7 ms·
Bitcoin Promoter Gets 2 Years for Silk Road Money Laundering
- ilamont 12y ago“I screwed up,” Shrem told U.S. District Judge Jed Rakoff. “The bitcoin community, they’re scared and there is no money laundering going on any more." Does this claim have any basis?
- Meekro 12y agoIt has some. Back in 2011 or so when mtgox/bitinstant were big, none of them really knew what they were supposed to do. Nobody even knew if bitcoin was enough like "money" to qualify under money transmitter laws. The state and federal regulatory agencies didn't know what bitcoin was, and certainly didn't provide any guidance for the exchanges on what they were supposed to do to comply with the law. Now, we have more regulatory guidance and the exchanges are, by and large, complying with it. The dominant companies are Bitstamp, Coinbase, and Circle, and they are all demanding identification info from their customers and notifying the regulatory bodies of any suspicious activities.
- meowface 12y agoIf you deal with legitimate US companies like Coinbase, then yes, it does. Bitcoin is now seen with some degree of legitimacy by the US government and the parts of the US public that are aware of it. Bitcoin, like anything else built on strong cryptography and/or decentralization (Tor, BitTorrent), is of course still used for nefarious purposes including money laundering and funding of criminal enterprises. But the legitimate use likely outweighs the illicit use. And the bulk of the illicit use is primarily for what I would consider very minor crimes (like buying drugs for recreational use in one's own home).
- kiba 12y agoUS dollars are used for illicit purposes, in much greater volume than Bitcoin in its entire history. I don't see how this change anything with bitcoin.
- krapp 12y agoIt doesn't. Money laundering is still illegal either way.
- meowface 12y agoYou're right, but there is a difference. Cash can be easily used to launder, but it has to be done physically and generally requires in-person interaction. Cryptocurrencies can be used to launder but can be done remotely and through various forms of proxied mediums.
- baddox 12y agoBut that difference is one caused by all sorts of technological advancements, including completely unrelated advancements, and in my opinion is not a great excuse to preemptively treat the currencies differently. By your same reasoning, the advent of air travel made laundering cash easier.
- meowface 12y ago>By your same reasoning, the advent of air travel made laundering cash easier. That's true, though. Law enforcement agencies around the world had to account for plane flights as a potential way to trade illicit substances and gains from those substances. They had to hire experts in satellites and radar systems to track air vehicles carrying contraband when necessary. And the same is true of cryptocurrencies. Law enforcement has to quickly adapt to the new medium and overcome extra hurdles. I'm not discounting cryptocurrencies or air travel at all, I'm just saying that technological inventions often create many new intended and unintended externalities for all sorts of entities.
- downandout 12y agoHe's lucky he didn't also catch a case for ripping people off through Bitinstant. While no one knows the total of orders that they failed to deliver, it's likely to be in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. A class action suit was filed against the company before it folded. I'm guessing a big chunk of the stolen money went into this guy's pocket. Curiously, it looks like he's also asking for donations on Twitter: https://twitter.com/CharlieShrem/status/546367889625079808 https://twitter.com/CharlieShrem/status/546367889625079808
- eof 12y ago> He's lucky I'm not sure about that. I don't know the details; but I strongly suspect that while Shrem very likely knew he was laundering 'illegal' money (at least, I think he would have done it whether he knew or not), he was not ripping people off on purpose. Personally, I find it hard to feel too bad for Shrem; since he was sloppy and loud.. and kind of just had it coming. That being said, I don't think he did anything morally wrong w/r/t what is he is being convicted of. This is more a case of a bad law and a stupid person than a bad person. In a more reasonable world where people are legally allowed to enter into mutual, private contracts without a nanny state policing people's morals.. what Shrem did could not even be considered a crime. His fault? sure. Stupid of him? Sure.. but laundering money for drug dealers is not morally reprehensible in its own right (unless they are violent drug dealers); it's just dumb to do in an obvious way with thousands of people watching you (and not even charging a ridiculous mark up!)
