9 ms·
This speaks to the patent system being so far perverted from its original purpose that I feel it's time to seriously begin considering if we want to support it
by Karunamon 12y ago
This speaks to the patent system being so far perverted from its original purpose that I feel it's time to seriously begin considering if we want to support it in any form. Are patents in 2015 being used more for "promoting the useful arts"[1] or more as a weapon for large enterprises to use against their large and small competition?
This same broken-ness applies to another system of legal monopolies too: copyrights. Are those used more to "promote the useful arts" in 2015, or are they used more by rightsholders to stamp out that which they don't like?
I wonder what our economic, artistic, and technological landscape would look like if we decided, as a society, that these legal monopolies are causing more harm than good, and that they should be severely curtailed, if not outright abolished? I wonder if it would really be as bad as the people who have a financial interest in these things say it would be?
[1]: http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llsl&fileName=001/llsl001.db&recNum=232 http://memory.loc.gov/cgi-bin/ampage?collId=llsl&fileName=00...
(interestingly, the copyright laws use the same "useful arts" wording almost verbatim)
- ams6110 12y agoThe thing about patents is that they are public. They encourage sharing inventions in exchange for a period of protection for the inventor. It is generally fair, I think, for an inventor to be able to see a return on his/her investment of R&D effort and expense. Without such a system, inventors would keep their work secret under "Trade Secret" protection or just not bother at all. I think abolishing the patent system would slow technological progress. The problem with patents is that they seem to be awarded for many "inventions" that do not seem to really be novel. Patent inspectors have not kept up well with the rapid pace of innovation that software allows. Fix that problem, and I think a lot of general unhappiness with the system would go away. Copyright? I'm not aware of any general problem with that. It's pretty simple, the original author has a period of protection for their work. What's wrong with that?
- dalke 12y ago> Copyright? I'm not aware of any general problem with that. If you do a Google search for "problems with copyright" you'll find many articles on the topic, including http://gizmodo.com/5989166/everything-wrong-with-digital-copyright http://gizmodo.com/5989166/everything-wrong-with-digital-cop... and http://epubs.utah.edu/index.php/ulr/article/viewFile/7/11 http://epubs.utah.edu/index.php/ulr/article/viewFile/7/11 and https://web.law.duke.edu/cspd/publicdomainday https://web.law.duke.edu/cspd/publicdomainday . To start, copyright terms are getting longer and longer, while "economists who have modeled the ideal copyright term have uniformly suggested that it should be far shorter than it is right now. Some have suggested that it should be as short as 15 years."
- pdabbadabba 12y agoI think that's why GP said "general problem." GP was responding to the suggestion that we roll back all or almost all copyright law, not just, e.g., shortening the term to 15 years.
- dalke 12y agoI have a hard time understanding what "general problem" meant. It could mean "the existence of copyright", but the text is structured in contrast with patents, and ams6110 seems to say that the existence of patent protection is not the fundamental flaw but rather the threshold criteria for notability. So "general problem" doesn't seem to mean the bare existence of those monopolies but something more specific. I didn't ask for qualifications because the implication is that "a period of protection" it simple. I focused mostly on that. The US Constitution says that copyright is for a limited time. Some people think that the current time is too short and want it to be "forever less one day". This is not allowed, so the current method is to keep extending copyrights, giving an effective infinite copyright period in the US. A common view is that Disney wants to keep Mickey Mouse from entering the public domain. This is why the Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act is sometimes pejoratively called the Mickey Mouse Protection Act. So does "a period of protection" mean that the protection can be extended retrospectively? If so, is it okay for extensions for be applied indefinitely, to get an effectively infinite period of protection? I agree with Karunamon in that even this 'simple' aspect is "causing more harm than good, and that they should be severely curtailed, if not outright abolished." (I'm for the 'severely curtailed' part.) Resolving that in the way that I think it should be is definitely not simple.
- snsr 12y ago> Copyright? I'm not aware of any general problem with that. https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-fifteen-years-under-dmca https://www.eff.org/pages/unintended-consequences-fifteen-ye...
- informatimago 12y agoopen source?
- informatimago 12y agoopen source?
- speeder 12y agoI am from Brazil, here piracy is widespread, also I make games, a industry that loves copyright. First, it must be understood that the "official" original explanation of copyright was to prevent people not authorized by the author to sell the author stuff, ONLY that, it was NOT intended to prevent the general public from getting free stuff. (the actual explanation was that the first copyright laws were made to allow censorship, but I don't have enough information to explain that now). Today what I see is lots of people on the "First world" frankly believe they are entitled to earn money from pure intellectual work and that poor people should stay uneducated/ignorant/cultureless if they can't pay. I personally had lots and lots of pirated games, books, and media in general, because then there was no other choice, I was one of the first "gamers" in Brazil, I was also poor, and stuff was mostly not available here, even to get a pirated copy of Doom (the first one) was hard, very hard (my dad had to make some engineering work for Kia Motors, and asked as part of the payment a copy of Doom, after he learned that the factory manager had a copy). I am very sure, that if I went with the route of obeying copyright laws, I would be a very, very different person today, probably I would be a cashier, and would contribute to society much less than now, and the same applies to almost all programmers from the third world. Or you frankly believe a random indian/pakistani/brazillian/peruvian that is a WinAPI programming master had a legal copy of windows and all the tools when he was first learning as a kid?
