4 ms·
> Most teachers understand that what students learn in school is because the whole school has made an effort, not just some individual teachers. In the educatio
by danso 12y ago
> Most teachers understand that what students learn in school is because the whole school has made an effort, not just some individual teachers. In the education systems that are high in international rankings, teachers feel that they are empowered by their leaders and their fellow teachers.
As a layperson, I agree with the OP...The focus on the quality of teachers -- and firing "bad" ones and hiring just the "good" ones -- has always seemed to me to be overemphasized, as it makes for a sexy, easily digestible political debate. Not that good teachers (whatever your definition of "good" is) aren't worth having, but it's doubtful that they alone can have a significant impact on student outcomes...in the way we should be doubtful that the well-behaved, well-equipped cops from a rich crime-free suburb would, when moved to the Detroit PD, would have a significant impact.
I lived with a teacher and my best friend is a teacher, both are young and about my age and who work at impoverished schools, and I've been constantly amazed at how much of their talk is not about how bad the kids are, but how bad the administration is...over things such as playing favorites (among teachers) and squabbles over office space and, of course, having to buy their own supplies and books (some of which is reimbursed at the end of the year). You can chalk some of this dysfunction to the educational hot topics of the day: the power of teachers unions, teacher pay, standardized testing...but the bottom line is that passionate, effective teachers can be nullified by a weak system...in the same way that a great programmer may be ineffective in an engineering environment with poor testing/documentation processes and a terrible office environment.
- TwoBit 12y agoReminds of how NFL coaches are so frequently fired when their teams do poorly. It makes for good press, but the teams usually do the same under the next coach.
- bennettfeely 12y agoFiveThirtyEight examined this in the NHL. > Teams that fired their coaches performed exactly the same on average in the following season as teams that kept their coaches. Notably, teams that were sub-.400 performed 20 percent better on average the following season regardless of whether they fired their coach or not. [...] Playoff performance is no better under new coaches. Non-playoff teams go an average of 0.5 playoff rounds the following season, whether they fire their coach or not. http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-predicts-if-an-nhl-coach-will-be-fired-and-whether-it-matters/ http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/what-predicts-if-an-nhl-...
- cheepin 12y agoShouldn't team performance decrease the season after a coach change since the players have to learn a new system? This seems to say that the cost of firing a poor coach is zero because at worst you will do the same as before in the short term, with a great potential upside for longer time spans.
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoThese teams have large coaching staffs that don't get fired and change more slowly. I would guess that a coach's impact is often more long term (in training, recruitment of players and staff).
- philwelch 12y agoIf anything, it would be more fair to fire the GM. It's not uncommon elsewhere in the world for management to be fired if their team as a whole performs poorly. Being held responsible for the performance of the group as a whole incentivizes the right behavior, as long as management is empowered to do what it takes. Head coaches aren't really that empowered because they can't make personnel decisions.
- maaarghk 12y agoDistracted by management? They don't sound passionate or effective to me. Do you think that there's no red tape in Scandinavia and their teachers ste better for administrative reasons??
- japhyr 12y agoI'm not sure you know how difficult some administrators can make it for people to teach well. Teaching is hard enough, when people who have power over you actively get in your way and set you up for failure, that's pretty difficult to ignore. It takes experience and the willingness to risk your job to stand up to that kind of administration.
- learc83 12y agoI'll give you an example. I have a friend who teaches 1st grade. Part of the curriculum was writing in a journal about what you did at home the day before. My friend realized that the kids were more interested in writing about what they did at home in the morning as soon as school started, so she moved journal time from after lunch to first thing in the morning. It worked out great, the kids were writing more and enjoyed writing more. Then the assistant principal observed her class and forced her to move journal time back to the old slot. Another time my friend wanted to do an interactive history lesson that took a bit longer than normal, so she took 15 extra minutes from math that she planned to make up later in the day. The same assistant principal found out and formally disciplined her for not following the approved schedule. Teachers are supposed to be professionals capable of developing their own lesson plans, but when administrators don't treat them like professionals their options are limited.
- ploxiln 12y agoThe paying for supplies part is a bit funny when compared to small competitive software or electronics companies. As an engineer, I'm always offered monitors, computers, peripherals, test equipment... whatever I want, they'll order with next-day shipping.
- Melchizedek 12y agoMore importantly, the thing about Finland is not mainly the teachers or the school system - it's that the students are white. _White_ American students perform about as well as Finnish (almost all white) students.
- jpatokal 12y agoAnd by remarkable coincidence, Finland's GDP per capita is roughly equivalent to GDP per capita for white Americans: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_U... Maybe, just maybe, the differentiating factor is poverty, not race?
- Melchizedek 12y agoNo, white (and asian and jewish) students perform much better than for instance black students from equally wealthy families.
- sopooneo 12y agoI agree with everything you say. But how do we get better administrators? My understanding is that the job can either be cushy or horrific depending on whether you play ball with the superintendent. So perhaps in some districts, trying to be a great administrator is as difficult as trying to be a great teacher. I do realize administrators tend to get paid a lot more.