15 ms·
Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicated'? [video]
- PuercoPop 12y agoThis appears to be a presentation of part of the work of VPRI[0], you should check it out, they made a whole OS and the (word processor, PDF viewer, Web Browser, etc) in under 20K lines of code. There is more info on: http://www.vpri.org/vp_wiki/index.php/Main_Page http://www.vpri.org/vp_wiki/index.php/Main_Page Besides Nile, the parser OMeta is pretty cool to imho.
- renox 12y ago> you should check it out, they made a whole OS and the (word processor, PDF viewer, Web Browser, etc) in under 20K lines of code. Check it out? Where is the source code for the OS? I haven't found it in the link you gave..
- david927 12y agoA doctor told a programmer friend once, "I have to fix problems that God gave us. You have to fix problems you give yourselves."
- adamnemecek 12y agoThat doctor sounds a bit like an arrogant douche.
- binarytrees 12y agoa tip of that hat
- thirsteh 12y ago"It's not exactly brain surgery, is it?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THNPmhBl-8I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=THNPmhBl-8I
- _lce0 12y agoI wonder if the teams at NASA, working on rocket science says "it's not rocket science, you know"
- singlow 12y agoI have a relative who works for Raytheon as a physicist on rocket systems. Whenever he tells be about a dumb mistake he had to fix, he always uses that expression.. followed by, "Oh wait, I guess it is."
- randlet 12y agoTo be fair, doctors are often fixing problems we've created ourselves too.
- a_dutch_guy 12y agoGod on HN? Come on, the world isn't flat anymore.
- jacquesm 12y agoYou don't have to take that literally in order to understand it, but just in case you really missed the point: the doctor is essentially saying that he is dealing with problems that have no direct cause or architect that he can consult whereas the IT people have essentially only themselves to blame and have made the mess they're in (usually) rather than that it has been handed down to them through the mists of time or from above. In a general sense that is true but in a more specific sense it is definitely possible to be handed a project without docs and horrible problems and it might as well be an organic problem. Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity.
- a_dutch_guy 12y agoOf course I am not taking it literally. But he does mention God. Being a technical guy Stephen Hawking makes much more sense to me than God.
- iamcreasy 12y ago> Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity. Well said.
- dasil003 12y ago> Even so, the simplest biology dwarfs the largest IT systems in complexity. And also mercifully in continuous real-world testing over time with no Big Rewrite to be seen. While an individual organism might have unsolvable problems, nature doesn't have the same tolerance for utterly intractable systems that we sometimes see in the software community.
- justathrow2k 12y agoOh, look, someone who has proven that God doesn't exist. Please, post the proof for all of us to see.
- lucozade 12y agoWith my 2015 budget and 2015 requirements, I'm going to need a few miracles.
- navan 12y agoIn a way both are fixing bugs created by someone else.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- ploxiln 12y agoMy mother, a family practitioner, sometimes gets a patient which is on 15 or so different medications, all prescribed by different specialists at different times. She whittles it down to 3 or 4, and they get a lot better.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoMy doctor for one, would benefit most from fixing his own basic problems than from dwelling on God or what problems God has given us, but like most doctors he pretends to solve big problems while saying pretentious things. I'm just saying you'd expect these doctor types to have the greater powers of analysis, but in my experience they just pretend harder. [Edit to remove that off putting stuff]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- andrewchambers 12y agoThat doctor is wrong. All human problems are caused by the constraints of our physical world.
- dredmorbius 12y agoEspecially gross oversimplifications of reality and absolute statements.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y agoThat's why God endows them with greater analytical prowess.
- sivers 12y agoVery interesting related talk about complecting things - "Simple Made Easy" - by Rich Hickey, inventor of Clojure: http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy If you're a Ruby person, maybe watch this version instead, since it's almost the same talk but for a Rails Conference, with a few references: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rI8tNMsozo0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rI8tNMsozo0
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Bootvis 12y agoTo add a third reason: to save it and view it later.
