4 ms·
The problem with this form of hyper-libertarianism is that a large percentage of the people your are consigning to your "unproductive" ghetto are children who a
by kasey_junk 12y ago
The problem with this form of hyper-libertarianism is that a large percentage of the people your are consigning to your "unproductive" ghetto are children who are not productive in or out of these neighborhoods and who had no agency in the process that got them placed there.
So you've doubled down on the hardship these children have to overcome. Even if you are ok with this from a moral perspective (which is a pretty high bar to get over in my opinion) it seems like a pretty ineffective way to limit the number of "unproductive" in your society.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoFrom what I see, a fixed number of people will be subject to the predatory behavior of the underclass. We are collectively unwilling to fix this. I don't see a compelling reason why it matters which children are victimized this way. Now if you want to say that none should be, I agree. Find a way to stop crime. Spreading crime around is not that way. (FYI my thinking on this issue draws far more from neo reactionaries than libertarians.)
- com2kid 12y ago> Spreading crime around is not that way. There is also the idea that by separating out problem elements, that in the long term you decrease overall crime. A child in a ghetto who knows not of the potential for escape will likely stay in that ghetto. A child who is surrounded by choices, options, and multiple role models has a choice to make.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoIf you have evidence that exposing everyone to criminals reduces crime, I'd love to see it. Not knowing one can leave can be handled with direct communication. For example, billboards: "get a job and you can leave this place. Any adult is here by choice."
- techsupporter 12y agoOther billboards we can put up in the ghetto to make sure people are fully informed and that experience tells us work just as well: - Not having sex means no babies. - Don't do drugs. - Stay in your local, neighborhood school to perform as equally well as your similarly-aged peers in schools located in more affluent areas. Well, maybe that last one not so much. Your argument strikes me as a reason people raise in objection to mass transit: the "undesirables" might come to town. I'm actually somewhat sympathetic to your position. I live in an area of my city that, on paper, has a pretty high average household income but due to history also has a decent amount of petty crime. The answer isn't to redline those people off to somewhere else. There is a huge difference between being poor and committing crime, except that the poor tend to go to jail and the wealthy tend to pay a fine with no admittance of wrongdoing. And the latter also tend to screw over more people in one pop. The answer is to make it socially unacceptable, in all areas, to commit crime and to demonstrate that the law and society won't tolerate it.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThe billboards you describe work to help people understand their choices (an issue raised in the post I responded to). The fact that poor folks continue making bad choices in spite of this is a different issue. If you scroll up, you'll see that I agree with you about stopping crime. I oppose our current system of anarcho tyranny (to borrow an excellent term).
- techsupporter 12y agoBut that's also my point: How do you stop crime or, more accurately, how do you break the cycle of crime and poverty unless people are given an equal opportunity? My last, fake billboard illustrates the problem with your concentrate-them-all-in-one-spot proposal. We fund everything locally. Schools, transportation, parks, the works. People in nice neighborhoods have opportunities that the ghetto literally does not because the folks in those other neighborhoods won't fund them, believing them to be a waste of time. It's easy to say "just get a job and leave the slums." It's much, much more difficult to do that, especially when there is a bifurcated society.
- aosmith 12y agoSpreading it out just makes everyone feel the burden. I feel bad for the genuinely disadvantaged like everyone else. I dropped out of college and worked my ass off to live in a nice neighborhood. I'd prefer to live around people with a similar drive. I would also prefer to not have my tax dollars used to move possible criminals into my neighborhood.