6 ms·
The Weirdness of 50s Bomb Shelters
- kulkarnic 12y agoThe rational reason we don't build nuclear shelters anymore is because they're no longer effective. As weapon yields increased, it's become apparent that a concrete, underground hideout is not going to save you. The irrational reason is that it's been 60+ years since atomic weapons were deployed, and we are confident the danger has passed. But really, there's plenty of weapons out there: http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/11/map-nuclear-bombs-power-weapons http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2011/11/map-nuclear-bomb...
- waynecochran 12y agoAn underground hideout was never going to save you if you were near enough to the blast -- I always thought it was more of a way to protect yourself from nuclear fallout -- wouldn't that still be a valid reason to build a shelter?
- kulkarnic 12y agoYes, you can save yourself from the fallout (which decays exponentially with distance anyway). Unfortunately within around 15mi, you're still going to get pretty bad burns, unless you duck into your shelter immediately after the explosion. That's where the early warning systems are useful-- you get 6-8min with an ICBM strike.
- Someone 12y agoYou don't need reinforced shelters against fallout; above-ground buildings will do fine, as long as they can be made reasonably airtight (as additional protection, one could provide for material to replace broken windows) Also, I think most shelters would be far enough from blast areas to provide some protection. Eizo Nomura (who, amazingly, doesn't have a Wikipedia page) was 170 meter from ground zero in Hiroshima, and survived (http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_and_Nagasaki#The_bombing http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_bombings_of_Hiroshima_...) Akiko Takakura was above ground at less than 300m and lived for 60 years. Even though later bombs were much more powerful that makes it likely that shelters at the edge of the blast radius can save lives. Not all of them, but any program to protect civilians is a statistics game. All the construction in SF isn't 100% effective against earthquakes, either.
- hga 12y agoPer Cresson Kerney, who's nuclear war survival stuff was actually tested against reality (vs. the deathtraps like at least one of those early shelter plans in the OP which was dreamed up by D.C. bureaucrats) says air tightness concerns are entirely overblown, so to speak ^_^. As I recall, the heavy stuff that falls out early is too big to be a concern of that sort, the light stuff decays to safe (enough) levels before enough of it drops and becomes an issue. We have a lot of data on this thanks to those eeeevil above ground tests. What you need is plenty of mass between sources of radiation, i.e. fallout particles where they settle, and from "skyshine". In a sufficiently bad situation, which would be pretty common, a simple ditch where you made sure the fallout kept out and didn't accumulate on, say, the tarp you were using for that, you'd still get zapped by gamma rays that bounce off atoms in the air and come down into the ditch. So the most basic expedient fallout shelter is a ditch with hollow core interior doors over it or the like, and foot of dirt on top, which through arching holds most of its weight. An above-ground building is iffy, because you want, say, 3 feet of dirt all around you, and either a foot on top or if the roof is high enough that's not as much of an issue. Middle stories of a tall building could suffice.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoNo, a shelter is a perfectly valid way of surviving a near miss-being 20-30 miles away, you'll want a shelter.
- Retric 12y ago10,000 nukes * pi * 30mi ^2 = 28,274,000 square miles. The lower 48 states are only 3,119,884.69 square miles if you inclde waterways. With just land it's only 2,959,064.44 square miles. So, 10k nukes let's you carpet bomb the lower 48 and have one within 10 miles of just about every point. Focus on population centers and I suspect you could easily get 95+% of the population within 5 miles of a detonation.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoWhere do you get 10K nukes (Russia now? Soviet Union circa 1984?) Do you mean warheads or delivery vehicles? Do you assume that every one of those 10K will be delivered to the lower 48? Or that every one of those 10K will be successfully launched and reach its target? That there won't be any out of commission for maintenance or second strikes? Or that a western pre-emptive strike won't hit any? Or that there might be BMD systems that will make an incoming strike suffer attrition? Are you factoring in that some targets will get much more than a single warhead?
