7 ms·
In his garage lab, Omahan aims to bend fabric of space
- rmason 12y agoThere were several well funded efforts to create the first airplane, Alexander Graham Bell among them. Yet they got bested by two bicycle mechanics. I truly believe if someone creates a warp drive it will indeed be someone like this guy operating out of a garage and not NASA.
- cordite 12y agoThe pressure to succeed vs the pressure to show progress in any form or fashion, eh?
- rmason 12y agoWhat is utterly fascinating is that the Wright Brothers two well funded competitors, Alexander Graham Bell and Samuel Pierpont Langley, both quit after the first flight. Both of them wanted to be first and when they couldn't do that they walked away from what they both surely should have seen would be the birth of a huge high growth industry. They definitely could have gone back to the lab and with the map the Wright's provided have gone on to build a better plane. In fact Alexander Graham Bell's chief assistant Glenn Curtiss did exactly that creating what ultimately became the larger company Curtiss-Wright corporation.
- wwweston 12y ago> What is utterly fascinating is that the Wright Brothers two well funded competitors, Alexander Graham Bell and Samuel Pierpont Langley I've seen this conclusion drawn about Langley before. And it seems like a great anecdote for underscoring the idea that motivation is key. At least, until you consider some other facts: - Langley had a long and pretty distinguished career in physics before looking at aviation, indicating some innate dedication. And he did research in flight (and had success with models) for 12 years before he ever became a well-funded competitor to the Wrights. - Langley was almost 70 years old at that point and he died three years later. I'm not sure why that isn't the go-to explanation for why he didn't keep going and participate in industry. - Langley also apparently is recorded to have remarked to Rudyard Kipling that he didn't think he'd live to see the airplane happen, but that he was certain that it would happen. This is not exactly the mark of someone whose only motivation in participating was an attachment to personally being first.
- colechristensen 12y agoThey were successful because they _were_ bicycle mechanics. They were particularly suited (and lucky in a few ways) to reducing the weight of a powered aircraft enough while being structurally sound to a point where it could sustain flight. If they didn't succeed somebody else would have in a very short time. Increasingly light internal combustion engines and increasingly strong and light materials and manufacturing techniques made powered flight inevitable in the early 20th century. Who got there first is memorable, but the breakthoughs they made were going to happen with or without them. If someone creates a warp drive it will require the energy density, funding, and high technology materials fabrication of a nation state behind it sitting on the foundation of theoretical physics well established. You might as well suggest the first nuclear bomb was more likely to be created by a tinkerer than the Manhattan project.
- rpedela 12y agoIn hindsight, it is obvious that bicycle mechanics had a good chance because they succeeded and their design was more like a flying bicycle than a modern aircraft. However I am sure most other people thought it was only possible from groups with significant funding before the Wright brothers succeeded. We don't know if a warp drive is practically possible, nor do we know how one would work. It may turn out that it is so easy that it can be done with a modest budget in a garage. To be clear, I am not saying this guy is on to something (probably isn't but I would be pleasantly surprised if he is). I simply object to the assumption that this type of discovery must come from a well-funded entity.
- logfromblammo 12y agoThe "nuclear boy scout" was well on his way to something before he was shut down due to public safety concerns. I'm not certain what that something would have been, but Mr. Entropy suggests that a destructive device was more likely than a constructive one. Granted, he was working off of principles already explored and established by Manhattan and other nuclear physics research, but it is still possible that he would have created something novel before killing himself, and possibly others, simply because externally funded researchers must necessarily be prudent and rational to secure external research funding, and therefore don't intentionally try anything too far beyond the ordinary. Crackpots, on the other hand, can do whatever crazy thing they can imagine with their own money. The only thing really stopping a tinkerer's nuke is poor availability of appropriate isotopes. And David Hahn began construction of a breeder reactor in his own backyard. At age 17. The "demon core" accidentally went critical twice, killing the person closest to it within a month, both times. In both cases, that person had the presence of mind to remove the neutron reflectors as quickly as they were able. An amateur, acting alone, might have accidentally caused a criticality event large enough to qualify as "the first nuclear bomb". Manhattan was more about adapting nuclear bombs for military use. It's really easy to create a bomb if you don't care about blowing yourself up (see also: "Things I Won't Work With" blog), but much more difficult to destroy only what you want to destroy, without dying yourself or going bankrupt.
- mjfl 12y agoInspiring. I'm sure there's more then a few members of this community content to knock down and debunk everything that he's doing. I'm not going to do that, instead I'm going to upvote and hope more people take on similar crazy ventures.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoWe should try and debunk everything he is doing. It is the best way of finding out if it might work.
