6 ms·
What If Obesity Is Nobody’s Fault?
- PaulHoule 12y agoA dangerously wrong article. Obesity is a hot topic because it is epidemic. There may be a genetic predisposition in some people, but there is no way the gene pool could have changed so fast since Reagan got elected. Most likely obesity has become the new normal thanks to some environmental toxin. (Ex. Bisphenol A). So there is someone to blame somewhere. As for the in != out stuff I'll say that scientists have been wrong on this so long in face of the evidence; for instance, based on that theory long term weight control could be attained by cutting one cookie a day from your diet, which doesn't work. Also if you look at the metabolic charts, there are enough alternate pathways that the efficiency of metabolism could vary by 10% or more.
- vinbreau 12y agoThis is the point not made in the article. We did not historically have so many obese people until very recently in history. Looking at the 'fat' brothers in an old Guinness Book I noticed how much they resembled an average 'fat' person today. They aren't even near the far end of the overweight spectrum. Heck, even watching movies from the early 80s, what is often called 'fat' is considered average or normal today. We've changed our cultural definition of fat to make the average feel better about themselves.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoYou definitely should not use a Hollywood movie for any sort of understanding of body norms whatsoever.
- beagle3 12y agoYes, you shouldn't. And yet, when you watch a show from the 70s, say "Soap" (highly recommended - passes the test of time with flying colors), you'll notice that all the actors there -- and they all look considerably thinner than modern actors (e.g., take Friends for a nineties comparison). Standards have changed, regardless of Hollywood, and you can measure relative changes (though not absolute values) on through Hollywood.
- waterlesscloud 12y agoActors now are generally much more fit than actors from the 70s. Don't mistake bulk for fat.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoDon't Panic. http://www.nih.gov/about/impact/images/LifeExpectancy.jpg http://www.nih.gov/about/impact/images/LifeExpectancy.jpg
- vmarsy 12y agoSure, some people may have a DNA more prone to obesity. But some questions to ask: What kind of food were the mice given? What would happen if we gave them some "healthy"(mice-wise) food?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- BrainInAJar 12y ago> Only when they were fed 10 to 15 percent less did they slim down to the size of their unaltered siblings. So, it has a fault. Metabolic efficiency means if one has a slower metabolism, one requires less fuel. Eat less.
- dpweb 12y agoIsn't there a social problem in calling something genetic in that regardless of what genetic component may be a factor, it absolves one of personal responsibility. It reminds me of the "chocolate and wine are good for you" news stories. Very pleasing news, but ultimately net harmful.
- nitrogen 12y agoPersonal responsibility is only as good as a person's ability to choose. Since there is no dualistic free will, this ability to choose is based entirely within their brains and bodies, which are 100% the product of their genetics and environmental influences. Thus, "personal responsibility" is a red herring if you are trying to get people to stop making bad choices. Instead, find out what neural, genetic, or environmental influence makes those bad choices more appealing than good choices, and fix that influence. If this is the same study as a recent Ars article, then no choice is involved at all. Nobody chooses to have more or fewer immune cells converting white fat to beige fat.
- MisterBastahrd 12y agoWhat if the sky were peuce? If you expend more energy than you take in via calories, you lose weight, period. With a rational approach to food intake, that 10-15% the researchers claim is like cutting the crust off of a sandwich. It's nothing. You don't see a lot of obese animals in nature, regardless of any genetic metabolic mutation, because they have to actually work to acquire their food. It's funny that when I see people stick to traditional diets, they gain weight at a vastly slower rate than people who eat fast food and drink sodas. They may still end up being technically obese, but it will be at age 70 instead of age 35.
- vowelless 12y agoDisclaimer: I am not a doctor, just someone who is curious about how the body works on a high level. To better understand cause and effect, a question that Peter Attia asks is that, do children eat more and grow (gaining weight as they age), or is it because they are growing that they eat more? Nutrition turns out to be a lot more complex than just calories in and calories out. It looks like that is a manifestation of something deeper, like growth hormones triggering a different type of metabolism. He asks the same question about obesity. Do people get fat (elevated number of triglycerides stored in the fat cells) because they are eating more than expending energy? Or, are they eating more because of hormonal imbalances? He (along with many other doctors) suggest that it is actually the effect of insulin that causes the body to be conservative with the expending of energy. Insulin resistance also leads to diabetes, which is strongly correlated with obesity. So the hypothesis is that it is out of control insulin (due to sugar intake, HFCS, simple carbs, prevelant in american diet) that is the cause for the obesity epidemic, and not just less exercise (although exercise can be used to eliminate the excess glucose in the body which triggers the insulin response). Here are some of his talks: TED: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UMhLBPPtlrY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAWdHYSrh7M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dAWdHYSrh7M And his blog http://eatingacademy.com/ http://eatingacademy.com/
- AndrewKemendo 12y agoIf you expend more energy than you take in via calories, you lose weight, period. I think your phrasing is important here, because there is a lot of debate about "Calories in, calories out" especially considering studies showing that not all calories have equal effects on the body. Generally though the first law holds, the distinctions are about what timeline...