- Retric 12y agoThat was just a nice round number. According to Wikipedia from ~1970 - 2000 Russia had 10,000+ nukes with a peak of ~40,000 in ~1985. No idea what the actual numbers where though. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_arms_race http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_arms_race Mostly, I was just pointing out that fairly soon they could branch out and target just about any population center. I don't think they ever actually targeted death valley for example. Anyway, the important thing to remember is by the mid 1970's many of these bomb shelters had been unused for 20+ years. It's very natural to look at something like that and say spending more on this is probably pointless.
- rhino369 12y ago
- ErikRogneby 12y agoHere is a pretty well built companion tool for looking at blast radius. http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ http://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/
- hga 12y agoYields didn't really increase that much, there's a limiting factor where more and more of the energy released simply radiates out into space, and that's somewhere around 1MT as I recall. A serious, concrete underground "hideout" will save you from anything but a really close hit; I can look up numbers if you want, but I maybe remember a good metric is 1MT and one mile of separation, requiring a less intense shelter. And a large fraction of the population can get by with much less, carpet bombing suburbia and exurbia was never going to happen, especially due to counterforce requirements and the Soviets believing that MAD was profoundly immoral and never buying into it.
- dba7dba 12y agoSome may disagree but the reason we did not have WW3 was because of nukes. Had there been no nukes, I firmly believe we would've had WW3 (or even WW4). Because both leaderships of US and USSR knew starting WW3 would mean end of civilization on the planet, they controlled themselves.
- alan_cx 12y agoI thought that was the whole point of building lots of nukes on both sides. They called it MAD, mutually assured destruction.
- hga 12y agoThat was never the Soviet's game, they planned to win if it came down to it, and note all the mentions of 2nd World shelters in this discussion for part of that plan. I've also read a translated version of their basic civil defense book, it was good. MAD was insanity cooked up by Robert Strange McNamara and company of Vietnam infamy in the early-mid-60s. The Soviets never bought into it, and thought, correctly, that a plan to burn alive children in their homes was irredeemably evil, and a sign the US was very evil. And at this level it was and still is.
- dba7dba 12y agoWhat do you mean by Soviets never bought into it? Did they think they could win without themselves being destroyed by American nukes?
- hga 12y agoYes. Although emphasize could, it was hardly certain. (And if this strikes you as crazy, well, remember that since a little before 1920 they explicitly were planning on taking over the world, and got uncomfortably close to achieving that goal.) This was one of the reasons SDI, even on paper/in the lab, was so terribly effective. Against an even partly effective ABM system a counterforce first strike becomes impossible, since you can't choose which warheads or boosters get intercepted. Counterforce is an attack on your opponent's strategic forces, aimed at preventing them from retaliating. That's one of the reasons we had to build the expensive "Triad" of ICBMs, SLBMs, and manned bombers. Reliably taking all three out is very difficult.
- masklinn 12y ago> The rational reason we don't build nuclear shelters anymore is because they're no longer effective. The rational reason we don't build nuclear shelters anymore (which is not actually true by the way, Switzerland still builds them although they're not required anymore for private residences) is because there's very little chance of a massive nuclear war which is what they were for. > As weapon yields increased, it's become apparent that a concrete, underground hideout is not going to save you. Weapon yield has decreased, not increased. In the 50s, delivery was through bombers, you wanted big bombs because many bombers were going to be shot down so each nuke delivered had to pack as much punch as it could. Early ICBM had similar-ish issue, you had few inaccurate rockets and they had a warhead each so each warhead had to count, you built a big rocket and a big warhead on top of it, and the ones that didn't fail and weren't shot down razed a city even when they missed it by tens of miles. That's where you had multi-megaton designs With the 60s and MIRV multi-megaton went online (they'd been designed in the 50s) but systems designed in the 60s and deployed in the 70s for the exact same role all went sub-megaton, half a megaton at most, usually less, for smaller and more precise delivery platforms and MIRV systems. The most numerous warhead in the US nuclear arsenal is the 100kT W76.
- jules 12y agoThat does not make logical sense. For any given nuclear weapon that doesn't kill the entire planet there is a range from the epicenter where a bomb shelter is effective, regardless of weapon yield. Yes, the area where people are killed even if they are in a bomb shelter is larger, but the area where people are saved by a bomb shelter is larger as well.
