3 ms·
MIT runs Lincoln Lab which is a think tank / R&D facility for the military. You have to pass through an armed checkpoint to get to the the complex located on an
by kevin_thibedeau 12y ago
MIT runs Lincoln Lab which is a think tank / R&D facility for the military. You have to pass through an armed checkpoint to get to the the complex located on an AF base. I would consider that node compromised already.
- hdevalence 12y agoI'm confused. Are you saying that the MIT Tor node is at Lincoln Lab, or are you suggesting that anything MIT-affiliated is tainted because of LL?
- lambda 12y agoYou realize that Tor came out of the US Naval Research Laboratory, right? https://www.torproject.org/about/overview https://www.torproject.org/about/overview
- sneak 12y agoIt's also open source. Can we stop with this fucking red herring already? He's talking about a service, right now, under the direct control of the US military. You're talking about grant funding for an open source tool. Stop.
- thefreeman 12y agoNo, he's not. He's talking about a single research laboratory MIT runs on a military base. Which somehow makes the entire university under direct control of the military?
- nl 12y agoNote that 'the military' and 'a hypothetical government agency opposed to Tor' are not necessarily the same thing. Counterintuitively sometimes the best protection is to operate under another agency. That makes moving against Tor a battle of internal politics rather than a legal battle. 'The government' rarely has uniform views on something as complex as Tor.
- SolarNet 12y agoThe mistake of course being that the military (and the CIA, it's very useful for their assets) is pro-TOR and were the ones who developed it. It's the FBI/NSA that are anti-TOR. The government is rarely monolithic, especially when it comes to the security divisions.
- indolering 12y agoIt's not monolithic but power is magnified. A branch of the military relying on Tor for operational security ensures that the DoD will be at least split on officially sanctioning the technology.
- vasundhar 12y agoI have 0 Trust on MIT, since Aaron Swartz incident. I consider that place no more than deep shit. I Don't want to believe, if I can trust a Tor Network passing through that gate in MIT
- eob 12y agoFWIW according to the listserv traffic at MIT CSAIL right now, some members of the community seem to believe that the TOR node lives in CSAIL, not LL.
- jlgaddis 12y agoAssuming the PTR RRs are accurate, that would appear to be true: $ traceroute 128.31.0.39 ... 15 mitnet.trantor.csail.mit.edu (18.4.7.65) 40.218 ms 40.661 ms 40.900 ms 16 asperta.helicon.csail.mit.edu (128.30.0.246) 45.345 ms 47.082 ms * 17 belegost.csail.mit.edu (128.31.0.39) 44.074 ms !X 45.023 ms !X 45.549 ms !X