- Strilanc 12y agoProbably. or they may have already seen it, or be able to tell from the first part that it deserves an upvote. I'm not sure I have a problem with the behavior. The new links page cycles so fast that watching the whole video before upvoting would result in the post not making it to the front page.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- msane 12y agoThere was an alan kay video on the front page yesterday.
- msutherl 12y agoI don't think I've ever upvoted after reading/watching what's been shared. I normally upvote, if at all, prior to clicking, otherwise I would never remember.
- bhuga 12y agoI always watch conference talks at double speed, speaker speed permitting. Alan Kay's voice works fine. (But I didn't upvote, and your question is valid)
- dang 12y agoName recognition seems to encourage reflexive upvoting, which is one reason we often take names out of titles. We've removed "Alan Kay" from this one. (Nothing personal—we're fans.)
- ad_hominem 12y agoSee also "No Silver Bullet — Essence and Accidents of Software Engineering"[1] by Fred Brooks wherein "essential complexity" vs "accidental complexity" is explored. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Silver_Bullet
- ecesena 12y agoMy prof. of calculus once said that complex doesn't mean complicated, yet more group/set/combination. He clearly didn't use any of these terms as all have a specific meaning in Maths (but I don't have any better translation from Italian). I believe it's very true for complex numbers, and I'm trying to keep the same distinction in real life as well. So, for me, complex means putting together more things in a smart way to have a more clear -not more complicated- explanation/solution.
- htor 12y agoThis video is very interesting. Very good point about the manufacturing of processors being backwards. Why _not_ put an interpreter inside the L1 cache that accomodates higher level programming of the computer? Why are we still stuck with assembly as the interface to the CPU?
- valarauca1 12y agoThis should answer your question. Albeit satirically but the context is very solid [1]. Basically like most forms of engineering, making processors is hard. [1] https://www.usenix.org/system/files/1309_14-17_mickens.pdf https://www.usenix.org/system/files/1309_14-17_mickens.pdf
- frik 12y agoWe had already Lisp running directly on a CPU: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisp_machine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lisp_machine Java runs directly on hardware: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_processor http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_processor , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_Card http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Java_Card Pascal MicroEngine: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal_MicroEngine http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pascal_MicroEngine And some more: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:High-level_language_computer_architecture http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:High-level_language_co... And the x86 instruction set is CISC, but (modern) x86 architecture is RISC (inside) - so your modern Intel/AMD CPU already does it. http://stackoverflow.com/questions/13071221/is-x86-risc-or-cisc http://stackoverflow.com/questions/13071221/is-x86-risc-or-c... Backward compatibility aside, we could have CPUs that support a ANSI C or the upcoming Rust directly in hardware, instead of ASM.
- vezzy-fnord 12y agoDon't forget the Burroughs B5000, from 1961: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burroughs_large_systems#B5000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burroughs_large_systems#B5000 The fact that we had an architecture running entirely on ALGOL with no ASM as far back as 54 years ago, is quite astonishing, followed by depressing.
- nilkn 12y agoI think there's an unfortunate trend throughout a lot of human activity to make things complicated. The prototypical example in my mind has always been the Monty Hall problem, where you often see convoluted explanations or detailed probabilistic calculations, but the solution is just plain as it can be when you consider that if you switch you win iff you chose a goat and if you stay you win iff you chose the car. I've also always been a fan of Feynman's assertion that we haven't really understood something until it can be explained in a freshman lecture. At the end of his life he gave a now famous explanation of QED that required almost no mathematics and yet was in fact quite an accurate representation of the theory.
- marvy 12y agoOk, that is the best Monty Hall explanation I've ever heard.
- jodrellblank 12y agocar: switch and lose. Goat: switch and win. Is OK as far as it goes, but it's not enough explanation to cover why you should switch. You need probability in the explanation because of the two goats/one car choice in part one .. and here I am trying to explain it again. You already know how it works, but you don't see that your explanation of it doesn't explain it. After they removed one answer, you have more information... Because the choice isn't balanced... If it was as simple as you suggest, it wouldn't make a good part of a game show. Everyone would see straight through it.
