2 ms·
I had to look up this allegedly befuddling question, because I assumed the dad was just being a partisan complainer. Here's what came up: http://dailycaller.com
by danso 12y ago
I had to look up this allegedly befuddling question, because I assumed the dad was just being a partisan complainer. Here's what came up: http://dailycaller.com/2014/03/16/bizarro-common-core-kindergarten-math-homework-stumps-dad-with-ph-d/ http://dailycaller.com/2014/03/16/bizarro-common-core-kinder...
(to save you the clickthrough: it's a single-page question consisting of a simple illustration of a day at the park...the prompt is: "Today in class your child practiced telling subtraction stories. For tonight's homework, your child will tell you 3 subtraction stories using the attached paper"...presumably, the child is supposed to look at the picture and observe, for example, that there are 10 trees and 9 birds, leaving 1 tree empty)
I stand corrected in my assumption: that is a bizarre question. I guess it depends on what was taught in class...if the class went over a similar question and walked through examples...then I guess it's a useful exercise...in the same way that I challenge students whom I teach programming to look at a real-life situation and think about how programming applies. Can 5-year-olds think like that? I seriously have no idea...I just came back from visiting my 1-year-nephew who apparently can recognize words in 3 different languages (English, Spanish, Vietnamese) and communicate common phrases (I'm hungry, I'm sorry) in sign language...admittedly, he still craps his own diapers, but still...I've forgotten how early-brain development can be.
Side note: Awhile ago, I asked why HN's Google pagerank was so low (something like a 4 or 5) Paul Graham has stated that the robots.txt on HN throttles Google spiders...and yet when I googled "north carolina common core dad"...the parent comment was one of the top search results. I guess HN's pagerank is moving up?
- acdha 12y agoDaily Caller is a right-wing activist site, so be careful about anything they claim, particularly when it's an unsourced forward. The big thing to remember is that Common Core doesn't actually dictate the implementation details people commonly complain about. It's possible that a particular state, district or school does something weird but that's like using some horrible enterprise Java monstrosity as an argument that object orientation is a bad concept.
- bane 12y ago> Daily Caller is a right-wing activist site That may be, but this is a bizarre question. The problem and blame seems to keep coming up over and over again is that CC didn't have implementation control. Why not? Why didn't CC go out the door with a gold standard reference implementation publishers could license and a certification program for alternates? The internet is full of crazy examples like this. Questions that will simply drive people away from math on multiple levels.
- acdha 12y ago> That may be, but this is a bizarre question. I'm not arguing that – only pointing out that they have a strong partisan motivation to spin this as mandated by Common Core, which parts of the conservative movement have been trying to spin as part of some Democratic conspiracy for years, rather than the more honest “Local teacher / school / district does something dodgy / buys substandard curriculum” story which wouldn't be of much interest to anyone outside of that particular city.
- adventured 12y agoThe inherent problem HN faces with pagerank, is that it's a site with a million outbound links. I would imagine also that thread pages tend to have more outbound links in them than they do backlinks going to them. On the bright side, the PR result I just got in checking it, came back a seven (Reddit is an eight by comparison).