10 ms·
A lucky little fish solves iron deficiency among women in Cambodia
- oopsiforgot 12y agoI got this for my wife for our 6th anniversary. Iron!
- hwgd 12y agointeresting. does cooking with cast iron also help increase iron levels? Or is the increase insignificant?
- sp332 12y agoYes, it can definitely help. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2621.2002.tb09582.x/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2621.2002....
- randlet 12y agoIt helps, but it mentions in the article that they didn't want to switch to cast iron cookware because they are heavy and expensive.
- pcrh 12y agoWhat do they use then?
- randlet 12y agoAluminum or steel I would imagine.
- raverbashing 12y agoYeah, but you don't need to switch, throw an iron nail on the pan and that's it.
- pzxc 12y agoI'm getting a 404 Not Found Here's the google cache version for anyone else: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:SfJuFHxKLswJ:www.thestar.com/news/gta/2011/11/12/canadians_lucky_iron_fish_saves_lives_in_cambodia.html+&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:SfJuFH...
- pcrh 12y agoWhat are the local cooking pots made of? Steel and cast iron would be the cheapest, and I assume leach iron into the food. I also imagine that the surface area of the pot is much larger than that of this "lucky fish". A quick search found this, which appears to be cast iron: http://www.pbase.com/bmcmorrow/image/28438185 http://www.pbase.com/bmcmorrow/image/28438185
- mattdotc 12y agoThe article answers your question. >the women won’t switch to iron cooking pots because they find them heavy and costly.
- wereHamster 12y agoPower to those who read the article: [...], and the women won’t switch to iron cooking pots because they find them heavy and costly.
- pcrh 12y agoOK, I searched a bit and found an article from 2011, which appears to be the original source (free access [1]). It appears that aluminum is the most common material from which local pots were made. [1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-3156.2011.02878.x/pdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-3156.2011....
- destructopuffin 12y agoYou can support the project at their website. http://www.luckyironfish.com/ http://www.luckyironfish.com/
- nickff 12y agoThanks for the link, I put in $45. Shipping the fish to supporters was a great idea, because we can show them to friends, and promote the project. This is the kind of project that I wish more researchers and activists would do, as it has the potential to improve the lives of a large number of individuals in a meaningful way, as well as giving other people who are far away the means to help.
- GotAnyMegadeth 12y agoDoesn't ship to the UK :-(
- ars 12y agoAnd now you know why so many people believe in luck or talismans. Next time you come across such things don't ridicule them, or the people that believe in them.
- Zikes 12y agoIt wasn't until it was spun as a lucky charm that they actually deigned to use it properly. The pre-existing superstition was only a delivery method for the solution, not a result of it.
- ars 12y agoOnly for the first year, after that cause and belief will be swapped, and people will believe the fish is lucky because of the iron fish. Give it a generation and people might not even remember that the living fish was ever considered lucky (or why).
- Zikes 12y agoIt's pretty incredible that so much effort was even necessary. The solution was there at the start - put a chunk of iron in the pot - but despite the known and obvious health benefits and miniscule amount of effort, the population simply rejected it.
- code_duck 12y agoI've spent a great deal of effort trying to convince people around me to do things that are clearly healthy in the short and long-term… Eat vegetables, drink enough water, avoid artificial colors, preservatives and sweeteners, exercise proper precautions in workshops. It's futile. I agree it's frustrating that people won't simply believe facts about how to fix their health problems when presented to them, and then are happy to embrace superstitious symbols instead of logic. But I'm not surprised, considering how many people I know who complain about the common symptoms of dehydration daily but refuse to believe that what they need to do is just drink some water... But are happy to take an Excederin with Coca Cola to mask their dehydration headache.
- hessenwolf 12y agoDon't get me started on trying to convince them not to spend 10 year's earnings on an overpriced dwelling.
- csours 12y agoOk, so what is the issue with: > artificial colors, preservatives and sweeteners I understand that they are a signal that what you are about to consume has been processed, and is likely unhealthy on balance; do you see an inherent problem with these ingredients?
- spacehome 12y agoI don't know about the colors and preservatives, but there were some very surprising results recently indicating that zero-calorie sweeteners were just as bad for your weight as sugar. http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v514/n7521/full/nature13793.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v514/n7521/full/nature1...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- i_cannot_hack 12y agoWhat's your point? That you think the villagers are stupid? They are obviously not any more stupid than the countless other humans who risk their health for esthetic reasons, like not wearing a bicycle helmet. Either way I think there are both more interesting and more pleasant things to say about this story than a condescending and snarky remark about the villagers. Spread some love, will ya?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pkaye 12y agoWell the iron fish does solved the issue of medical compliance. What good are iron pots or pieces of iron if the villagers not follow the advice.
