4 ms·
Fernvale: An Open Hardware and Software Platform
- mschuster91 12y agoWhen it comes to radio, though, it's not just copyright that gets into your way. Unlike wifi/bluetooth, which happen in the license-free ISM bands (2.4 GHz), you need your entire product certified by FCC (US) and by whomever in Europe in order to legally operate in the GSM/UMTS bands; not to mention carriers won't exactly like you if you mess up their network.
- akiselev 12y agoFor the really interesting stuff (GSM + CDMA cellular) this is a "cross that bridge when you get there" kind of problem. Before you can get on the airwaves you need to break the Qualcomm/Broadcom stranglehold on cellular basebands and if you do that (by developing the open source hardware + software implementing RF/protocols) then the licensed spectrum bit becomes tractable. AFAIK much of the rest of the spectrum, licensing + part procurement is significantly easier and although there are some more monopolies they are nowhere near as bad as Qualcomm/Broadcom.
- mschuster91 12y agoAt least on the baseband front there's OsmocomBB, what they lack iirc is hardware.
- rasz_pl 12y agoOsmocomBB is not the way, what they have is a patchset over closed source GSM firmware, they merely patch DSP firmware on the baseband to bend it a little. but we already have open source GSM/LTE implementations, everything is ready from the hardware (various SDRs), thru baseband openbts, to whole network controllers like openbsc
- zw123456 12y agoMy take on it is to not bother with the older GSM and CDMA but to instead focus on LTE. Although GSM will probably be around globally for a while, it is on the wane as is CDMA. There is a lot of interesting open work going on for LTE including LTE on unlicensed bands. http://sourceforge.net/projects/ltemodem.motorola/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/ltemodem.motorola/ http://www.eurecom.fr/en/content/virtulization-lte-softmodem http://www.eurecom.fr/en/content/virtulization-lte-softmodem http://sourceforge.net/projects/openlte/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/openlte/
- evanwolf 12y agoIs there a low-power variety of LTE to improve battery life on devices?
- femto 12y agoThe FCC/ETSI certification isn't too much of a barrier, being a matter mainly of money. Any manufacturer can pay to have their product tested by a third party lab and certified to conform to FCC/ETSI regulations. The real barrier is the spectrum licensing, which is a matter for the operator rather than the manufacturer. These at the rules that say that a particular carrier payed for the exclusive use of a band of frequencies and no one else is allowed to use that spectrum. As I understand it though, the law is reactive, in that the law is not broken by owning a capable device, but by using it. Even then, the enforcement depends on a complaint from the carrier (ie. they have to catch you), but if you get caught the penalties are severe.
- maguirre 12y agoAnyone know what's up with their certificate? Firefox does not like it
- timw6n 12y agoThey're using a CACert (a kind of community-based CA) certificate, that isn't trusted by default on most systems. If the root certificate you're getting is from "CA Cert Signing Authority" and matches the details given on http://www.cacert.org/index.php?id=3 http://www.cacert.org/index.php?id=3 then you're probably not being MITM'd.
- akiselev 12y ago> We took special pains to ensure our method was lawful and the resulting work is copyright-clean under U.S. law. We did review some non-open-licensed chip documentation and code examples available for download from open file-sharing sites. None of these materials were restricted by DRM. American copyright law contains a fair-use exception that allows limited copying and examination of such materials for the purpose of understanding the ideas and functional concepts embodied in them. We believe our download and review of those materials is fair use. Should potential copyright holders disagree with our interpretation, we invite any offended parties to engage us in rational discourse. I really hope this works out and they figure out how to get past the IP traps in a repeatable way based off of the work in China. Unfortunately, we won't know until this is tested in court and while I'm sure there is plenty of precedent, I don't think many companies will want to take the risk. Until someone does, I fear that projects like this will fail to bring in corporate supporters (like Red Hat supports the Linux kernel) that would really move both the hardware forward by leaps and bounds. If you look at all of the open hardware today, most of it is stagnant and only exists at the behest of the chip manufacturers so that they can have easily available but rather trivial reference designs (e.g. BeagleBone, PandaBoard, OpenRD, etc). After working for a only a few years, I've developed the opinion that electrical engineering is one of those few fields where patents and other closely guarded IP demonstrably hold back innovation. When I work for big companies on mass manufactured products, 75% of the time I get my documentation from Chinese forums [1] and parts shipped in from Shenzhen a week or two before I really get a chance to engage with the manufacturer's reps. On a few occasions, I've even received better chip errata and more up to date software from the hardware pirates than from the original manufacturers! Considering how hostile the electronics industry is to their biggest customers, let alone amateurs and makers, it's a wonder that startups using cutting edge chips can launch at all. [1] http://bbs.eetop.cn http://bbs.eetop.cn is one of my go to's
- minthd 12y agoThanks. The site looks very interesting. But where do you buy your chips from shenzen ? And how do you manage reliability and long term availability ?
- 12y ago
- rasz_pl 12y agoSource of this seems to be in west mentality of charging what market can bear. Texas Instruments idea of IoT chip is $20-30 cc3000 wifi solution. Chinese company on the other hand is fine repurposing USB WIFI dongle chip and selling $2 ESP8266. Thats right 10:1 cost difference. Guess who will make and sell millions of those.
- revelation 12y agoTexas Instruments? This seems like a case of "you'd be surprised".
- mng2 12y agoI've heard, perhaps apocryphally, that binary blobs are one roadblock IC makers set up to keep rivals from going through their implementations and finding stuff to base patent-infringement lawsuits on. (Just as in software, there are dumb hardware patents too.) I wonder if this 3rd-party disclosure might open MT up to lawsuits.
- desdiv 12y agoTo save people a Google: there aren't any source code or even detailed specifications yet. The talk takes place tomorrow (Dec 28), so presumably more information will be available then.