7 ms·
At Harvard, Wharton, Columbia, MBA startup fever takes hold
- grandalf 12y agoI wonder if this will impact the mantra "don't hire MBAs"...
- Dwolb 12y agoI realize MBAs have a bad rap (disclaimer, I'm getting my MBA), but I think they can bring a lot of variety to the start-up scene. The MBA class is chock full of students from almost every industry who know very well the problems these respective industries face. Furthermore MBAs approach problems through different lenses that may be more sensitive to firm strategy, finance, operations, accounting, etc. These approaches may uncover new insights into the business or market.
- dougbright 12y agoIt's also worth keeping in mind that a good chunk of MBAs come from engineering and other technical backgrounds. In fact, they comprise a full 40% of the latest HBS class (according to http://www.hbs.edu/about/facts-and-figures/Pages/mba-statistics.aspx http://www.hbs.edu/about/facts-and-figures/Pages/mba-statist...).
- brianbreslin 12y ago@Dwollb I'm also getting my MBA, and agree with you. There is a propensity for MBAs to get a bad rap in this community. I came into my program (Kellogg) with a tech background, and I know it has radically changed how I approach problem solving and other tasks.
- alexweberk 12y agoI wonder how they're going to repay their MBA tuition. Typically a tenure in consulting or high finance would pay for this. Perhaps some don't have this burden, but for many I assume tuition is paid in large part via student debt. Are they planning to pay themselves large salaries from the get-go? Quite a culture to start a business on...
- codeonfire 12y agoUnlike engineering degrees that no wealthy person would suffer through, MBA's are sometimes obtained by people from wealthy families or who are wealthy themselves. Not everyone starting a business is starting from zero either. Think Winklevoss twins who both did MBA's and are doing startups.
- npkarnik 12y agoThere are more wealthy people suffering through engineering degrees than you'd think.
- codeonfire 12y agoWealthy as in never have to work again wealthy, i.e. greater than $10 million personal net worth? If so I'd like to meet some of those people. The thing about research oriented degrees is that for the last few centuries wealthy people studied those things for status reasons. They were part of royal societies and the more time spent making esoteric discoveries, the more they displayed wealth and leisure. Engineering, though, is usually about applying things that are already known. So if there is someone who is set for life that has gone through an engineering program then they are not doing it for wealth, sustenance, or status. They must really like engineering.
- 1971genocide 12y agoThe amount of money and media attention around "startup" is eventually going to lead it to its downfall. There is no quick "make money fast" schemes in life. The reputation that the tech sector has created after the dot-com era was created purely on sweat and hardwork ( not mine but the veteran engineers in SV whose shoulders I am standing on). Now the vultures seems to back and many tech products on the markets seems to have a over-inflated valuation because of this dumb hype. I am keeping my options open since I know this is going to lead to a crash in the next few year.
- ritchiea 12y agoMost companies are sweat and hard work without a doubt. That said there are occasional stories, Groupme comes to mind, where you build a product, work hard on it for a year or so and get bought out by a bigger company with no serious plans for your product. Then you just ride out the golden handcuff period and collect your cash. By no means should anyone expect starting a company to be that sort of experience but it happens and some people believe they can be that company.
- gjmulhol 12y agoSo how does this market crash? This is something I have struggled with for some time. Markets have typically crashed because public investors buy at very high prices and then the market loses faith that the future cash flows of the business will pan out. But IPOs aren't happening like they were. Facebook buying Instagram for $! billion is crazy, but Facebook continues to grow and generate revenue (because of or in spite of Instagram) to exceed investor expectations. If these acquiring companies continue to grow and succeed, then how does the bubble collapse? We have no idea whether Nest can justify the $3.2 billion Google paid for it, we just know that Google continues to beat estimates and the Nest guys continue to afford nice cars. I also do take exception to the fact that MBAs are all vultures. I am trained as a computer Engineer, practiced as a materials scientist, and got an MBA. Now I am one of those exact vultures you speak of with a startup of my own that I, by the way, believe is going to contribute meaningfully to society.
