9 ms·
The Man Behind Common Core Math
- duckingtest 12y agoIf I were to design a school program from the ground up, I would teach programming just after reading & writing. The best way to learn math is to try to make a program that solves specific problems.
- logfromblammo 12y agoThe very first class I would teach would be about how to learn what you need to know in spite of what you are being taught. After that, I would teach the same class. Later, I would teach the same class again. Then again. And again. Then a sixth time. After that, I would just make the students ask a new question every day, and then answer it, instructing the teachers to throw erasers at anyone who slacks off. The erasers are essential. The knowledge particles wiped off the greyboard are physically transferred to the student, and are then absorbed through the skin. The knowledge slowly decomposes, releasing about a microsatori of electromemetic radiation, and the waste metabolites are exhaled into the room to create an atmosphere of learning. Needless to say, I will never be permitted to design a school program from the ground up.
- EliRivers 12y agoThe best way to learn math is to try to make a program that solves specific problems. An often reasonable way to ensure that you can mechanically apply a problem solving technique (which is related to, but absolutely not the same thing as understanding the maths) is to make a program that does it. Trying to learn maths by programming it is a terrible idea. Just this morning I've been looking at Riemann's geometry; learning that through the medium of writing a program to "do it" would be painful. I don't even know what it would mean to write a program that "does" Riemann's geometry. I suppose I could write a program to apply some equations, but that's not learning the maths at all. That's automating some equation solving and it teaches me nothing about the maths.
- duckingtest 12y ago>An often reasonable way to ensure that you can mechanically apply a problem solving technique (which is related to, but absolutely not the same thing as understanding the maths) is to make a program that does it. What "problem solving technique"? There's no algorithm you can mindlessly remember and use it to create algorithms. Making a program that solves the problem is the highest possible understanding. >I don't even know what it would mean to write a program that "does" Riemann's geometry That's because it's an abstraction, not a problem to be solved. In the same way you can't write a program that 'does' functional programming, you can only program in a functional way. Well, I guess writing an AI which can solve problems in Haskell would be an exception. I bet you couldn't remember its code and execute it in your head, though.
- parfe 12y agoIt hit the mainstream in early 2014, when a dad in North Carolina posted a convoluted "Common Core" question from his son's second-grade math quiz on Facebook, along with a letter he'd written to the teacher. "I have a Bachelor of Science Degree in Electronics Engineering which included extensive study in differential equations and other high-math applications," he wrote. "Even I cannot explain the Common Core mathematics approach, nor get the answer correct." Lunch costs $14.45. You pay with a $20. If you calculate your change without borrowing you just did common core math. The best facet of common core is the amount of adults complaining they don't understand it. Rather than an argument against, it is exactly an argument in support of teaching kids multiple ways to think about math.
- boobsbr 12y agoIf you calculate your change without borrowing you just did common core math. Borrowing?
- trebor 12y agoThe OP may mean calculating from left to right, instead of right to left. One is merely the reverse of the other. EG: $20 - $14.45 = ... $6 ($0.45 excess) $5.60 ($0.05 excess) $5.55 ($0.00 excess) Instead of: $20 - $14.45 = ... $0.05 ($14.50 total) $0.55 ($15.00 total) $5.55 ($20.00 total)
- Practicality 12y agoWhen I learned calculating left to right it sped up so much of my daily arithmetic. I didn't learn to do that until I was 27. I feel like I wasted a lot of time doing it the hard way first.
- AngrySkillzz 12y agoThis is what they're trying to do with the Common Core. We should teach everyone these strategies, not just let smart people figure them out for themselves have everyone else be left behind.
- jndsn402 12y agoIMO, the problem with the way Common Core has been implemented is that there is a whole new analytical/critical thinking component that is bundled together with math. But parents when parents think of math they think of computation, arithmetic, formulas etc. Not 'explain why ancient calendars used 60-day units' (actual question from my daughter's 6th grade curriculum, may be misquoting a bit. The answer is because 60 has many factors). I'm not saying it's good or bad to teach math that way, it was just not communicated well and still isn't. Math has been replaced with math+critical thinking. It's as if English class now also included Latin. Maybe good, maybe bad, but it's a whole different class.
