23 ms·
Charlie Hebdo: first cover since terror attack depicts prophet Muhammad
- nailer 12y agoEdit: actually this is wrong: the Guardian and Independent (left) have published, Sun, Times Telegraph and Mail (right) have not. Original: it's also worth noting that all the UK newspapers, from both sides of politics, have republished the relevant cover.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 12y agoSpeaking on Today, [Omer el-Hamdoon, president of the Muslim Association of Britain] said causing offence “just for the purpose of offending” was not freedom of speech. Distancing yourself from the extremists [FAIL]
- Guthur 12y agoJust because someone doesn't take your side in debate does not necessarily mean they took some other non affiliated point of view.
- MrBuddyCasino 12y agoOne could argue that he did, indirectly. Freedom of speech means exactly that - the freedom to say whatever you want, within the margins allowed by the law, regardless of how it could be perceived by some specific group of people. Somebody is always going to be offended, I think el-Hamdoon missed the whole point. What he could have said instead, but didn't, is this: "While I find the cover disgusting, freedom of speech protects their right to publish this, and they should not fear for their lives because of it."
- Guthur 12y ago"Within the margins of law" So it's not completely free. There is a hate speech law in France. So there are limits to speech and many people might find them acceptable limits.
- chernevik 12y agoThank you for the excellent example of why hate speech laws are such a terrible idea.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sfjailbird 12y ago> Freedom of speech means exactly that - the freedom to say whatever you want ... regardless of how it could be perceived by some specific group of people No. You can't publish porn freely. Why? Because some people find it offensive. It's not that simple.
- icebraining 12y agoOr maybe it is. What makes you uncritically accept those restrictions as not violating free speech? Just because the countries that impose them happen to claim they support free speech?
- chernevik 12y agoFrom the article -- Omer el-Hamdoon:"what’s happening here is not that different from what we witnessed back in 2005 with the Danish cartoons when media outlets went into a cycle of just publishing the cartoons just to show defiance. And what that caused is more offence." It's pretty clear that the likes of Mr. el-Hamdoon want it both ways. They want to sound supportive of free speech, but they want that speech curtailed to their liking. No, they wouldn't kill anyone themselves. Yes, they are fostering a dangerous notion of "incorrect" speech that is very dangerous to the whole idea of free speech. Those dangers are so obvious that it is very hard to assign good faith to those preaching it.
- venomsnake 12y agoI have always thought that the offence was in the eye of the offended. If something drawn by a human can disturb a person's inner world so much - the problem is his and not the artists'
- fafner 12y agoI don't understand how anyone could claim that CH published those comics "just for the purpose of offending". All of the CH comics had messages, very valuable messages in my opinion.
- odiroot 12y agoAnd even if they were crafted to offend it is our choice to be or not to be offended. A sane, mature person would just shrug and ignore the newspaper in the future.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoThis guy has an amazingly unhelpful point of view. It's literally freedom of speech to cause offence for the purpose of it. He's just exposed MAB's viewpoint as being opposed to freedom of expression, which is a shockingly stupid thing to do here.
- palmer_eldritch 12y agoEspecially since Charlie Hebdo's goal has never been to offend "just for the purpose of offending". Their comics are for their readers. For most of their history (before the internet) only the few people who bought it read it and their drawings didn't make the news even if most of them would've been very offensive to some. They try to convey something insightful in an humoristic way, usually in a pretty unflattering way for the depicted. That's what satire means. If they end up making pictures about islam these days, it's because islam hits the news much more than it did in Hara Kiri's days. Their drawings and articles always followed the news. And when YOU hit the news because some people can't take a joke, you keep following the news and respond in your next issue: "please stop being so stupid" in an humoristic and unflattering way for the depicted. If you can't depict the world around you in a funny way, usually unflattering to the depicted because the depicted might be offended, then you can't do satire. At least have the guts to say it in plain words: "I'm all for free speech except when stuff I hold dear are being caricatured". Which means you don't want free speech because anyone can then claim they're offended by anything.
- geographomics 12y agoThis isn't a 'fail'. Being repulsed by Charlie Hebdo's offensive depictions of religious icons does not imply being in favour of the assassination of its editorial staff. You can stand squarely against both, without contradiction.
- icebraining 12y agoI didn't quote someone saying he was repulsed; I quoted someone saying it wasn't free speech. The two are very different statements. And I didn't say he's in favor of the assassination, either - just that he failed to distance himself from them.
- geographomics 12y agoWhy should he have to distance himself? That notion in itself implies that his default position is showing some favour.
