8 ms·
> "When people say we should raise the minimum wage. I worry about what that does to job creation ... potentially damping demand in the part of the labor spectr
by bambax 12y ago
> "When people say we should raise the minimum wage. I worry about what that does to job creation ... potentially damping demand in the part of the labor spectrum that I’m most worried about."
Bill Gates has been saying this many times and I really, really don't get it.
Of course when the price of a commodity goes up, demand goes down; but if there's a perfect substitute that's free, demand for the non-free alternative should be zero anyway, so its "price" is irrelevant (as long as it's non-free).
Why would anyone hire a human at any cost to do a repetitive and low-added-value job that a robot can do perfectly, without error, without ever arguing or getting tired, etc. AND AT NO MARGINAL COST??
How does "minimum wage" matter in this scenario?
- - -
Humanity has been wanting to not work since the dawn agriculture, 10 000 years ago at the latest. It's finally happening and we're freaking out about it.
What we need to think about is not how to get people employed, it's how to redistribute wealth so that what you earn is not somehow morally related to the job you're holding.
The solution is universal basic income, not "minimum wage".
- dllthomas 12y ago"Why would anyone hire a human at any cost to do a repetitive and low-added-value job that a robot can do perfectly, without error, without ever arguing or getting tired, etc. AND AT NO MARGINAL COST??" Because the robot costs money up front. If energy, maintenance, depreciation, and amortization of the robot exceeds the marginal cost, errors and oversight of the human, then it's rational to keep paying the human. Raising the cost of the human makes the robot more attractive sooner.
- nashashmi 12y ago> Raising the cost of the human makes the robot more attractive sooner. Which is exactly why the minimum wage should rise. Just like the price of coal energy should rise or the cost of unsustainable goods should rise. People are a limited resource and you can get only so many people over time. It is important that people, who are entities of incredible intelligence should be repurposed to harder and mentally more involved processes.
- dllthomas 12y agoI basically agree, but that doesn't mean it's not hurting anyone in the short term. For a few reasons I think a basic income is a better way to raise the price of labor than a minimum wage.
- alexro 12y agoHow about that: Open source, he said, creates a license "so that nobody can ever improve the software," he claimed, bemoaning the squandered opportunity for jobs and business. http://www.wired.com/2008/04/bill-gates-what/ http://www.wired.com/2008/04/bill-gates-what/
- crpatino 12y agoIf by "improve" he means creating a mediocre clone of an existing and successful product, leveraging a monopolistic position to wreck the original, and then go through a long process of incremental improvement on the clone until it is objectively better that what was available 20 years ago (and selling every milestone along the way)... then I guess he's more or less right.
- clarky07 12y ago>What we need to think about is not how to get people employed, it's how to redistribute wealth so that what you earn is not somehow morally related to the job you're holding. Tell me again why you deserve to profit from my hard work? Or why I deserve to profit from your hard work? Shouldn't we both just profit from our own work? This isn't to say I don't think we shouldn't help those less fortunate than ourselves. I try to give a decent amount to charity, but I don't think for a minute that everyone should get paid the same. If you don't provide any benefit to society you shouldn't be as well off as people who provide enormous benefit to society.
- nashashmi 12y agoOP means to say that all work should be valued equally. Because all work is precious. But then again, I have found that earnings usually commensurates intelligence and efficiency. A highly intelligent individual gets disproportionately more money than his counterparts because he is smarter than the median intelligence in the industry.
- clarky07 12y agowhile i'm not sure i agree that all work should be valued equally, that would be more reasonable than what a basic income implies. a basic income means you get it whether you work or not, and that is the part that I find undesirable. that being said the problem with valuing all work the same is that people's definitions of what work has any value at all will be different. it's much easier if the work actually has to have value, i.e. someone willing to pay for it.
- agumonkey 12y agoI really wonder what a society would look like if people didn't have to work to ensure a decent lifestyle (shelter, health, food). I'm thinking that in adult minds there's a psychological need to relate to others that is filled partway by working together and also a need not to have complete freedom about how you spend your existence (paradox of choice). And that when people say they'd love not to work, they mean they'd prefer to balance work ROI differently.
- Futurebot 12y agoAn 'arts, sports, and leisure' society. More people playing video games (the industrialized world is excellent at creating cheap entertainment - we could create WoWs and Candy Crushes forever); playing sports; exercising; socializing; nature walks/hiking/hanging around in parks; learning for learning's sake (with cheap books, MOOCs, etc. you could essentially do self-directed academia for life); amateur science/wilderness exploration; art and music creation; lots of recreational drug use, and eventually, wireheading or its equivalent (top-notch VR would probably get us pretty far down that road, anyway.)
- nradov 12y agoYou don't have to wonder. Take a look at any public housing development where the majority of residents depend on some form of public assistance.
- agumonkey 12y agoI think it's irrelevant, these are minorities, and not first-class lifestyle or culture (not working is frowned upon).
- waterlesscloud 12y agoGenerally that public assistance comes with conditions that require you to remain non-productive if you want to keep having your needs provided for. That's not at all the same thing.