3 ms·
Ah, The problem is that nothing I've seen about Wave indicates that it really addresses the real challenges that email has raised. Challenge: email invites t
by joe_the_user 17y ago
Ah,
The problem is that nothing I've seen about Wave indicates that it really addresses the real challenges that email has raised.
Challenge: email invites the user to put in too much text and factual information into their communication knowing too little of psychological/social context that the receiver will get.
Talking face-to-face lets a person judge what to say and not say based on the state of the other person. The phone is poorer than this but still works better than Internet chat. The old personal letter worked better than email only because it forced the person to spend time thinking about the context of their communication.
Wave gives a "context" but there's little indication that this context gives a solid, social foundation for saying and not saying. Instead, it sounds like chat and worse than chat - the context each communicator is made aware of is the previous text rather than the feelings of each person. And so, like forum threads, the pressure will always be there to get the last word.
- pohl 17y agoIs that the only real challenge, raised by email, that comes to mind? I can think of another one right away: the protocol allows people to send me messages as if they have come from someone else. Another one: people can send me emails that I cannot reply to. ("Thank you, kind sir, for offering me some Tadalafil, but you can exclude me on any future offers.") By my reckoning, Wave addresses both of those challenges pretty well. I've noticed that not even talking face-to-face will guarantee that a given participant will judge what to say or not to say. I've known several people over the course of my life who seemed to be born with a missing mechanism that allowed them to sense, from nonverbal cues, when it's time to terminate an interaction.
- joe_the_user 17y agoThose are more logistical challenges to email and could be changed with technical means. What I mentioned earlier is more social and inherent to email - and moreover, Wave actually would make these problems worse.