7 ms·
Americans aren't getting married, and researchers think porn may be to blame
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- creativeidiot 12y agoThe thieving nature of the divorce and child support regulations in the USA are clearly unrelated.
- therobot24 12y agoanyone blaming the cost of divorce and child support as a reason not to get married probably aren't that great to be married to
- colordrops 12y agoWith the inability of anyone to accurately predict the future, the 50% lifetime divorce rate in the US, and the hugely unfair consequences of divorce, your judgement of the OP is unwarranted.
- intopieces 12y agoThe divorce rate is not 50%. We don't know the divorce rate, because we haven't been keeping track. http://qz.com/306166/the-divorce-stat-that-just-keeps-cheating-50/ http://qz.com/306166/the-divorce-stat-that-just-keeps-cheati...
- baddox 12y agoIt seems you should have omitted the first sentence.
- usaar333 12y agoFor the cohort of HN readers, it is nowhere near that high. See http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2013/article/pdf/marriage-and-divorce-patterns-by-gender-race-and-educational-attainment.pdf http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2013/article/pdf/marriage-and-di... Among folks with college degrees, divorce rate is 31% for those marrying between 23 and 28 and 23% for those marrying between 29 and 34. Those with a masters degree, divorce at ~22%. Even ignoring education and marriage age, only 26% of those who have kids while married (not before married) get divorced: http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr049.pdf http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/nhsr/nhsr049.pdf
- waterlesscloud 12y ago1 in 4 chance is still a pretty huge risk considering the consequences.
- prostoalex 12y agoAlso, the rate counts marriages not people, so serial offenders like this guy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glynn_Wolfe http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glynn_Wolfe skew the average and require 28 marriages that don't end up in divorce just to even out.
- tomp 12y agoIt's not the current rate that is important, it's the trend. People marrying today will be getting divorced in 10-20 years; by then, the divorce rate could well be way more than 50%.
- therobot24 12y ago> inability of anyone to accurately predict the future sarcastic response: "sorry hun, we can't get married cause i'm not sure we'll be together forever and i don't want to pay money if we break up." real response: There's risk in everything you do, and if you aren't willing to risk some of your time and equity into another person then you wouldn't do well in a marriage anyway
- colordrops 12y agoMost risks that people take, especially with risks of such high probability, don't involve another person visciously working to make your life miserable in and out of a court of law. Romance and taking a leap of faith and all that are just very recent fictions, especially in Asia. Marriage has been a utilitarian tradition since it began. There are lucky people with wonderful loving marriages, but it's completely unrealistic to expect everyone to seek this out at extreme long term risk to livelihood and happiness.
- fosk 12y agoNot to sound insensitive, but here's another way to look at it. At the end of day marriage is like a contract between to persons with expensive "cancellation fees" that you need to consider, exactly like it happens when you sign any other contract during your life. It is very shortsighted to sign a contract without considering every aspect of it, even more considering there is a good chance that things can go wrong. You can still love a person and have a child and give your contributions as a parent without signing a contract, like many people actually do.
- andreasvc 12y agoTaking into account the risks of an enterprise is laudable.
- sliverstorm 12y ago... and anyone that passionately objects to doing so probably aren't that great to be married to? :)
- _delirium 12y agoWorries about child support aren't a particularly good reason to get married or not get married, because they apply iff you are a parent, regardless of marital status. If you get married and don't have kids, there is no issue of supporting kids. On the other hand, if you don't get married and do have kids, you're still legally required to support them. The obligation to support isn't a consequence of marriage, but of being father or mother to a child. In fact a pretty large proportion of child-support cases that end up in court involve parents who were never married.
- noblethrasher 12y agoAt least in Oklahoma, child support laws encourage marriage: I had a friend that ended up paying child support for about six to eight years for a kid that always lived with him. The reason is because his partner got emergency food stamps for a week while he was out of the state taking care of his sick mother. He later married her (though they were living together even before the kid), but was still having his wages garnished for something called “child support”.
- baddox 12y agoStill, the fear of having to pay child support could discourage people from having extended exclusive relationships, and those are generally a prerequisite to marriage.
- dragonwriter 12y agoNot having "extended, exclusive relationships" doesn't decrease the risk of having to pay child support. (Not having unprotected sex with people you aren't both married to and going to stay married to does, but, all other things being equal, avoiding "extended, exclusive relationships" seems to be more likely to increase that risk than decrease it.)