- icebraining 12y agoIt's not the default position; it's - in my opinion - the implication of what he said. Criticizing the cartoonists in a moment like this reveals, if nothing else, a tremendous lack of compassion.
- melling 12y agoDo you still think Cumberbatch was poorly cast in the Imitation Game? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8777831 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8777831 A best actor nomination.
- geographomics 12y agoYes I do, but what does this have to do with Charlie Hebdo?
- melling 12y ago
- tomp 12y ago> Warning: this article contains the image of the magazine cover, which some may find offensive. It's the first time I've seen something like this on Guardian; I don't even remember it on articles discussing rape, murder or such, which is usually where "trigger warning" applies. Personally, I find such trigger warnings, and especially "you might be offended" warnings, totally ridiculous. What about me? I find such warnings an insult to my intelligence and a trivialization of people's personal responsibility, where is my warning?
- venomsnake 12y agoAnd it makes things worse. The idea that you have to tiptoe and thought police yourself around some group of people is sure way to antagonize part of the society against that group.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- draugadrotten 12y agoMakes you think about their motives for adding such an exceptional warning.
- venomsnake 12y agoBall gripping fear?
- xaa 12y agoVery likely. I heard an two-way interview on NPR with the editor of the Washington Post, another editor from a prominent UK paper (either the Observer or Guardian, can't remember and can't find the episode, but both are members of the same media group) and the anchor. The editor of the Observer(?) and WaPo were duking it out because the editor of the Observer admitted that he and his staff were frankly terrified of reprisals, and that it was important to admit that publicly, especially if a paper makes the decision not to republish, and that appealing to "sensitivity" as a reason for not republishing the cartoons was a cop-out. The WaPo editor stood by the "sensitivity" excuses. I obviously completely agree with the former.
- ThePhysicist 12y agoI'm sure the Wednesday issue will sell out in no time, despite its edition of 3 million, and become a "collector's piece" for those opposing terrorism and violence (as well as for those who want to resell it on Ebay for a profit ;)). I really admire the courage of the Charlie Hebdo staff, who, just one week after the attack, publish a new issue of their journal. For me, the main problem now is how we deal with the political consequences of this tragedy: Many politicians already bring themselves in position to create new laws that will allow them even more wiretapping and surveillance. British prime minister David Cameron was arguably one of the first here, as in his recent speech he even puts in question the right of anyone (terrorists included) to communicate in private [1]. Other politicians from (mostly) right-wing parties all over Europe are seizing this opportunity as well and demand stricter anti-terror laws and more government surveillance. I think we need to be very watchful now if we don't wanna loose even more of our democratic freedoms for the sake (or the illusion) of more security. [1] http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/jan/12/david-cameron-pledges-anti-terror-law-internet-paris-attacks-nick-clegg http://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/jan/12/david-cameron...
- atmosx 12y agoI live in Greece and I would buy one, if I could. I guess whatever the number (even 10 mil copies) will be (or better say) should be sold.
- dtf 12y agoHere's a great interview with Luz, whose signature you can see on the cover drawing. The interesting thing is that Charlie was at heart an iconoclastic magazine, and yet ironically has now become an icon of free speech - something the staff aren't particularly happy about. http://www.lesinrocks.com/2015/01/10/actualite/luz-eyes-us-weve-become-symbol-11545347/ http://www.lesinrocks.com/2015/01/10/actualite/luz-eyes-us-w...
- apricot 12y agoThat interview should be read by everyone who cares about the attack on Charlie Hebdo and subsequent "Je suis Charlie" worldwide movement. Many people, for all kinds of reasons (many good) are trying to make Charlie Hebdo into what it is not, and never will be, some kind of reluctant messiah of free speech.
- neals 12y agoI used to think society would, at some point, grow up and leave religion behind. But lately, it just feels like a far 'lower' form of religion is just taking over. I think that western christianity has made some big strides. For example, by leaving all the violence behind. Now the violent ones are winning. This makes me sad for the future of Europe.
- nailer 12y agoOrthodox folk - Christians, Jews, and Muslims - generally believe that secular folk aren't religious at all. I know a whole bunch of Christians who's idea of god is 'life and family' and, despite attending church and believing that Jesus was real, don't believe in an all-powerful creator with human characteristics. Secularism is now so secular that the only religious people you hear about are the orthodox ones.
- Lewton 12y agoWinning, how?
