3 ms·
I think it's important to consider that maybe scientists aren't worth paying that much. The average scientist is probably moving society forward, but I'm not s
by dnautics 12y ago
I think it's important to consider that maybe scientists aren't worth paying that much. The average scientist is probably moving society forward, but I'm not so sure the median scientist is. Having been to a 'top 10' PhD program in a 'hard science' (chemistry), I am not sure 75% of the professors there were worth a dime. I am not sure 50% of the thesis defenses were, either (mine included).
This is in contrast to the doorman example, or in my case, being a Lyft driver (which pays more than being a postdoc). Every night, I help society out by providing a service that someone wants, and if you want to be more abstract, by keeping drunk people off the road.
I was able to raise $56,000 for an experiment in anticancer research. That doesn't seem like much (it isn't) but in retrospect it's about right. I asked for money for one experiment, and that's what I got. It doesn't pay my salary, but I probably don't deserve it (yet) until I've proven myself at least at one stage. Drug development is risky, why should society pay much more than the bare minimum to get it done?
- acgourley 12y agoI too have had interactions with academics I don't think society is benefiting from. I think it's important to say out loud - maybe we need less research scientists and when we do that we might work on more important areas with slightly better funding.
- emodendroket 12y agoIs this any less true for the median lawyer or doctor or office worker or any other profession you care to name which involves more than the most basic skills?
- dnautics 12y agoincreasingly doctors and lawyers are coming up against this professionalism/credentialism creep.
- emodendroket 12y agoI suppose my point is that it's not as though having some people be more capable than others is unique to science; it does not seem to be much of an excuse to pay scientists less.
- dnautics 12y agoit's a supply/demand issue. The supply is high. The demand (in this case the price willing to be paid) is tempered by the fact that in most cases what you hire is going to be mediocre.
- noobiemcfoob 12y agoYour Lyft example is exactly the point of this article, and many other comments here. Science, specifically academic pursuits, is not something that can be quantized in the now. The scientific work that enables us to live our lives, that enables that very Lyft app to function, wasn't made last month or even last year. These technologies are based on fundamental theories developed 30 or more years ago (centuries if you want to count the basic electronic theory that's enabled circuits). Scientific research has practically $0 value in the now, but it is nigh impossible to say what value any specific scientist's work will have in 50 years. It is for that reason that science and its practitioners need to be seen as public service/benefit, not a business commodity. They aren't even playing the same game as CEOs
- dsp1234 12y agoThis reminds me of a Quora answer[0] about what Mathematics graduate students do all day. "And, indeed, you are lucky! After a hundred years or so, your idea (along with a bunch of other ideas) leads to the development of aquarium air pumps, an essential tool in the rapidly growing field of research on artificial goldfish habitats. Yay!" [0] - https://www.quora.com/What-do-grad-students-in-math-do-all-day https://www.quora.com/What-do-grad-students-in-math-do-all-d...
- dnautics 12y agoand because there's effectively no accountability, it's ripe to be gamed with fraud and cronyism. Although it is not a business commodity. The knee-jerk reaction of the 20th century is to fund public benefit causes using the government, but that's especially irresponsible when there is no accountability. It's a problem compounded by diminishing returns on science (low hanging fruit has been picked) creating a greater demand on money, a top-down funding structure, and nationalistic measuring contests. None of these are conducive to good science being done. There is a demand for science. People like contributing to something bigger than themselves. Just, the demand may not be as big as we 'hope for it to be'. But 'get it done now' might not be the best approach to some parts of science... Often times discoveries that were a total schlep to get through become nearly trivialized, shortly after discovery, by an orthogonal set of technical enablements.
- api 12y agoThat's like saying you can dispense with all the members of a football team except the star players. Science is an exploratory discipline. You don't know what's most valuable until you've got the benefit of often 20-50 years of hindsight.
- person_1987 12y agoNo, it isn't like saying that. It is saying that you can't expect all the players on the football team to collect the same salary as the star players, which incidentally is exactly what happens.
- noobiemcfoob 12y agoBut that misses the point too. The star researchers aren't standing on just their own work. They are able to pull off what they do because of all the other researchers in their field. A researchers work is largely dependent not just on advances in related fields, but in their colleagues incrementally advancing their own ideas. Eventually an all-star may envision and pull off a way of combining all those advances previously unseen, but it still requires those advances to have been made in the first place. That's how science advances, not by individual genius, but by the collective ability of the field. Even if 70% of the field aren't doing groundbreaking work, the work they are doing allows the other 30% to focus on the groundbreaking things.
- dnautics 12y ago> "The star researchers aren't standing on just their own work. They are able to pull off what they do because of all the other researchers in their field." It's more like they are able to pull off what they do in spite of all the other researchers. (that are spawning off bad hypotheses, producing fraud, using up precious grant money, etc.)
- person_1987 12y agoIn my own experiences I've found that to be mostly a myth. Most researchers are too focused on grants, running labs, etc to actually get proper collaboration and support done. It seems the "good researchers" who are actually worth paying have built a career from advancing their one topic from day one, lone wolf style. Probably 50% of that non-groundbreaking work you mention is completely worthless, and the field grew in spite of those wasted resources, as dnautics says. Even then, if the system was honest with individuals about their science abilities (not everyone can be a superstar), then there would be much benefit in preventing these people from advancing on their own in a broken system, and giving them the opportunity to have an actual job in the groundbreaking areas as a tech or such.
- letitgo12345 12y agoScience is a very stochastic process though. Yes, not a lot of research is eventually useful but that's because chance can play a huge role. If the success rate is 1%, then investing less will not necessarily increase the success rate. It will decrease the absolute rate of discovery.
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoWhy is the median utility a better point estimate of scientific effectiveness than the expected value?