- Lost_BiomedE 12y agoIt always seemed a bit easy to me without running through probabilities due to the fact that the game show host was forced to choose goat (which is different depending on where the car is). The idea of a forced non-random choice is more clear to me than a probability explanation, but you need probability to demonstrate a proof.
- cbd1984 12y ago> The prototypical example in my mind has always been the Monty Hall problem, where you often see convoluted explanations or detailed probabilistic calculations, but the solution is just plain as it can be when you consider that if you switch you win iff you chose a goat and if you stay you win iff you chose the car. The problem here is, when two people disagree, they both think the problem is simple and they both think their answer is trivial. The thing is, they haven't solved the same problem. In the standard formulation, where switching is the best strategy, Monty's actions are not random: He always knows which door has the good prize ("A new car!") and which doors have the bad prize ("A goat.") and he'll never pick the door with the good prize. If you hear a statement of the problem, or perhaps a slight misstatement of the problem, and conclude that Monty is just as in the dark as you are on which door hides which prize and just happened to have picked one of the goat-concealing doors, then switching confers no advantage. A large part of simplicity is knowing enough to state the problem accurately, which circles back to your paragraph about Feynman: Understanding his initial understanding of QED required understanding everything he knew which lead him to his original understanding of the problem QED solved; for his final formulation of QED, he understood the problems in terms of more fundamental concepts, and could therefore solve them using those same concepts.
- samspot 12y ago15 minutes in, I am finding this talk to be slow and unfocused. I assume this is getting a lot of promoters because we all agree with the theme?
- bbcbasic 12y agoSeeing the 1:42:51 length scared me at first. That's going to take me days to get through given how much free time I have per day! Anyway best bit is to skim through bits of it. It is all interesting and good but I do prefer it when he talks about code.
- dredmorbius 12y agoThis is where I find 1) downloading the video and 2) playing it back using a local media player to be vastly superior to viewing online. I can squeeze the window down to a small size (400px presently), speed it up (150%), start and stop it at will, zoom to full screen, and _not_ have to figure out where in a stack of browser windows and tabs it is. Pretty much the point I was making some time back where I got in a tiff with a documentary creator for D/L'ing his video from Vimeo (its browser player has pants UI/UX in terms of scanning back and forth -- the site switches videos rather than advances/retreats through the actual video you're watching). And then as now I maintain: users control presentation, once you've released your work you're letting your baby fly. Insisting that people use it only how you see fit is infantile itself, and ultimately futile. (Fitting with my Vanity theme above).
- yazaddaruvala 12y agoP.S. In Chrome I can play almost all Youtube videos at 2x speed. Most presentations are still very understandable. I've been doing this for a while, maybe start at 1.5x. Anyways, just a tip. Its saved me hours and keeps slow speakers from getting boring.
- TheBiv 12y agoI have made it to 31 min in, and I genuinely think he made this talk too complicated.
- bbcbasic 12y agoHa ha I skipped through until he started talking about code again. Go back and do that!
- serve_yay 12y agoWell, we made it complicated because one must complicate pure things to make them real. I guess things would be better if our code ran on some hypothetically better CPU than what Intel makes. But "actually existing in the world" is a valuable property too. Plato was pretty cool, though, I agree.
- ozten 12y agoSo the "frank" system, which he uses throughout the presentation is real enough to browse the internet and author active essays in. It is written in 1000x less code than Powerpoint running on Windows 7.
