/state-bitcoin-2015-ecosystem-grows-despite-price-decline/ http://www.coindesk.com/state-bitcoin-2015-ecosystem-grows-d... [2] http://blog.bitpay.com/2014/12/09/bitcoin-black-friday-2014-recap.html http://blog.bitpay.com/2014/12/09/bitcoin-black-friday-2014-... [3] http://www.coindesk.com/cex-io-halts-cloud-mining-service-due-low-bitcoin-price/ http://www.coindesk.com/cex-io-halts-cloud-mining-service-du... [4] This is KncMiner's facility: http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/sites/default/files/KnCMiner-Boden.jpg http://www.datacenterdynamics.com/sites/default/files/KnCMin...
- SilasX 12y ago>If Bitcoin were a currency, it'd be the worst-performing one in the world, worse even than the Russian ruble. ... >But that's not much of a consolation to anyone who bought anywhere near Bitcoin's $1,100 top. Or near $1,000, or $900, or $800, or, well even yesterday's prices. Looks like the usual Bitcoin trilemma: - Price goes up? Everyone knows that appreciating currencies can't work. - Price goes down? Obviously it was a bubble all along and my criticisms are vindicated. - Price stays flat? Obviously its market cap is too low to support broader usage. Was this same author praising Bitcoin as the best performing currency of 2011, 2012, and 2013? [1] I don't want to sound like this all wine and roses; obviously, Bitcoin has its issues. I just hope that when the mob's "head is done spinning, its face is to the front". (Disclosure: I'm behind understandingbitcoin.us, which is supportive.) [1] Before anyone says it, I know: a good currency is one that's stable, and the author is criticizing the change in price, not the loss in value. Then why not criticize (or at least mention) the Swiss Franc's recent 30% appreciation?
- kordless 12y ago> almost nobody uses it to buy anything other than drugs This is a patently false statement. You can verify this yourself by looking at serveral Bitcoin survey results: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pz3BiQr8jEVM98PuZtSo7gOaLmEaAyIoOsU6EllGCKU/edit#gid=757082055 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1pz3BiQr8jEVM98PuZtSo... and https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Avvn4_NlztWedENNRkZ5SVhwSUJFamtxM0lJZzF3S0E#gid=6 https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/ccc?key=0Avvn4_NlztWedEN... I'll go ahead and use this fact as a good excuse to discredit Matt's entire shitty post.
- Dylan16807 12y agoAs long as you admit it's an excuse to ignore an entire post because you are going to counter one sentence with an anonymous survey. Unless that was the joke.
- kordless 12y agoGiven it was used by the author to ad hominem Bitcoin, yeah, it's a joke. Typed with tongue in cheek, of course.
- baddox 12y agoThis one's already in the running for the most hedged and meaningless article of the year. > If Bitcoin were a currency, it'd be the worst-performing one in the world, worse even than the Russian ruble. > But Bitcoin isn't a currency. Okay, it starts off with an admitted paradox of entailment. If 2 + 2 = 5, then Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth. And besides all that, there are plenty of time periods over which Bitcoin would be the best-performing currency in the world. > It's a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth from one libertarian to another. At least that's all it is right now. One day it could be more. Venture capitalists, for their part, are quick to point out that it's really a protocol, like the early internet, and its underlying technology could still be revolutionary. What are they supposed to say, though, when they've bet hundreds of millions of dollars on it? This is a hedge that reveals the inane clickbait nature of the headline. The author isn't talking about Bitcoin, but rather about some group of people and firms involved with Bitcoin is some way. We could say "economics is a Ponzi scheme for redistributing wealth," because lots of people have utilized economics to implement Ponzi schemes. > It has no inherent value, after all, because, despite companies trying to get free PR by saying they'll accept it, almost nobody uses it to buy anything other than drugs. To make the claim falsifiable, the author would need to define "almost nobody." To make the claim accurate, that definition would need to be preposterous. > Bitcoin miners, you see, borrowed money—and real money, as in dollars—that they could only pay back if Bitcoin prices kept rising, or at least didn't fall this much. Bitcoin is not the first currency or technology around which foolish investments have been made. > This means we don't need a bank to know that I've sent money to you and only you, but it comes at the cost of making it irreversible. The irreversibility is likely a cost to some and a benefit to others. Since no one that I'm aware of has been forced to use Bitcoin, I don't see this as a problem. If you consider the irreversibility of a bitcoin transaction to be a significant cost, then do not make the bitcoin transaction.
- dailen 12y agolol this article is HORRIBLE I like the part about it being irreversible...I recall a humorous back and forth between two politicians where one was arguing that we should outlaw all currencies that can't be logged or tracked and the other politician said "you mean like we do with cash? Oh well lets outlaw cash then!"
- benjaminjackman 12y agoI don't think that the strong majority of people that buy bitcoins have any idea of what they are actually doing or what the bitcoin protocol is. Under that assumption it would seem that the price of bitcoin is dominated by "the other people are doing it" school of trading. This is typical, most numbers in the financial space just go up and down because some people are willing to put more money in their belief than others. The author pulls bitcoin out by one dimension of its pros and cons and then says it does unfavorably in that dimension. It was not designed to be stable in that dimension (price relative to currencies), therefore it isn't stable in that dimension. It never will be, unless central banks start pegging their currency to Bitcoin, or start pegging Bitcoin to their currency (which they could do if they wanted). Who else has the interest or capability in printing / destroying large amounts of fiat currency or ramping up / down large amounts of mining horsepower to balance out the volatile speculative nature of bitcoin? So until some force acts to provide stability in that dimension, and that force likely only being a large central bank, there will be no stability, only the fluctuations of speculation. Ultimately the question bitcoin is posing isn't should I store my money in Rubles or Bitcoins or leave it in my bank account, or in S&P's or USG Treasuries or etc.. It's should I conduct an electronic transaction in Bitcoins or Rubles or Visa USDs or Paypal USDs etc?
- stevedekorte 12y agoDid it seem odd to anyone else that the author doesn't appear to understand the meaning of the word "deflation"?
- ewzimm 12y agoFocusing on such a small period of times makes for a deceptive chart. Everyone knows that it's been volatile for a while. That's not news. You really need to look at the value over a larger period of time. http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg1460ztgSzm1g10zm2g25zv http://bitcoincharts.com/charts/bitstampUSD#rg1460ztgSzm1g10...