5 ms·
Well, that's fairly hyperbolic. It wasn't near self-evidently fantastical, unless you base that entirely on political willingness. As for what you thought mad
by kbenson 12y ago
Well, that's fairly hyperbolic. It wasn't near self-evidently fantastical, unless you base that entirely on political willingness.
As for what you thought made it fantastical, I would love to hear a short list. My last understanding of it was that there wasn't anything specifically physical or technical that prevented it from being possible (albeit requiring more real-world testing), and there was at least some effort put into addressing the implementation details. If there are portions that are actually impossible rather than just unlikely I would rather know than remain ignorant.
- tptacek 12y agoNo, it was fantastical. For instance: the cost estimates Musk provided were premised on advancements in tunnel drilling and elevated track construction costs that would have revolutionized all of civil engineering, not just hyperlooping.
- kbenson 12y ago"Ahlborn says, and Musk's cost estimate of $6-10 billion for a 400-mile stretch of Hyperloop is on point, based on the team's work." Obviously this is a fluff piece, and he has incentive to not play up any problems with the budget, but it's stated there openly. You've stated the opposite, since I don't have evidence from either of you, why exactly should I consider your opinion more worthy than a group of many competent engineers?
- tptacek 12y agohttp://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy-ideas-are-fine-if-youre-an-entrepreneur/ http://pedestrianobservations.wordpress.com/2013/08/13/loopy... Musk's viaduct costs, for instance, were 1/10th those of California's HSR. His premise is that he can decimate the HSR cost. Obviously that is a comparison that is relevant for LA-SF, but potentially not for Houston-Austin. Which I acknowledged upthread. As did the "many competent engineers" in this piece.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Musk's viaduct costs, for instance, were 1/10th those of California's HSR. ISTR -- and I may be mistaken -- that a significant portion of the underestimation there wasn't engineering-related, but real-estate related, in that costs of acquiring the land for the footprint was low-balled or ignored.
- tptacek 12y agoThis is addressed, at least somewhat, in the source I just cited.
- kbenson 12y agoI also seem to remember that, and I believe Musk attributed so much savings to it because there was very little right of way that needed to be worked out, he was going to put it in the median of I-80. That reduces the theoretical cost quite a bit. I think that's the goal of the company doing this, to test the feasibility of the design in more detail. It's also why I'm inclined to give them some weight in their assessment of the costs. But not too much. If I was an investor in some of this testing, I would want to go over their cost assessments with a fine toothed comb. It does seem this is one of the biggest unknowns in the proposal, and it's also one of the things that could change the most depending on where it's implemented, making it hard to make definite statements about.
- tptacek 12y agoIt's tough to seem to remember something about a source that is contradicted in the source itself. I think you should start by reading the link, and then opine on it.
- kbenson 12y agoNo, it's not tough to seem to remember anything, human memory is very fallible. That's why I prefaced the statement with that bit, because I was in no way sure. That said, my memory wasn't that bad. Here's what I was slightly misremembering from the proposal: By building it on pylons, you can almost entirely avoid the need to buy land by following alongside the mostly very straight California Interstate 5 highway, with only minor deviations when the highway makes a sharp turn. [1] So it's I-5, not i-80, and it's beside the highway, not in the median. I'm not sure how either of those mistakes affect the point I was trying to make to the degree it's not worth addressing, so I'm unsure why you used a rhetorical tactic instead of just correcting (since you obviously knew it was incorrect) and addressing that point, but that's your prerogative. 1: https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/blog_images/hyperloop-alpha.pdf https://www.teslamotors.com/sites/default/files/blog_images/...
- TrevorJ 12y agoThe cost to build one mile of 6 lane interstate in an urban area is estimated at 11 million dollars per mile. If you look at the estimated cost for the hyperloop, it seems to come out at around 25 million per mile. This isn't outside the realm of possibility at all, just a little more than twice that of traditional methods.
- tptacek 12y agoThe hyperloop isn't a 6-lane interstate. It's an elevated track, some of it tunneled through rock.
- smackfu 12y ago11 million dollars per mile does not seem accurate. They recently widened the Turnpike in NJ from 6 to 12 lanes over a 35 mile stretch, and it cost $2.3 billion. That's $65 million per mile. And that was considered a successful project. http://www.northjersey.com/news/nj-turnpike-widening-set-to-ease-bottleneck-1.1116551?page=all http://www.northjersey.com/news/nj-turnpike-widening-set-to-...
- duaneb 12y agoSo, it's not fantastical, it's ambitious... Fantasy implies an impossibility.
- tptacek 12y agoOnce again: I chose the word fantastical somewhat carefully and think the evidence bears it out. It's not an ambitious cost estimate; it's simply unrealistic.
- duaneb 12y agoA), ambitious and unrealistic are not mutually exclusive. It was ambitious and unrealistic to attempt a moon landing in under a decade. B) Again, I believe fantastical implies a rational person would think it highly improbably. I'm a rational person, but so is Elon Musk; what appears fantastical to me appears ambitious to someone with a better understanding of the situation. I suspect this would apply to you, too.
- tptacek 12y ago"Because Elon Musk" isn't a real argument, but as this thread shows, it is routinely mistaken for one.
- duaneb 12y ago"Because consensus" hasn't been terribly great either, thought it is routinely mistaken for one. IMHO fantastical implies that it directly contradicts rationality, not common knowledge.
- tanzam75 12y ago> A), ambitious and unrealistic are not mutually exclusive. It was ambitious and unrealistic to attempt a moon landing in under a decade. That's absolutely not true. It was ambitious and totally realistic to attempt a moon landing in 10 years. Kennedy only selected that goal after von Braun said that it could be done "by 1967/68". He even added an extra two years of padding, just in case von Braun was being optimistic. Anyone who knew anything about space flight knew that Kennedy's goal was achievable. In fact, some thought that von Braun was gold-plating the program unnecessarily. McDonnell did some engineering studies for landing one man on the moon using Gemini and a Saturn C-3 (about half the payload capacity of a Saturn V). If 90% of civil engineers would say in 2013 that Elon Musks hyperloop plan was realistic, then it would be where the moon landing was in 1961. But they wouldn't. In comparison to the moon landing, Elon Musk's hyperloop was wildly unrealistic.
- dragontamer 12y agoThe "some effort" included a 3-stage FEA that I accomplished in less than one semester of study. And I'm a computer engineer, I don't even have a real mechanical or civil-engineering experience and I could tell that the FEA proposal in the paper was a complete joke. You say there wasn't real world testing. I go further, there wasn't even a serious theoretical analysis of the proposed Hyperloop system.