3 ms·
It is usually sold as a way to make Office collaborative. It also has a set of badly implemented other features which allow it to check boxes on product compari
by nl 17y ago
It is usually sold as a way to make Office collaborative. It also has a set of badly implemented other features which allow it to check boxes on product comparison feature lists.
It also sucks.
It sucks like Microsoft products used to suck, back when Microsoft was evil, not just irrelevant.
Did you ever use Windows 3.1? It's roughly that level of quality - crashes frequently, is difficult to navigate and relies on people begging others to do things that should be easy ("can you upload this document because I can't find the correct place").
As a specific example, one of the primary use-cases for it involves a person uploading a word document, and then other finding it. The problems with uploading are numerous, but we'll ignore them for the moment (sufficient to say that depending on which version of Word you have you may or may not be able to save directly to the Sharepoint repository, and of course it might crash while saving, losing anything you have done). The real problem is the search - by default it only searches on office metadata, so finding "Template for xxx" is no problem, but unless everyone correctly sets up their metadata you can never find the documents. Apparently it can be reconfigured to index content as well, but at in the first place I came across it I found it more effective to build my own search index by crawling the webdav directly structure (That was in Java, with NTLM authentication, extracting text from MS office document - so that shows how "easy" it was). The company used that index for years, because Sharepoint was so sucky.
Sharepoint sucks - I hope Google Wave kills it, but if you are doing a start up aimed at it please, please, please succeed!
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoTranslation: I did not understand how to set up indexing or search on my Sharepoint installation. In addition, I was unable to make it stable. This is not like using BaseCamp, guys. These huge featurefests from Microsoft are complex animals and require training and work to get right. Use a hosted box and let somebody else worry about all of that.
- mrtron 17y agoIsn't that exactly what people do with BaseCamp?
- dualogy 17y ago"These huge featurefests from Microsoft are complex animals and require training and work to get right." Yes, that was precisely his/her critique -- and mine.
- nl 17y agoYes, or pay someone to do it for you. That's another complaint - it's really consulting-ware, but sold as end user installable. (And I didn't have admin rights, so I did what I could to work around the problems)
- pbhjpbhj 17y agoHa, you don't have admin rights and were installing groupware software ...? That's not exactly Microsoft's problem is it, that's messed up.
- nl 17y agoWho said I was installing anything? I only got involved because I tried to find a document on it and couldn't So I built a search index. Which worked better than the Sharepoint version (This was Sharepoint 2001, and I don't think that supported full text). Incidentally, the company I was at was a MS Solution Provider (tm), so they did have some expertise in installing software. My view is that any software which has defaults as bad as this sucks.
- pbhjpbhj 17y ago[...] sold as end user installable. (And I didn't have admin rights, so I did what I could to work around the problems) If the problem was not the installability then you fail to mention the antecedent to "the problems" in your post. I think it was a reasonable conclusion from what you wrote that you were "installing software and had problems because of permissions". I wasn't saying you were wrong to install it, some corporate environments require workarounds themselves!