- raverbashing 12y agoExactly The best debunkings are the ones that were done carefully and failed
- japhyr 12y agoHis work sounds easy enough to test: hang a weight in an electric field, and the weight moves farther than it should. Has there been any effort to independently test what he claims to have discovered?
- raverbashing 12y agoTake a look at the pictures The interesting part is: the weight is inside a faraday cage The V-Shaped panels, no idea what's going on there, the fractal part maybe has a flat frequency response?
- daveloyall 12y agoI am frequently in Omaha. If he will let me, I'll stick my hand in the region of the supposedly warped space. How should I approach him? Secretly I hope he's actually warped space. I'll stick a dowel rod in there before my hand... :)
- steventhedev 12y agoHere's his site, for those who want to start the analysis of his data/methodology: http://www.paresspacewarpresearch.org/ http://www.paresspacewarpresearch.org/
- raverbashing 12y agoI can deal with the 90s website, but some numbers he's presenting are off with what is mentioned from the micro-deflections of his experiments I can buy a micro-deflection (after some independent replications are done, surely)
- colordrops 12y agoI don't know what to make of this. It has a lot of the same idiosyncrasies of a lot of other pseudo-scientific endeavors, with the 90's style website design, several spelling errors, a disproportionate amount of media coverage, poorly designed charts, jerry rigged lab setup, etc. They always include a model of their "spacecraft" in every shot. In this video, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TKTsAa4sSs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8TKTsAa4sSs, they already have a pilot, random equations on the blackboard, and a spread of meters in front of the person speaking. Their lead scientist is a physics student, who is the president UNO Paranormal Society. It all seems rather fishy, but I'll withhold my judgement until someone comes and reproduces or falsifies their claims.
- colechristensen 12y agoSomeone should find that student's advisor and inform him of his student's dealings... To put it bluntly, any university willing to give a PhD to a physics student who actually believes this is real should lose it's accreditation based on this fact alone.
- raverbashing 12y agoYes, let's keep the Ad Hominem going. What someone believes or not should not disqualify their work or published results. Period. The work should be evaluated on its own merits. Unless the idea is really to form a cabal and only allow research on topics that don't question anything, which seems to be what several aim for (and of course, it's easier to get a grant for those)
- colechristensen 12y agoA cranky old man who makes racist remarks shouldn't have his earlier works in biology questioned. A mathematicians beliefs on God should have no bearings on the quality of her theorems. A physics student in training unable to recognize (much less participating with and encouraging) a crackpot's physics theories which should be obvious to any undergrad, should not attain a degree in physics. It's not about persecuting beliefs, but a disturbing lack of basic understanding.
- colechristensen 12y agoThis is bollocks. The Wright brothers did not break any barriers in basic science, they solved an engineering problem. The basics of fluid dynamics and prerequisites to flight were established in the late 19th/beginning of the 20th century. There were plenty of details to sort out and experiments to do, but the scientific foundation was there. The problem of flight had been reduced to the engineering problem of improving two ratios: Thrust/Weight and Lift/Drag. What this man in his garage is proposing he's done would be earth shattering if the demo he's impressed upon a rather impressionable reporter (and several HN commenters) were real. More impressive than anything the $10 billion LHC could hope for, but he hasn't, let's be clear. What's actually happened is a guy tinkering in his garage with electromagnets has gotten himself and a few people surrounding him caught up with grandiose ideas. Electromagnets aren't blocked by faraday cages, which easily explains away any warping he thinks he's accomplished. You shouldn't need technical knowledge to figure this out though, because the top half of that article isn't about what he's doing, it's about the underdog ignored maverick thinker making revolutions in his garage. It's in an online newspaper hosted at omaha.com. It's written by someone with obviously little scientific training. Personal bollocks filters are important to develop.
- jccooper 12y agoThe Wrights did novel and indispensable practical research on airfoils and what can actually generate lift. The "theoretical" understanding of fluid dynamics and lift before them was quite wrong... because no one had tested it. So too they solved the problems of aerodynamic stability and how to effect control through numerous experiments. They also had plenty of engineering challenges, such as structure and power and skin and how to activate control surfaces. But to consider what they did to be a mere "engineering problem" is bollocks.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoI'm always a sucker for these kinds of stories. It's the science version of watching somebody play the lottery -- terrifically long odds, and probably not a good investment of time or money, but sooner or later somebody is going to hit on something. If the guy can build an artifact that floats? I think it's game over; we have a new natural law to add to the list. If not? There's still something to be said for using scientific principles to explore things, even if those things are long shots.