- venomsnake 12y agoSame here in Eastern Europe - every game pirated, every software product - pirated. 20 years later - huge steam library, working in software and paying a lot of taxes, etc etc.
- innguest 12y agoGreat point and wonderful way to show how copyrights harms everyone. It's the epitome of selfishness to create something and not allow others to look at it and copy it when there is no loss to the creator. The expectation of profit from just having others listen to a song or use a decide whose blueprint you created is a problem of entitlement in our current culture.
- javajosh 12y ago
- pizza234 12y ago> Without such a system, inventors would keep their work secret under "Trade Secret" protection or just not bother at all. I think abolishing the patent system would slow technological progress. Patents are not a black and white problem (either with or without). What I think is the really core problem is that the length of patents must be inversely proportional to the innovation pace of the field they apply - which is the opposite of the current legislation. Patents may be OK "in general", but it's not OK to have a 20 years exclusive in a field where such amount of time represents many generations of products, otherwise it simply is a legalized racket.
- alistairSH 12y ago> Copyright? I'm not aware of any general problem with that. It's pretty simple, the original author has a period of protection for their work. What's wrong with that? The Mickey Mouse Protection Act is a huge problem. In a nutshell, every time a large company's copyrights are about to expire, they pay Congress to extend them for another period of time.
- ploxiln 12y agoThis is the original and first argument for patents and copyright. The point is that it is very naive. Patents don't actually work that way. No engineer looks at a patent in order to make something. Have you ever read a patent? A few that cover useful technologies? They do not provide information useful for implementing anything useful, they only use strange language to cover a couple related ideas as generally as possible so they can apply to as many independent creations as possible, to maximize their offensive, defensive, and monetary value. Copyright has been extended to last way way too long and the idea of it is often abused to threaten people who are actually abiding by the law with expensive and hugely inconvenient court cases. Throwing out copyright altogether would probably have strange effects and not be a good idea. Throwing out the patent system would be quite fine. Patents are literally only used to stop things from being made, never to enable something to be made.
- TheCraiggers 12y ago>Throwing out the patent system would be quite fine. Patents are literally only used to stop things from being made, never to enable something to be made. I don't think you're considering the bigger picture here. For example: it costs billions of USD to create a normal prescription drug. That's an insanely serious investment. How likely do you think that investors will be willing to help fund drug research when a month after your new wonder drug hits shelves there are generics sitting right along side it? Generics which cost considerably less because they don't have to recoup all that R&D. Same thing applies to any other product with a sizable R&D budget. Now, I'm definitely not saying the current patent system is without problems, but saying that patents never enable development is a tad short-sighted in my opinion.
- ploxiln 12y agoWell you're right, drug companies bankrolling clinical trials is the biggest (and only) real argument for keeping patents. On the other hand, drug companies mostly develop lifestyle drugs these days. Drugs that cure people are less subjective and not profitable enough. I'd bet most of the real medical research still comes from academics sponsored by government, *-for-the-cure fundraising organizations, etc.
- Houshalter 12y ago>Copyright? I'm not aware of any general problem with that. It's pretty simple, the original author has a period of protection for their work. What's wrong with that? Not just their work, but derivative works, and they get control over it essentially indefinitely. It used to be that works went into the public domain after 15 years. Thus anyone can print copies of A Christmas Carol, but not anything from the 20th century. Most books from the 20th century have disappeared entirely. E.g. see this graphic: http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/03/the-missing-20th-century-how-copyright-protection-makes-books-vanish/255282/ http://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2012/03/the-mi... There is really no economic advantage of copyright after 5-10 years, but a huge cost on society.
- seanflyon 12y ago> There is really no economic advantage of copyright after 5-10 years I agree that Copyright lasts much too long, but there is a significant economic advantage to the Copyright holder for more than 5-10 years. Disney does not keep lobbying for longer copyright because they are stupid. Plenty of 10 year old media is still purchased.
- Houshalter 12y agoI meant there was no benefit to society. Obviously there is a benefit to (some incredibly small percent of extremely successful) copyright holders (at the expense of everyone else.) Even Disney movies still would have been made if they only got the revenue of the first five years. The vast majority of movie's profits are made at the box office and then a few years afterwards.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> I agree that Copyright lasts much too long, but there is a significant economic advantage to the Copyright holder for more than 5-10 years. Disney does not keep lobbying for longer copyright because they are stupid. ISTR seeing that for the vast majority of works, most of the income ever earned for the copyright holder is earned within the first 5-7 years after creation. Of course, some copyright holders have some works that are valuable longer, and use the proceeds from them to produce enough that they'll hit more of those jackpots (or can outright buy others.) But its not clear that supporting the ability to create those jackpots supports economic gains for society as a whole (rather than providing a gain for a minority of copyright holders at the expense of everyone else) or that it serves the constitutional purpose of copyright (which isn't to maximize rewards to creators, but to provide some reward to creators in order to "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts".