- MrGando 12y agoI think the French people and most of the world has reacted in an admirable way after this attacks. Showing no fear and Charlie, showing that they are going to keep up, doing what they do, because it's right. The world has to be very careful with how many governments are going to use this attacks as an opportunity to empower mass surveillance and other policies that will affect general people privacy. Still, I'm happy about how the French people have handled this horrible situation.
- olavk 12y agoWestern Christianity certainly haven't left violence behind. Just take the christian terrorist Anders Brevik who killed 80 people in Norway.
- fafner 12y agoBreivik isn't a Christian terrorist. He described himself as not being overly religious. He is also very critical of modern (I think that's what's meant by Western here) Christianity, both in the Church of Norway and Catholicism.
- quonn 12y agoMuch better than expected: It's defiance and almost turning the other cheek at the same time.
- WillNotDownvote 12y agoDoes a fantastic job of threading a very thin needle. I was surprised at how perfectly they pulled that off.
- mcv 12y agoIt's forgiveness and turning the other cheek. It's surprisingly Christian for such an anti-religious magazine. Also check out the beautiful cover they had after the 2011 firebombing: http://beta.images.theglobeandmail.com/static/world/charlie_hebdo/kissing_hebdo.jpg http://beta.images.theglobeandmail.com/static/world/charlie_...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- higherpurpose 12y agoIf only the governments wouldn't use this "attack on free speech" to umm...restrict free speech. If the terrorists change your way of life, they've won. I thought the whole point of the march was to say that "We are not afraid! And we'll continue to be just as free as ever! Your violence will not scare us!" - and so on. But nope. Apparently what it meant is that we need more censorship and self-censorship caused by increased and more intrusive mass surveillance: http://www.zdnet.com/article/europes-answer-to-terror-attacks-on-free-speech-is-to-double-down-on-internet-censorship/ http://www.zdnet.com/article/europes-answer-to-terror-attack... http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/what-it-means-to-stand-with-charlie-hebdo/2015/01/08/ab416214-96e8-11e4-aabd-d0b93ff613d5_story.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/what-it-means-to-stan... If the alternative to once in a while terrorist attacks is turning every democracy into Russia or China, then I'd rather stick with the risk of terrorism.
- lovelearning 12y agoI'm rather curious why this depiction is considered to be that of the prophet Muhammad. Is it said so somewhere in their paper, or do we all just accept whatever interpretation is handed down to us by the fundamentalists?
- infruset 12y agoBecause the character is depicted similarly as in a previous cartoon by the same cartoonist: https://i.imgur.com/Lm4p71F.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Lm4p71F.jpg I don't get why you're being downvoted though. Have an upvote.
- PeterWhittaker 12y agoAnd another.
- lovelearning 12y agoThank you for the upvote. If the downvotes were due to religious reasons, then I have to admit it is rather sad to see them on HN. On the other hand, if they were due to perceived ignorance or stupidity, then I accept them. From the link and history of the cartoons, I've reached the rather odd conclusion that anyone named "Mahomet" or "Muhammad" in a cartoon is automatically assumed to be the prophet Muhammad.
- unclebucknasty 12y ago>if they were due to perceived ignorance or stupidity, then I accept them You were just asking an earnest question. What's actually stupid is the downvote feature itself. Upvotes can help promote good content and flags can call attention to inappropriate or problematic content. Likewise, comments can be used to express disagreement. So, what's the purpose of downvotes? Are we in preschool?
- corin_ 12y agoIf users should be trusted to push comments up, then why not down also? A down vote doesn't have to mean "this comment should not be on HN", it can be "I disagree with this comment" or "I think this comment should be lower down".
- xianshou 12y agoAs the article points out, this is essentially the only viable move for Charlie Hebdo. To have so often depicted Muhammad in the past, have most of their staff killed for it, become the focus of a worldwide movement that promises not to be intimidated or cowed by terrorism, and then not publish Muhammad in the next issue? An admission of complete defeat. That said, bravo.
- Guthur 12y agoThe article and many peoples reaction comes across as if these two 'individuals' actually represented the Muslim community. This is quite obviously not the case if it is looked at objectively. And to say that somehow the Muslim community must bear responsibility for the individuals actions is like saying that all the people of France must bear responsibility for every wrong committed in their neighbourhood, or their city, or by their government, were those wrongs not commit by French men and women.
- matthewmacleod 12y agoNo, it really doesn't come across as that.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- infruset 12y ago> book a ticket in the home supporters area How is that related? They didn't book a ticket in Mecca for all I know.