- downandout 12y agoThe last ~200 pages (like 2,000 posts) of the Bitinstant support thread at Bitcointalk.org before they shut down were essentially all complaints about undelivered orders and excuses by staff, including Charlie Shrem, about why orders weren't being delivered. Things got so bad that they hired someone specifically to respond to complaints in that thread, and then after a month or two he quit.
- eof 12y agoRight; but they were getting fucked over in the fiat world left and right up until that point too. Not saying they didn't over-promise and under-deliver but you can't really examine these things in a vacuum.
- arto 12y agoReddit thread on /r/Bitcoin: http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2pu0b2/american_justice_hsbc_launders_billions_no_jail/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/2pu0b2/american_jus...
- wyager 12y agoSo can someone clarify this for me? It sounds like he didn't actually do any money laundering, but sent money on behalf someone who was accused of being a money launderer? 2 years seems pretty harsh for that.
- Meekro 12y agoIt was harsh, doubly so because nobody at the time knew what the money laundering rules for bitcoin were supposed to be. They were trying to bring down Silk Road, and this guy was accused of buying/selling bitcoins for a major Silk Road dealer. This isn't about banking, it's about the war on drugs.
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI think you are being a bit too charitable. If you send something which is being traded into and out of currency on behalf of someone else, or on your own behalf, you are have to ask the question if this is legitimate or not. Now if you sell PEZ collectibles on Ebay for others, and find they start sending you back the same collectable you sold before, you have to sit back and ask, Hmm what is really going on here? And if you don't do that, then you risk finding yourself, like Shrem did, in a place which really wasn't a legal place to be. The key here was the judges observation, "months and months" of activity. If you do this and stop for a second and say "Hmm, why is this so profitable for me, what is the deal here?" a couple of weeks in, maybe even a month in, and you document seeking legal advice. Then you get off with a wrist slap. It was like the bitcoin for gift cards site that someone here said was "amazingly profitable", you have to stop and ask yourself where is the "value" here that I'm getting to keep so much of it.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- wmf 12y agoShrem was the compliance officer for a company and he deliberately broke the company's own compliance policies. He wasn't even trying to follow the law.
- 12y ago
- patrickg_zill 12y agoWhere are the criminal convictions for HSBC and Wachovia's money laundering for the Mexican drug cartels? They laundered over $300 Billion USD over the years, and no one went to jail?
- hurin 12y agoBecause criminal convictions against a major bank could have serious repercussions, probably both in terms of international relations and economically. In the same spirit - Silkroad the great online evil of the drug trade, had a yearly turnover of less than .1% of the world drug market.
- higherpurpose 12y agoNot as serious as sending them the message that they can continue uninhibited.
- epscylonb 12y agoIf you owe me 100 dollars you have a problem, if you owe me a million dollars I have problem.
- api 12y agoLaws are for little people.
- hfx902 12y ago"Little people" may take offence to that. The correct saying would be "Laws are for poor people"
- forrestthewoods 12y ago"Little people" are free to be offended when that term is used with respect to them. However they don't get to ban the word 'little' from the english language. The way it was used was perfectly fine and correct.
- deleted 12y ago
- marlinspire 12y agoHe was threatened with 30 years so he took a plea-deal. It is a shame he was denied a trial. May or may not have been guilty - taking a plea under such extreme duress is hardly an admission of guilt.
- higherpurpose 12y agoYet people here keep defending these ridiculous charges because they "don't matter", and "aren't real anyway". Yeah, tell that to the person that had to hear that charge and then got scared shitless into accepting "only 2 years" of prison time.
- spacemanmatt 12y agoI haven't seen that. Prosecutorial abuse is better understood around HN than most of society, that I've seen. YMMV.
- Zigurd 12y agoHey! He wasn't driven to suicide so it's a success story.
- shiven 12y agoFor those who may have read ‘The Billionaire’s Apprentice'[1], Jed Rakoff is the same judge who was involved in sentencing Rajat Gupta. [1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/30/books/review/the-billionaires-apprentice-by-anita-raghavan.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2013/06/30/books/review/the-billionai...
- consz 12y agoThis guy doesn't sound too bright. His best plea to the judge was, what, that he could be a motivational speaker for not obviously flaunting AML laws? He really couldn't come up with anything better than that?