- wglb 12y agoThis was particularly memorable for me as during that time, my dad, a wheat farmer, during the winter would construct shelters for folks in town. None were quite so elaborate as the more extreme ones shown in the article. A little later, the county was dotted with the Minuteman missle sites and control centers. One silo was on a friends farm. He said it was sobering to think that the several-foot thick concrete lid would blow the better part of a hundred yards away just before launch.
- arethuza 12y agoI'd have thought it would be even more sobering to think about what would be arriving 20 to 30 minutes after the missiles blasted off. NB The novel "Arc Light" includes one thread where the crew from a a Minuteman control center surviving an attack and spending weeks underground then having to make an escape through the devastated landscape: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arc_Light_%28novel%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arc_Light_%28novel%29
- hga 12y agoEven that nasty a situation is survivable with sufficient strength shelters, luck to avoid a random direct hit, and enough food and water/water supply to wait out the longer period required before evacuating the indeed "devastated landscape". What I find weird is the attitude that it's better to die than survive with most all of your loved ones and friends, albeit at a reduced quality of life for a long time. A rather ultimate materialistic attitude, or perhaps it's as Dean Ing put it in Systemic Shock: The American public had by turns ignored and ridiculed its cassandras: city planners, ecologists, demographers, socialists, immigrants, who had all warned against our increasing tendency to crowd into our cities. Social stress, failure of essential services, and warfare were only a few of the spectres we had granted only a passing glance. We had always found some solution to our problems, though: often at the last moment. Firmly anchored in most Americans was the tacit certainty that, even to the problem of nuclear war against population centers, there must be a uniquely American solution; we would find it. The solution was sudden death. A hundred million Americans found it.
- 12y ago
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- stephancoral 12y agoPhoto number 9 isn't simply a bomb shelter, its a decommissioned ATLAS F missile base - http://www.silohome.com/ http://www.silohome.com/ The Las Vegas shelter is awesome, almost like an art installation.
- torgoguys 12y ago20th Century Castles (http://www.missilebases.com/ http://www.missilebases.com/) has been at this for a while. If you check out their site, you can find out how you too can own an old underground missile silo. :-)
- cjg_ 12y agoAnd the last photo is from Bahnhof's datacenter in central Stockholm (which is a former command centre). See this Wired article about it, http://www.wired.com/2012/11/bahnhof/ http://www.wired.com/2012/11/bahnhof/
- freshyill 12y agoWhen I got to that image, that's when I completely gave up on it. This article was complete spam, and devoid of any real content. Somebody spent five minutes googling "bomb shelter" and then posted a few photos with some asinine remarks.
- wtbob 12y agoI really don't care for the snide tone of the article. Bomb shelters weren't weird; they weren't irrational. Recall that WWII had involved mass area bombing of civilian targets; many Europeans and Brits were alive in the 50s due to their nations' bomb shelter programs (I don't know about Japan or the Soviets, so I can't say there). A nuke isn't some magical death-and-destruction device: it's just a really powerful bomb, which releases some really nasty pollutants. It's a difference of degree, not of kind: other bombs are weaker and still releases less nasty pollutants. Sure, no home bomb shelter could survive a direct hit; but home shelters weren't made to resist direct hits: they were made to resist blast waves from hits on nearby cities; they were made to resist nearby conventional hits. What made them less useful investments was a factor of several things. Precision targeting made area bombing less likely. Improved air defenses made large-scale WWII-style bombing raids less likely. It might also be the case that larger bombs made the risk-reward ratio different. While cleaning out my grandparents' home a few months ago I came across a government civil defense pamphlet my grandfathers' firm had republished. It was full of good, scientifically-accurate, well-founded advice. It wasn't alarmist; it was up-to-date for the time when it was published. It certainly wasn't weird to be prepared for something which at the time was likely to happen.
- fennecfoxen 12y agoIn related news, even the much-maligned "Duck and Cover" is full of good advice (which is coincidentally also useful against large meteors). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_and_Cover_(film)#Accuracy_and_usefulness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duck_and_Cover_(film)#Accuracy_...