- corin_ 12y agoThat part of the analogy was just part of the "everyone knows what would happen so why do it" rather than a direct equivalent. I presume. Terrible analogy either way.
- venomsnake 12y agoI would expect Real Madrid fans to not break the laws ...
- MarvinYork 12y agoMan, I hope you're trolling.
- mercurial 12y agoBy "measures" you mean "murders", right? You know, it sounds awfully like what you hear when somebody gets raped. "Oh, of course, I don't approve of rape, but have you seen how she was dressed?"
- RobAley 12y agoTry that argument with yet another topic : If you, as a woman, go out wearing a short skirt, to a bar with all of these men, then what do you expect to happen? I mean, I don't approve of the measures taken by the rapist, but they had it coming, and they seem to have been wanting it.
- cpwright 12y agoI find it interesting that European stadiums feel the need to separate home vs. away fans.
- chroma 12y agoThe Charlie Hebdo attacks show that these days, real satire of Islam can't be done without significant risk of violent reprisal. If you doubt that statement, remember The Book of Mormon. (The play, not the actual book.) Could you imagine Trey Parker and Matt Stone making an equivalent Broadway play about Islam? Could you imagine them calling it The Qur'an to Google-bomb the original? Even if they disregarded their own safety, dozens of organizations would do their best to stop it. Venue owners wouldn't take the risk. Insurers wouldn't accept standard policies. Audience turnout would be lower, fearing attacks. And yet, both religions are similar in their ridiculousness. One just happens to encourage less violence in its hosts. For a little while, we'll all pile-on the cartoon Muhammad bandwagon in show of support. But after this dies down, who will be the first to step forward with some new blasphemous ridicule? Who will single themselves out, risking their life, their family, their friends? Whoever does so will certainly be braver than me.
- saalaa 12y agoCharlie Hebdo? I'm pretty sure they'll keep mocking religions.
- mlrtime 12y agoWho will raise the bar? Ouch for the down-votes. When I say raise the bar, I don't mean to incite violence, I mean to say who else is going to take on the task that so little are willing to risk their lives for.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoWhy does the bar need raised? It's not a competition to see who can piss off religious people the most. The point of the cartoons is to convey a message. Just take a look at the new Charlie Hebdo cover for example. They could have acted in revenge and really, really mocked Islam - and it sounds like that's what you would have done. Instead they created something quite beautiful while still exercising their right to free speech and expression even as radicals tried to stomp them out. It's not a competition to be most offensive. It's trying to convey your message in the best way possible without fear of reprisal compromising that.
- jpgvm 12y agoIt takes a great deal to stand up against the advance of political correctness on free speech. Other countries haven't nearly done as well as France. At the end of the day the situation was tragic but the defence of free speech against prevailing winds is incredibly important. As for religious extremism... I don't think we will see an end until enlightenment spreads and religion fades into historic irrelevancy. This is happening faster than people think, especially religious people as they can't see out of their bubble. At least here in Australia the vast majority of people may "identify" as Christian but they don't actually practice any semblance of faith. That being said the Christian lobby parties still have an unreasonably large amount of sway due to being a very vocal minority that leverages this weak "identity" of Australians to further their conservative agenda. Nevertheless there is less and less children becoming indoctrinated into this nonsense and gaining access to real information sooner through the Internet that by the end of my lifetime I expect religion (in it's current form) in developed countries to be all but extinct. I think extremism will still be around, it will just be over more real issues and less fairy tale beliefs.
- gws 12y agoI don't think that the religion is the issue, I think that desperate people with desperate lives will always find something irrational to fill their life with and kill for. As an example on a smaller scale (smaller as in less desperate) in Italy we have people whose life revolves around going to the stadium on Sunday to watch their football team and getting into fights with the fans of the opponent team. That's the only thing that keeps their life together. And they are ready to kill other teams' fans, we have people killed every year. Likewise we have extreme right or extreme left groups who fight and kill each other... desperate people filling their life. Religion, political faith, football team, doesn't really matter, the issue is the people, not the ideas.
- jpgvm 12y agoTrue, which is why I went to to explain that I don't think all extremism would go away - just religious extremism. I just think it's harder to incite organised extreme violence without some highly charged agenda and removing religion goes a long way to making our world a better place.
- TIJ 12y agoRead news about the biggest gathering in paris ever as a tribute to the legendary cartoonist, terrorists are failing in their objectives.
