13 ms·
F-35 stealth jet 'will not be able to fire its guns until 2019'
- jacquesm 12y agoThat's good news. I sincerely hope that it won't be able to until 2050.
- krylon 12y agoI was thinking the same thing when I saw the head line.
- rodgerd 12y agoYep. I am not unhappy when death machines don't work.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoSo you are also scornful at geeks who fetishize the latest cool crap that DARPA works on?
- cheeseprocedure 12y agoI feel good until I realize who's paying to fix it.
- rodgerd 12y agoFortunately I'm not a US taxpayer.
- toomuchtodo 12y agoWe still get our pound of flesh from you unfortunately. /us taxpayer
- tsotha 12y agoWell, that makes sense then. You won't be depending on this "death machine", so why would you want it to work out?
- inDigiNeous 12y agoEven if one of these military projects were converted into machines that would shoot food or seeds into peoples backyards instead of bombs, we might have real chance.. here's hoping to somebody having some sense in the future.
- ortusdux 12y agoThis clip from the Pentagon Wars always comes to mind when I hear about a delay in the F-35. Needless to say this clip is on my mind every few months... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aXQ2lO3ieBA
- dmix 12y agoThis clip never gets old, no matter how many times I watch it. This is how I imagine somewhere in the world malware is currently getting engineered at this very moment.
- jacquesm 12y agoWas 'malware' an accident or a purposeful entry? (I read 'software', then did a double-take and read 'malware' instead...)
- chm 12y agoI'm pretty sure he meant malware. What's the difference between a software engineer writing malware to the specifications set by an employer (whoever that might be) and the mechanical engineer shown in the clip? For example, a request such as making the vehicle amphibious could translate into a request for making the software attack both OS X and Windows.
- fubarred 12y agoBonus hilarity is presence of the Jump to Conclusions Mat guy.
- Twirrim 12y agoSurely at some stage it's better to write off this mess and start again from scratch? It really seems like they're throwing good money after bad. It's a nice idea to have a completely flexible plane capable of doing every role, but it's clearly not working. What we're ending up with is the proverbial camel designed by a committee who was designing a horse.
- mercurial 12y agoIt's guaranteed subsidies to the military-industrial complex for decades, not to mention employment. Why would you stop that?
- mkr-hn 12y agoWe could spend the money employing people to do useful things like repairing our failing infrastructure.
- jiggy2011 12y agoNot the same people.
- ihsw 12y agoSo?
- jiggy2011 12y agoThey won't vote for you if you take their jobs, especially if they are in a niche industry.
- CamperBob2 12y agoSo give them different jobs.
- 12y ago
- rocky1138 12y agoThe article states that the gov't has been forced to deny the report. So, is it true? Will they be able to fire its cannon or not?
- UnoriginalGuy 12y agoWhen I got to that line I just closed the article. I'm a pretty big critic of this program, but this article is no good even relating to this specific report.
- protomyth 12y agoWe will know at the next update in front of Congress. I am not sure when they are scheduled. I posted the article mainly for the whole "software glitch" angle. I am a little uneasy about the number of items on this bird that keep going back to software. Sadly, it looks like we should have built the full complement of F-22s and got rid of this. The F-22 seems to be ironing out its problems where the F-35 just keeps getting worse.
- Focalise 12y agoThe F35 is hilarious. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxDSiwqM2nw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mxDSiwqM2nw
- tim333 12y agoAnd some counter points to that - "Pierre Sprey's Anti-F-35 Diatribe Is Half Brilliant And Half Bullshit" http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/pierre-spreys-anti-f-35-diatribe-is-half-brilliant-and-1592445665 http://foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/pierre-spreys-anti-f-35-dia...
- smessinis 12y agoBetter not have an wars till 2019 then.
- nraynaud 12y agoit's less and less relevant. With less and less care for civilian casualties (and cover up by declaring anyone over 15 a enemy) With drones (they are imprecise, but see 1) With less emphasis on actual ground occupation (the US as been unable to organize any democratic transition after a war since WWII) With virtualization of war. it's still relevant because the transition is not complete, but the clone war is coming faster than the new plane is coming, you can afford to lose a drone and you don't want to lose a pilot, you learn faster developing a drone program.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoWow, your post is like buzzword bingo.
- ars 12y ago> With less and less care for civilian casualties Did you completely skip history class? In all of recorded history civilian casualties during a war have never been lower.
- Evolved 12y agoAre the statistics for civilian casualties lower because we've actually killed less civilians or because we've labeled more civilians as enemy combatants? This could easily skew the numbers in either direction very quickly.
- CamperBob2 12y agoDid you completely skip history class? No, I went to all of them, including the ones that discussed how governments lie by default.
