7 ms·
Snowdrift.coop: Funding for free projects
- MaxGabriel 12y agoSnowdrift is written in the Haskell web framework Yesod https://github.com/dlthomas/snowdrift https://github.com/dlthomas/snowdrift
- joelthelion 12y agoThey also said they were looking for some help with the coding, so if anyone is interested it could be a nice project.
- yzzxy 12y agoLooks like a lot of the same ideas behind the Internet Archive, but focused on asset creation rather then preservation. I also like to see more people moving into the Patreon-style market - Patreon has probably figured out a lot of the pain points and will probably rightfully hold some permanent market share for being first, but I think the ability of nonprofit/coop projects to be more agile and respond better to user needs due to the general lack of ulterior motives will be valuable for this specific business model in the long run.
- quadrangle 12y agoPatreon wasn't actually first. Gratipay (formerly Gittip) was around well before Patreon and "be a sponsor" via an ongoing monthly or annual membership is a concept that has existed for centuries. Online, Paypal has offered ongoing donations for years. Patreon is just the most prominent and so far successful of several dedicated platforms for the idea of ongoing sponsorship. In the Snowdrift.coop review of hundreds of existing sites, they even list a handful of other subscription-style sites https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/othercrowdfunding#subscription https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/othercrowdfunding#su... (most with no real success, but many of which were around before Patreon).
- untilHellbanned 12y ago> I also like to see more people moving into the Patreon-style market Onarbor, https://onarbor.com https://onarbor.com, is one such site. Its precisely for funding "soft" goods: videos, music, research, as mentioned by the OP.
- mike-cardwell 12y agoAny chance you can add an RSS feed to your blog so I can follow the project?
- uaygsfdbzf 12y agoI'm not affiliated with snowdrift but their website source code is here: https://gitorious.org/snowdrift/snowdrift/ https://gitorious.org/snowdrift/snowdrift/
- icebraining 12y agoUntil it can be arranged, here's a version built with Yahoo! Pipes: http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.run?_id=ff5133ba1971595f95eda66d287c67ab&_render=rss http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.run?_id=ff5133ba1971595f95... Feel free to clone it and fix any issues, if you want.
- NicoJuicy 12y agoFor the ones wondering, you can clone / fix it here : http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.info?_id=ff5133ba1971595f95eda66d287c67ab http://pipes.yahoo.com/pipes/pipe.info?_id=ff5133ba1971595f9...
- icebraining 12y agoOh, right, thanks. I also want to say that I have no affiliation with Snowdrift, so the feed is in no way "official".
- mike-cardwell 12y agoNice. Thanks.
- quadrangle 12y agohttps://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/feed https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/feed can be fed into an RSS reader, but it's not the blog specifically, it's a busier list of all sorts of activity, including links to blog posts.
- giantLinux 12y agoGratipay (formerly gittip) does something like this, except without the complications: patrons choose to give a weekly recurring amount of money to... well, anyone with a twitter or github account.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- niche 12y agoHere's an idea: PTE (Publicly Transparent Entities); every transaction is posted (down to the bits) and known to the public; no convolution; nothing to hide
- kentf 12y agoLove this! Great job on the launch!
- spacecowboy_lon 12y agoSo you on a .coop and your not sure that you actualy a coop? Open, voluntary membership. Democratic governance. Limited return on equity. Surplus belongs to members. Education of members and public in cooperative principles. Cooperation between cooperatives.
- jameshart 12y agoLooks like they have that covered here - https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/co-op https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/co-op - what's your concern?
- quadrangle 12y ago.coop is a sponsored TLD. It's not possible to have a .coop without being recognized as legitimate by http://nic.coop http://nic.coop Anyway, for Snowdrift.coop, it's planned as non-profit so there is no equity or return on equity. All revenue must serve the non-profit mission. The rest of what you mention is affirmed in the Bylaws (which are still only a draft, pending legal review): https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/bylaws https://snowdrift.coop/p/snowdrift/w/en/bylaws
- jerf 12y agoAnd just to minimize friction, the crowdfunding campaign itself: https://snowdrift.tilt.com/launch-snowdrift-coop https://snowdrift.tilt.com/launch-snowdrift-coop I gave a while ago. For me, it isn't that I necessarily 100% believe this is guaranteed to work, it is that it is good enough to be worth a try. My long-term hope is that this takes off enough and attains enough credibility that I can go to my employers and say with a straight face that we ought to be participating to a significant degree, but with life and the world working as it does, the project is first going to have to bootstrap the credibility to do that before I can even bring it up, let alone get it approved.
- listic 12y agoThey are still pledging fake money, I presume? I wonder when they will finally launch for reals.
- dllthomas 12y agoStill fake money, yes. We'd like to launch ASAP, of course. Early 2015 seems realistic.
- KajMagnus 12y agoI liked the overall idea, and I like that they're trying to fund the project via their own platform, and that they are a non-profit (right?). So I had a look at their site — and apparently they're building their own forum, wiki, blog, and issue tracking software. This seems like things that can take a tremendous amount of time, and derail them from their main mission. And I'd guess the results would be average at best in comparison to what is produced by other teams that dedicate all their time on one thing, e.g. Discourse for new forum software. Their model that calculates how much money that is paid out to each project feels like the opposite to what I would prefer. One would get paid something proportional to the number of supporters ^ 2. But if I wanted to donate money to something, then, if few other people donated, I would want to donate more, so that the project got a reasonable amount of funding. And if many people donated, I'd want to automatically donate less (not more), because I don't want the project to get more money than what it actually needs. With Snowdrift's current model, I'm afraid a few projects will get a lot more money than what they actually need, and won't be able to use that money efficiently. Whereas most projects will get like $0.1 a month. I'd love to see that their ideas work out well despite the things above :-) Best wishes to you the Snowdrift team.
- quadrangle 12y agoNo projects should take more than they need because the requirement is that funds go to ongoing development. Thus, a project can specify when they are adequately funded and not take extra. Projects that don't show good use of funds over time won't keep getting people funding them. Anyway, if the system actually gets to where projects are adequately funded, it will already mean the system is a success. Yes, there's a natural intuition that you should pay less if others join you, but that only makes any sense after a project already has adequate funding. Anyway, the intuition is a failure in reality. Why should I add my donation if it just means others will donate less? The question to think about is: "what will most encourage others to donate who aren't donating now?" And the answer is definitely in matching as a big factor. Anyway, the whole snowdrift dilemma is about the fact that you would indeed like to donate as little as you can and have everyone else donate as much as they can. The point of Snowdrift.coop is to acknowledge how that thinking is destined to be a failure for the project, so we have to make people adjust their thinking. The mission-creep concern is totally valid, but there's pros and cons as well to having a more integrated system. I happen to agree with you that wheel-reinvention is a big problem in general. And Discourse is indeed pretty nice for what it is, and no way would it be easy for someone else to quickly whip up something comparable.