3 ms·
How many driveways does your residence have? You're fighting a pretty tough natural monopoly to get multiple sets of competing wires. That we have both copper
by mindslight 12y ago
How many driveways does your residence have?
You're fighting a pretty tough natural monopoly to get multiple sets of competing wires. That we have both copper and coax is a relic from the days where they could each only carry specific type of signal.
A form of competition could be fostered by making the wire layers into utilities that wholesale to transit providers. However, it already is this way on the telco side. In most areas, there is little third party interest for investing in competing transit networks, so the ILEC is left as the only provider. Perhaps there would be more interest if latest gen technologies were (de)regulated in the same way, but that undermines investment in new physical wires.
- sitkack 12y agoMost people don't need wires. In a normal density neighborhood, wireless on the pole would serve most people's needs. I am absolutely in favor of the last mile being owned by the people and ISPs competing for services and bandwidth. That also means that cross town traffic would be extremely low cost (free or a couple bucks a month).
- mindslight 12y agoWireless in a neighborhood doesn't really address the problem, as you still have to backhaul from there. (And most people would be fine investing in wire from house to pole if they could switch it between providers without digging). I'm all for community networks, but top-down "federal" policy will never prescribe them.
- sitkack 12y agoI was just pushing a specific technological solution for the last mile that is a little cheaper. Yes, a wired connection to every location would be great, but 80% of my neighbors don't need that. In Seattle we just rolled out an LED streetlight replacement project, it would have been an excellent time to have installed the hardware for city wide mesh network. Power, placement and line-of-site are there at the top of a street light.
- jpwgarrison 12y agoThey did roll out a mesh network here in Seattle. The problem was that it was police only, and scared everyone. I think they mothballed it till we all forget. I found the controversy mildly funny as the public got up to speed on how WIFI works. I am personally more concerned about private businesses tracking my MAC around the store, which is already pervasive - but not eough to bother turning off WIFI... http://www.komonews.com/news/local/Police-deactivating-controversial-WiFi-network-in-Seattle-231692161.html http://www.komonews.com/news/local/Police-deactivating-contr...
- thirdtruck 12y agoI think the more fitting comparison would be this: How many roads does your driveway open onto? Just one, right? Now, would you rather that be a public and regulated road, or a private road where the road owner can set up a tollbooth at the end of the driveway and even charge you extra for driving a Toyota instead of a Ford?
- baldfat 12y agoLook at UK. The wire is owned by a third party that rents the use of the wires for your service. So we only need one fiber and one copper wire. P.S. I live int he city I don't have a drive way the street is my park lot :)
- snowwrestler 12y agoInterest in CLEC DSL fell off because interest in DSL fell off in general. It just can't compete with cable or fiber for bandwidth. If the coax and/or fiber lines were open to competitive carriers, I bet there would be quite a bit of interest.
- mindslight 12y agoOf course, one can make the argument that fibre would never have privately been built out if it were subject to sharing rules. It would be great if individual communities built out in infrastructure mode, but that push has to come locally because it's never coming from corrupt DC. Pragmatically, I'm still a huge fan of DSL (thanks to Sonic.net/Omsoft). I haven't even kept aware of what the bigcable caps are looking like these days, but I've had many months where I've done >1TB over ADSL2+ (one third of my available bandwidth).