- baddox 12y agoI suspect it does, given that the likelihood of conceiving a child (from protected or unprotected sex), as well as the likelihood of a female knowing who the father of her child is, increase as relationships become longer and more exclusive.
- alextgordon 12y agoI would go as far as to say that married couples should banned from divorce until all their children are at least 16 1/2. That would solve the child support problem for married couples, reduce the divorce rate and incentivise stable families.
- numair 12y agoYeah, because the fact that the average young American can barely support one person, let alone two + child, on a basic income can't have anything to do with the reduction in marriages...
- thret 12y agoPlus the expense of the ring, the wedding, the honeymoon. People put it off until it can be done 'right'.
- _delirium 12y agoAn interesting trend in Greece, where due to the economic crisis many people can't afford to "properly" get married, is that it's become common to get a simple civil-ceremony marriage, with an intent to get a "real" marriage (church ceremony, reception, photos, etc.) sometime later. That may or may not eventually happen, but it seems universal that people at least theoretically consider it their plan (the civil paperwork-signing isn't culturally considered a "real" wedding). Not getting married at all is also increasingly common, but many people choose the in-between option of a legal marriage without the ceremony. The plus side is that you get the legal benefits even while waiting to plan the "real" wedding (things like medical visitation rights, joint property ownership, etc., become simpler).
- imaginenore 12y agoWhat does this have to do with being married? It's not like if you marry, you have to have children and have to pay more. If two people make A and B amounts of money, they still make A+B together, married or not.
- archgoon 12y agoTaxes actually favor single income families. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_penalty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_penalty
- baddox 12y agoI assumed that the majority of couples with children (married or not) have both worked for at least a few decades. I'm not sure why an average decrease in purchasing power relative to costs of living, if that has even occurred, would cause a reduction in marriages. I would expect a reduction in birth rate, or at least a birth rate distributed differently to income, but not necessarily a reduction in marriages.
- visakanv 12y agoHere's my random, unsolicited opinion: I doubt porn is the cause. Porn might be a comorbidity (what I'd put my money on), or maybe a symptom (I doubt that, too), but the idea that it's the cause is pretty odd to me. I think marriage is fundamentally an economic institution. People got married because it made economic sense. You needed a partner to rear children with, assuming you wanted children at all. There's all the stuff about love and companionship and all that, but there's no reason why we need to fixate on one particular arrangement. It was about partnerships of families. I think marriage made a lot of sense in small towns. It makes sense for large, political dynasties, for the old wealthy, etc. It doesn't make so much sense for the young middle class today. This is my rough, unvarnished opinion. Would love to hear criticisms, refinements, etc.
- selmnoo 12y ago> I think marriage is fundamentally an economic institution. I don't like that reduction of marriage. Having known several couples who've made it for over 50 years and above, it really makes things clear to me -- they let themselves be totally truthful and vulnerable to each other, they rely on each other in the other's time of need, they find joy in doing things as one. Like most things, marriage is what you make of it, if all you want out of it is economic benefits, it can be just that.
- imaginenore 12y agoNothing stops you from being truthful and vulnerable without getting married. There are tons of marriages with lies and mistrust.
- selmnoo 12y agoOf course, you can have that without getting married. But you see, more than anything, marriage is really a cultural institution. It has a strong symbolic power. It's an excuse for a big party, a signaling of commitment, etc. We humans do a lot of things based on tradition and culture. Marriage is one of those things. Because come on, if we don't have culture, what do we have?
- jiggy2011 12y agoDoes this study examine the difference between people who are in long term non married relationships and those who are not? Does porn cause people in relationships not to convert those relationships into marriages or does porn cause people to be less likely to enter a relationship at all?
- bluedino 12y agoI'd have never noticed. A large amount of the people my age (25-35) that I work with are married, most of my friends are married, both of my brothers (younger than I) are married, and I myself was even engaged for a few years.
- baddox 12y agoIt is reasonable to expect that marriage rates could drop significantly while there still remains a large number of people who observe most of their peers getting married.
