3 ms·
Having designed a decentralized social networking system, I have become firmly convinced that - unlike bitcoin - it actually helps to have a server for each con
by EGreg 12y ago
Having designed a decentralized social networking system, I have become firmly convinced that - unlike bitcoin - it actually helps to have a server for each conversstion, in order to both have efficiency in the network topology as well as much more easily implement things people har come to expect, such as fair message ordering and no client able to mess up the others in a conversation. Mental poker is possible but clients still need to trust each other. May as well designate one as a server then.
The CAP theorem is likewise addressed by partitioning all the messages by conversation. There is little need for total consistency between conversations, only within them.
If you want me to elaborate further, you have to email me because there's too much to say.
- e12e 12y ago[Edit: never mind, I think I misread what you were saying - you're also advocating one "client"/participant to be on a dedicated "server" (aka daemon on a well-connected/always connected host? Leaving the rest as it might have some value either way for those considering conference solutions and topologies...] You're commenting on the parts about authentication? Because I don't see how setting up some dsl subscriber (or 4g mobile client) in (say) Japan is going to be very helpful in splitting two dozen 720p video streams across the global Internet for a modest multi-user video conference. Never mind the issues with the connection dropping for everyone if the designated "server" experience network (or other) issues..? The original Planetside game from SOE bundled TeamSpeak (which is not p2p, but client-through-central-gateway/server) - but the bundled version was pretty much unusable in part because it meant one player hosted the server. Worked fine with a dedicated TeamsSpeak server (eg on a vps etc). For many uses I can also see optional recording of conferences might be useful - but that could probaly be accommodated using a dedicated recording client (probably on a "server").