6 ms·
How Possibilities of Life Elsewhere Might Alter Held Notions of Faith
- _sword 12y agoIt seems like it would be very fun to have a chat with Guy Consolmagno: “One incarnation seems absurd but not inconsistent with the data,” he said by phone from Florida, where he was watching manatees. There is no data, I pointed out. “Exactly!” he responded, laughing.
- hobs 12y agoHe seems like a very interesting person, but it always confuses me when someone so steeped in science chooses the unknown. When you say things like “That’s not the kind of god I’m happy with", I wonder why you would choose an organized religion with all the strings attached in terms of dogma?
- lukeholder 12y agoThe way I think about it is, if God created the earth, and placed us all together - then why shouldn't we try to meet the measure of our creation together as a team?
- JasonFruit 12y agoThat's a statement I like the sound of, but I'm not quite sure what you mean by it. Care to elaborate?
- lukeholder 12y agoOrganised religion is seen as full of dogma and inefficiencies, but people organising themselves for the benefit of all within the organisation might be the primary reason we are all together sharing the this earthly experience - to progress together - to help each other. Spiritually as solely personal internal pursuit may conflict with the reality we are sharing a common earthly experience, born into families and tribes that we are emotionally/spiritually bonded to.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> He seems like a very interesting person, but it always confuses me when someone so steeped in science chooses the unknown. I've known lots of people who are both religious and scientifically oriented, and none of them have seemed to view religion as "choosing the unknown", but more as not abandoning as irrelevant that about which understanding through empiricism is not viable. > When you say things like “That’s not the kind of god I’m happy with", I wonder why you would choose an organized religion with all the strings attached in terms of dogma? Er, when he says that, he says it about a particular science-fiction account, not about what a particular real world religion believes, so I don't see how those things even relate. Why would not liking the picture painted by a particular piece of science fiction put you off of organized religion in general, particularly an organized religion whose doctrines do not demand the account proposed in that piece of science fiction?
- valvar 12y agoor How to Completely Miss the Point.
- xj9 12y agoIf I may ask, what is the point you're referring to?
- phkahler 12y ago>> If I may ask, what is the point you're referring to? Perhaps as someone else pointed out, aliens could be a metaphor. There were plenty of places here on earth that didn't get the message about god back in the day. When that guy says "there is no data" he's ignoring a lot of history. Replace planet with continent and you can see how God actually handled beings in different places - he didn't.
- valvar 12y agoThat religious truth and religious dogma are not the same.
- palmer_eldritch 12y ago"Pope Francis suggested in a homily in May that he would baptize Martians if they landed in St. Peter’s Square and asked for it." Forget about astronauts or reality shows participants. Let's send catholic priests to Mars.
- irishcoffee 12y agoWhats the difference between sexual discrimination, racial discrimination, age discrimination, and religious discrimination?
- netrus 12y agoNot to defend OP, but to answer your question: I'd say you have far more choice concerning your religion than in your sexual orientation, race or age - at least in the Western Society, where you are free to go Christian->Atheist->Muslim, if you want to.
- irishcoffee 12y agoSo you're saying its ok to have bigoted opinions about things people choose? Honest question.
- Elrac 12y agoYour question may be honest, but you may not be aware how strongly you loaded it with your use of the word "bigoted." In looking through definitions, I came across words like "extreme," "unwilling to change," "prejudiced," "unfair," and "intolerant." You seem to be trying to propose that being opposed to one religion (or all) is an extreme position - which I think is debatable in view of just how many people fit this bill. Is this position prejudiced if it's based on thorough examination and reasoning? If people come by this position based on evidence and reason, do you have a reason to believe they could never be convinced they're mistaken? Finally, is there something wrong with being intolerant of intolerance, oppression and violence? People compare social institutions, technologies and ideas all the time. And people develop opinions on them; some are viewed as better than others. This is the social learning process which has taken us (more or less) from cave dwelling, widespread violence, ignorance, slavery and "an eye for an eye" to the foundations modern societies rest on, more or less to everyone's approval. You wouldn't be trying to use a knee-jerk negative word to discourage, for religions, the kind of discussion which has stood us in good stead in many other areas of social discourse? I hope you won't be too offended by this literally shitty analogy that was the first to come to my mind: Imagine a modern society just like ours, but in which people choose to do without toilets. Nobody talks about it much, it's just what they've always done, and they're unwilling to break with tradition in this respect. It's common practice to do your "business" in the street gutter, next to the curb. There's a daily removal service, and a 3x daily deodorizing service, and they reduce the associated problems. Still, this society has an unusual rate of some infectious diseases, and especially in the summer, deodorizing just doesn't seem to keep up. Here's a different society with a different choice on how to do things. Would you be bigoted if you criticized this society for the pursuit of this practice? If you feel it's important to accept the choices of other groups, would you be willing to live in such a society? Would you think it wrong to at least try to talk to those folks about improving their lives by re-thinking their stance on indoor plumbing? I think I still owe you the answer to your question. So: Yes, I think it's OK to critically examine all ideas, and choices, including religious ones, and to raise those objections we feel are in order. Why on Earth not?
