8 ms·
Apple goes to war with the BBC
- rtpg 12y ago>Williams countered that Apple has tracked the weekly hours of over one million workers within its supply chain, and that its suppliers have achieved an average of 93 per cent compliance with the 60-hour workweek limit this year. 60 hour workweeks... plus "93% compliance" is not exactly reassuring.
- LaSombra 12y ago> In an email to around 5,000 staff across the UK, Apple senior vice president of operations Jeff Williams said both himself and the chief executive were "deeply offended by the suggestion that Apple would break a promise to the workers in our supply chain or mislead our customers in any way". Well, that makes 7% being lied to. Did I understand this correctly?
- notjackma 12y agoClearly Tim Cook and senior management are in a bind. They keep telling people they're geniuses ('only Apple could do this') and industry leaders in environmental practices. The BBC film has shown this to be false so either Tim Cook is a pathological liar or he doesn't have a clue what goes on in the supply chain. Meaning he's not the genius the fawning press like to make him out to be. The best quote in the film is when an Indonesian supplier is asked what he thinks of Apple's envieonmental policy. His response: "Apple bullshit. Bullshit Apple.". The subtitles make this an instant internet meme.
- dalke 12y agoIt would be nice to compare those numbers to that of other companies or organizations. But even if you stay strictly with US companies, is it possible to find the compliance rate for Microsoft, Google, Twitter, Red Hat, etc., much less the various game studios known for overworking their employees?
- debacle 12y agoA 60 hour work week for wage laborers should not be baseline in any country in 2014. Apple is doing what they can to exploit these workers in a PC fashion.
- rndn 12y ago* as any other company that outsources manufacturing.
- debacle 12y agoSo should we not also look down on those companies? Why do we give companies a pass to exploit workers because other companies do as well?
- Retric 12y agoI don't know if a 60 hour work week counts as exploitation. If you options are 400$/month and 40 hour weeks or 600$ a month and 60 hour weeks a lot of people are going to chose the second option. IMO, when it comes to exploitation pay, working conditions, and irregular work schedules can be far more exploitive than simple hours worked. Also, dorm style housing next to a factory dramatically cut down on commute times which changes the work life balance equation. It's much like a 50 hour work week with a 1 hour commute which is fairly common in the US. PS: IMO the US trucking industry is probably more expletive than most Chinese factory's. The hours are often comparable but the risk of death is much higher. And the industry often increases peoples risk of death for just a little more profit.
- vidarh 12y ago> I don't know if a 60 hour work week counts as exploitation. If you options are 400$/month and 40 hour weeks or 600$ a month and 60 hour weeks a lot of people are going to chose the second option. And that is why it is exploitation: They are in a position where they don't realistically have a choice, and hence don't realistically have power to negotiate higher salaries for more reasonable hours. This is the basis for e.g. EU working time regulations that makes 60 hour work weeks illegal within the EU with few exceptions.
- sgnelson 12y agoWhile admittedly, I know nothing about Apple's internal policies and how it tracks these workers and the hours they're working, I wonder how real those numbers are. What I see often (very often) is that people see data and they take the numbers at face value. Could it possibly be that in order to appease Apple, the suppliers are cooking the books on the hours their employees are working? Obviously, in terms of profit margins, they want to squeeze out every penny of labor they can. What type of data integrity system does Apple have set up to make sure that these are truly the case? With 1 million workers and multiple companies (and all the suppliers) does Apple truly have an independent employee (unaffected by any pressure from factory management) at every factory to watch over the labor standards? I kind of doubt it. But yes, 60 hour work weeks, how noble of Apple. "Thank you sir, may I have another?" Personally, this really does make me rethink buying an Apple product.
- qq66 12y agoIt should make you rethink buying any electronic product whatsoever, since Apple's supply-chain audits are, though insufficient, by far the most thorough of any company (since they face the most scrutiny).
- sgnelson 12y agoRather, I would say, "it should make me rethink buying any electronic product _not manufactured in the US or other developed world countries that have much higher, stricter standards on labor conditions_..." Not everything is manufactured in China (though I certainly don't know of any laptops not made in China, and only a select few phones.) edit: oh, and also, my main point was "how good are those audits?"
- qq66 12y agoThe audits are probably pretty bad, but also probably better than the audits that less scrutinized companies do. What consumer electronics products are manufactured in the US... not counting "final assembly" in the US where the PCBs come in fully populated from China and are screwed into the enclosure in the US?
- notjackma 12y agoIt's worse. The documentary shows how Foxconn and Pegatron fake payroll slips so that long hours don't show up. 93% compliance is rubbish. Workers are forced to sign forms saying they consent to night shifts and overtime, when in fact overtime is mandatory. Apple's required reporting is nothing more than window-dressing; lipstick on a pig. Apple's release schedule of one big yearly event and 10 million units ready to ship on day 1 must bear some of the blame. Near impossible demands are being placed on manufacturers desperate to keep a lucrative contract, who in turn drive workers like slaves.
- beltex 12y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVaTl2kW6YU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AVaTl2kW6YU The full documentary by BBC.
- arthurfm 12y agoFor those of us in the UK (or with access to a UK-based proxy)... http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b04vs348/panorama-apples-broken-promises http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b04vs348/panorama-apple...