- mason240 12y ago>US as been unable to organize any democratic transition after a war since WWII South Korea isn't a place?
- davidattprice 12y agoThis explains a lot about why we can't kill the F-35 program: the contracts are spread over 45 states, by design. http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/12/the-tragedy-of-the-american-military/383516/ http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/12/the-trag...
- baddox 12y agoThat article says that the B-2 contracts were spread over 46 states. I don't see anything about the F-35.
- tim333 12y agoThere's a 45 state source here: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-22/flawed-f-35-fighter-too-big-to-kill-as-lockheed-hooks-45-states.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-22/flawed-f-35-fighter...
- tsotha 12y agoThat's normal for pretty much every military contract. It's not just the military, though. Why does NASA need ten separate "space centers"? Education, infrastructure... every dollar spent by Congress is viewed through the filter of whose district is going to receive it. The US political system is antithetical to efficiency.
- nullterminated 12y agoMaybe the purpose of the F-35 project is to con the Chinese into building shitty fighters, too?
- Implicated 12y agoWhat if their's aren't shitty?
- nullterminated 12y ago...US starts buying fighters from China?
- Havoc 12y agoWith bonus spyware...
- gaius 12y agoLike Reagan's strategy of bankrupting the Soviets by forcing them to compete with SDI? Don't think that will work on China.
- scottlocklin 12y agoWe actually ended up doing something like this with the F-111; ruining a generation of Soviet fighter planes (though the Aardvark and Su-24 are pretty good low level bombers). The F-111, you may recall, was the last "do everything, all three service branch" jets we attempted to field.
- arethuza 12y agoYou got us to cancel the lovely TSR-2 in favour of a modified F-111 version that was itself cancelled.... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2 Eventually we ended up with a classic Euro-compromise in the form of the MRCA/Tornado - a swing winged jack of all trades.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoIs the software gun issue with the F-35 fleet in general, or with the very glitchy F-35B? The article doesn't do a good job of explaining that-though since its a British article, I'd assume its the F-35B, which will be on the QE2 class carriers. Really, if you want a culprit for the F-35, blame the US Marine Corps (MARINES, RAWR!!) for insisting on the highly faulty and problem plagued F-35B. If the Brits had insisted on building proper through deck carriers, this wouldn't be an issue (at least the F-35B issues). The QE2 class are awfully big, and really should just be through deck without the ski jump.
- arethuza 12y agoIn true British fashion we did haver about looking at changing one of the QE2 class to be CATOBAR but then changed back to the current configuration. In fact that the US Marines might be the first people to actually fly from the QE2 class: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/the-reporters-30229988 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/the-reporters-30229988 [NB If you are feeling particularly cynical you might want to take note as to whose constituency the QE2 class carriers were assembled in and note that the relevant politcian was notoriously stingy when it came to providing money for helicopters etc. for soldiers actually fighting a war.]
- spartango 12y agoNeither the F-35B nor the F-35C carries a gun. The USAF's F-35A is the only model affected by this issue. Also, the Marines want the STOVL F-35B for operation on LHA/LHDs, as well as small island bases with short/limited runways. It's not just the ski-jumping Brits who want that feature. With that said, you're right that the STOVL capability has added substantial complexity to the airframe.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoThat's the problem, the Marines want to field their own superfluous air force. USN carriers routinely go to sea with understrength airwings, its not as if there's not enough room on CVNs to support Marine F-35Cs.
- Someone 12y agoMakes you wonder about http://isocpp.org/blog/2014/12/five-popular-myths-about-c-bjarne-stroustrup http://isocpp.org/blog/2014/12/five-popular-myths-about-c-bj...: "C++ has been used for demanding embedded systems and critical systems for years, examples are The Mars Rovers (scene analysis and autonomous operations), The F-35s and F-16s (flight controls), and many, many more" Also: what does that software do? I can think of several: - Interface with friend-or-foe detectors - Check that the plane is in the air But I cannot see why either would take four (more, but let's ignore that) years to develop.
- icegreentea 12y agoThe software on these planes do almost everything. There are basically no mechanical/analog linkages left in those planes. Everything the pilot does gets filtered through computer systems. Controlling weapon systems, sensors, flight, navigation, life support, communications - everything is digital. 'Check that the plane is in the air' is like the extreme under statement. Modern fighter jets are inherently dynamically unstable. They require constant adjustment to even fly level. As such, the entirely of flight control is now computer guided. For example, computer systems may apply as series of hard constraints on control surface positions/movements based on the current state (altitude, attitude, speed, rate of change of everything weight, etc). Nearly every aspect of the plane involves software.
