4 ms·
We've had the benefit of live communication before, in face to face communication and over the phone, and it has many benefits, but it is not an unalloyed good
by InclinedPlane 17y ago
We've had the benefit of live communication before, in face to face communication and over the phone, and it has many benefits, but it is not an unalloyed good by any means.
Live communication is full of repetition, verbal tics, and inexactness. Necessary mechanisms as one thinks out loud and mentally edits their own words until they circle in on the best expression of their idea. There are many downsides to this. For example, it's much easier to get into a meaningless argument as people stumble or become fixated on conversational detritus (the words and thoughts that would have been edited out of conversation in the final draft), either because people are needlessly confused by awkward wording or use of an inapt metaphor, or because they are being intentionally confrontational. Anyone who has ever read a transcript of a live interview has almost certainly been struck by the degree to which live speech seems convoluted, distracted, and poorly structured when compared to typical written communication.
I can see why google thought it was "neat" to put live chat into wave, it makes for a slick demo. But if their goal is to build a communication medium that is superior to existing technologies (phone, IM, email), then relying on live chat is a step in the wrong direction.
- joe_the_user 17y agoDoes anyone remember video phones ... from the 1950s?? Obviously, Google Wave isn't the same thing but anyone following communications media over time should draw the conclusion that more information, more quickly, is no always useful. No one wants their boss to see their undone hair, no one wants to have to respond in real time to some document and have their keystrokes visible. The delay of email as compared to chat, has it's advantages, otherwise some form of chat would have 'won' already.