2 ms·
Your premise of morality is based on the notion that one person has the right to the produce of another person. Your theory, boiled down to its core, rests on t
by adventured 12y ago
Your premise of morality is based on the notion that one person has the right to the produce of another person. Your theory, boiled down to its core, rests on the complete invalidation of property rights, all rights of ownership. That in some cases - decided by some random people, bureaucrats of course - you have no right to what you create, that it is to be owned by someone else, because they have a need.
I argue that your system is responsible for most of the brutality of the 20th century; yours is the notion that violence makes right. That using guns to confiscate property is proper. The market system is the only moral system, it's the only one that doesn't hold some people to be the slaves of other people, with endless claims of need held over their heads, and their property expropriated by way of force.
Your theory posits that my wealth is owed to anyone else that is poorer than I am. Because my wealth could go to significantly improve their life in countless ways. Whether I have $50,000 or $50 million to my name makes no difference when we're talking about the bottom 15% of the world's poor. Whether I own a drug, or own cash, there is absolutely no difference, the claim is the same: I'm rich, and I have no right to my property, because there is someone poorer that has a need. I don't owe anyone the coat off my back, and that principle goes the same for America inherently owing a poor country anything; and if I choose to give someone my coat, it should be solely up to me.
The only moral system when dealing with such poverty is one of voluntary charity. Anything else is a crime against humanity, for there's nothing more disgusting than 'charity' at the point of a gun.
- PhasmaFelis 12y ago> The only moral system when dealing with such poverty is one of voluntary charity. Anything else is a crime against humanity, for there's nothing more disgusting than 'charity' at the point of a gun. Objectivism in a nutshell: It is more moral to let an innocent child die in pain than to require someone to help them. And just like Rand, you'll fight like a demon to suppress public assistance until it's your neck on the line, and then suddenly it's Social Security and Medicare on the sly, like a homophobic preacher hooking up blowjobs in men's rooms.