6 ms·
More Data on Attributing the Sony Attack
- twrkit 12y agoWow, I have a great deal of respect for Schneier, but referencing GotNews (aka Charles C. Johnson) as a credible technical source? Yikes. [1] [1] my comment when this "source" was posted to HN (before it was flagged for removal): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8789341 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8789341
- rgbrenner 12y agoAnd Schneier's reply when someone said something about it: Yes, I know that Chuck Johnson (http://gawker.com/what-is-chuck-johnson-and-why-the-web-s-worst-journal-1666834902 http://gawker.com/what-is-chuck-johnson-and-why-the-web-s-wo...) is unreliable and worse. But in this case, I thought the data sound enough to republish. After reading that article.. why would he believe anything from this guy?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- sroerick 12y agoSorry, I deleted my post because it came out more sarcastic than I meant it. For transparency's sake, my post was (from memory): > The data is publically available on torrents. > >You could easily prove Schneier wrong.
- sroerick 12y agoNo, he also posted the timecodes from the torrent, which imply the data was transferred at USB 2.0 speeds. This data can indeed be verified with the torrent. I agree with your criticism of naming former executives. But Schneier also expresses his skepticism towards this viewpoint, and merely states that the data transfer speeds do seem to support the "inside job" argument. He continues to say that he still doesn't buy the "inside job" theory.
- sroerick 12y agoI deleted my last post which came out snarkier than I meant it. The point I meant to get at was that the timecode analysis which was featured is not just claimed by Charles Johnson, but rather is in the torrents released by GOP. I don't have any problem with Schneier referencing this article.
- rilita 12y agoBesides reposting the notion that timestamps imply a USB2 file dump, I am seeing only speculation in this article and no "new data on attributing". I would like to point out that any skilled unix developer can create a script in about an hour that can make any set of files appear to have been transferred using USB2.
- rudolf0 12y agoOf course. Even more likely is that the timestamps aren't forged, but are merely a result of the attackers copying everything to some sort of local storage a few days before preparing the big dump to release to the public. It's possible that in reality the data was initially copied 3+ months ago. You can't rely on file timestamps as a sole mechanism of when the true "original" version of a file was created or modified. (This is "conclusion 2" from the post.) This isn't really news at all, and I'm kind of surprised Schneier thought it was worthwhile enough to publish it. Look at how incredibly sensationalistic this article is, which Schneier cites as the primary source: http://www.4thmedia.org/2014/12/breaking-we-can-conclusively-confirm-north-korea-was-not-behind-sony-hack/ http://www.4thmedia.org/2014/12/breaking-we-can-conclusively... "BREAKING: We Can Conclusively Confirm North Korea Was NOT BEHIND Sony Hack", seriously? I understand he just wanted to aggregate all the updates and commentary since his last post, but this is practically nothing and is just about bordering on FUD (I'd say "reverse-FUD" but that's not how it works, just like "reverse-racism" doesn't exist). So far, no 3rd party has provided any strong evidence showing that North Korea either was or wasn't involved.
- netman21 12y agoVery surprised that Schneier fell for this source. A little research would have provided this on the author, one Charles C. Johnson "The Worst Journalist on the Web" http://gawker.com/what-is-chuck-johnson-and-why-the-web-s-worst-journal-1666834902 http://gawker.com/what-is-chuck-johnson-and-why-the-web-s-wo...
- woodman 12y agoSo I've been out of security for a while, but I don't think I've ever seen this sort of misdirection applied before - or even disused.
- wahsd 12y agoAll I can think of is the FBI statement about how they in consultation with other federal agencies have conclusive evidence that the "hack" emanated from NK. I seriously hope that is rubbed in everyone's face if this turns out to be an insider action that almost and possibly even caused a cyber attack by the USA on a sovereign nation, no matter how much we have been trained not to like NK.
- patronagezero 12y agoI think people should really consider that there was nothing but the intent to assist in the Sony PR campaign in the first place. The US Government is a corporation first and foremost, both on paper, and in action. They want to see all of their subsidiaries do well. The way I see it, they're bending over backwards for the sake of profit and consumerism, as that boat is currently sinking.
- pdabbadabba 12y ago> no matter how much we have been trained not to like NK. I get that you're skeptical of the U.S. government. For good reason. But nobody needs to be trained to dislike NK (except, perhaps, North Koreans). Is your implication that NK isn't really so bad, and it's only a brainwashed reflex to think that it is? I, personally, really wish that were the case, for the sake of everyone who lives in NK. But it isn't. There are things much worse than the U.S. government. http://www.hrw.org/world-report/2014/country-chapters/north-korea http://www.hrw.org/world-report/2014/country-chapters/north-... Edit: You might also want to reflect on why it is that you're so willing to doubt NK's responsibility for the attack on Sony, but apparently pretty eager to believe that the U.S. is behind the attack on NK. Is the evidence for the latter claim somehow stronger than the evidence for the former? I would have thought the opposite was true.