- wglb 12y agoI really don't care for the snide tone of the article. I didn't read it that way. At least it wasn't more skeptical than my Dad, who thought the idea was a little impractical, perhaps irrational.
- IgorPartola 12y agoI was born in the 1980s in Ukraine, so I have both an experience to share and questions to ask. Questions first: how common was it to build your own shelter in the US? Was it something that most people did? Most people talked about? Were the people who built them considered as irrational as people who build "zombie apocalypse" shelters today? Were they stocked with guns the same way that today's shelters are? Experience: I grew up in Kharkiv, a city with roughly a 1m population, and the second largest city in Ukraine. Most people lived in large apartment complexes that were organized into planned neighborhoods. Imagine four buildings surrounding a common area that was laid out as a small park. Inside this common area that my building was surrounding were three bomb shelters. We called them "old", "weird", and "new" based on their outside appearance. The entrances were fairly small: just a triangle structure with a door and a staircase going down. We never went too deep into them when they were open (the authorities would periodically close them up), but at one point I remember using an iron bar to break the chain on one of them and leading a few of my friends down into it. I really wish we had good flashlights, rope, etc. (we were all around 11 or 12). We went down two levels and looked at these huge rooms. Some of them looked to be set up for bunk beds and it looked like the beds were at some point taken out. I did wander into a random room without a flashlight and almost took a step into a darker area before realizing that it was an opening with a step ladder down to the lower level. I would have been badly hurt had I taken the step before checking. This naturally scared me enough to get out of there in a hurry. The next week this particular shelter was closed up with a better chain so we didn't get to go in again. Edit: I tried to find some pictures of what it looked like. Surely someone has taken some photos at one point, but sadly I cannot find anything that resembled the bomb shelters I explored as a child. I do have a strange fascination with the Cold War, so now I really wish I could go back and take some pictures/explore things as an adult.
- wglb 12y agoIn the rural area where I grew up, I would guess that one household in twenty built a shelter. I wasn't aware of any community-based shelters in the area.
- Ueland 12y agoNorwegian here: While building their house, my grandparents had (by law) to build the basement solid enough to be used as a bomb shelter, this was in the fifties i believe. I now live in an apartment block from early sixties and every block here (with around 24 apartments) has their own bomb shelter in the basement. Even some of our subway stations are (rather large) bomb shelters. In my home village, both some of the schools and sport facilities all had their own bomb shelters which also had facilities for keeping gas out. I do believe that is no longer required to build new bomb shelters but all existing ones has to be maintained and be ready to be used within a specified timeframe.
- ZanyProgrammer 12y agoThe balance of forces was such that it was very conceivable that most of the US could remain unscathed in a nuclear war with the Soviet Union in the 1950s. The strategic disparity was simply too huge. Therefore, shelters made tons of sense.
- anovikov 12y agoEven if shelters had absolutely no protection from blast they would anyway did most of the job they were intended to do: protect from fallout. Just a few days of shelter time will cut number of casualties in half. Also today's nuclear weapons are in general, weaker than those of 1950s, especially late 1950s. Weirdly, this means that shelters give somewhat LESS protection because fallout is less of a factor than blast and prompt radiation (you probably can't get in a shelter in time to avoid prompt radiation).
- ck2 12y agoCongress built themselves a massive, posh nuclear shelter with taxpayer money but when it was revealed by newspapers in the 1990s they closed it. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Greek_Island http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Greek_Island Wanna bet they built another secret one with taxpayer money? Basically if there is nuclear war, congress should die first because it was their job to prevent that from happening in the first place. We certainly should not want them to survive their failures.
- hga 12y agoEh, it was obsolete by sometime in the 60s, e.g. when the SS-9 got accurate enough to take it out. In the '50s and '60s we had a real Civil Defense program, I still have my mother's Civil Defense Block Mother sign from the end of that, when I was in 2nd grade. It was only later that CD -> FEMA and "crisis relocation" replaced sheltering, since it was cheaper. During the same decade we gave up on missile defenses....
