5 ms·
>> John Carmack and John Romero had a lot of freedom in their work at a company. Yet, they decided to moonlight on their >> own projects (working all weekends
by bluedino 12y ago
>> John Carmack and John Romero had a lot of freedom in their work at a company. Yet, they decided to moonlight on their
>> own projects (working all weekends without sleep, on a “borrowed” computer equipment) to accomplish their goals
Which didn't work out well for Softdisk, their employer. Since they were employed as developers, they were obligated to offer the technology (2D EGA side-scroller for Commander Keen), but Softdisk turned them down since they still wanted to do CGA games. Off then went to form ID, and you know the story from there.
Also similar to how Woz had to get HP to sign off on the Apple I. They didn't want anything to do with it as they saw the original Apple computer as a toy device, which freed Woz to go start a computer company with Steve Jobs...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- hvs 12y agoI'm not super familiar with the ID story (I haven't read the book), but that seems awfully simplistic. Certainly many companies have been short-sighted and missed opportunities (your second example is one of the most obvious ones, although HP may have just screwed that up), but a game company not wanting to use newer technology for games doesn't jive with my understanding of the game industry at any point (and I've been programming since the early 80's.) That said, you might be right, it just seems weird.
- toyg 12y agoIt could have simply been a question of effort. Maybe Softdisk saw it as a speculative R&D project and didn't want to go pedal-to-the-metal committing lots of resources to it, like Carmack & Romero clearly thought they should. Also, the PC games market then was very complicated and segmented, making side-bets quite risky. I've personally never met anyone with an EGA card, whereas CGA and VGA were popular. The PC market was also smaller than other games-oriented ecosystems back then.
- Kiro 12y agoMaybe the cost of learning and adapting the new technology was too high. I know many things that could be modernized at my company but we choose not to do it right now because we need to focus on other things.
- bluedino 12y ago>> I'm not super familiar with the ID story (I haven't read the book), but that seems awfully simplistic. Softdisk (SoftDisk?) was a company who sold subscriptions similar to companies like MicroZine. Each month or two you'd receive a disk in the mail with games, utilities, and other software. The ID guys had recently moved from writing Apple ][ software to the IBM PC. When they did a demo called 'Dangerous Dave in Copyright Infringement', which consisted of a clone of the first level of the NES game Super Mario 3, they sent it off to Nintendo, who of course responded that they weren't interested in doing PC games. ID ended up partnering with Apogee to do their sales and distribution, when SoftDisk found out, the guys ended up having to do a handful more games for SoftDisk. To make it even worse, they took their PC's home on the nights and weekends from their desks at SoftDisk!
- hvs 12y agoI'm not super familiar with the ID story (I haven't read the book), but that seems awfully simplistic. Certainly many companies have been short-sighted and missed opportunities (your second example is one of the most obvious ones, although HP may have just screwed that up), but a game company not wanting to use newer technology for games doesn't jive with my understanding of the game industry at any point (and I've been programming since the early 80's.) That said, you might be right, it just seems weird.
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- nkantar 12y agoI wonder (genuinely, no trolling) if the mentality has changed with the startup explosion. In other words, would large companies in general be as keen on signing away rights to pet projects by their best and brightest today as they seem to have been in the past? Or maybe I'm just young/naive...
- adventured 12y agoPeople make a lot of the missed ideas or technology. I think that's the least valuable thing HP and Softdisk missed out on. Carmack and Woz were the only real value, they were the only parts to those stories that mattered, lots of people had the same ideas, and that is always the case. If you have a Carmack, everything else is possible, so to speak. Sure you could give those companies the tech. Then Carmack and Woz are both going to eventually quit and go out into the market place, and create something new and better. Meanwhile HP would have been sitting on the old Woz tech, having no clue what to do with it or where to take it.
- jiggy2011 12y agoI don't know if Carmack or Woz wanted to be founders or entrepreneurs. They might have been content to work as employees on a steady salary if they were given freedom to work on their ideas.