- kbart 12y agoNope. Terrorist have won again. The aim of Islam terrorism is not to cause direct damage, but to install fear in all of us and reduce our freedom/democracy. Here's one of example that's relevant to people here on HN: "In wake of Paris shootings, Prime Minister wants to ban encryptions that government can't read in extreme situations" http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/whatsapp-and-snapchat-could-be-banned-under-new-surveillance-plans-9973035.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/new...
- Udik 12y agoYesterday the Guardian published the best opinion I've read so far about satire, Charlie Hebdo, the terrorist attacks and our reaction to them. And it's a short comic strip by the cartoonist Joe Sacco: http://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2015/jan/09/joe-sacco-on-satire-a-response-to-the-attacks http://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2015/jan/09/...
- mxfh 12y agoWhile I respect Secco and his work as well it's also wrong and out of context in some regards. Ruben Bolling: http://gocomics.typepad.com/tomthedancingbugblog/2015/01/in-non-satirical-defense-of-charlie-hebdo.html http://gocomics.typepad.com/tomthedancingbugblog/2015/01/in-...
- jholman 12y agoI'd never heard of CH a week ago, and Bolling's interpretation of CH's cartooning may be more accurate than Secco's, and it was an interesting perspective. But I think that Bolling's conclusions are wrong, except perhaps when he rebuts Secco's use of the word "vapid". Bolling says that the only reasonable reaction to the murders is to defend free speech. No. Defending free speech is necessary, but it's not at all clear that it's sufficient. Freedom of the press isn't the only issue here. There are also issues of what to do about violence/security, what to do about racism, what to do about freedom of religion, etc. Those issues aren't any more important post-murder, but they were important before and they still are, and this is an opportunity to put some eyes on them. I don't interpret Sacco's piece as saying "CH is unworthy of our defense". I interpret it as saying "Let's defend CH, but also notice that they were missing the point, here's the point". Bolling argues that CH wasn't missing the point. But Sacco's proposal for where our greatest attention should lie is still a good proposal.
- jules 12y agoWhat exactly do you see as Sacco's proposal? Maybe it's over my head, but as far as I can see his comic basically says that in response to the murders we should focus on not offending muslims.
- nahiluhmot 12y agoI'm nervous about the response that these attacks will conjure from the far right. There have already been a good deal of attempts on the lives of innocent Muslims [1] since the attack on Charlie Hebdo, and I find it very concerning that I have heard none of this from the national/international news media. Would these not as well be considered acts of terrorism? Why not report on them? Doing so would seem to unfairly advance the anti-Islam sentiment in France by effectively silencing the acts of terrorism from non-Muslims. [1] http://mic.com/articles/108206/how-bad-is-france-s-anti-muslim-backlash-to-the-charlie-hebdo-attack-check-this-map http://mic.com/articles/108206/how-bad-is-france-s-anti-musl...
- digi_owl 12y agoYeah, thats the really big one here. Frankly i see the shooters and the "far right" as pretty much two variants of the same. Swap around a few words on various slogans and you would not know if it came from jihadists or skinheads. In almost all cases we are seeing young men with no apparent future being scooped up by some "recruiter" and indoctrinated. Street gangs, cults, terrorists, all the same once you boil away whatever "makeup" they apply...
- esaym 12y agoHow do you know those attacks were done by the 'right'? What you have done is no different than people saying all "Muslims are terrorists".. Yet you get upvotes. People that harm people have one thing in common. It is not the 'right' or religion. They are loony and mis-guided, and have their priorities severely out of place. Plain and simple. Such polarization will never lead to any kind of peace.
- nahiluhmot 12y agoThat's a fair point, the article I quoted does not mention if these people were on the 'right' or not. However, by saying "far right", I was trying to imply that extremists from that side would carry out acts on Muslims, much like extremist Muslims attacking the Hebdo. I assumed these attacks would come from the right because of a culture of Islamophobia that I've seen on places like Fox news, which I consider to be a far right media outlet. For example: http://www.vox.com/2015/1/12/7533159/fox-news-pirro-rant http://www.vox.com/2015/1/12/7533159/fox-news-pirro-rant http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/muslims-are-evil-lets-kill-them-all-us-tv-commentator-erik-rush-provokes-furious-reaction-with-boston-bombing-twitter-rants-8575176.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/muslims-are... http://www.salon.com/2014/08/20/foxs_andrea_tantaros_you_solve_it_with_a_bullet_to_the_head/ http://www.salon.com/2014/08/20/foxs_andrea_tantaros_you_sol...