- jokoon 12y agoI'd always prefer having a system that use analogous signals for simple things when it's possible, instead of a full software approach. Hard, thick wires and big components are more resilient and work for a long time. Of course there are task where software will be necessary and will add features, for there are simple things that should not always be digital.
- icegreentea 12y agoThe flip side is that by big thick wires and big components are add mass and volume, both of which are at a premium in planes, and fighter jets especially.
- jokoon 12y ago* Stealth is not always about not being detected, it's also about reducing the distance you will start being detected. * The F35 has battle awareness, but I wonder if those systems could have been integrated into existing airplanes, I'm not a aeronautics or avionics engineers though. Obviously it might increase pilot effectiveness, and decrease the amount of stuff pilots have to learn. * I also read that the f35 has been designed around many sensor systems, allowing it to see enemy aircrafts much more before they would, giving it more time to react or to avoid dog fights: that's the argument against a non maneuverable aircraft, that information is more important in a fight situation. Also stealth is not always about land radars, it's maybe also about embedded aircraft radars, which are much less capable. * The only point of VTOL is because air bases are hard to come by and build. It requires a large strip of road to take off, and flat areas are hard to defend. VTOL allows a jet to land in remote areas. Maybe the F35 is all about electronic, detection and spying and not about dog fights, maybe the military also doesn't want to talk about the functionalities that make a difference so that other countries don't pick up on it. Although it's weird to see that so many will be built, since it seems like a very specialized jet.
- gaius 12y agoIt's not specialised at all. The theory was to make a generic jet that could do any mission and therefore achieve economies of scale for parts etc. But it turns out that trying to be all things to all men means compromises that make no one happy. Compare two existing jets, the F16 and the A10 for example. They have one mission each and they do it well - but you couldn't send one to do the others mission. The VTOL capability is also needed for aircraft carriers.
- neurotech1 12y agoF-35B is Short Takeoff / Vertical Landing STOVL. On the Amphibious Carriers (eg. USS Wasp) the Harrier and F-35B takeoff with a short roll.The Harrier or the F-35B STOVL version cannot takeoff vertically under most conditions. F-35C is the Carrier version of the jet and lands with an arresting hook onto the deck.
- greedo 12y ago
- gte525u 12y agoNot to imply the F-35 is the be-all end-all but the article is a bit misleading. Military avionics is developed in a waterfall fashion with functionality spread out over several increments. Initial weapons capability is to be included in block 2B increment which /should/ be released to the fleet this year [1]. The fleet is currently using block 2A, the gatling gun seems to be block 3f by the release date cited in the article. Secondly, even after the software development is done there are still /months/ of testing (including flight tests) required before it's released to the main force. As example, f35 block 2b was reportedly finished last summer but will be ready to be fielded this summer. [1] http://www.janes.com/article/40733/farnborough-2014-block-2b-software-testing-for-f-35-nears-completion http://www.janes.com/article/40733/farnborough-2014-block-2b...
- neurotech1 12y agoArticle is somewhat misleading. The software that implements the gun (Block 3F) is slotted for 2017. That is largely a program management decision and not a major "technical" snag. The F-35 may not be able to fire its guns in operational service until 2017, but test pilots will likely fire the gun well before then. The F-35 is designed to use 25mm rounds instead of the more common 20mm rounds used currently in other jets including the F-22 Raptor. The 25mm rounds have to be physically certified, then the software for the gun validated and certified, and finally pilots (& ground crew) trained to operate the gun.
- engi_nerd 12y agoThe cannon itself has already been test fired on the ground. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KD_A69B1cyg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KD_A69B1cyg for video of that.
- fubarred 12y agoIt looks like it's just a 5 barrel General Dynamics GAU-12/U. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-12_Equalizer#Specifications_.28GAU-12.29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAU-12_Equalizer#Specification... ^- Same video as YT What's delay in integrating this into the platform? Haven't they done this several times before? Or is this a low priority item (how often do jets use their cannons)?
- Eskali 12y agoIt's mostly the new ammo that's being developed and most weapons aren't scheduled untill block 3F, Block2B is just JDAMs and AMRAAMs.
