3 ms·
Whether or not the surge kicked in automatically and the tweet was made merely as an announcement, or the surge was instigated manually...It's surprising that U
by danso 12y ago
Whether or not the surge kicked in automatically and the tweet was made merely as an announcement, or the surge was instigated manually...It's surprising that Uber doesn't take advantage of these situations for PR purposes. Would it kill their bottom-line to overpay their drivers for several hours in extreme situations?
I guess the problem is that anytime an "extreme" situation happens (which could be any kind of accident or dangerous weather), Uber would then be expected to absorb the costs.
That said, maybe Uber shouldn't say anything during emergencies? I mean, what's the usecase here? People in the area are panicking for their lives...their first thought is to check Twitter, then check @Uber_Sydney to see if Uber has anything interesting to say about the terrorist hostage situation? Uber should've made no statement on this, and everyone would've more or less accepted the auto-surge situation. Instead, they not only inserted themselves into a citywide emergency for PR purposes, but then they did something that will never, ever be popular. Would really love to hear the PR strategy that inspired that original tweet by @Uber_Sydney
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- rjayatilleka 12y agoThat snippet would make sense if it was automated. But the front half of Uber's tweet was directly about the situation -meaning they acknowledged terrorists were in the area and then jacked up prices. That's terrible PR. Much better to say the price surge was automatic, and only have no tweet or an automated tweet
- mikeash 12y agoUber seems to be convinced that surge pricing is a good idea. In a purely rational world, I agree with them. Higher prices means more drivers means more capacity when it's needed. But humans aren't rational, and what sounds good in a dispassionate analysis looks like profiteering in the heat of the moment. They don't seem to really grasp this. It's almost as if the company as a whole suffers from something like autism.
- wutbrodo 12y agoI think you're conflating "is a good idea" with "has people react as if it's a good idea". You're absolutely right that people respond irrationally, but it doesn't take "something like autism" to believe that surge pricing is good for users. I do agree that they don't seem to deal with this irrationality well. The way they handle PR quite evidently needs work.
- mikeash 12y agoI don't mean the surge pricing itself, but how they do it and keep presenting it like everybody should be overjoyed about it is really weird. Stuff like advertising surge pricing during a hostage crisis is what I meant to refer to by "something like autism". So I think you're right, it's not so much about "is a good idea" as thinking everyone else must necessarily agree, at least once they have the facts in hand.
- meepmorp 12y ago> I mean, what's the usecase here? People in the area are panicking for their lives...their first thought is to check Twitter, then check @Uber_Sydney to see if Uber has anything interesting to say about the terrorist hostage situation This is the best point I've seen here. Why say anything? They've made the point of surge pricing known in the past, so there's zero reason to call out its existence as people are trying to get away from a police standoff. Maybe after the fact they could've made this exact statement and not come off as giant douchebags, but saying this as the situation is ongoing is astoundingly tone deaf. Surge pricing strikes a lot of people as unfair, and the more extreme the circumstances, the less fair people are apt to think it is. Somehow, nobody at Uber understands this or that they need to shut the fuck up about it at especially sensitive times. Edit: missing word
- agwa 12y agoInstead of taking a loss to compensate drivers, perhaps they should just waive their 20% cut during emergencies, so 100% of the fare went to drivers. They could sell the surge pricing as hazard pay for drivers without opening themselves to the criticism of profiteering off an emergency. Another reason to like surge pricing is that, in addition to increasing the supply of drivers, it reduces demand by incentivizing riders to conserve: people are more likely to split a ride with strangers when surge pricing is in effect. That's a desirable property when there's an emergency and your goal is to get people out of an area as efficiently as possible.
- jessriedel 12y agoI agree. There's always going to be a fraction of the population that has a silly reaction to the very sensible notion of surge pricing, but Uber can avoid a lot of the bad PR at very little cost by simply forgoing their cut during any sort of public emergency. Such emergencies are extremely rare, so this is cheap, and most bad PR is deflected soon as they say "we don't make money during emergencies, it all goes to the drivers to get them on the road".