3 ms·
Someone should find that student's advisor and inform him of his student's dealings... To put it bluntly, any university willing to give a PhD to a physics stu
by colechristensen 12y ago
Someone should find that student's advisor and inform him of his student's dealings...
To put it bluntly, any university willing to give a PhD to a physics student who actually believes this is real should lose it's accreditation based on this fact alone.
- raverbashing 12y agoYes, let's keep the Ad Hominem going. What someone believes or not should not disqualify their work or published results. Period. The work should be evaluated on its own merits. Unless the idea is really to form a cabal and only allow research on topics that don't question anything, which seems to be what several aim for (and of course, it's easier to get a grant for those)
- colechristensen 12y agoA cranky old man who makes racist remarks shouldn't have his earlier works in biology questioned. A mathematicians beliefs on God should have no bearings on the quality of her theorems. A physics student in training unable to recognize (much less participating with and encouraging) a crackpot's physics theories which should be obvious to any undergrad, should not attain a degree in physics. It's not about persecuting beliefs, but a disturbing lack of basic understanding.
- dsfsdfd 12y agohttp://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20927952.900-scorn-over-claim-of-teleported-dna.html http://www.newscientist.com/article/mg20927952.900-scorn-ove... http://news.techworld.com/personal-tech/3256631/dna-molecules-can-teleport-nobel-prize-winner-claims/ http://news.techworld.com/personal-tech/3256631/dna-molecule... I guess this guy should never have got his doctorate, let alone a Nobel prize?
- sonoffett 12y agoA world dominated by the dogma of the fundamental materialists is quite scary indeed. Geniuses such as Ramanujan would never see their gifts blossom. ``...and claimed to dream of blood drops that symbolised her male consort, Narasimha, after which he would receive visions of scrolls of complex mathematical content unfolding before his eyes. He often said, "An equation for me has no meaning, unless it represents a thought of God." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Srinivasa_Ramanujan
- api 12y agoI've been wondering if fundamentalist positivism might not be the "Vatican dogma" of the next dark age. I'm skeptical of this claim, but I don't fault them for trying. I also don't fault them for having strange beliefs. All sorts of geniuses have had very odd beliefs, from Newton onward. Seems to go hand in hand with the kind of bravely inquisitive mind that does such things.
- sonoffett 12y agoYep, going to leave this here again: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_Inquisition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_New_Inquisition
- api 12y agoYeah, I'm not by any means the first. Note that I do not mean science. Fundamentalist positivism is really a religious fundamentalist movement built around scientific nomenclature and academic orthodoxy. I consider it a form of cargo cult pseudoscience.
- dsfsdfd 12y agoCrazy smart people often believe crazy things. I'll let you into a little secret - it's because they are very smart. They have the mental horsepower to ignore the wisdom of the crowd and look at the facts for themselves. Sometimes this means they are persuaded by non-sense, but sometimes it means they see what others do not.
- dsfsdfd 12y agoAlso, personally I think it is entirely possible that we have been visited by aliens. Why is it so difficult to believe, you think we are the only life in the universe? Of course the idea is mixed up in a whole lot of mythology, it's a magnet for crackpots. But underneath all that, the central position that we may have been visited by aliens and we may have observed them, is not really crazy, when you think about it coolly and logically. I haven't seen any evidence in my life that can convince me either way and I am comfortable with that ambiguity.
- Retric 12y agoThere is a vast difference between life out there somewhere and life out there, that's intelligent, can travel in space, is close enough to visit, and can visit without being obvious about it. Suppose there were 1 trillion intelligent civilizations spanning 2,000,000 light years wide civilizations in the observable universe right now. Observable universe has a radius of ed: ~78 billion light years. 4/3 pi * r ^3 = ~2 * 10 ^ 33 cubic light years. Where those 1 billion civilizations would cover 4/3 * pi * (2,000,000/2) ^3 * 1 trillion = 4.19 * 10 ^ 30 cubic light years. End result we would have (2e33/4.19e30) = less than 1% chance of being in the area of even one of them. PS: Sure it's a silly example, but space is ridiculously huge. If assume there was 1 billion billion billion civilisations as advanced as us (as in radio at current power levels) and chances are we would not detect any of them.