- hnnewguy 12y ago
- ChuckMcM 12y agoOk, I am about ready to call it a 'bubble' :-) One of the things which became apparent about 1998 was that people who were interested in the "business" of technology were arriving in numbers to make all the right motions, say the right words, and get money to rain from the skies. Not that they had a product or solved a problem, but the incantation was good. I am always perplexed by people whose target is essentially simply a score.
- analog31 12y agoI suspect that a bubble is preferably defined by investor behavior, not worker behavior, even if the workers call themselves "founders" or "entrepreneurs."
- ChuckMcM 12y agoThat is true, and it needs wide participation, but my observation from the last time was that "business people" who need an audience for their incantations solicit the necessary investors. I am entirely unclear if the last bubble was caused by retail investors unilaterally deciding to "invest in tech" because they thought they would get rich, or caused by persuasive people asking folks who didn't know any better to invest in them with the promise of riches. But I have observed (at least one time, and past performance is no predictor Etc.) that when folks in business school, or fresh out of there, say they are going to do "startups" and they describe them not by their risk, their approach, or problems uniquely suited to them, rather they use a bunch of meta terms like "agile" and "MVP" and "social" and "sharing economy", they have lost sight of the notion of creating value, and shifted into the mode of "executing a process that seems to return more money than you put into it."
- rgbrgb 12y agoThis is a historically bad signal for market health but it's not all bad for hackers. More piranhas to watch out for but also more bizdev hustlers willing to help sell and/or raise money. Edit: I've personally been taken advantage of by an Ivy B-schooler so the piranha thing is real. It was the typical thing you hear where I, an undergrad, had written a bunch of code with a verbal contract from the MBA student that I'd own 10-20% of the business. After a few weeks, when paperwork was being filed, I was informed that I'd get more like 1% to be the first engineer and finish building the MVP. It's not that MBAs are bad but a lot of the ones I've known have been indoctrinated into this way of thinking of creative people as resources to be harvested. It's not evil, it's approaching business like a game, knowing all the rules, and playing to win. It does look and feel evil when the rules are used against you before you know you're playing.
- gaius 12y agoBeing an early employee is an incredibly bad deal. The first dozen people really should be equal partners, in writing.
- bigchewy 12y agoThen why would anybody start a company? why not just join as #12, once a ton of work has been done and you can anticipate, relative to when it was just an idea, the path of the company.
- jonnathanson 12y agoWe're speaking about expected values here. The expected value of joining a slightly de-risked startup as an early employee -- provided you don't get entirely screwed on equity, which is certainly a nontrivial risk -- is higher than the expected value of founding your own startup at T=0. This has a lot to do with things like risk, salary/equity mix, and the probability that your startup will actually succeed. Of course, the absolute value of a big win, should a win come along, is higher for the founder than for the early employee. But the early employee has more flexibility, and probably takes more swings at bat over the course of a given time period. He won't hit a homerun, but he may hit a series of doubles. The founder might hit a home run, or he might strike out. And on an unrelated note, the expected value of a stable job at a place like Google or Facebook is probably a lot higher than the expected value for either a startup founder or startup employee. This doesn't mean everyone should go BigCo and not mess around with startups. It just means people should figure out their personal risk-tolerance levels and ambitions, and act accordingly.
- kylec 12y agoI remember Paul Graham once saying that 9 out of 10 startups fail, but it seems that nowadays outright failure is less and less common. Sure, only a fraction of startups get really big, but it seems like acquihires are becoming the default failure mode. With the upside of striking it rich and the downside of employment at another company with a generous signing bonus, it's no wonder lots of people want to hop on board the gravy train.
- nkangoh 12y agoDo you really think that acquihires are becoming the default failure mode? What about all of the startups that fail silently? I'm seeing some selection bias here.
- kylec 12y agoI don't know, but what actually happens is immaterial. All that matters is perception, and my perception (selection bias and all) is that starting or being involved in a startup seems much less risky than it did 5 or 10 years ago. I'm sure that there are lots of people at Harvard, Wharton, and Columbia that share this perception, leading to an increase in demand for programs about startups.