- ekianjo 12y agoNot sure this question was worth a full blown article in the NY times. It's fairly obvious religion makes only sense in a human context, and on Earth. Unless we find humans elsewhere (which is pretty unlikely, there is no specific reason why an intelligent being would have to be a primate on another planet), the question does not make much sense.
- nsxwolf 12y agoWhy does religion make sense only to humans, and not other intelligent life forms?
- ekianjo 12y agoBecause religion is a human creation, and all our holy texts are very human centric (and barely regard animals as anything else than food, while we now know that tons of animals have a great deal of consciousness and emotions similar to humans). EDIT: Just to make things clear, I'm not saying that God does not exist, but what I'm saying is that the system derived from that belief (i.e. religion) is very much created by humans and for humans.
- hyp0 12y agoBuddhism includes reincarnation as animals
- ekianjo 12y agoI was waiting for that one. But animals are just vessels for humans souls while waiting for another reincarnation, as far as I understand. So animals are not given much soul on their own.
- krageon 12y agoPut another way: "animals are vessels for souls while waiting for reincarnation". It now applies to everything souls (possibly) reincarnate into, while still being true. I think that viewed in this way, it is obvious that the Buddhist concept of a soul is not human centric. The soul would be an entity trying to escape a cycle of reincarnation (and one of the potential candidates for reincarnation is a human). Aliens could fit right in there as just another vessel.
- taylorlapeyre 12y agoI'm always surprised by how scientifically minded and educated the Jesuits are.
- hawleyal 12y agoTheologins created the first universities, no?
- russnewcomer 12y agoAn interesting article, perhaps, but Mr. Overbye clearly presents just a surface look at Catholic theology and thought processes about extra terrestrial life, mixed with his apparent skepticism [shown in the form of Clarke's story] about the morality or rationality of such a worldview. No real depth, no apparent ability to see the theological equivalence, in this case, between someone in a remote uncontacted tribe in the Amazon and an extra terrestrial, and a host of further issues that I frequently see in someone who seems to subscribe to Stephen J Gould's 'non-overlapping magesteria' ideals. Kind of feels like a short Vanity Fair or Rolling Stone article on a complex technological topic. If Clarke's story ideas are tantalizing to the reader, I would suggest reading Perelandra by C.S. Lewis for a [admittedly dated] view from the other side of the equation. (I know of no similarly posited and argued Catholic story, so my apologies for suggesting a strongly Protestant one after the Catholic points in the article).
- c0brac0bra 12y agoI'd think Chesterton would have had something to say about it but I'm having a hard time finding any references. I would posit that there's some relevant material in The Everlasting Man, though.
- kej 12y ago> I would suggest reading Perelandra People should read Out of the Silent Planet first, and then Perelandra. The third book in the series is also good, but goes in a different direction and doesn't really touch on the relationship between the Christian God and extraterrestrial life.
- explorigin 12y agoHa, the number 2 slot on HN. The nerds must be bored before Christmas.
- JasonFruit 12y agoHear, O Israel: The LORD our God is one LORD. That being said, this whole conversation is academic: we haven't seen any evidence of life beyond Earth. If we do, we'll be able to have this conversation in a more useful way than the mere speculation that's available to us now.