- kalleboo 12y agoI would love to see if they could find a multinational company WITHOUT issues like this in their supply chain - I imagine none exist. (I still support "exposé" programs like this since people need to be reminded what the actual cost of their toys are - but they should cast a broader net)
- hawleyal 12y agoI don't know why "everyone is doing it" somehow mitigates the problem.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoBecause they blame one company. From what I've read Apple has done more than anyone else to improve the situation and yet they're the ones that constantly receive blame. Do a report on the supply chain as a whole and how the entire tech industry has workers that are being exploited. They select one company (a popular one) because it'll generate more clicks regardless of the fact that it makes the reporting slightly biased.
- hawleyal 12y agoThey don't blame one company. They did an expose of one company. And one of the companies with arguably the most popular product.
- k-mcgrady 12y agoThe company who's also arguably doing the most to improve the situation. If the journalist actually cared about what was going on they would expose all offenders and highlight the worst, not expose the one who's already been exposed by several other journalists and is working to improve the situation.
- hawleyal 12y agoMy heart bleeds for the plight of Apple.
- swombat 12y agoThe problem with Apple criticism is a lot of it seems full of cheap shots and unfair framing, like this Panorama report. That makes it more difficult to tell when a criticism of Apple is genuine, because every idiot journalist looking for a controversial story can write a story about something Apple is doing not well enough and get away with it, since everyone seems to love to hate on Apple. So if Apple really is up to no good in some area of their business, we won't have a clue, because it's drowned out in tripe like this.
- patcon 12y agoI am by no means an Apple fan anymore, but I feel the exact same way.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoReminds me a little of how people somehow don't believe McDonalds when they reveal their food sources. Because people love to hate on them, McDs and Apple have higher standards than their competitors.
- funkybro 12y agoSee also: Facebook and security/privacy
- TeMPOraL 12y agoOr Google and privacy/surveillance. A lot of criticism is just fashion or signalling.
- kybernetikos 12y agoConfused about these two comments. Are you both literally arguing that Google has higher standards for privacy/surveillance than its competitors and that facebook is better than its competitors for security/privacy?
- 12y ago
- xedarius 12y agoI wouldn't quite call that war, more a disgruntled sigh.
- wernercd 12y agoThat wouldn't generate as many clicks...
- everyone 12y agoAgreed. One of the more egregious examples of hyperbole in an articles title, for the purpose of being clickbait, that I have seen. A better title would be; "Apple refutes BBC documentary"
- thyrsus 12y agoWould that we aspired to that definition of "war", in which a country's response to an attack was: "I'm deeply offended. Here are the statistics concerning the behavior to which you object. Here is our program to improve."
- frabcus 12y agoThis is a good place to mention Fairphone, a dutch foundation who make phones and document their supply chain in public, improving various things about it
- kmfrk 12y agoI recommend everyone to subscribe to China Labour Watch [http://chinalaborwatch.org http://chinalaborwatch.org]. Reports of workplace abuse are so recurring that you end up dying a little inside from reading about one huge company after the other pulling this shit - but at least it'll stop you from reverting to an automatic defensive response to bad news about companies like Apple. ++ fwiw, I still agree that it's generally counterproductive to do reporting focused on Apple, because although they're the most obvious company to scrutinize, it makes it seems as if the issue is specific to Apple and not the systemic rule across corporations. ++ PS: Consider donating to CLW while you're at it; it's Christmas, after all.
- dzhiurgis 12y agoSleeping publicly in asian cultures is perfectly normal. I remember seeing these asian students just passed out on university benches once I started studies abroad. The journalist says 'it seems that they have no choice'. So he just displayed his cultural unconsciousness and publicly alleged Apple of wrongdoing. One could easily speculate that people working in western societies are pumped up with caffeine, sugar or other drugs, freely available by their profit-hungry bosses.
- Zikes 12y agoIf I recall, in Japan if you're not seen sleeping at your desk then you've not been working hard enough.
- andybak 12y agoAnd it's perfectly acceptable to beat your domestic help in the UAE. Let's not confuse 'accepted' with 'acceptable'.
- Zikes 12y agoWell, that's about as ridiculous a leap as I can imagine. Some Asian nations have culturally integrated the fact that naps boost productivity[1][2][3] but we should impose our own cultural standards on them because they might actually be a bunch of uncivilized mongrels and it's our responsibility to teach them the error of their ways. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2012/07/24/why-you-should-take-a-10-minute-nap-every-day/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/daviddisalvo/2012/07/24/why-you-... [2] http://www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/features/america-its-time-for-your-nap http://www.webmd.com/sleep-disorders/features/america-its-ti... [3] http://www.health.harvard.edu/newsletters/Harvard_Health_Letter/2009/November/napping-may-not-be-such-a-no-no http://www.health.harvard.edu/newsletters/Harvard_Health_Let...
- aikah 12y ago> Sleeping publicly in asian cultures is perfectly normal. So is sleeping on the job after 12 hour shifts. The issue isnt sleeping publicly but the 12 hour shift thing. Your argument is a big strawman,even the best spin doctors wouldnt dare using that argument,unless maybe those on fox news.
- coob 12y agoGenuine question: Which large companies do supply chain auditing to the same or greater extent than Apple do? Do they make the audit publicly available as Apple do? I'd like to compare.
- Zikes 12y agoWalmart does a fair amount of supply chain auditing. http://corporate.walmart.com/global-responsibility/ethical-sourcing/audit-process http://corporate.walmart.com/global-responsibility/ethical-s...