- flatline 12y agoI'm a sucker for these kinds of stories too, but after a little reflection I'm usually just left disappointed. I don't think he's really using scientific principles, unfortunately. Science would require a constant attempt to falsify his results, at least enough to ensure he's not fooling himself. This capacity for genuine self reflection is exceedingly rare. The guy has the academic background to carefully test and verify his own conclusions, and lay people typically assume those credentials in themselves are sufficient when really they are worthless by themselves. I understand being driven by something like this. When you work alone on a long shot, you've got to go through periods of speculation, exploration, driving ahead somewhat heedlessly. But you also have to go through periods of withdrawal, reflection, checking the assumptions that you made in your wild flight forward, and making course corrections as required. What happens when you find you've reached a dead-end? Some people change course or give up. Others just keep plodding ahead as though it weren't the case. This has the feeling of the latter, and it makes me sad. I wish all the best for the guy, but I'd put my money on a lotto ticket.
- DanielBMarkham 12y agoNot my money :) Look, it's very easy. Just like those Steorn guys, you either produce something that's big and does something really strange -- or you don't. What usually happens, as you know, is that the experimenter creates something that is basically reproducible lab error. So it's there, but it's small, and there doesn't seem to be an easy way to make it macro-sized. They run out of money, still convinced they're on to something. At that point you have the newspaper articles, the full-page ads, and so on. It's a well-trodden path, no doubt. But I don't see any of these guys appealing to mysticism or supernatural forces. All of them think that either they'll make something of wonder or it will fail. So both the people in question and the audience share some common framework. Just like watching people argue politics, it makes for a nice example of how really smart people can fool themselves. That's something we all can learn from. Plus I have unshakable faith that some sort of field propulsion possible, although I have no idea how far away it might be. I base this on many years of watching science fiction shows on TV <g>
- FiatLuxDave 12y agoSome comments as a fellow garage experimenter and physicist: There are two experimental results which are presented. The first is the generation of fringe patterns with the laser beam sent through the crossed fields. The second is the force generated which is measured using a weight scale. There is not enough detail available on the fringe patterns, which is too bad because it is the more interesting of the two results. First, there is no 'before and after' picture, to see how much change in fringing occurred. Second, nothing is mentioned about verification that the fringing effect was not coming from mechanical distortion of the display screen. It is not so easy to alter light beams using EM fields in free space, so if it could be shown that the light is actually being affected (with a better designed experiment), that would be cool. The force effect is a mess, both in presentation and experimental design. First of all, it appears that they are mixing experimental values with modeled values in their graphs and tabulated forces, and they don't say which is which. I don't believe that they actually delivered 305 watts with their antennas and measured 559607.4 Newtons of force. That much force could lift a Abrahms battle tank, and is unlikely to be measured down to the tenth of a Newton. That appears to come from their exponential model. I do believe the 1.25 g up and 1.30 g down points at 5 watts were actually measured. Static force measurement can be notoriously misleading. It is very easy to do (all you need is a scale) and it can be easily done wrong; wrong in the sense that the result may not be indicative of what you are trying to measure. It is just too easy in a world filled with small forces to end up measuring something other than what you think you are. I see no indication that they are not just measuring normal electromagnetic interactions, instead of a warp bubble. One way to fix this problem is to measure dynamic forces, where your effect must transfer a goodly amount of energy. With static forces, you can easily turn 0.0001 J into a large force. There are significant issues with the exponential model of the force. Force x velocity = power, so if you find a way to generate exponential force from a power, at some velocity you will be generating more power than you use. Now, if you believe that your power is coming from the fabric of space, this might not be a problem, but it also means that your experiment should show this by operating at or above that velocity. Velocity relative to what, you ask? Hey, it's not my inconsistent hypothesis. The biggest issue of course, is that the experiments are showing 'something', but there is no direct link to show that what they are showing is coming from the hypothesized warp bubble. More control experiments are needed. That is where you really learn where you are wrong, and hopefully where you are right. I will say that for those of you who are focusing on the style of the presentation or how jury-rigged the experiments appear, you might see those things in poor science, but you also see that when someone doesn't focus on presentation. I doubt Pares expected this to end up on HN. I've done work that looked just as bad, and while I would want to clean it up before presenting it to the world, sometimes that is what simple experiments look like. When my friends ask me why I don't share more of my experiments on the web, I can point to this discussion.
- jcfrei 12y agoFiatLuxDave already did a great write up of his concerns: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8815059 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8815059 . I won't/can't criticize any physics mentioned on their website - but I would argue that there is a pattern in the (perceivably) recent surge of experimental space drives. I believe it's a simple economical cause: Finer and more precise measuring instruments become more and more affordable. And as FiatLuxDave points out, measuring any (small) amount of force or disturbance in a regular workplace is just more likely than not. So you get lots and lots of people with these hyper sensitive devices, which then come up with some crazy explanation for the unexplained force rather than changing the setup of their experiment.