- einhverfr 12y agoInteresting article. One of the obvious problems in the typical discussion is that folks think of human bodies as mechanistic and identically so. I.e. we can reduce obesity to calories in/out because all human bodies are effectively identical or can be assumed to be such. But we know that assumption is false (this happens with remarkable regularity in the sciences, that important theories that generally work are built on assumptions known to be false). People metabolize pharmaceuticals differently (google "cytochrome P450 defect", and try to convince me that such natural variation in metabolism of certain pharmaceuticals is a defect from any perspective other than big pharma's). Now, the assumption, even though it is false, is generally useful because we know also that exercise changes metabolism. In other words, the human body isn't even static and so the abstractions generally work to an extent even though we know they are wrong. I think this sort of thing is why Heisenberg argued at book length that data does not imply theory.
- gooseus 12y agoIndeed, even comments here present the (calories in) < (calories out) == (weight loss) simplification. Currently reading Antifragile by Taleb and it goes in to these fallacies at length (machine vs body and data vs theory).
- fredophile 12y agoCould you explain what's wrong with (calories in) < (calories out) == (weight loss)? This article doesn't refute this idea and specifically talks about it. This is just showing that some genetic mutations affect metabolism in ways that reduce (calories out) independent of activity level. This shouldn't be shocking. Metabolism varies across different people and across the same person over time.
- gooseus 12y agoI wasn't really commenting on this article, so much as on the comment I was replying to. But, what's wrong is that it's an oversimplification of how the human body regulates fat levels. This oversimplification leads many to employ strategies of weight loss that revolve around simply measuring the calories they expend vs the calories they consume while ignoring the source of calories or other habits which affect hormone levels. I'm not an expert on nutrition, fitness, biology, genetics or medicine... so you are free to dismiss my assertions if you require such a qualification. Though, I do recommend reading some Nassim Nicolas Taleb, as he makes a much better case for what I'm discussing while also dismissing the idea that one needs to be an expert to recognize bullshit. Also, I personally think articles drawing conclusions from scientific studies shouldn't be published before the study is replicated... but of course, that would reduce the supply of articles for the ravenous pseudo-scientific commenter and we'd have to have more rigorous arguments on a smaller set of more rigorous information and people would run the risk of coming to all sorts of agreements and reducing click-through.
- dkural 12y agoVery misleading article. The vast majority of human obesity is not caused by genetics - indeed, this is why we have many more obese people now than we did a century, although we have the same genetics. Our great grandparents gave their genes to us, but they didn't suffer as much from obesity because they ate only what they needed and were more active. For the unfortunate minority that truly does have a very strong genetic component, the fact remains that eating slightly less - just 10-15% less, will allow them to match their metabolism. This is not to say we should "blame" people - social and environmental factors are very important. Lack of sleep due to too much work / artificially lit environment causes more eating, lots of food is engineered to be super tasty for us, there were no cookie trees in our ancient past :)
- henryl 12y agoEpigenetics?
- weeksie 12y agoBut what if genetics hasn't changed? I honestly don't know, and it certainly looks like the first world diet has gotten higher in calories and that people in the first world have gotten more sedentary—but, what if it's another factor? Epigenetics is a possibility but there are others as well. Another major difference is antibiotic intake. I don't know if humans consume enough antibiotics to affect their weight, but antibiotics are regularly administered to livestock primarily to fatten them up. We're just scratching the surface of the human biome and it's entirely possible that there's an answer in there. You might be right (and my intuition agrees with you) but I wouldn't be so certain of it. Life is incredibly complex.
- jacques_chester 12y agoLife is definitely complex, but most of the variables with some influence on weight are either unobservable or unchangeable. Luckily, you don't need to observe them or change them. You can ignore them and focus on what is observable -- appearance and weight -- and on what is controllable -- diet and exercise. It may well be that gut biomes, antibiotic usage, inflammation, corn syrup, global warming, diesel particulates, preservatives etc etc have an influence. But the forcing factor in the weight system is net caloric balance, which is also the easiest to control.
- autokad 12y agowhat a terrible headline. a subset of mice have a predisposition towards obesity, so america's exploding obesity epidemic may not be the individuals fault despite: #1 genetic ratios couldn't possibly be changing that much #2 most people who do go on diets and exercise DO lose weight. #3 as the article points out, the gene in study is rare in humans.