- rauljara 12y agoI found it quite moving that the theme of the cover was forgiveness. Fighting extremist hate with more hate has a best case of only shifting which people suffer because it, and a worse case that is truly horrible to contemplate. I know saying you forgive your attackers will almost certainly not make the world a better place. But there were so many reactions that could have added to the fire. It's very hopeful to see people struggling to break the cycle even in the face of such loss.
- ca98am79 12y agoI agree with you almost completely - except I do think that forgiveness definitely will and does make the world a better place. It just did - you and I and countless other people have been moved and inspired by this gesture of forgiveness. How can that not make the world better? If they had instead requested vengeance - it would continue the cycle of misery, hate and destruction.
- rikacomet 12y agoFirst of all.. certainly as a Muslim, I condemn the attack on Charlie Hebdo. This is not Islam. But, if I were to take the liberty to express my own opinion, I would say honestly, I think both parties were at wrong here. First that their have been many instances in the life of our prophet, when he faced not just harsh but inhuman treatment, specially in his hometown of Mecca. Yet he never lifted a finger or even wished for those people to get hurt (there is specific mention of this in Islam). It is against the moral of our religion to engage in such "eye for an eye" notions. Yet people (like the 4 suspects) who are not aware of their own religion and the finer lines tend to do these things when agitated or pushed in a corner. On the other hand, Religion is a personal affair. People are serious about it, be it any religion. People live and die by the religion, it is the very guide of majority of the people in this world. And if someone portrays something so closely associated to people, it is a kin to playing with their feelings. And that is where things start to get ugly, and such mishaps happen. Satire is accepted in Islam, as evident from the semi-fictional writings about Mullah Nasruddin. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasreddin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nasreddin But the level of Satire in question here, was perhaps too much. Besides the additional fact, that impersonation/impersonification of Prophet Muhammad is highly condemned in Islam. Even if we are to write a play on factual things about him, it is prohibited to have someone portray him (even for a good/just reason). To say that in other words, to Muslims, a graphical satire is acceptable on anyone except the prophets, which includes Moses, Jesus, Abraham, etc. Yet, if someone does want to amuse himself or exercise his liberty knowing that it is something that hurts us, we simply have to ignore him. Things should not go further than that. People in the west have indeed respected this, as seen in the movie: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074896/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0074896/ Let us understand each others liberties as well as sensitivities, so that by standing firm together, we will all make a better society, both in France and the World.
- trhway 12y ago>First that their have been many instances in the life of our prophet, when he faced not just harsh but inhuman treatment, specially in his hometown of Mecca. Yet he never lifted an finger or even wished for those people to get hurt. It is against the moral of our religion to engage in such "eye for an eye" notions. that just a blatant lie. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Badr http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Badr among the others fights against Meccans that the paedophilic Muhammad led the Muslims into.
- yousef1234 12y agoNEW IMAGE OF CHARLIE BEEN SHOT: http://goo.gl/CsFP8F http://goo.gl/CsFP8F
- yousef1234 12y agoNEW IMAGE OF CHARLIE HEBDO SHOT: http://goo.gl/CsFP8F http://goo.gl/CsFP8F
- Shivetya 12y agoHow do we obtain a copy in the US? Anyone have a good source?
- jayess 12y agoIs there anyone in France willing to take a paypal payment to buy me a couple of copies and mail them to the USA?
- simias 12y agoI've heard that this issue will be translated in something like 16 languages, I would be surprised if it wasn't officially distributed abroad, especially in the USA.
- ThomPete 12y agoCharlie Hebdos fight is not a fight for freedom of expression but against self-censorship. I think a lot media and politicians forget that. We all deal with self-censorship every day as we live amongst each other. Some people have more courage than others and dare take it "behind enemy lines" where other rules apply. Freedom of expression is a legal right to express yourself without fearing those in power is going to shut you down or prosecute you. We mostly have that and the only people who can threaten it is the politicians which unfortunately is exactly what some of them are going to do. We already see the first reactions like this http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/news/whatsapp-and-snapchat-could-be-banned-under-new-surveillance-plans-9973035.html http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/new... And all over Europe there are people taking advantage of the situation and proposing laws that will actually threaten freedom of expression.
- geographomics 12y agoThere are already plenty of laws in France and most (perhaps all) other countries that restrict freedom of speech. Examples of censured expression include but are not limited to: Holocaust denial, hate speech, some forms of pornography, leaking state secrets, harassing communication, copyright infringement, libel and slander. I don't think that freedom of expression is absolutely permitted anywhere. There are so many exceptions to it - many of which are necessary for a cohesive society - that it's pretty much an invalid concept in real terms.