- r109 12y agoReally? From my perspective people can't afford marriage, a kid, house, cars, and ultimately a divorce. Man it would be nice to just have $3k for a wedding ring, I could pay off a fraction of my debt! Oh! Wedding reception costs? Fuck that, I need to finance a good car that gets excellent mpg! OH, child support laws? Yeah I had an older brother that had his wallet raped for 14 years of his life. He's now looking at houses, hopefully his current wife doesn't divorce him with the kids they have. :P
- kingmanaz 12y agoUsury. Not long ago one high school educated American working a factory shift could support a wife and four kids. His large, hand crafted home is now found in the gentrified corner of town, which today's blue collars couldn't dream of buying a piece of. Today's "middle class" typically live in a chicken-wire-and-stucco tract home built by economic refugees rather than craftsmen, lease to own a $40,000 sedan, and dream of one day paying off their education debt before their medical bills start to pile up after mid-life. Marriage has been, like every other thing in America, reduced to a question of economic efficiency. But hey, there's always Bing Crosby this time of year to evoke an America that was more than a place to make money.
- sliverstorm 12y agoYou can still have that large hand crafted home if you don't expect to live in the middle of San Francisco or Boston. There are gorgeous houses within two hour's drive of me that cost five figures. I can't afford my parent's house. But when they bought it, it was surrounded by peach fields, not bustling metro America with top schools. To me, it is like bemoaning how your Grandma was able to afford a house in Beverly Hills in 1920, but you can't today. How unfair the economy, how cruel the world! Except Beverly Hills wasn't Movie Star City in 1920. My take is that our nation's appetite for coveted, increasingly scarce real estate has silently grown without our realizing it. Not one of my friends today would consider moving to a house surrounded by orchards.
- sdenton4 12y ago
- XorNot 12y agoCorrelation is not causation and they have no plausible mechanism beyond old-style stereotypes of human sexuality.
- Kenji 12y agoIt never ceases to amaze me how sophisticated people are at demonizing porn.
- spacehome 12y agoDemonizing? They're saying porn discourages people from marriage. We call that a win-win where I'm from.
- kingmanaz 12y agoThe decrease in marriage in today's generations stems from the increase in failed marriages of the Boomer generation. Many of today's eligible Gen-X'ers and Millennials come from broken homes.
- patronagezero 12y agoYou really believe that just because their parents failed the children decided not to try for themselves? Perhaps it has more to do with seeing how their parents failed. Specifically since the article is geared towards men, maybe it speaks towards a generation (or few) of boys watching the system screw their fathers over.
- patronagezero 12y agoI live with a girl and have no intentions of classifying that relationship through the state. This article is a joke. Check out the MGTOW movement if you're interested in the real reason guys are refusing to get married.
- imaginenore 12y agoIt's not porn. Porn has been around for a long time. It's the information. People now know more and they see that marriage is heavily stacked against males and against higher earners. We also have a ridiculous situation when prenups get thrown out by judges. People just don't see that many benefits in marriage. And what are they exactly? I can only think of four: * Slightly lower taxes * Visitation rights * Ability to make medical decisions about the spouse when the spouse can't * Spousal testimonial privilege and privileged communication
- foobarian 12y agoI feel secularization is probably a large contributor. Without peer pressure of a religious community it's easier to put off the marriage.
- InternetUser 12y agoRegarding lower taxes, another commenter linked to this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_penalty http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_penalty
- phazmatis 12y agoBecause only men look at porn. Crap article.
- wes-k 12y agoBeen with my partner almost 10 years (I'm 29). We most likely will never get married. We feel we don't need it and plus, the institution from an equal rights point of view is fairly troubling. Even today's traditional wedding is filled with male / female imbalances, not to mention gay marriage is still not universal. I'm also happy to keep a few extra thousand in my hands instead of De Beers.
- parag_c_mehta 12y agoThat will be nice for now until one of you decide to move on for greener pastures. Lonely old age may also follow...
- logn 12y agoMarginal Effect on Marriage Probability Porn Site -0.6310 Finance Site -0.5889 News Site -0.5877 Education Site -0.5823 Health Site -0.5744 Sports Site -0.5928 Religious Site +0.5399 A natural public policy option is web filtering. [...] If the results in this paper are correct, policies along these lines have the potential to reduce pornography usage and increase marital entry, with its attendant welfare improvements. Is allowing only religious sites another natural policy option? Because that's what the data suggests too. Edit: Linked study: http://ftp.iza.org/dp8679.pdf http://ftp.iza.org/dp8679.pdf -- table data from PDF page 31 and quote from page 25.
- noblethrasher 12y agoI attended a talk where porn and video games were cited as candidates for explaining the surprisingly low crime rate during the last economic downturn. I mention this without value connotation since, while low crime is “obviously” good, society may also have benefited from stronger displays of discontent in the long-term.