- zackmorris 12y agoOne of the key points of the talk happens around the 32-37 minute mark, comparing the crew sizes of various ships. He makes the point that the core of development is really putting together the requirements, not writing code. Unfortunately we've put nearly all of the resources of our industry into engineering rather than science (tactics rather than strategies). What he stated very succinctly is that a supercomputer can work out the tactics when provided a strategy, so why are we doing this all by hand? That’s as far as I’ve gotten in the video so far but I find it kind of haunting that I already know what he’s talking about (brute force, simulated annealing, genetic algorithms, and other simple formulas that evolve a solution) and that these all run horribly on current hardware but are trivial to run on highly parallelized CPUs like the kind that can be built with FPGAs. They also would map quite well to existing computer networks, a bit like SETI@home. Dunno about anyone else, but nearly the entirety of what I do is a waste of time, and I know it, deep down inside. That’s been a big factor in bouts with depression over the years and things like imposter syndrome. I really quite despise the fact that I’m more of a translator between the spoken word and computer code than an engineer, architect or even craftsman. Unfortunately I follow the money for survival, but if it weren’t for that, I really feel that I could be doing world-class work for what basically amounts to room and board. I wonder if anyone here feels the same…
- jpgvm 12y agoSoftware is a force multiplier. If the initial force is headed towards uselessness software won't save it from it's fate, it will in fact just get it there faster. By the same token if you manage to write some software that is magnifying a force of good the results can be staggering. Software allows us to accomplish more net effect in our lifetimes than was ever possible before. However if we spend our time writing glorified forms over and over again we aren't going to live up to that.
- keithpeter 12y ago"...I’m more of a translator between the spoken word and computer code..." At our current level of technology and business sophistication, that strikes me as a hard enough problem to justify a career with good compensation. Any patterns you are noticing in the translation process?
- rndn 12y agoAround the 31 minute mark, shouldn't the gear and biology analogies be the other way around (biological systems being analogous to bloated software), or am I missing something?
- rndn 12y agoOh, the tactics should be realized by biological systems rather than by manual "brick stacking" of technical systems?
- andrey-g 12y agoWhat was he talking about at 51:45? Pseudo timer?
- dgreensp 12y agoPseudo-time -- I think he's talking about something called Croquet. There's a trail here: http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/2021/ http://lambda-the-ultimate.org/node/2021/
- e12e 12y agoTeaTime is very interesting: http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1094861&dl=ACM&coll=DL&CFID=470663128&CFTOKEN=18653614 http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=1094861&dl=ACM&coll=DL&CFI...
- raspasov 12y agoPeople that enjoyed this talk should check this out http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy
- WoodenChair 12y agoPeople in this thread who seem to be asserting that building for the Web as opposed to native apps is an example of how things should be "less complex" perhaps have never written for both platforms... Also the entire argument completely misses the point of the lecture.
- ankurdhama 12y agoI think those people are just suggesting that we should be writing apps and NOT android app, ios app, windows app, linux app etc etc.
- rimantas 12y agowe will do that once there is just OS, not android, ios, windows, linux, etc. And no, web does not fit as a substitute for common OS.
- tdicola 12y agoWow, this is a really great presentation that resonates a lot with me.
- 3minus1 12y agoAlan Kaye seems to enjoy making asinine statements. "Teachers are taught science as a religion" "Romans had the best cement ever made" "We live in the century where the great art forms are the merging of science and engineering" There's also a kind of arrogance when he shits on intel and djikstra that I find off-putting.
- anfedorov 12y agoOnly familiar with one of them, but "teachers are taught science as a religion" seems spot-on.
- 3minus1 12y agoI disagree. Teaching science as a series of facts is in no way akin to religious indoctrination. Edit: And Kaye is also ignoring the fact that every high school science curriculum covers the scientific method and includes hands on experimentation.
- e12e 12y agoYou've never seen how students too often get better grades on "perfect" science experiments than on honest reports of "failures" (experment differed from expected outcome)? You must've been in an elite high school.
- 3minus1 12y agoThat actually did happen to me sometimes. I don't think you can convince me that there's anything religious about it.
- david927 12y agoKay, not Kaye. Roman concrete is universally considered superior to modern concrete.
- 3minus1 12y ago
- Jugurtha 12y agoStill no love for Heaviside and Poincaré? :(
- stevebmark 12y agoI'm 15 minutes in and frankly I'm finding the video hard to follow. Is there an article that accompanies this that might help summarize his points?