- Retric 12y agoMedical drug patents are arguably the best use case for patents and there doing exactly what they are intended. Remember the advantage of patents is what happens when they expire and we have a huge number 'generic' drug options cheaply available. However, if you look at most fields (ex: engine design) they benifit from the same thing. In the end the real issue is new fields spend their first ~50 years in patent hell where the most obvious things are easily patented and you can't default to a 20 year old 'safe' design without major compromize.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Medical drug patents are arguably the best use case for patents and there doing exactly what they are intended. Remember the advantage of patents is what happens when they expire and we have a huge number 'generic' drug options cheaply available. What happens all too often when drug patents expire is that no one manufactures the drug at all, because the people with the capacity to do so get better returns manufacturing things that are still under patent (even if that's a newer but less effective treatment for the same condition, or even if it leaves no effective treatment for a condition available.)
- geon 12y agoThat makes bo sense. Why woul rhey abandon a working drug if no one else is interested in manufacturing a knock-off?
- Kliment 12y agoThe way it works is approximately this: 1. Your patent on drug A expires 2. You have an active patent monopoly on drug B which is functionally similar 3. You use your giant network of marketing staff to convince medical professionals to use B instead of A 4. The market for A collapses due to lack of demand. The generics manufacturers cannot afford to spend nearly as much bribing doctors, so you don't get an equivalent demand push for generics unless one of the competing large pharma groups decide that the generic is profitable enough to counter the targeted campaign with a targeted campaign of their own. But why would they, when they can milk their own patent monopoly cashcows a bit more using the same marketing spend.
- pdabbadabba 12y ago> interestingly, the copyright laws use the same "useful arts" wording almost verbatim That's because "useful arts" comes from Art 1 s. 8. cl.8 of the Constitution, which authorizes both patent and copyright laws: > [Congress shall have the power] To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries.
- belorn 12y agoThe first question I would ask is one about duration. Does 20 years promote the useful arts more than 10? 30? 15? 4? Same for copyright. We currently have 95 years after the creators death. Would 10 years fill the same role, and if not, how much worse would it be. 1% worse? 5%? 10%? In one of Eben Moglens talk (professor in legal history), he spoke how the fundamental system of government changed in the 20th century. The administrative Procedure Act of 1946 made everything subject to the rule of cost/benefit analysis, asking whether proposed government actions are more helpful than they are harmful and making a systematic and careful evaluation of the relationship between benefits and cost before deciding to intervene in the economy. The change was profound, and just about the only thing that didn’t get changed to conform with it was patent law and copyright.
- jeangenie 12y agoHappen to have any more info for finding this talk from Moglen?
- belorn 12y agohttps://www.softwarefreedom.org/events/2009/Moglen_Cardozo/ https://www.softwarefreedom.org/events/2009/Moglen_Cardozo/ Despite its title, Bilski is only talked about in the last 1/5 of the talk. The 4/5 before that, he goes through a historical perspective of the patent system.
- derf_ 12y agoThe difference between copyright and patents is that as a property right, copyright has a clear boundary: you know whether you copied someone else's stuff [1]. You can infringe a patent without knowing of its existence, and even if you do know and actively try to work around it, the only reliable way to determine if you are successful is in an expensive lawsuit. Imagine if you wanted to put an addition on your house and needed to file a multi-million dollar lawsuit that could stretch over a decade before you could determine whether it would cross your neighbor's property line. [1] There's still some gray area around fair use, but the contrast with patents is night and day.
- baddox 12y ago> copyright has a clear boundary: you know whether you copied someone else's stuff You can violate a copyrighted song by writing a song with a similar melody or motif. In the U.S., the accuser needs to prove that you previously heard the original song, but not that you were aware of the similarity or purposefully copied the musical idea.
- nullc 12y ago> the accuser needs to prove that you previously heard Yes, indeed there are corner cases; and ugly outcomes. At the limit anyone can sue anyone for anything. But by broad strokes, both in theory and in practise the situation around copyright is far more clear, and appears to produce less collateral damage.
- pjc50 12y agoThe real estate situation happens sometimes, in countries without proper cadastral mapping and central registries. It's why title insurance exists.
- ihsw 12y agoOr we could simply cut all of the nonsense verbiage out and be more honest about the purpose of the current patent system -- the government offering usage of the courts to protect companies that agree to keep their IP within the confines of the country. Notice how I'm not making any spurious claims about "useful arts" or whatever.
- javajosh 12y agoIt's strange this modern affinity for "honesty", as if admitting being a jerk somehow makes you less of a jerk. If something has been perverted from it's stated goal, nothing is gained from perverting the goal statement. In fact, I'd argue that much would be lost, as you'd get people saying (correctly) "the system works as intended". Losing a good statement of purpose is always a great loss. It's much harder to make people aware of an error of omission than an error of inconsistency. When we find a good statement of purpose, we should cherish it, defend it, and fight until our systems embody it!
- pjc50 12y agoIt has nothing to do with keeping it in the country either; plenty of non-US countries have US patents.