- the_decider 12y agoThe Researchers of the Study miss the obvious...its hard to find an optimal oportunity to "jack it" when your wife is constantly there, breathing down your neck. Marriage leads to total loss of individual privacy, which is needed to properly enjoy Porn ;-)
- the_decider 12y agoThe Researchers of the Study miss the obvious...its hard to find an optimal oportunity to "jack it" when your wife is constantly there, breathing down your neck. Marriage leads to total loss of individual privacy, which is needed to properly enjoy Porn ;-)
- susan_hall 12y agoMarriage in the USA peaked in 1958. Please see the chart here: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/07/opinion/sunday/the-real-reason-richer-people-marry.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/12/07/opinion/sunday/the-real-re... Marriage peaked the same year that male participation in the wage economy peaked. It was also the peak year of the baby boom. It was also the peak year for the wage-to-rent ratio (average rent was only 22% of average wage, versus 32% now). It was also the peak year for wages for males under the age of 25. (Average male wage began to decline in 1973, but the average wage for young males has been declining since the recession of 1959.) Internet porn was not the problem in 1959, or 1969, or 1979, though the marriage rate, and the birth rate, plummeted during those years. But it is possible that the sexual revolution played a role. Barbara Ehrenreich has a fantastic book on the subject "The Hearts Of Men": http://www.amazon.com/The-Hearts-Men-American-Commitment/dp/0385176155 http://www.amazon.com/The-Hearts-Men-American-Commitment/dp/... Although the marriage rate is now back down to levels last seen in the late 1800s, there is clearly a big difference in people's sexual practice. 41% of all the children in the USA are now born outside of wedlock. The number is comparable to London in the early 1700s (see Will and Ariel Durant's book "The Age Of Voltaire" where they quote the Bishop Of London, in 1719, estimating 50% of all couples with children in London were not married. This was at a time when the English government had decided to suppress marriage among the poor by raising the price of a marriage license to something only the middle and upper classes could afford, thus turning marriage into the ultimate status symbol.) Marriage has once again become a status symbol. The poor raise children without the benefit of marriage, while the (shrunken) middle and upper classes enjoy the prestige of marriage. The suppression of marriage in the 21st century is less easy to identify than in 1719, because back then it was an explicit policy of the government, whereas now marriage licenses are cheap. But marriage is a commitment to make things work over the long term, and without a stable job no one can reasonably make long term commitments, nor does anyone want to rush into a marriage that they know will fail, so the poor are left going through life without the benefits of marriage (or you could restate this as: "the poor are left going through life without the benefits of financial stability, which limits their ability to make the long-term commitments necessary to make a marriage work.")
- patrickg_zill 12y agoIf a woman can be replaced with (essentially) Youtube.com , then, she isn't offering much is she? Something tells me the article is not right in blaming porn.
- pakled_engineer 12y agohttp://www.thelocal.de/20140117/dating-in-berlin-unwilling-to-commit-single http://www.thelocal.de/20140117/dating-in-berlin-unwilling-t... Look up exact same articles for Japan, China, S Korea, anywhere. We work more with less social time, prefer independence and marriage expectations are too high so short-term obligation free hookup services like Tinder are preferred to maintaining a relationship.
- ejp 12y agoI rarely hear the alternative explanation that speaks most to me: marriage as an institution is currently a segregated privilege. I do not want to participate, lest I lend it some small sliver of legitimacy. Where are the articles talking about the people who don't get married because they no longer need a plausible cover for their sexuality? Or because they are creating loving non-traditional families? Or those like me who empathize with those who are disallowed from participating? (These are not rhetorical questions, if you know of such research going on I would like to read it!) I suppose it's easier to blame the newfangled interwebs and kids these days, rather than talk about the very real social changes that are taking place.
- msandford 12y agoSeems like someone needs to read this again: http://xkcd.com/552/ http://xkcd.com/552/ People consuming more porn is a more likely a symptom of what's going on rather than the cause. As whatever forces cause people to be less likely to get married it creates a larger market for porn that the industry is more than happy to supply in greater quantities. What forces are causing people to be less likely to get married? I can speculate but I suspect it's highly multifaceted. I doubt there's one thing that's largely to blame but more of a death by a thousand papercuts kind of situation. 1. Housing is a bigger commitment 2. Job security is less available making buying real estate less attractive 3. Expectations of what should happen once you get married aren't necessarily realistic 4. Ending a marriage is highly speculative and non-negotiable (a judge says what goes and that's it) and can have lifelong or very long-lasting consequences financially 5. There's a lot less societal pressure to get married to have kids from a moral perspective 6. The economic incentive for a woman to get married so she can stay home to raise kids has largely disappeared as pay equality has largely arrived (so has the notion that it's what a woman should do). It's not 100% across the board but women don't work for 30% of what men do, meaning that marriage might only bring a marginal improvement in financial circumstances. 7. Child support being completely unrelated to marriage means that women can choose not to settle for a man they once liked/loved but who isn't their ideal partner. I'm not saying that any of these factors are good or bad or just or unjust. I suspect that there are 20 more factors that I couldn't think up in the last 10 minutes.