- gedrap 12y agoWe should aim to keep the mass media out of our perception, because all it cares about is generating clicks :) They don't care about plain simple failures, but they are large part of startup life. One day they will move on from startups to some other hot thing, just like they did with Bitcoin, Ebola, etc. Don't believe the hype!
- WalterSear 12y agoI think this graph should spell it out for you. Keep in mind, it's just displaying the Series A crunch. http://image.slidesharecdn.com/02paulmartinobullpen-final-140626185921-phpapp02/95/premoney-2014-bullpen-capital-paul-martino-seed-is-the-new-a-what-the-seed-stage-explosion-means-for-every-investor-7-638.jpg http://image.slidesharecdn.com/02paulmartinobullpen-final-14... That's all a quick google image search could find: I've seen the 2014 data, it's more of the same - the deals remains flatlined while the number of ventures starts to go parabolic. I highly doubt that most ventures that can't make Series A are going have that many opportunities for acquihire.
- gedrap 12y agoWelcome to selection bias. A lot of startups completely fail but that's not interesting, "<a startup you never heard of> has failed" won't get many clicks on TechCrunch. People share stories about how they 'failed' (got great job offer afterwards, etc) and managed to come out with plenty of cash. But there are a lot of people who get burned. They simply don't make headlines, no one is interested in those stories except from small circles such as HN. Startup is not a quick, and fail-proof way to get rich as mass media portrays it to the public. Some people will end up seriously disappointed but real businesses will continue moving forward.
- curiously 12y agoThis reminds me of the speech Peter Thiel gave about how MBA flocking to a sector is a good early bubble indicator. The reason is that MBA don't give a crap about an industry until it is at peak. Then shortly the bubble almost certainly bursts . Examples he mentioned, junk bonds, dot com, subprime and now startups...
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoA lot of people here seem to think this is the "end of start-ups" or that this is a leading indicator for a bubble burst. I fail to see how that would be the case as there is no reason that a specific group of market entrants would crash a business model. I think if anything, it will be a wake-up call to people who think that "start-ups" are a get rich quick scheme. The only way for this to turn out badly is if somehow this group sucks all of the angel/vc money out of the "start-up" ecosystem and into their own pockets.
- tuke 12y agoA little late to the show.
- arfliw 12y agoIf you want to found a startup, I can think of a lot better ways to spend 2 years and $100k than getting an MBA.
- raincom 12y ago1. Most people don't go to HSW (Harvard, Stanford, and Wharton) to start startups. Well, for some edge cases, it is a way to get admitted. Many of the grads here love to get hired by PEs like KKR and Blackstone. 2. Business schools are good at marketing themselves: they try to set up labs for new trends, fads, etc.
- raincom 12y agoEven in 2005, Chicago Booth GSB used to show their startup labs to prospective students.
- lmg643 12y agoThis sounds pretty healthy. I can't imagine anything we'd really prefer to see MBAs do, after all. Go be investment analysts or work at a hedge fund? Doesn't do much for the world. Go be a highly paid grunt in the finance arm of a corporation? Write business analyses? uh... Go take a risk on introducing a new product into the world? Check. Sounds like "business" to me. This is a great trend, hope it continues! Challenges to this change sticking long term - starting a boot company puts you on even footing with any other person who wants to do the same. The reason we decry "MBA" is the reason people earn them in the first place - they function like a $120k entry fee into a protected job class - like being an analyst as mentioned above. Using the degree to enter a business without protections is risky. That said - to the extent that the university morphs into an incubator to make sure their students are successful - this will give their students an advantage. The MBA would then be weighed against dozens of other incubator type opportunities, or just going and doing it alone.
- brianbreslin 12y agoAs someone currently getting their MBA (and coming from a tech background, been coding since I was 14), I feel that this is a good sign. I would much rather see MBAs try to create new value rather than get sucked back into the vicious cycle of investment banking or management consulting. Startups can offer people of all types the chance to have impact in a positive way. I see lots of startups fail because the founders don't understand basic business concepts and practices, so if some business savvy is injected into this market, great.