- waynecochran 12y agoThis seems appropriate for bomb shelters and Christmas -- Weird Al's "Christmas at Ground Zero:" http://youtu.be/t039p6xqutU http://youtu.be/t039p6xqutU
- trhway 12y agobasements in Donetsk (Ukraine) today many people use as shelters, for example - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jY15tgcE7c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3jY15tgcE7c A lot of the buildings there are typical USSR-style 5-9 stories concrete block apartment buildings with basements made out of concrete blocks of between 0.3-0.5m thickness. The modern, high precision weaponry, isn't available in Ukrainian army, instead it is mostly "classic" low precision "area attack" USSR stuff, like artillery guns and multiple unguided rocket launchers. When the city is shelled from a system like this (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BM-27_Uragan http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BM-27_Uragan) using cluster munition, such basement shelters work great. (http://america.aljazeera.com/multimedia/photo-gallery/2014/7/photos-donetsk-enduresshelling.html http://america.aljazeera.com/multimedia/photo-gallery/2014/7... - starting 2nd photo - the buildings itself ok if no direct hit with basements having very good chance to be ok even in case of direct hit into the building)
- masklinn 12y ago> The modern, high precision weaponry, isn't available in Ukrainian army Even if it were, it's expensive and it requires point & aim so it's not drop & forget and you're bombing a very small surface. You're not going to use it against random civilians when shelling a city center, that's a waste of money, time, airspace, efficiency, everything anyone can care about.
- trhway 12y agoin some cases when mapping the hits (especially when there is whole salvo), it is sometimes pretty clear that Ukrainians were targeting some specific target, and the civilian buildings would just happen to be either in the flightpath on the downward trajectory or just pretty close (again, it is an USSR tech - so 1000ft(300m) is pretty close when unguided missile is launched from 15-20km away) and we're talking about pretty populated city.
- masklinn 12y agoMisses I can believe no problem, but then precision ammunition would probably have turned it into a hit, not into a civilian building eating a bunker buster.
- taivare 12y agoI saw one of those manual-hand-cranked blower's at a flea market , it was old and I couldn't figure out what the hell it was used for now I know it came out of a 50's bomb shelter, the guy selling it didn't know what it was either.
- nsxwolf 12y agoWhere are these shelters now? Were people really building a lot of these? It seems they could be all over the country in mid-century communities everywhere. I look at a lot of real estate listings but I can't say I've ever seen one mentioned.
- teddyh 12y agoRelevant short story by Philip K. Dick, written in 1955: Foster, You're Dead! http://www.american-buddha.com/dick.phildickreader.17.htm http://www.american-buddha.com/dick.phildickreader.17.htm
- hga 12y agoMaybe. Hmmm, in general, very much not a "Maker" attitude. Think about how much fun it would be to recast it into that sort of upbeat "survival in style" ethos. Low power micro-controllers and ARM devices would be even more popular! One form of bragging rights would go to the teens who fashion the lowest power dissipation 1080p shelter media system ^_^. I see from Dick's Wikipedia personal life section that he is almost certainly a city boy through and through, which would explain a lot of this story. As for particulars, ignoring the arms-race part of it, really good basic fallout shelters are ridiculously low tech, the sort of thing people in flyover country are supremely competent to make without any fuss---and most of us don't get caught up in the next year model craziness (E.g. my parents bought a very high end Mercedes in ~1990 ... and sold it this year; they are, of course, members of the Silent Generation). If you need blast protection, then the doors and vents require more serious stuff that's best produced in a factory to standard designs. As for the new sophisticated threat from the Soviets in that story, no, I think not. Very much not in their style.
- teddyh 12y ago> very much not a "Maker" attitude At the bottom of the page is a link labeled "Go to Next Page", which leads to Pay for the Printer, written by Philip K. Dick the year after, 1956. Read that and see if you change your mind about PKD.
- PhantomGremlin 12y agoIn image 4 and 6 the woman is wearing heels. In image 6 the man is wearing a white shirt and tie. Did they just arrive from work, or are they simply intent on keeping up appearances while in the middle of a nuclear war? In image 7 some of the glass jars are so precariously placed that they are actually hanging over the edge of the shelf. Overall, I agree with someone else's assessment here. They said: Somebody spent five minutes googling "bomb shelter" and then posted a few photos with some asinine remarks. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8811872