- woodman 12y ago> Edit: ... First, what evidence? Second, the USG has demonstrated the fact that it cannot be trusted to tell the truth. That has been the funniest thing about the whole Snowden story, the cycle of lies and spin when the lie is exposed by an additional leak the following day. Third, Obama publicly threatened retaliation - so a hasty cyberattack by the USG isn't far fetched at all.
- ssenkus 12y agoViral marketing for The Interview, nothing more
- bitwarrior 12y agoNot even remotely likely.
- sroerick 12y agoThis is the correct response to this meme. The hacks are far too damaging to be viral marketing. That said, there can be no denying that Sony turned lemons into lemonade, and milked this attack for all the awareness it could possibly get. I saw "MPAA cyberterrorism experts" on CNN, I saw CNN commentators say that in the interest of free speech, it was every American's patriotic duty to see this film. This was happening in the context of Project Goliath, and threatened legal action against twitter and individual users for posting the leaks.
- snowwrestler 12y agoThe most important data on attributing the Sony attack might be out-of-band data: data that has been collected and analyzed totally separately from the data involved in the attack itself. There's no question that the U.S. and allies are heavily invested in surveilling and analyzing everything that the North Korean government does, so they would have a lot of opportunity to collect such data. And if they did, it's not likely that they would publish one bit of it. I think the firmness of the U.S. statement that it was North Korea, combined with the waffling on the execution details (maybe they outsourced some of the hacking, maybe not) points pretty clearly to out-of-band data. They would know who to blame, but not necessarily every detail of how the attack was conducted. For everyone else out here in non-classified land, trying to analyze the attack using only the data that the attackers themselves leaked is going to be tough, because the attackers have total control about what data we see. They can redact and obfuscate to their hearts' content before releasing it.
- rbobby 12y ago> the very same day that Sony Pictures' head of corporate communications, [... name removed by rbobby ...], publicly resigned from a $600,000 job. This could be a coincidence but it seems unlikely. So Schneier is repeating GotNews' (Charles C. Johnson) accusation that this fellow is connected to a serious set of crimes. All on the basis that a portion of these crimes appear to have happened on the same day the alleged conspirator resigned from his job. Pretty outrageous behavior. Especially since the FBI has has identified NK as responsible. It's worth noting that the FBI had access to _ALL_ the available data and has presumably investigated any employees known to have left recently on bad terms (i.e. the FBI did a professional job of investigation). All the bullshit speculation as to why the FBI is wrong has been based solely on crumbs of publicly available data/information. The underlying premise is that the FBI is utterly incompetent and unable to investigate a crime of this nature. That doesn't pass Occam's Razor let alone any kind of smell test.
- woodman 12y ago> That doesn't pass Occam's Razor let alone any kind of smell test. Really? So North Korea launching a cyber attack in order to prevent the release of a stupid movie seems like a plausible story to you? Of course the story is a moving target, as they are now hedging with the whole foreign contracted hacker angle... Do you think they conducted a "professional job of investigation" before blaming North Korea? Do you think that they'd change their position on the matter even after discovering evidence that they were wrong? Keep in mind, Obama quickly restated their claims and threatened retaliation.
- sroerick 12y ago> The underlying premise is that the FBI is utterly incompetent and unable to investigate a crime of this nature. No, there's lots of different things that could be happening. The FBI could have said it was North Korea to save face. As @thegrugq (who, by the way, is one of three security researchers who I can find who believes it was North Korea) suggests, the NSA could have investigated, discovered the culprit was DPRK, and then just informed the FBI. The FBI could also be incompetent. But lets bear in mind that this is the same organization that blackmailed MLK and told him to kill himself, launched the COINTELPRO program, started fires at Waco, spied on Elvis Presley, Frank Sinatra, John Denver, John Lennon, Jane Fonda, Groucho Marx, Charlie Chaplin, MC5, Lou Costello, Sonny Bono, Bob Dylan, Michael Jackson, and Mickey Mantle, and three years ago used a chainsaw to break into a house before realizing that it was the wrong house. So you'll forgive me if I'm skeptical of the organization's claims. PS. If you have any other 3rd party security researchers who believe the FBI's claims, I'd be happy to add them to my list.