- ThomPete 12y agoI agree. My primary point is just that it's not "the others" that threaten our freedom of expression its ourselves.
- geographomics 12y agoMy apologies, I misread your comment as saying that freedom of expression was only just beginning to be under threat. I do agree with your primary point.
- lxc 12y agoThe face and turban is shaped like a penis
- lxc 12y agoTest
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- gadders 12y agoWe're allowed to talk about this now? I thought all the stories on it were getting flagged off the front page?
- big_astrocyte 12y agoIt is not about Islam but about a school of thought which is not only 100% certain in its beliefs (Quran is the literal word of God) but also likes to impose it on others under the banner of "don't hurt our feelings". I've seen examples coming from Budhism (Burma-Sri Lanka), Hinduism (India), Sikhism (India), Christianity (UK-middle age Europe-African countries). People from even non-islamic religions regularly kill each other for hurting 'religious feelings'. When someone 'hurts' your religious sentiments, you can't be sure whether it was done deliberately or for deeper reasons. I can see deep reasons in why those cartoons were published. Anyone against free expression is kinda against science itself. Certain religions will never grow (the word of god is limited to Quran/Bible/Whatever) but science will keep growing. What happens when science ends up infringing on religious feelings? Will we be allowed to publish potential treatment for HIV found in a pig's liver in a sharia state? Even saying that "Charlie Hebdo" did something wrong is taking a step towards a world where science starts becoming bound. This sentiment can easily go out of hand in a matter of 100 years. A perfect example would be Pakistan. A supposedly liberal place 100 years ago ended up forcing its only nobel prize winning physicist into exile, defacing his grave and making sure more awesome scientists are not created. Because apparently, Dr. Abdus Salam (the nobel laureate) wasn't Muslim enough!! I wouldn't take even one step towards intolerance for the sake of our great-great grandchildren.
- Killah911 12y agoA very interesting cover. I was thinking about drawing a cartoon: a bunch of Muslims sitting around saying "I hate freedom soo much!..." Note this wouldn't be satirizing Muslims, but rather the fact that we rush to draw these comical worldviews even in the face of such tragedies. Let's just label it Radical Islam & call anyone that doesn't agree with our definition of "values" a Radical. The Islamic world is in deep shit, not necessarily because of the west. Meaningful change often isnt even a remote possibility in many of these places. The "extremists" are just another group vying for power and legitimacy in a dystopian Muslim world & something like Charlie Hebdo is a PR opportunity. Religious injunctions aside, what makes criticizing Islam is not just the beliefs that some hold. What makes it dangerous is you're likely painting a target on your back. They won't take on the U.S. army, or the seriously oppressive armies of dictatorships. A journalist, celebrity etc is a great opportunity. It's not fucking about free speech, unless you believe in a comical worldview where you depict what doesn't match your worldview as I did earlier. The cartoons are funny. I'm all for freedom of speech. But our principles don't make ground realties any different. We should think of the fact that at least we have the luxury of having principles. In principle, nobody should rob me while I'm going walking down the street. But it's a whole different thing if it's in a rough neighborhood & I'm standing out like a sore thumb. What happenned was wrong, and my heart goes out to all who are directly involved. And I mean that (A close family friend was recently shot by a deranged lunatic on a shooting spree, leaving him permanently disabled). The violence is senseless and irrational. Let us them not rationalize it away with a little bias thrown the other way. It's not what I expect on HN. Let's not fool ourselves into thinking it was about freedom of speech. Yes, it has caused fear. Which is why I thought the cover was interesting. It's saying to us: we are not afraid & it's not hurling hate back with a message of forgiveness, which is atypical in the aftermath of a terrorist attack. Surprisingly Charlie Hebdo's cover is more thoughtful & less comical than the inane chatter of people saying "why do they hate us". And that is Brilliant. Alas this attempt at communication is probably lost on a majority of the Muslim world. In truth, everyone wants freedom. Let's take a second to think about what's really at play here. For the perpetrators of these acts like to win, it requires us to becomes irrational & start becoming hateful and shortsighted. Let's not give in to that
- resonantcore 12y agoIt's difficult to be surprised by this turn of events. It's in poor taste, in one sense, but overall it's the only appropriate response that a satirist magazine could take in the wake of this tragedy. Followers of Islam the whole world over will continue to ignore these publications nonviolently, though a few extremists might be further radicalized by this decision. Meanwhile, David Cameron is trying to outlaw cryptography after these attacks. Surely that deserves more of our attention right now?