- KeytarHero 12y ago> The problem of iron deficiency can be solved with iron cooking pots, or pieces of iron not shaped by fish. can be is a whole different thing from is being. Or, to use the old, tired cliche, "you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink" There are several steps to solving iron deficiency. Yes, an iron cooking pot or a plain iron pellet solves one of those steps. But the human step is every bit as important. It's clearly not just a matter of aesthetics either - it's "a piece of iron shaped like a local river fish believed to be lucky". Sure, saying "they're dumb and should just learn to use a round pellet" makes sense from our educated western perspective. But that's completely ignorant of their deeply-ingrained cultural attitudes. When you're in a society that believes a certain kind of fish to be lucky, you can't just say "use science, idiot" and expect them to actually do what you say. As a more extreme example, remember that in Liberia, armed men broke into an Ebola clinic to free patients [0]. In cases like these, the human side of the problem is far more important than the scientific side. [0] http://www.cbsnews.com/news/report-armed-men-attack-liberia-ebola-clinic-freeing-patients/ http://www.cbsnews.com/news/report-armed-men-attack-liberia-...
- FractalNerve 12y agoIs his MSc. or PHd. thesis on the iron fish online?
- kaybe 12y agoI found three papers on the topic authored or coauthored by Charles: Iron content of Cambodian foods when prepared in cooking pots containing an iron ingot http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-3156.2011.02878.x/full http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-3156.2011.... Iron-deficiency anaemia in rural Cambodia: community trial of a novel iron supplementation technique http://eurpub.oxfordjournals.org/content/21/1/43 http://eurpub.oxfordjournals.org/content/21/1/43 Women's nutrient intakes and food-related knowledge in rural Kandal province, Cambodia. http://apjcn.nhri.org.tw/server/APJCN/23/2/263.pdf http://apjcn.nhri.org.tw/server/APJCN/23/2/263.pdf (I'm not logged in, so it should be public, I hope)
- teddyh 12y agoThat second link leads to a paper containing this: Results: Blood iron levels were higher in women in the iron fish plus follow-up at 3 months compared with controls, but this was not maintained. At 6 months, haemoglobin and serum iron had fallen in all groups and the proportion of anaemic women had increased. Conclusions: This study shows that the iron ingot was effective in the short but not longer-term against IDA. Though a novel treatment option, further research is warranted to determine bioavailability of leached iron and whether or not the surface area is large enough for sufficient iron leaching. (The third paper does not seem to mention the iron fish.) Does this mean that the whole thing is another bogus gimmick which only survives because it’s a cute thing which first-worlders like to throw money at?
- AdmiralAsshat 12y agoBefore any more "How silly, he had to make the iron look appealing to get people to do something healthy" comments arise, I invite readers to consider how many of you have paid $15 or more for a BPA-free glass/stainless steel/double-walled plastic reusable water bottle. Did you really need that over a simple plastic water bottle? Or a cup? My guess would be no. But you did it because you're trying to get yourself to drink more water, and perhaps that requires getting a vessel that looks or feels aesthetically pleasing to use habitually. Disclaimer: I bought an Ello glass bottle from Target less than 48 hours ago for this very purpose--to make myself drink more water. I don't consider shaping iron into the shape of a fish all that different.
- maerF0x0 12y agoI did need a BPA free drinking source. You're right a cup would do though.
- electromagnetic 12y agoAh porcelain, BPA free since 1600 BC.
- hereonbusiness 12y agoI'll take my porcelain cup in classic lead white, thanks ;)
- johansch 12y agoOr put a completely different way: Why would the people of Cambodia trust their government if they came out and said you should put some iron stuff in your pots? This would be from one of the few governments on earth that are less trustworthy than the average american one. Perception-wise or in reality, does it matter? Anyway, this is an angle americans should be able to identify with. :)
- electromagnetic 12y agoWe've got lots of hard proven facts on a lot of topics, like vaccinations. People still don't get their kids vaccinated, and then we get outbreaks where kids die from the measles. Perception can easily outweigh facts for a lot of people. If we could find a way to trick people into vaccinating their kids we would use it. The attitude of "they're just stupid people who don't know better" is kind of disgusting when we've got college and university educated people exhibiting the exact same behaviour. Who's dumber? The person that doesn't know better or the person who should know better, because I think it's the latter. So to all the people who think these are just stupid people. If the US government had exterminated 70 million Americans three decades ago, would you be giving your kids a single vaccine? Or would you expect it to be part of another genocide campaign?
- Scoundreller 12y agoThe body is very good at conserving iron and unfortunately not very good at dealing with iron overload. It says that the device can provide up to 75% of iron requirements, but under what conditions could it start to give >100%?
- electromagnetic 12y agoThat's a very misleading statement, the body is able to significantly reduce the amount of iron absorption through the intestines. Non-genetic related iron overload is rarely heard of outside of dietary supplement overuse, predominantly children eating iron fortified supplements. For an ordinary person to eat too much iron, you would have to have an exceptionally bizarre diet, especially if you're overdosing on iron via elemental iron. The upper tolerable limit for a daily intake of iron is 45mg. To get this via sirloin steak, you would have to eat three and a half pounds a day! Or 3700 calories of steak per day. Given that heme-iron is the most readily absorbed by the body, and that guidelines suggest vegetarians consume 1.8 times the RDI, which would suggest an 80mg upper tolerable limit for non-heme iron. So lets take Broccoli, everyone knows that's iron rich. 2.1mg per medium stalk (1/3lb), which would amount to 7 lbs of Broccoli a day. Please, don't state bullshit like it's a fact.