- jwmerrill 12y agoIt's hard for me to imagine a world view where adding critical thinking to a subject might make it worse. > It's as if English class now also included Latin. I think a better analogy would be "it's as if English class now included critical thinking." Or "it's as if Science class now included critical thinking." Or "it's as if History class now included critical thinking." All of those sound unambiguously good to me.
- debacle 12y agoThe math curriculum I was exposed to in school (relatively recently, by any standard) always included critical thinking and was likely the subject that involved the most critical thinking because it was the subject where critical thinking was the most objective.
- kaitai 12y agoAs someone who teaches at the college level, I hope it works! Many American student come in not only unfluent with basic mechanical moves like adding fractions and dealing with exponents, but with little "number sense." Finding that you need to go -0.55 miles an hour to go from Cleveland to St. Loius (about 550 miles) in ten hours just does not faze some of them at all. In college I'm always asking students to analyze the results to applied calculus questions and it can be a struggle and a revelation. You mean these numbers have meaning?!
- 12y ago
- Strilanc 12y ago> As powerful and influential in reshaping American classrooms as the standards could be, they don't include lesson plans, or teaching methods, or alternative strategies for when students don't get it. That seems like a really serious flaw. Did the teaching community at least make and share their own?
- grejdi 12y agoWe at BetterLesson have been working on this for the past 2 years. We have accumulated a vast amount of lesson plans from some of the best teachers throughout the country and from various environments, whether urban, suburban or rural. Teachers have free access to all these Common Core aligned lessons, among other standards that we have started supporting. See http://betterlesson.com/common_core/browse/624/ccss-math-content http://betterlesson.com/common_core/browse/624/ccss-math-con...
- ashark 12y agoThat's what consultants are for. The typical cycle for curricula, teaching strategies, and/or discipline plans in schools: 1) OMG the kids aren't learning better change everything! 2) District, state, or both pick some new system and pay some consultants and various companies a bunch of money. 3) Administrator presents plan to teachers: Here's the new system. Half of it's not finalized yet. Should be done in a year or two. We're not implementing some parts of it because they make me uncomfortable. The old way is stupid and sticking to even the parts of it that work well for you will result in my making your life miserable and eventually trying to fire you. You'll need to re-write all your lesson plans to conform to the new system. Here's a mountain of new paperwork for you. No, you can't stop filling out any of the old paperwork. 4) A couple years pass 5) Goto 1
- acdha 12y agoA few years ago, a veteran teacher told me his version: 1. Introduce a new test with an unfamiliar blend of questions, new style questions, etc. but don't give teachers extra time to actually receive updated textbooks, update their classes, etc. 2. Start giving the test to students immediately before they have any experience with the new format 3. Use the result low test scores as proof that things were really bad before 4. As everyone gains experience with the new system, attribute rising scores entirely to the brilliance of the new model. Give bonuses to district / state officials. 5. Once scores plateau at roughly the previous levels after a few years, start talking about repeating the process. At no point should you seriously consider tackling the structural problems preventing holding perennially under-performing groups back.
- atratus 12y agoI have looked over some of the common core material given to both early grade school and middle schoolers and its very clearly attempting to teach abstract reasoning. There is alot of word problems that ask how to decouple a concept from the concrete values calculated in a previous step. Most people from older generations are not going to see the value in this... parents (and teachers) need to know there is much more to math than arithmetic
- ploxiln 12y agoIsn't it much easier to just use "x" and "y" instead of strange terms like "subtraction stories"? I always did quite well in math, but sitting there at the back of the class messing around with stuff at the end of the book, I found that teachers tried so damn hard to make the content easier, and in the process made it harder. I could figure out how what they were saying corresponded to the material, because I already knew the material, but could not see how anyone else would understand it. Few did. That said, "Common Core" is probably fine, as usual the implementation quality is just much more important than any particular methodology. (just like "object oriented programming" etc).
