4 ms·
The laws of any potential biology and the messiness of the world could together effectively limit a civilization's energy usage to much lower than indicated by
by joe_the_user 12y ago
The laws of any potential biology and the messiness of the world could together effectively limit a civilization's energy usage to much lower than indicated by the easily deducible laws of physic (the explicit laws of physics might limit the output of an internal combustion engine to a certain but the effective maximum winds up less than that. Human biological systems experience serious damage by being weightless for significant periods, etc).
I only recently realized that this "paradox" looking at the possibility not of "earth advanced" civilization but supposed advanced civilizations that would put out much more energy than humans put out.
The whole thing seems to rest on false-extrapolations of mid 20th century hard-science fiction authors. Our Western Civilization has experienced an exponential growth of some things, has expanded it's "frontiers" quickly in a variety of ways, conquering the rest of the globe and then labeling space "the final frontier".
But all this has been low-hanging fruit. We're reaching the end of population expansion, space is fundamentally hostile to human life in a way that would take tremendous progress to overcome and we're facing longer term consequences of the rapid expansions we have achieved (global warming is just one of the consequences). If humans survive this, we'll have to have somehow achieve a steady-state for energy consumption and related things. But once we do achieve that steady state, why would we want or need to suddenly start using the energy of an entire star (after the thousand years of scientific progress we'd need to under how to do that)?
- XorNot 12y agoThe problem here is the assumption we need scientific progress to do this. We don't. We have the technology today to launch satellites into solar-orbits which would be capable of beaming power back to Earth. It would be clean, efficient and non-disasterous to the biosphere. With any amount of space-borne industry, the costs would also plummet and get cheaper with every additional satellite. Once you can harness the energy of an entire star, there's almost no reason not to achieve it.
- vorg 12y agoHumans can build large sealed cities on the Earth-facing side of the Moon using solar-propelled remote-controlled "drone" technology. The response time is only about 1 or 2 seconds so the human operators on Earth wouldn't need the equipment to have much of its own AI (unlike later on when humans repeat the process on Mars). Once enough such specialized machinery is on the Moon, entire "cities" the size of an apartment building could be built, funded in the same way Ordos in China was. The hard part would be experimenting with different biochemical processes afterwards in each city so one of them could provide enough oxygen, water, and food for humans who'd arrive much later on.