- jseliger 12y ago1. Housing is a bigger commitment Interestingly, this is a policy choice—and a bad one—foisted on us primarily by incumbent land owners who vote: http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0078XGJXO , rather than a law of nature.
- ps4fanboy 12y agoBeing young myself (early 30s) most of my male friends are terrified of marriage because their parents are all mostly divorced and its ugly. Men now see marriage as a huge risk, if your wife decides she doesnt like you any more she takes at least 50% of your assets and if you have children its very unlikely the state will give you custody and you will be on the hook for child support if you cant pay (because you get a worse job etc) you will go to debtors prison.
- unclebucknasty 12y ago>"The natural reaction might be to dismiss the findings as confirmations of an obviousness: that men who are married tend to look at porn less frequently precisely because they are married. The researchers, while careful to say that their findings fall short of being conclusive, insist that the relationship between the two also "likely runs in the direction that we assert." The reason, Malcolm explains, is likely tied to the relationship between marriage and sexual gratification...." Hmm. Seems to be a pretty massive gap in their logic path. In reply to the very real possibility that married men simply view less porn, they quickly spun to the reasons they suspect porn could lead to men not getting married. It also "likely" runs in the direction we assert and here is a likely reason that it might? C'mon guys.
- poulsbohemian 12y agoIsn't this just as simple as the US catching up to Europe? Average marriage age throughout northern Europe is 30+, often when a couple decides they are ready for children.
- raincom 12y agoPorn is one of many causes, but not a clinching cause. It is all economy. 1. In 1970's highschool graduated were able to raise families on a single salary, could afford a home, a couple of cars. 2. The above situation does not exist anymore. Have you seen graduates from places like UC Irvine, working at Enterprise car rental? 3. Yes, there are jobs for students graduated from top schools like HYP, Stanford, MIT. For others, it is either a tech job or a job like that. 4. Wherever there are jobs, there the cost of living, raising a family is a darn expensive. Imagine Silicon valley for instance: if you are just a software engineer, you can't afford raising a family here, unless you and your spouse slave away at work and in commutes. Then add day care costs, mortgages, etc. It is a stressful situation. 5. For many in the middle income bracket, the future is bleak: you can't guarantee that your kids gonna have same economic opportunity as you have.
- InternetUser 12y agoYou may be familiar with the "Old Economy Steven" meme: http://www.quickmeme.com/Old-Economy-Steven/page/1/ http://www.quickmeme.com/Old-Economy-Steven/page/1/ Bloomberg: What the Economy Has Done to the Family (some shocking statistics) - Nov 10, 2014 http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-11-10/how-the-bad-economy-breaks-up-families.html http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-11-10/how-the-bad-economy... "Is a college degree worth the cost? You decide." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXpwAOHJsxg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kXpwAOHJsxg And see this 8-minute video, comparing the 1970s economy (and how it shaped the lives and choices of young adults) with the economy of the 2010s: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzOTykfGxzE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AzOTykfGxzE More about that: http://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/2m7xp1/bloomberg_what_the_economy_has_done_to_the_family/ http://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/2m7xp1/bloomberg_w...
- Jugurtha 12y agoAnyone thinks they might be holding off because of insane laws? Getting kicked out of your own house (that you bought with your own money) as if it's a given. Getting ruined by divorce, or losing half your stuff as if it's so natural. I've read an article a while back. The cheapest divorces are those of billionaires, the most expensive ones are those of artists and athletes who married without a prenup. Who were naïve enough to think that in the case of divorce, they'd be the same as when they first met, and they'd treat each other with the same respect and love. Looking at the state of things, the question to ask is How can anyone get married in the U.S.?
- Umn55 12y agoThe reality is women won't marry low status men and men don't really want the burden of having to support a wife and child without any income. It's really about money/status, in a status obsessed society.
- bob917 12y agoSome particular bedroom practices I learned from porn scared away two of my prospective wives.