- DanBC 12y agoWe know that dieting is a terrible method for losing weight. It's untrue to say thT most people who diet lose weight - they only do so in the short term while they maintain that diet. As soon as they stop they regain weight, often settling at a higher weight. Unless by "dieting" you mean "permanent lifestyle change" which is fair enough.
- autokad 12y agoI am addressing the article's statements about mice not loosing weight despite changing their diet and exercising. the length of time they loose the weight is less important, and the fact that the reason why they put the weight back on after reverting to their previous habits only works against the article that argues the obese may be at the mercy of their genes - diet and exercise wont help them.
- glenra 12y agoYour #2 point is false. Most diet/exercise programs appear to "work" in the short run, but fail in the long term. Very few people who diet haven't gained the weight back and then some within 3 years. The sad truth is that we don't yet have any GOOD advice to give overweight people who want to not be overweight. Telling them to diet to lose weight is, in practice, terrible advice. The headline is fine if you keep in mind that the subject of the study is only one of a number of mechanisms by which people could be not at fault for their weight gain. There's things like the "fat virus" (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infectobesity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infectobesity). There are epigenetic factors - we're just learning that how well your grandparents ate can affect your health. There might well be chemical or medical factors too - overuse of antibiotics changing the bacterial load is a common suggestion.
- gpcz 12y agoFor the people asking questions about the experiment details, here is the full paper in Science (registration required): http://www.sciencemag.org/content/341/6143/275.full http://www.sciencemag.org/content/341/6143/275.full . Based on the paper, it appears that they performed targeted mutations to manipulate the Mrap2 gene and fed the mice equal quantities of chow, and then they did the tests described in the parent article. At least to me, this is strong evidence that this gene affects obesity in mice.
- mratzloff 12y agoFeel-good blather.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- pollinaise 12y agoWe can play the blame game but we can't disregard the laws of thermodynamics. Too much energy intake and not enough expenditure means that energy goes somewhere. We can examine the science and sociology of how it happens, but the only thing pieces like this accomplish is to make people feel better about their health issues and filled the coffers of snake oil salesmen. Don't read the article and read the studies instead.
- lotsofmangos 12y agowe can't disregard the laws of thermodynamics. Given the less controllable tail end of the process creates a widely variable amount of flammable solids and gases, it isn't as though it is just the inputs you should be considering. I'm skinny and fairly sedentary and I know damn well that with a different set of genetics and the same behavior, then I would be fat. Also, seems that in terms of lifespan, I may be better off being a bit overweight than slightly under, really, the benefit seems mainly aesthetic for most people, which is a crap reason to guilt-trip a society.
- lotsofmangos 12y agoI have often wondered if my shit would burn well compared to people who put on weight. I can increase the amount I eat while really doing nothing and I still remain skinny. I put on muscle if I exercise and eat, but I do seem to have a digestion that ignores stuff unless I am busy. Though it might just be that when I am not busy I tend to poison it with spirits.
- imroot 12y agoSo, I'm obese. I have no problems admitting that -- at my heaviest, I was 400 pounds, and while I'm nowhere close to the weight that I want to be, I watch my diet, work out every day, and try to live a life that promotes a great body image. My mom is/was obese -- before she had a lap band installed. My dad is obese. My significant other is/was obese. Being a 'bigger' person is something that I grew up in, and something that I attribute to being normal. I didn't realize that being a "bigger" person was a problem until I went off to college and noticed that I was the exception, and not the norm. I only dated bigger women, because that's basically the only type of woman who would date someone who's bigger, and you can begin to see a cycle move forward again. My SO got a full gastric bypass surgery in 2009 (after we had been through the second round of our post-grad work), and went from 400 pounds down to 150 pounds (for a 6' tall woman). She's been egging me on to get a lap band or bypass, but, I've already dropped a good 100 pounds from my heaviest weight, and will be able to drop the last 100 pounds on my own. My SO no longer has diabetes, heart issues, or anything like that -- other than some vitamin deficiencies, she's a pretty healthy (and stubborn) woman. I don't think it's a genetic thing -- I think it's an environmental thing; you don't see a lot of chubby kids in a smaller household, and vice versa -- I don't see a lot of skinny/smaller children in a household that has obese or overweight people in it.
- dllthomas 12y ago"you don't see a lot of chubby kids in a smaller household, and vice versa -- I don't see a lot of skinny/smaller children in a household that has obese or overweight people in it." That's liable to be the case whether it's environmental or genetic (or, most likely, some sort of combination - though one may well dominate).
- lectrick 12y agoDNA may or may not be one factor; gut flora may be another. The fact is that we now have proof that 2 mice can eat the same energy, burn the same energy and poop the same energy, and yet 1 will become fat and the other won't. Say what you will about responsibility when it comes to obesity, you can no longer argue with authority that "calories in - exercised calories out = weight" due to this single counterevidence.