3 ms·
I actually posted about this very topic a few days ago here. Once you have von Neumann machines spreading they will take over each new star system pretty much
by danieltillett 12y ago
I actually posted about this very topic a few days ago here.
Once you have von Neumann machines spreading they will take over each new star system pretty much as soon as they reach it. Assuming the von Neumann machines are small and are being powered by an energy source (i.e lasers) from their origin star system they will spread through the galaxy at close to the speed of light. This spread method creates an interesting effect in that we would not see the stars go out until the von Neumann machines had almost reached us if the origin star was within our galaxy - basically the von Neumann machines would be traveling only a little behind the light front from the origin star system (this would make a good science fiction story).
If the origin star system was far enough a way, then the slightly slower speed that the von Neumann machines would travel at should allow us to see them progressing though a distance galaxy. Such a galaxy would look to us like part of the galaxy had a chunk taken out of it. It would be worth looking through the galaxy classification data set [1, 2] to see if there are any galaxies like that out there that look like this. My feeling is we won't find any as I think intellegent life is near unique within the visible universe, but it is at least a testable hypothesis.
1. http://www.galaxyzoo.org http://www.galaxyzoo.org
2. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_of_Peculiar_Galaxies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_of_Peculiar_Galaxies
- yzzxy 12y agoStephen Baxter's Manifold novels deal with this problem quite extensively. I would recommend them from anyone interested in the implications of the Fermi paradox expressed in science/speculative fiction.
- maaku 12y agoAnother testable variation of this is the gravitational effect of voids. Voids[1]are regions of the universe devoid of visible matter (stars), as far as we can tell. These are predicted by the inflationary model as regions of low energy distribution in the early universe. But if we find a void that appears to have gravitational effects on its neighbors, what an astronomer might call "a concentration of dark matter", that could be a Type III civilization. I'd look around the edges and see if we can find any half-eaten galaxies... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_%28astronomy%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Void_%28astronomy%29
- danieltillett 12y agoAnother testable variation of this is the gravitational effect of voids. Yes, the only problem might be that we don't yet have a good explanation for dark matter so it would be hard to know if a void with mass is due to a Type III civilisation or just a local concentration of dark matter. A spiral galaxy with a perfectly spherical void would be pretty hard to explain as anything other than the result of intelligence.
- marcosdumay 12y agoThere are stuff out there normaly tough of as "concentrations of dark matter"[1], altought nobody is really sure. I never heard about a "half eaten" galaxy, but I'd guess you hypostesis keep them that way for a very short time, so this is not surprizing. The biggest problem I have with this family of explanations is that, unless the aliens discovered how to revert the Second Rule of Thermodynamics, they must irradiate some low temperature wave. And we measure nearly every candidate nowadays. Unless they are extremely far away, the only thing that could escape us is some very narrow band that happens to be out of range of all current telescopes - and those are not the features of a good heat sink. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_galaxy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_galaxy
- darkmighty 12y agoInteresting. Just a note: it probably wouldn't seem as if a chunk of the galaxies was removed; in fact, I believe the luminosity (after some settling time) of a start with a Dyson sphere or the like would emit about the same light a regular star does -- the difference would be the temperature. The apparent temperature of the star should increase(?) (i.e. it emits(?) higher entropy radiation): by simple energy conservation, we wouldn't expect the energy to build up indefinitely inside the sphere. Presumable the energy would be used for computation -- so the end result is that the Star's energy is used to compensate Landauer's Principle[1], essentially cooling the computer. So instead maybe we should look for galaxies that are hotter than expected for their brightness/age? [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Landauer%27s_principle
- marcosdumay 12y agoHighter entropy radiation has lower temperature. But yes, the energy must go somewhere, thus the total energy irradiated is the same. It just shifts into infrared or radio.
- darkmighty 12y agoOh yea I wasn't sure which one was it! Intuitively it seemed to need to be at lower temperature, but the association of entropy of gases with their temperature made me write otherwise, but of course E=h*f dictates that the entropy from a larger number of lower energy photons must be higher. Thanks for the correction!
- danieltillett 12y agoSuch galaxies already exist [1]. They appear to be natural, but who knows for sure. The temperature of the Dyson Sphere will determine the wave length the star apears to shine at. If the sphere is designed to capture the maximum energy possible then the temperature will be close to the cosmic background radiation temperature (2.73K) and so would be very hard to detect. 1. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminous_infrared_galaxy http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luminous_infrared_galaxy