3 ms·
"Now this method of "business" is only possible if the government continues to allow these crooked insurance contracts to be written in secret, allows them to h
by Tichy 17y ago
"Now this method of "business" is only possible if the government continues to allow these crooked insurance contracts to be written in secret, allows them to hold little or no money in reserve for payment "
This is what I don't understand. Why is the government responsible? Shouldn't the buyer of an insurance make sure that they are getting their money's worth? If the insurance is not transparent enough, it is just another reason not to buy.
- vlod 17y agoIt's not insurance. It's a credit default swap which is a financial instrument and AFAIK not regulated as much as insurance. Insurance is really the wrong word, even though the article uses it. I'm not sure how nobody is going after the credit rating agencies. They're the ones that rate how stable a bank is.
- cwan 17y agoAll forms of insurance are financial instruments. Not all forms of insurance are as regulated. Premiums are another word for savings/downpayments for some potential future payout. Insurance is an appropriate word for credit default swaps - as it is insuring against the default on a given loan. In this case, I have my doubts as to how significant the role CDS's played in the crisis in the first place given that after they were all netted out, the actual size of the market was nowhere near the initial scare numbers put out in the press. Here's a decent overview of how the market works: http://www.wilmott.com/blogs/satyajitdas/index.cfm/2009/4/12/Credit-Default-Swaps--Through-The-Looking-Glass http://www.wilmott.com/blogs/satyajitdas/index.cfm/2009/4/12... More here: http://seekingalpha.com/article/138047-how-cds-spreads-affect-equity?source=yahoo http://seekingalpha.com/article/138047-how-cds-spreads-affec... In the aftermath I figure we'll probably find that the much larger issue was in the debt markets and fears of the underlying asset values related to subprime cascaded down to other loans.
- vlod 17y agoNo credit defaults swaps are NOT insurance they are a swap. They can be used to hedge 'bets' as options can be used to hedge positions. Heres a link: http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/07/04/why-insurance-commissioners-should-not-regulate-cds/ http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2009/07/04/why-insuran...
- cwan 17y agoYou're arguing over semantics. Insurance is about making bets. Life insurance? You bet you're going to die, your insurer bets you won't die that soon. From the link you provided: "Many swaps can be thought of as being like an insurance contract, should one be so inclined." Just because you call it insurance, doesn't mean that insurance commissioners should regulate it as such. Just as insurance commissioners shouldn't regulate financial options even though they can also be used conservatively as insurance against given financial risk as much as wild financial bets.
- vlod 17y agoAs wikipedia says, with insurance there has to be a debt obligation. With CDS there is none. i.e I can't buy life insurance on you, but I could (potentially) buy a CDS that covers me if you declare bankruptcy. Maybe CDS 'should' be regulated as insurance but thats for another day. :) Anyway.. for those that are interested.. From: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_default_swap http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_default_swap CDS contracts have been compared with insurance, because the buyer pays a premium and, in return, receives a sum of money if one of the events specified in the contract occurs. However, there are a number of differences between CDS and insurance, for example: - The buyer of a CDS does not need to own the underlying security or other form of credit exposure; in fact the buyer does not even have to suffer a loss from the default event.[1][2][3][4] In contrast, to purchase insurance, the insured is generally expected to have an insurable interest such as owning a debt obligation; -the seller need not be a regulated entity; -the seller is not required to maintain any reserves to pay off buyers, although major CDS dealers are subject to bank capital requirements; -insurers manage risk primarily by setting loss reserves based on the Law of large numbers, while dealers in CDS manage risk primarily by means of offsetting CDS (hedging) with other dealers and transactions in underlying bond markets; -in the United States CDS contracts are generally subject to mark to market accounting, introducing income statement and balance sheet volatility that would not be present in an insurance contract; Hedge Accounting may not be available under US Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) unless the requirements of FAS 133 are met. In practice this rarely happens.
- jimbokun 17y ago"Shouldn't the buyer of an insurance make sure that they are getting their money's worth?" That's similar to placing the responsibility on the buyer of a gallon of milk to make sure it has not been poisoned.
- Tichy 17y agoIs it? Poisoned milk is not the same as milk, so selling poisoned milk as milk would be fraud (among other things). Of course fraud should be illegal. But it should be possible to sell something that has risk attached. Of course claiming it has no risk would be fraud again, but I think that would be covered with current laws.
- jimbokun 17y ago"Of course fraud should be illegal." This applies very well to the insurance business. If you are promising to pay a certain amount if a certain event happens, then it turns out you did not actually put away any money to pay out, that's a pretty straightforward case of fraud. With milk, the government has decided to put processes in place to keep milk that could sicken or kill people off the shelf, instead of just letting the survivors of people killed by poisoned milk sue after the fact. Regulating the financial industry is the same idea, make sure companies have enough assets to pay off their obligations, for example.