- ca98am79 12y agoOffering forgiveness in the face of such brutality is very powerful and meaningful to me. It is moving and inspiring. When something so brutal like this happens, I can get depressed and not understand. It is easy to feel a lot of anger about it. But then in the face of this brutality, when their co-workers and friends were murdered in cold blood, to offer forgiveness - it really does a lot to restore my faith in humanity.
- bane 12y agoThe meaning of satire has lost its edge. People today think satire = political humor, but satire is supposed to be daring, edgy, and in its highest form be: a) virtually indistinguishable from reality b) expose the author to real danger and reprisal c) nearly impossible to reverse on the satirist Satire has very often been very dangerous to produce, and I think we're being reminded of this right now. It's why satirists take their work so seriously, because it exposes malformed thinking by people who've built their power bases on such thoughts. In my opinion satire is one of the highest forms of free speech and one of the most powerful tools available for parsing people capable of rational thought and those who aren't. It's a kind of gom jabbar test and is not for the faint of heart. It's almost a true battle of the pen vs. the sword.
- jacquesm 12y agoRadical murderous bastards with long toes will use any excuse to ply their trade whether they're anti-abortionists or Islamists doesn't really matter. What does matter is that: - this will rub off negatively on all those in Islam that don't distance themselves unconditionally from actions like these - that it will be used to erode the rights and freedoms of people that had nothing to do with these attacks by railroading laws against the public interest while the anger and the fear are at high tide - that actions like these make people of all religions look bad, especially those who are more fanatical about their religion. On the whole, everybody loses. If your imaginary friend can't be made fun of or you'll flip then you should see a shrink, and if you think there was anything 'ok' about these murders then I'd invite you to join in. Other than that this is a police matter and politicians trying to use this to push their agenda should be voted out of office by all those who today think they too are 'Charlie'.
- mknits 12y agoMy one and only question: How can a religion be based mostly on one book? Surely the book isn't wikipedia or google. This question applies to Christians, Muslims and Jews.
- RRRA 12y agoI'm offended by the fact that there is a warning at the top of this page... Shouldn't it be there all the time then? How about, we don't believe in anything anymore, or we don't have any integrity?
- Yetanfou 12y agoOne thing I fail to understand is the general reaction - or, rather, the absence of such - of 'Islamic authorities' on this and other acts of violence in the name of their religion. There are many complaints about those who point fingers at all Muslims when these things happen, something which would be easily defused by a fatwa (a legal opinion) from some high-placed muftis declaring such acts as 'haram' - sinful. I do not know enough about Islam to know whether there is something resembling 'excommunication' in the Roman Catholic church, but if there is it would make sense to apply it to those who commit such acts of violence. If the perpetrators can no longer claim to be defending their religion they might start to realise that their acts of violence are criminal acts, pure and simple, without any religious excuse. Such a fatwa - or series of fatwas, as there are many currents in Islam - would take away the cause for the general blame which is aimed at Muslims when atrocities are performed in name of their religion.
- copsarebastards 12y agoThese events have really solidified an idea for me that I've been mulling for a while: I don't think I'm in favor of religion as a protected class[1]. Islam believes in inerrancy of the Qur'an. The Qur'an encourages violence. The faces of organized Islam in the west engage in apologetics and argue that this isn't so, but anyone can read this for themselves. Claiming that the Qur'an doesn't encourage violence is just doublethink. Most Muslims believe that the Qur'an espouses peace, only because they haven't read it. But if they actually do read it and realize it espouses violence, then they are faced with a choice: either give up the idea that the Qur'an is inerrant, or begin spreading Islam through violence. All it takes to turn a peaceful Muslim into a violent Muslim is that they actually read and understand their holy book. Even peaceful Muslims aren't great. Even in its milder incarnations, Islam is sexist and hostile to science. The interests of Islam are not aligned with my interests. They are, in fact, directly opposed to my interests. I believe that one of the most powerful ways in which I can act politically is through economics. There is a diner in my town which is well-known for its owners being racist. I don't go there, because I don't want to support racists monetarily. Similarly, I wouldn't hire a person who made racist comments. I believe that there should be significant repercussions for that kind of behavior. Likewise, I don't want to go to Muslim businesses or hire Muslims. Islam is every bit as harmful as racism, and I believe that there should be significant repercussions for that behavior. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class
- ziggrat 12y agoY HN become political?
- ziggrat 12y agoY HN become political?