- hackuser 12y agoUnderstanding the F-35: It's about information warfare. My hypothesis (I have no expertise in this area) is that the public is blind to fundamental changes in (aerial) warfare, much like people in the 1930s might have criticized aircraft carriers for poor guns and armor. The articles below revolutionized my perspective: Warfare is now (or will be) information technology warfare. The article at the end is best, but first a few excerpts: 1) Instead of focusing on individual planes, squadrons, or "strike packages" executing a particular mission, the new concept looks at all the deployed aircraft as a whole, linked together by secure wireless networks into the "combat cloud." This cloud would be enabled by "fifth generation" aircraft — specifically F-22s and a substantial number of F-35s — and their ability to connect electronically both to each other and to legacy aircraft. [1] This combat cloud shares data in a sort of mesh network, so instead of a pilot seeing only their own plane's sensor data they see the combined sensor data of all planes in the cloud, and share that with units and command on the ground. 2) Another way to describe it is that the fifth generation aircraft are primarily forward-deployed nodes in a network (fighting an enemy network across an air gap); there's even talk of their pilots operating fleets of drones. [2] 3) The sensor data's UI is much improved, with a massive impact (something HN readers will appreciate): "In my fourth gen airplane, I was the fusion engine, the pilot was the fusion engine. I took the inputs from the RHWG, from the Radar Homing Warning Gear, from the radar, from the com, multiple radios, from my instruments. I fused that into what was happening in the battlespace, all the while I’m trying to do the mechanical things of flying my airplane and dodging missiles and all these sorts of things," he says. / Combine the fusion engine, the ISR sensors, the designed-in stealth, the advanced helmet, and the eight million lines of software driving what it can do ... "What we’ve done with the fifth generation is the computer takes all those sensory inputs, fuses it into information. The pilot sees a beautiful God’s eye view of what’s going on. And instead of having to fuse three pieces of information and decide if that’s an adversary or not, the airplane is telling him with an extremely high degree of confidence what that adversary is and what they’re doing and what all your wingmen are doing. It’s a stunning amount of information," [from the article in #6] 3) Stealth: In this new perspective it's information warfare defense, hiding data (your position, etc.) from the enemy, or sensor defense. 4) A leak said that F-35's could conduct cyber attacks on radar systems, effectively hacking the radar's computers via their sensor inputs (based on my limited understanding of limited info). [I can't find a good link at the moment] 5) Background: This combination of information warfare components (sensors, stealth, computers) are part a cohesive plan developed in the 1970s, the Pentagon's second "Long Range Research and Development Planning Program" or "Offset Strategy". A third is beginning now; some interesting background at the links. [3][4] 6) The best overview I've seen of the F-35 and the new form of warfare: http://breakingdefense.com/2014/06/a-gods-eye-view-of-the-battlefield-gen-hostage-on-the-f-35/?print=1 http://breakingdefense.com/2014/06/a-gods-eye-view-of-the-ba... [1] http://breakingdefense.com/2013/01/why-the-air-force-needs-a-lot-of-f-35s-gen-hostage-on-the-com/ http://breakingdefense.com/2013/01/why-the-air-force-needs-a... [2] http://breakingdefense.com/2014/12/pawlikowski-on-air-force-offset-strategy-f-35s-flying-drone-fleets/ http://breakingdefense.com/2014/12/pawlikowski-on-air-force-... [3] http://breakingdefense.com/2014/11/hagel-launches-offset-strategy-lists-key-technologies/ http://breakingdefense.com/2014/11/hagel-launches-offset-str... [4] http://breakingdefense.com/2014/12/dod-to-silicon-valley-vcs-how-bout-some-help/ http://breakingdefense.com/2014/12/dod-to-silicon-valley-vcs...
- redact207 12y agoThe F-35 is the Duke Nukem Forever of the military aircraft industry. Over budget, over schedule, trying to be everything but ending up doing nothing well.
- michaelbuddy 12y agoI recommend this top 10 video doc. A good though slightly hokey presentation but good roundup of military aircraft - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IudSJE-TLxk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IudSJE-TLxk
- xpda 12y agoThe longer before its operational, the sooner its deployment will be replaced or reduced by UCAV (combat drones). Technology will make it economical and tactically advantageous for unmanned aircraft to replace manned fighters and bombers in many situations. It will be interesting to see how autonomous they become.
- protomyth 12y agooh, this gets worse "Equipped with a gun, Air Force’s F-35A version barely carries enough ammunition. Despite being able to shoot 3,300 rounds per minute, it will only be carrying 180 to 220 rounds." "The two other versions of F-35 – for the Navy and Marine Corps – have different configurations with external gun pods, however, they will not have a software for them either, the Daily Beast reported." http://www.defencetalk.com/computer-glitch-prevents-us-most-advanced-f-35-fighter-jet-from-firing-until-2019-report-61223/#ixzz3NgeCm600 http://www.defencetalk.com/computer-glitch-prevents-us-most-... For comparison, the F-22 has "A 480-round closed loop ammunition feed and storage subsystem is housed integrally under the right wing root/fuselage for easy ammo upload and download of empty casings." using the proven M61A2 which is in a bunch of fighters. http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/aircraft/f-22-weapons.htm http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/aircraft/f-22...