2 ms·
The writer is no James Joyce.
by jgrahamc 12y ago
The writer is no James Joyce.
- ajkjk 12y agoHis point entirely stands despite your carelessly dismissing one part of it.
- Dylan16807 12y agoStyle is not the same as making a mistake.
- thizzbuzz 12y agoAnd who should be the arbitrator of style vs. mistake?
- Dylan16807 12y agoIt's easy enough to ask the person that wrote it. Why, do you think answering that is typically difficult or unclear? And to be clear I mean asking about specific instances, so don't point back at the blog post, which seems to be a case of Amazon making a mistake. All of the hyphens quoted from Moonstruck are grammatically correct.
- thizzbuzz 12y agoTrue, if the process just involves asking the author then I have no issues with that, and it should be easy to resolve. I do think it is difficult for anyone other than the author to answer that question though. For me, only the "red-head scarf" example would be a mistake, but others in this thread indicated that 3 or 4 of the examples were wrong for them.
- zapf 12y agoAbsolutely agree. It is called 'artistic freedom' after all. Right?
- sebular 12y agoThat's a really poor response. When Joyce published his first novel as a nobody, people like you would've said something equally thoughtless about his grammar, followed up by a glib "the writer is no Arthur Conan Doyle."
- MilnerRoute 12y agoJames Joyce followed proper English when he published his first novel as a nobody. (And his second novel, and third.) He was also a professor of English at the time, so he wasn't really "a nobody" even then. So he may not be the best test case.