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- graycat 12y agoBackground My Ph.D. is in some applied math, stochastic optimal control. I've taught math in college and grad school, applied it in business and to US national security, published peer-reviewed original research in it, and now it is the crucial core of my start-up. Common Core Once I looked at some Common Core materials. I was outraged and concluded that it fills a much needed gap in educational materials and would be illuminating if ignited. E.g., for something like the problem 20 - 14.45 Common Core has several ways to understand how to solve that problem. Sure, for a student to have those several ways would'a, could'a, should'a be good, but with Common Core the rest was not good. Apparently much of the blame goes to Zimba. Sure, for 20 - 14.45 = 5.55 I have several ways to look at that, check it, etc. And, yes, in school I was actually taught only one of those ways. Apparently I picked up the other various ways much like Zimba did, just by a lot work with math and, in particular, arithmetic. Congrats Dr. Zimba: You developed some good intuition for yourself. Good. Now that you're educated, the real question is how the heck to educate millions of students, and for that just have to be quite careful on what you attempt and how. Sorry, Dr. Zimba, on that challenge, you just were not nearly careful enough. In three little words, you blew it. Why? First, parents, teachers, textbook authors and publishers, employers, etc. doing just fine, for decades, thank you, with arithmetic won't want to hear about your novel, alternative approaches to better intuitive understanding. You failed to reach your customer or constituency. Second, we need the kids to work to learn the stuff, and most of all what they need to learn about arithmetic is the traditional stuff, e.g., like millions of Americans have done well with for 100+ years, maybe like you are teaching your 7 year old daughter. For that alternative and intuitive understanding, that's the third desert of cookies after the second desert of ice cream after the first desert of chocolate cake after the main meal of meat and potatoes. In marketing speak, the meat and potatoes are the must have; your desert is the nice to have, later, after doing well with the must have, for the brighter students, if they really enjoy it, maybe. Your problem? You failed to see these first and second points. Why? Sorry, but you just didn't think hard enough. And, really, the people who funded you didn't have you test your work, controlled, double blind, in classrooms, with actual texts, then with actual teachers, etc. Instead, you went to your garage and just wrote it all out and pushed it out, and now a lot of people don't like it and are throwing it out. E.g., the first time I heard of a number sentence was in the Common Core materials. At Wikipedia I see that this terminology is common in math education and not just in the US. But, Dr. Zimba, as you and I both know very, very well, no one reading Bourbaki, Halmos, Rudin, Birkhoff, Lang, Coddington, Flanders, Cartan, von Neumann, Feynman, Goldstein, Jackson, Weinberg, Misner, Thorne, and Wheeler, etc. ever heard of a number sentence. So, number sentence is new terminology introduced by math education and really not part of either pure or applied mathematics. Uh, Dr. Zimba, in short, number sentence is not really mathematics; teaching about number sentences is maybe teaching about something, but it's not actually mathematics: We know, know very well, just what mathematics is, and it never mentions a number sentence. Moreover, parents, teachers, K-12 textbook publishers, mathematicians, scientists, engineers, etc. won't know what a number sentence is and will get torqued. By introducing or going along with this goofy terminology, you blew it. Dr. Zimba, the problem with teaching arithmetic in the US is due to, and the nominees are, standards such as Common Core, the standardized tests, the teacher evaluations, the curricula, the teacher training, the textbooks, the software for mobile computers, the local school boards, the National Education Association, too little money for classroom supplies, class sizes too large, not enough hours in school per year, too little class discipline, not treating the boys and girls the same, social pressure on the girls to regard arithmetic as a boy subject, and the homes of the children. May I have the envelope, please? And the winner is (drum roll, please) the homes of the children!!!!!! E.g., what you do each Saturday with your seven year old daughter. Rnally, before saying again that US K-12 education in arithmetic and math is falling behind Singapore, South Korea, Finland, etc., please do the testing controlling on country of origin. E.g., compare US education of US students with ancestors from Finland with education in Finland with students in Finland. E.g., let's compare apples and apples here, not apples and oranges. Control on -- as we know, that's a very important concept in social science. Finally, let me just mention, in K-5 or so, the goal is not to teach mathematics but mostly just to teach basic arithmetic. For trying to create the next von Neumann, that's different.