- rjuyal 12y ago"evidence of life beyond Earth". I sometimes think GOD is/was actually an extraterrestrial body. It/He came to earth when humans were apes ( or simply say human were not that intelligent as this extraterrestrial body was ). At that time humans decided to call him almighty for obvious reasons. That was the seed for a theory about GOD. Later on humans created lots of religions and lots of imaginary GODs as per their convenience. ( Now we have enough GODs and religions to fight with. And discuss my GOD is better/powerful than yours. You will not goto 'heaven' ( some imaginary place or may be another planet ) if you will not follow my religion ).
- michaelsbradley 12y agoFor a serious-minded treatment grounded in a Thomistic framework see Aquinas on Intelligent Extra-Terrestrial Life: http://www.unav.es/cryf/extraterrestriallife.html http://www.unav.es/cryf/extraterrestriallife.html
- j0e1 12y agoWe know far too little to answer the question. If there are other beings in the universe, it is only about Adam and the human race that any information is given in the Bible. I suppose it is plausible to have other created beings(with free will) who never fell in to sin and thus didn't need to redeemed.
- strange_orange 12y agoI wonder if any of these theologians will ever change the direction of their logic. It's funny that things like this are said, “How could he be God and leave extraterrestrials in sin?”, and not "if there are extraterrestrials, is there really a god?". What's the point on logically arguing from a position of faith anyway? Doesn't that defeat the point? Maybe we should just stop believing the stories of people who quite clearly tripped during a fasting high (or similar) in the desert over 2000 years ago.
- krapp 12y ago> It's funny that things like this are said, “How could he be God and leave extraterrestrials in sin?”, and not "if there are extraterrestrials, is there really a god?" I think you miss the point of religion if you think that's even on the table. Once you decide to take it literally, the preeminence of the supernatural by definition can't be questioned, it's a given. The only variable is the way reality can be reinterpreted to satisify dogma. I think that religion can have a great deal of value as a cultural and mythological framework, but to me, wondering whether aliens suffer from original sin makes as much sense as wondering whether the Great Dragon eats their suns as well as ours each night. Human religion is a human invention, and humans aren't even a rounding error at the scale of the universe. Billions and billions of stars and billions and billions of galaxies (as Carl Sagan apparently never said.) It's the height of arrogance to assume the superstitions of a few apes on an insignificant rock on an insignificant planet should mean anything to anyone but themselves.
- gpvos 12y agoThose people in the article don't sound very dogmatic to me (except maybe the pope).
- krapp 12y agoThat depends on your interpretation. Assuming that there might be other gods on other worlds sounds rational, even reasonable. I think Voltaire(?) even wrote a short story about how human religions might look to aliens[0], although at the time, the prevalent interpretation was far more dogmatic than what the article describes. But even working from the premise that there would even be a relationship between aliens and the Christian God to discover, to me, seems incredibly dogmatic. [0] I thought it was called Mondomegas, but apparently, Google's never heard of it.
- kr4 12y agoAlso of interest to readers: read about lokas [0]. As per the Indian philosophy every gross being has a subtle energy (prana) body [1] which is the same in whichever loka you go after death. You can experience this subtle form with yoga. It's also said that with years of yoga practice you can master subtle body and you can travel into other lokas in this lifetime with your subtle body (while the gross remains here on bhuloka in the still posture) 1] http://ramanan50.wordpress.com/2014/05/11/hinduism-14-lokas-quantum-mutiverse-study/ http://ramanan50.wordpress.com/2014/05/11/hinduism-14-lokas-... 2] http://www.sahajayoga.org/ChakrasAndSubtleBody/ http://www.sahajayoga.org/ChakrasAndSubtleBody/
- dean 12y agoI'm sure these people would laugh at a discussion of how-many-angels-can-dance-on-the-head-of-a-pin, but this is just an updated-for-the-space-age version of that discussion.
- dragonwriter 12y agoI think most of them would -- while still seeing the value in considering the topic -- recognize that it is in the same category of exploration of the implications of religious doctrines through hypotheticals that seem pointless from an external context as the "how-many-angels-can-dance-on-the-head-of-a-pin" discussion.