4 ms·
> “There is nobody out there who can talk about self-esteem, about individualism, and about capitalism with the moral certainty and the moral fervor we can,” Br
by PhasmaFelis 12y ago
> “There is nobody out there who can talk about self-esteem, about individualism, and about capitalism with the moral certainty and the moral fervor we can,” Brook declared.
It is so telling that this guy thinks moral certainty and "fervor" are a good thing. A person who is 100% certain and unquestioning in his beliefs is a person who cannot be reasoned with. This avowed rationalist speaks with the language of religious fundamentalistism.
- lucio 12y agoby definition you cannot support objectivism and at the same time be impervious to reason. http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/reason.html http://aynrandlexicon.com/lexicon/reason.html
- pja 12y agoHuman beings are really, really good at constructing logical arguments for things they want to be true and ignoring or downplaying counter-arguments. Objectivism is no exception.
- Retric 12y agoFurther, any philosophy that includes axioms limits the value of logical reasoning. If X (which is assumed to be true) and Y then Z. It might be logically valid, but it’s still meaningless.
- mentat 12y agoWhich is... every philosophy that exists?
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Further, any philosophy that includes axioms limits the value of logical reasoning. On the contrary, as logical reasoning in any particular system of logic depends on the set of axioms defining that system of logic, any philosophy which does not admit any axioms likewise does not admit logical reasoning, and any philosophy which only includes those axioms necessary to support a system of logic can't lead to any conclusions other than those that constitute the description of the system of logic. In order for a philosophy to have interesting consequences, it must have substantive axioms.
- Retric 12y agoAnd that’s a swing and a miss. Axioms might include input from observations. "If I observe X then the gods are pleased." Followed by a lot of meaningless but perfectly logical thought. Side stepping that, from a pure logic standpoint you can reason about philosophies independent from reality. But, with nothing actually connecting them to physical reality the value of such effort is basically just aesthetic in nature. "TRUTH is ..."
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- PhasmaFelis 12y agoThat's a bold application of no-true-Scotsman. What percentage of avowed Objectivists do you figure are liars, then? Or are you saying that Objectivism provides a magical shield against unreasonable behavior?
- api 12y agoRand set out to create an anti-Marxism and she succeeded... in creating a dogmatic totalistic philosophy that inverts Soviet-style fundamentalist Marxism. Never fight against-- you inevitably become that which you fight. (to paraphrase Nietzsche) Like Marx, Rand was far better at criticizing than she was at proposing a solution. Both proposed scenarios with a big hand-wavey "magic happens here" step in the middle followed by a utopia. I also have to say this: Rand's admiration for big business and for "captains of industry" was obviously coming from someone who'd never actually worked in the high corporate world. Your average executive is almost indistinguishable from a Soviet apparatchik, and corporations are internally not terribly unlike Soviet bureaucracies (especially big ones). The number of real executives who at all resemble Rand heroes is something you can count on one hand -- and interestingly most of them don't espouse Randian-type ideology. Most seem to be either apolitical or slightly to the left. Some of Rand's ideas are interesting and well stated. I think she's worth reading. But a lot of her politics sounds really archaic now that we're almost 25 years past the cold war. Today's totalitarians are mostly ultra-right-wing theocrats, strong men like Putin, and neoliberal state-capitalists who are attempting to create a kind of high-tech feudalism. The fanatical totalistic version of socialist ideology is dead (that's a good thing-- one down, three or four to go). I'd personally take European or Canadian style "light socialism" over Iran or Singapore, thank you very much.
- digisign 12y agoIt's worth noting something I picked up watching the "making of" of the Atlas movie a few years ago. Rand apparently put out several subtle books on the subject previously but no one seemed to get the point. It was then she finally resorted to knocking you over the head with an over-the-top version. I found the movie simplistic, but hearing that afterwards gave some perspective.