- Scoundreller 12y agoFood examples are great and all, but the article is about an iron block that you cook food with. Per your numbers, one would only need to consume 80mg+ per day (of the elemental) to start getting into trouble territory. My concern is over how cooking conditions (or other factors) may affect how much iron leaches out into the food, which would cause iron overload if high enough, just like those iron fortified supplements. I never stated that the body can't adjust the amount of iron absorbed. I stated that iron overload, which is when one's body already has too much iron accumulated, is not well handled by the body. This is true, because the body is very poor at excreting iron in response to excessive iron levels, because iron is conserved very well (unlike, say, Vitamin C).
- Turing_Machine 12y ago
- Scoundreller 12y ago> A disease of poverty, iron deficiency affects 3.5 billion people in the world. > They found a local scrap metal worker who could make them for $1.50 each Paging Bill Gates... A one-off payment (these would last forever, right?) of a few billion would solve this problem... everywhere and forever?
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoThey can't last "forever" because if they did there wouldn't be any increased iron in people's diet!
- evilduck 12y agoAt $1.50/ea I feel like humanity can afford to replace them like once every 800 years.
- UntitledNo4 12y agoFrom http://www.luckyironfish.com http://www.luckyironfish.com: "One Lucky Iron Fish can provide an entire family with up to 75% of their daily iron intake for up to 5 years". So we'll need to replace them a bit more often than that (not that I'm saying it's not a good cause).
- evilduck 12y agoBack of napkin math says we need approx 8mg/adult/day, say we're cooking for a family of 4, we'd need 32mg of iron leached from the fish per day. I'll guess from the picture that the fish weighs about 3/4 of a pound as pure iron, or 453593mg, so it should last about 38 years at that rate. So I was off by a bit. :) Surface area would obviously reduce as it dissolved and the rate of leaching iron would underserve the family before it really began to look unfamiliar, so you'd not want to completely dissolve it. 5 years is definitely overly cautious, it should easily last 2-4x that long, but gives them a good excuse to reinforce the reasoning of the fish when a replacement is provided.
- jedanbik 12y agoIt solves the problem and looks cute, while costing next to nothing. This is good design.
- pdm55 12y agoI'm confused. (It easily happens). How does adding an iron (Fe) object to a cooking pot increase intake of iron ions (Fe 2+). Note that I am saying Fe(2+) intake. As I understand it, haemoglobin has an Fe(2+) ion trapped in it's structure. This is required for the uptake of oxygen molecules (O2) from the lungs, carrying it in the blood stream and releasing it at sites where there is an oxygen deficit. This is a long way of saying that Fe (2+) is utilised by the body, not Fe. If this is unclear, think in terms of sodium. We use sodium ions (Na+) not sodium atoms (Na). We put NaCl on our food, not Na. Na is very reactive and would react violently with our moist skin. We know that once it loses its electron to chlorine, a similarly highly reactive element, and becomes Na+ (in combination with Cl-) it is in an unreactive form and is used by the body for propagation of impulses along nerves. Back to Fe (2+). I guess that talking about Fe is just an imprecise way of talking about our need for Fe2+. The question then in my mind is "How does the Fe added to the cooking pot become Fe(2+)?" Does it just become oxidised to iron oxide (FeO,Fe2O3, Fe3O4?). I am trying to think what would a soluble form of Fe2+. Wikipedia lists these as insoluble. Perhaps salt is required in the cooking pot and iron chloride Fe2+ Cl2- is formed. But I cannot see Fe winning in a charity tustle with sodium for the donation of it's electrons to chlorine. Maybe, the formation of iron oxides are an interim step. Who knows?
- coralreef 12y agoHow is the iron from the fish absorbed exactly? Do trace amounts just fall off from the fish when rubbed against the cookware?
- iopq 12y agoNutritionists HATE it!
- lovemenot 12y agoBetter print on it: "Not for human consumption" in Khmer and/or a crossed-out icon of a person dangling a lucky fish into their mouth.
- pvaldes 12y agommmh... Aluminium in excess inhibes enzymes, can cause colic, lost of memory, desorientation, kidney damage and even is claimed to cause dementia at long term. So (unless this fish can float?) I understand that you are also scratching the bottom of the pan with the iron chunk and this should release a lot of more AL than before because this metal is soft. I wonder what are the efects of using the fish in the aluminium intake of these people. They did some research about it?. Maybe a better solution could be to make pans with some iron embedded (ring?, bottom?, cover?) but not mobile pieces.
- sa1 12y agoHow is rust dealt with?