- sputknick 12y agoDoes anyone know: is their a difference between "Common Core" the method of teaching, and "Common Core" the idea that all students across the nation should be held to one standard?
- kaitai 12y agoCommon Core is a set of standards (http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ http://www.corestandards.org/Math/). I don't think there is one official way of teaching that is "Common Core." The texts currently labeled Common Core are mostly copy-and-paste remixes of existing material. The exams labeled "Common Core" are unfortunately similar. They don't test the standards as written. For math, a discussion at http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2014/11/30/a-dissection-of-common-core-math-test-questions-leaves-educator-appalled/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/wp/2014/11/... . Unfortunately, a theme seems to emerge of Pearson tests written to test Pearson materials, some of which have a "Common Core" label.
- btilly 12y agoMy children's school sent me a questionnaire on Common Core. They ended with a comment, maximum of 300 characters. Here is what I told them: Educational reforms usually result in an ambitious curriculum being presented by underprepared teachers to unprepared students. And parents don't understand the homework and can't help. For example, "New Math" ended with "Johnny Can't Add". I wish my kids weren't victims of the current round. I stand by that comment. Given how many failed reforms there have been over time, how could these smart people not have predicted what has happened? Right now we have a new set of standards. A new set of lesson plans. Every teacher has been retrained to teach in a new way. We have new homework going home with kids, which makes little sense to anyone. Kids learn to perform the operations, but do not seem to be mastering the concepts. There is an endless drum beat of positive messaging being sent home from schools. Parents that I talk to are..shall we say..less than convinced. This is about the worst kind of big bang upgrade that you could have.
- debacle 12y agoDoes it help that I haven't talked to a single teacher who has been bullish on the Common Core? Many of them feel that it breaks the K-8 curriculum up in such a way that it front-loads the wrong things. Almost all of them have been derisive of what they have seen as a "cash grab" for Common Core textbooks that are riddled with errors and also somewhat awful. Many also lament that it restricts their ability to expand on aspects of the curriculum, effectively lowering their autonomy. As a programmer, I have never seen a "one size fits all" system that can both bring up bad programmers and also provide good programmers with the autonomy they need to continue to be good programmers. Common Core is a "one size fits all" system to a much more complex problem.
- barry-cotter 12y ago>Almost all of them have been derisive of what they have seen as a "cash grab" for Common Core textbooks that are riddled with errors and also somewhat awful. This would be more convincing if there were some examples of good textbooks that were scrapped, or good textbooks period. The textbook procurement process in the US has been appalling for longer than most readers of this forum have been alive.[ http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm http://www.textbookleague.org/103feyn.htm ] Never mind that the best evidence available suggests that unsccooling, i.e. providing no systematic instruction to children whatsoever leads to a delay of one year in educational outcomes. Primary school hardly seems worth it unless the point is not education but teaching children to sit down, shut up and do as they're told. [ http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232544669_The_impact_of_schooling_on_academic_achievement_Evidence_from_homeschooled_and_traditionally_schooled_students=16 http://www.researchgate.net/publication/232544669_The_impact... ]
- cabinpark 12y agoI think the greater problem is not with the standards (which I know nothing about) but with who is teaching it. I have talked to people who are elementary school teachers who know nothing about mathematics, yet they are given the task to teach it to children. They have little understanding of why the mathematics they teach is important and useful. If you don't give children a solid foundation in their formative years, they will always struggle with mathematics.
