3 ms·
Eight out of ten are about programming languages, and strong on the functional side to boot. It's not that these topics aren't important, or that they're not g
by notacoward 12y ago
Eight out of ten are about programming languages, and strong on the functional side to boot. It's not that these topics aren't important, or that they're not great papers, but isn't that a bit too heavily skewed toward one area? Shouldn't at least one of those top ten be more directly about security, or performance, or some other kind of idea rather than the notation we use to express ideas?
Yeah, I know, make your own list. Maybe I will. Nonetheless, the author specifically mentions "cover a wide-range of topics" as a goal and this list fails to meet that goal.
- frozenport 12y agoPerhaps these 10 are among the greater set of papers that every programmer should read. I will shamelessly plug the IRLS paper on l0 optimization: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cpa.20303/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/cpa.20303/abstrac...
- DyslexicAtheist 12y agomight want to check http://blog.valbonne-consulting.com/2014/06/09/an-incomplete-list-of-classic-papers-every-software-architect-should-read/ http://blog.valbonne-consulting.com/2014/06/09/an-incomplete...
- dj-wonk 12y agoYes, there is an emphasis (and bias!) towards functional languages and distributed systems. Yes, Fogus' intent is to raise awareness of these concepts. Yes, other people would have different lists. Yes, the list could have more breadth. Personally, I'd like to see a concept map of essential computer science topics combined with some of the top papers and books that cover each. It could be implemented as a curated collapsable directed graph.
- tekacs 12y ago> Personally, I'd like to see a concept map of essential computer science topics combined with some of the top papers and books that cover each. It could be implemented as a curated collapsable directed graph. I've tried building one of these before, both for CS and for Maths. Funnily enough formatting, displaying and making it accessible (whilst retaining enough data) was the time-consuming issue, despite all the tech around for handling graphs. :/
- seanmcdirmid 12y agoMost of us program, so programming languages is actually a fairly general supporting field for the "computer science" community when other active fields tend to be more specialized. Other general fields include systems and algorithms, which seem to be represented somewhat. In my opinion, none of these papers are must reads, but that is just an opinion :) Disclaimer, I'm a PL researcher, but I work in a systems group.
- zak_mc_kracken 12y agoGood catch. These are definitely interesting papers, especially to someone like me who has a much stronger interest in programming languages than other (admittedly essential) topics like performance and similar, but this selection is a revealing demonstration that a lot of people who are heavy into functional programming tend to think that FP is the silver bullet of software engineering and that beyond it, there's nothing really interesting worth learning (especially not OOP or other non-FP methodologies).