7 ms·
Ori File System
- jokoon 12y agodoes it work best on local networks, or is it also good when there's high latency and lower bandwidth ?
- hucker 12y agoI wasn't quite able to grasp what this is. Is it similar to dropbox / btsync (without the bt part) in what it provides to the user? What are the usecases? Looks cool anyways, and I love that packages are already available!
- fit2rule 12y agoRead the white paper to learn how to use it: http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp13/papers/p151-mashtizadeh.pdf http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp13/papers/p151-mashtizadeh.pdf
- facepalm 12y agoNeither dropbox nor btsync are free software afaik. I would be excited about a viable open source alternative.
- urza 12y agohttp://syncthing.net http://syncthing.net
- higherpurpose 12y agoIf only Syncthing was as easy to use as BTSync.
- wildfire 12y agowww.seafile.com is another
- sillysaurus3 12y agoI promise I'm not being dismissive. My question is: Ori is a distributed file system built for offline operation and empowers the user with control over synchronization operations and conflict resolution. We provide history through light weight snapshots and allow users to verify the history has not been tampered with. Through the use of replication instances can be resilient and recover damaged data from other nodes. Does a user actually want to do any of these things? Not a techie user, but a user. Someone who cares about their photos, for example. One big use case, which I often run into, is that Dropbox is very valuable because it serves your files through a website. Yes, that means Dropbox and governments have access to that data. On the other hand, it's fine for Dropbox and governments to access my "chatlog with my ISP where I complain about a late fee and ask for a refund" that I saved to Dropbox but need to pull up on my laptop which doesn't have Dropbox installed. That type of thing is where Dropbox really shines, so I'm not sure I'd want to put my docs into a system which doesn't have a web interface. Those kinds of "casual documents" are extremely common. I'd say most of my stuff in Dropbox isn't actually sensitive, whereas a small percentage is highly sensitive. It'd be great to store the highly sensitive into a filesystem like this, since I could control it directly, but that involves quite a lot of effort to set Ori up and to understand it. And it's not entirely clear that it's more secure than, say, encrypting my Dropbox files directly. In summary, what precisely is the value add that Ori brings to the user? I'm trying hard to see it, and I want to believe there is one.
- mooneater 12y agoThe beauty of software is: It could be built upon. Including a simpler setup/interface, and a web interface.
- fit2rule 12y agoI think there is definitely a growing segment of people who do not want to contribute to the growing surveillance of their lives, but nevertheless do want to have a way to share their data and details with whoever they want, with trust, at a personal level. I know a few families, for example, who are now using their own social-media apps built by family members, and for which there is no outside access - yet they have their own network, trust system, shared media and data, and so on. It is completely within their control. So there are people out there for whom Ori and its peer technologies are very important. Not everybody wants to just genuflect in front of the ultra-corporate ruler(s). Its quite possible to continue using computers unhindered by third parties; tools like Ori assist that - technologically as well as culturally. Get all your friends on their own p2p networks.
- quchen 12y agoI don't see any end-user documentation (only a short building section). Is this not a release, but the project's "work in progress" page?
- fit2rule 12y agoYeah, I would have to say that Ori has the worst documentation ever. Except, this is pretty useful: http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp13/papers/p151-mashtizadeh.pdf http://sigops.org/sosp/sosp13/papers/p151-mashtizadeh.pdf
- Karlozkiller 12y agoYou could always run 'man ori' to see some end-user documentation. I agree that it would be nice with some documentation on the home page but man is nice if you found none.
- aristidb 12y agoThis is pretty cool stuff, but when I tried it in mid-2014 (release 0.8.1), there were stability issues with orifs, and the user interface was rather confusing. Quite possibly these issues are resolved now, as I see there have been new commits again from October onwards.
- biggot_man 12y agoC++ sucks
- BozeWolf 12y agoLooks kind of interesting to me. How does it compare to use a git repo as a "decentralized file store"? What is the speed of this thing.. I see it uses fuse, which generally isnt that fast. Speed probably isnt a goal, but none the less important. To make this a succes, docs should be available. Now it feels like a research project to me.
- BozeWolf 12y agoI quickly scrolled through the paper a few people mentioned earlier. About speed:An evaluation shows that as a local file system, Ori has low overhead compared to a File system in User Space (FUSE) loopback driver; as a network file system, Ori over a WAN outperforms NFS over a LAN. Interesting. Git is mentioned as well. I guess i have to read the paper after i finished cleaning the house ;)
- zvikara 12y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7072492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7072492
- kobigurk 12y agoHallowed are the Ori
- dpogg1 12y agoCame in to post this. Thank you.
- UserRights 12y agoTo the authors: please add immediately accessible documentation, best in form of a 'Quick Start' document. Also please add one page to your website that you call 'Features' where you describe what it can do / can not do and add another page to your site that you call 'Documentation' where you put the USER DOCUMENTATION. No, nobody wants to read a paper to get some sync software up and running. THANKS!
- ollifi 12y agoI have not looked into this much yet, but I think comparing it to Dropbox etc. like many are in here is silly. There is a huge amount of use cases where people work with large amounts of shared data in lan environments over nfs and such. This is very much tied to location and becomes a bit tricky to make offline, remote, conflict proof. Something like git can support distributed workflows in work groups, but it only works with light weight data and needs pretty educated users. I think programmes under appreciate how horrible it still is to work together with others using computers.
- gaalze 12y agowho the fuck is this for?
- jacob019 12y agoMy company has three offices. We have about 200GB of shared storage. We often need to access and write files that are 10-20MB in size. Currently we have a centralized file server at the main office and a VPN. Using the file server at the main office is a pleasure, using it from the other two offices is slow. I am looking for a stable distributed filesystem, so that I can have a full copy of the data on a server at each of the three locations. I wish to share between each server and it's local clients via both NFS and Samba. Clients should be able to read and write to their local server, and the three servers should collaborate to keep all their data in sync. Can Ori offer this? Something else?
- __david__ 12y agoIt sounds like it might work (caveat: I haven't tried it yet). The best info I could find on it was this paper[1]. It gives some command line examples, explains how the data model works (spoiler: it's similar to git) and provides some benchmarks. The NFS comparison benchmarks were very interesting (generally faster over a WAN than NFS is over a LAN). [1] http://dl.acm.org/ft_gateway.cfm?id=2522721&ftid=1403940&dwn=1 http://dl.acm.org/ft_gateway.cfm?id=2522721&ftid=1403940&dwn...
- jacob019 12y agoThanks for the link. "Ori over a WAN outperforms NFS over a LAN" that's a ridiculous claim, maybe if you ignore bandwidth. I might have to give this a shot though. I hope it's stable.
- gvb 12y agoI tried it ~2 weeks ago and was unable to figure out how to get it to synchronize across multiple computers as promised (could have been operator error or documentation lack). I also had a few times where I dismounted the virtual file system (or maybe not) and ended up with a repository that was in a broken state with an error message that said fixing it was not implemented yet. I've also played with SparkleShare, which has been working well in my very limited testing. The downside is that it is written in .net which has a large footprint (pre-paid if you are in the Microsoft world). With SparkleShare, I'm using my own git repositories (gitolite) which works well but requires some hand editing of the configuration file to make it work.
- vbit 12y agoUsually I want only a subset of my synchronized data on my phone. Can I set this up so all my data is synced to my nas but only some to my phone?
- logician76 12y agoReminds me of Brad Fitzpatrick's camlistore http://camlistore.org http://camlistore.org