- pm90 12y agoFirstly, I would love to hear what tokenadult has to say about this. Moving on, I think the article mentions the problem of getting good textbooks. This has always been a huge problem, I think. In India, there is a trinity of syllabi: one recommended by the Federal (Central) Govt. (CBSE), one by a consortium of private schools (ISCE) and each individual state's syllabus. So, a school does not have the independence to create its own curriculum, it has the choice of adhering to these 3 systems. It does have the independence of choosing textbooks; however, there are also officially prescribed books, and many teachers teach from them only because they cover things that are often asked in the standardized tests. So, I don't know if it does good to have just one system, and not give schools access to more options.
- bane 12y agoThe real problem is that Common Core tried to do several things in order to improve rankings against countries like South Korea. But instead of doing the things which high ranking countries have shown do actually produce high-level results, they put together an almost completely untested curriculum, then rolled out it out everywhere. There's not really any evidence that the approach in Common Core will improve student's math achievement scores, and lots of evidence that it's been an abysmal failure. Instead of confused students ignoring the subject, we now have confused, frustrated, miserable students, a generation of which will now hate mathematics more than the one that came before them. The only thing CC has achieved is in alienating an entire generation of students from the critical skills of math. The article makes the argument that the absurdity of the implementation of CC is a result of local standards overriding a national, well thought out program and that the CC creators are powerless to fix things. I call hogwash. Set up a textbook certification program: publishers have to pay some nominal fee to these guys to review the book and give it a seal of approval that "yes, this book fulfills what Common Core intends". Use that seal as a quality signal, books without the seal should be considered next to garbage and books with it are assumed to be better. They should also have written their own reference K-12 curriculum, providing a gold-standard example of what it should look like. Publishers can license that curriculum and publish it unmodified or they can license it and add (but not subtract) chapters to handle local requirements. That these things weren't done, on what's supposed to be a national educational reform that was "a lot of work" boggles the mind. It reminds me of various specification-by-committee standards that are all over the tech world. They're laid out in document somewhere, with no reference implementation and no certification that some other implementation really is compliant and we end up with a decade of lost time while every developer tries desperately to get their image to line up just right in half a dozen different browser rendering engines, or get their query to work right in a dozen different SQL standard databases to work the same.
- elberto34 12y agoThe way you improve test scores and increase America's economic competitiveness is to understand that higher IQ students will learn faster and more efficiently than lower IQ ones, and then by grouping the students accordingly. Instead of wasting billions trying to get everyone up to speed, let's devote more resources to those who demonstrate talent, while those who cannot keep up are encouraged to pursue vocational work. Hence, we see that that the problems facing our educational system cannot be lessened by throwing money at it with reckless abandon, but by better understanding human biological differences and how these not only effect learning, but economic outcomes. I don't want to make this a partisan issue, but what we observe is a leftist denial of human cognitive differences and a denial of the significance of these differences as the culprit. Better teachers, new technologies, and new curriculum can only go so far; for progress to really be made we need to stop being in denial of human biology as it pertains to IQ and learn to face these sometimes uncomfortable but inescapable realities head-on.
- mzs 12y agoI'm a parent and I've overall been very happy. In math it's very simple for a kid to get hung-up on one simple thing and then they have this hole and cause things build on previous knowledge later things are now trouble as well. For example one of my children could not factor in the way I was taught with the trees, but another way was presented and it totally clicked for her. For one of my sons he could not do long division in the manner I was taught, but another method worked for him instantly. He showed me and I even liked it, cause I remembered how hung-up I had been about getting the correct digit at each step myself. I also like how it seems to have this component about reasoning. To many people math is arithmetic, but it really is not that. The problem is that there are kids where requirements were different. So for example now a third grader is supposed to have memorized multiplication table, but there were schools that never did that before. Or a sixth grader is now already supposed to have done some geometry, but the school only did it in 8th grade or HS before. There is no route to fill in the gaps during this transition in many schools it seems.