- DonHopkins 12y agoSomeone asked Alan Kay an excellent question about the iPad, and his answer is so interesting that I'll transcribe here. To his credit, he handled the questioner's faux pas much more gracefully than how RMS typically responds to questions about Linux and Open Source. ;) Questioner: So you came up with the DynaPad -- Alan Kay: DynaBook. Questioner: DynaBook! Yes, I'm sorry. Which is mostly -- you know, we've got iPads and all these tablet computers now. But does it tick you off that we can't even run Squeak on it now? Alan Kay: Well, you can... Q: Yea, but you've got to pay Apple $100 bucks just to get a developer's license. Alan Kay: Well, there's a variety of things. See, I'll tell you what does tick me off, though. Basically two things. The number one thing is, yeah, you can run Squeak, and you can run the eToys version of Squeak on it, so children can do things. But Apple absolutely forbids any child from putting a creation of theirs to the internet, and forbids any other child in the world from downloading that creation. That couldn't be any more anti-personal-computing if you tried. That's what ticks me off. Then the lesser thing is that the user interface on the iPad is so bad. Because they went for the lowest common denominator. I actually have a nice slide for that, which shows a two-year-old kid using an iPad, and an 85-year-old lady using an iPad. And then the next thing shows both of them in walkers. Because that's what Apple has catered to: they've catered to the absolute extreme. But in between, people, you know, when you're two or three, you start using crayons, you start using tools. And yeah, you can buy a capacitive pen for the iPad, but where do you put it? So there's no place on the iPad for putting that capacitive pen. So Apple, in spite of the fact of making a pretty good touch sensitive surface, absolutely has no thought of selling to anybody who wants to learn something on it. And again, who cares? There's nothing wrong with having something that is brain dead, and only shows ordinary media. The problem is that people don't know it's brain dead. And so it's actually replacing computers that can actually do more for children. And to me, that's anti-ethical. My favorite story in the Bible is the one of Esau. Esau came back from hunting, and his brother Joseph was cooking up a pot of soup. And Esau said "I'm hungry, I'd like a cup of soup." And Joseph said "Well, I'll give it to you for your birth right." And Esau was hungry, so he said "OK". That's humanity. Because we're constantly giving up what's most important just for mere convenience, and not realizing what the actual cost is. So you could blame the schools. I really blame Apple, because they know what they're doing. And I blame the schools because they haven't taken the trouble to know what they're doing over the last 30 years. But I blame Apple more for that. I spent a lot of -- just to get things like Squeak running, and other systems like Scratch running on it, took many phone calls between me and Steve, before he died. I spent -- you know, he and I used to talk on the phone about once a month, and I spent a long -- and it was clear that he was not in control of the company any more. So he got one little lightning bolt down to allow people to put interpreters on, but not enough to allow interpretations to be shared over the internet. So people do crazy things like attaching things into mail. But that's not the same as finding something via search in a web browser. So I think it's just completely messed up. You know, it's the world that we're in. It's a consumer world where the consumers are thought of as serfs, and only good enough to provide money. Not good enough to learn anything worthwhile.
- m_mueller 12y agoThis talk blows everything out of the water. It's like the current culmination of the work from Douglas Engelbart to Bret Victor. Maybe just maybe there could be a rebirth of personal computing coming out of this research, it looks at least promising and ready for use - as demonstrated by Kay.
- mpweiher 12y ago>It's like the current culmination of the work from Douglas Engelbart to Bret Victor. This is no coincidence. "Silicon Valley will be in trouble when it runs out of Doug Engelbarts ideas" -- Alan Kay Bret works for Alan now, as far as I know.
- m_mueller 12y agoI've noticed that in his talk. Easily looks like the most prestigious CS R&D lab in the world right now.
- jamesfisher 12y agoAround 51:40 he talks about how semaphores are a bad idea, and says that something called "pseudotime" was a much better idea but which never caught on. What is this "pseudotime"? Google turns up nothing. Am I mis-hearing what he said?
- scotty79 12y agoDo you know of any languages that you could use to specify precisely what a program should do? Can you use that specification to verify if a program does what it should? I know BDD taken to extremes kinda does that. But could a specification be verified if it's non-contradictory and perhaps some other interesting things like where are its edges that it does not cover?