- malandrew 12y agoOne of the biggest problems in changing anything like this is that it requires extra effort from teaches to completely "retool". Anyone who has ever spent anytime teaching knows that when you first start out, you have to figure out a lot of stuff when teaching a new curriculum, but by the time you've taught the material 2-3 times [0], you start streamlining things and getting more efficient. The time you spend retooling almost always comes out of your personal time. i.e. from hours beyond the 40-50 hour work week. After you know a curriculum well, you end up with more personal time. Introducing new standards, means a new curriculum and a new curriculum means a lot of unpaid personal time from teachers if you want them to really adopt it and teach it well. I just don't see a new curriculum working well unless it comes with the notion of paid extra-time that you know teachers will have to put in to succeed with the new curriculum. It doesn't have to be a lot, but simply 5-10 more hours each week and a bonus equal to 10-25% of their salary to make up for the additional time would probably work. The only key would be that there needs to be a way to measure that teachers are putting in the extra time to really learn the new curriculum and apply it instead of collecting the bonus for putting in the minimum effort. At the end of the day, it you don't budget both time and money to learn any new curriculum, it's either going to fail or be met with resistance from teachers who feel like they already have a system that works for them and their students. [0] either in the same semester or school year because you teach multiple groups the same material or after 2-3 semesters or school years of teaching the subject to one group at a time
- jwmerrill 12y agoThe common core Mathematics standards are available for anyone to read here: http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ http://www.corestandards.org/Math/ I would encourage anyone who is really interested in this issue to spend some time reading, or even skimming just a few sections. I find the standard is generally quite readable (conceding that it's a non-trivial commitment to read more than 1 grade level, but then again, there's a lot to know about math...) and I also tend to agree with many of the ideas in it. I've been disappointed, but in hindsight not very surprised by the anti-intellectualism in the public response to the common core. I'm more surprised to see similar anti-intellectualism here. I expect better from you, HN! It's true that the common core places more emphasis on critical, analytical, and sometimes even abstract thinking than the "traditional" math curriculum (whatever that is...). But as people who read hacker news, doesn't that sound good to you? It's also important to know that the Common Core standards are a set of expectations, and that's actually all they are. They are not worksheets or standardized tests. If you see a bad "Common Core" worksheet, it is a bad response to the Common Core, but it isn't actually the Common Core itself. If you want to criticize the Common Core itself, choose a part of the document above and criticize it. Or failing that, criticize the process that led to its creation and dissemination. But criticizing a few oddball problems is not a powerful argument. My own criticism-in-hindsight is that the Common Core is trying to do two things at once. Maybe it would be succeeding better if it only tried to do one of them at a time. The first is to provide a nationally standardized set of grade level expectations. Many people have an interest in this goal because it makes it easier to prepare teaching materials for a large group of students, and to compare education effectiveness across regions. In an alternate world, this could have been done descriptively instead of prescriptively. The standards could have simply described what was happening in the largest fraction of the country's classrooms. The second goal is to improve math pedagogy in the U.S. and bring it up to the best international standards, including tying math more strongly to critical, analytical, and abstract thinking skills. This is a prescriptive goal. If the standard was a process, we could have started with 1, and moved to 2 incrementally. But I suggest this only half-heartedly, because I think 2 is a great goal, and I think the Common Core (as a document) does a pretty good job of it. Now to be clear about my own biases: I don't have any children (school age or otherwise). If my first exposure to the Common Core was seeing my child assigned problems that looked unfamiliar, unimportant, or even that I didn't know how to do, I'll concede that I might have reacted negatively too. I do have a physics Ph.D. (i.e. math background), I do think and care a lot about how people understand math, and I do work on a software tool that tries to help children think about (part of) math more powerfully.