3 ms·
Honest question: Can someone explain why a Mach 5 air-breathing engine is important for reaching low-Earth orbit (~Mach 25)? I still don't understand after wat
by jessriedel 12y ago
Honest question: Can someone explain why a Mach 5 air-breathing engine is important for reaching low-Earth orbit (~Mach 25)? I still don't understand after watching the video.
I recall from a video interview that Elon Musk is skeptical of the utility of air-breathing engines for economic access to LEO since, as he put it, the atmosphere is "thick as soup" and you basically want to get out of it ASAP before you get up to orbital velocity. Breathing air up to Mach 5 allows you to save some weight, but you have to bring enough liquid O2 for the rest of your acceleration from Mach 5 to Mach 25. So is the idea that this modest savings in weight is all that's needed for a single-stage to orbit?
- pwnna 12y agoSome background: This company's engine is based on its previous design, the SABRE engine. That engine is designed to reach an altitude at 28km, flying at Mach 5 (which works out to be about 1.5km/s at that altitude, ~15% of orbital velocity at LEO). After that the engine is designed to switch to a rocket mode, where it burns fuel and oxygen it brought, rather than taking it from the atmosphere. Since the an air breathing engine is much more efficient (10x) than a traditional rocket engine, it allows the launch vehicle to conserve mass that would otherwise be used to overcome the high drag encountered in lower altitudes. You can roughly think of this as a rocket with all of its mass being launched at 28km, with a velocity of Mach 5 already. "Getting out of the atmosphere" is a pretty vague statement. Atmospheric pressure and density is about 1-2% that of the ground. So drag at these altitudes will be less. However, some quick and dirty calculations by me makes this seem like a relatively small number compared to the amount of energy it takes to actually get to orbit. Quick search indicates the same as well[1]. However, a "thick" atmosphere is something that has to be dealt with. For example, rockets also need to overcome pressures that exists at lower altitudes. If you take a look at any rocket launch videos, you will notice that the exhaust at higher altitudes (typically about 2-3 minutes after launch) will expand outwards with respect to the rocket itself. This means that the flow out of the rocket engine is "underexpanded", making the engine less efficient than it would be otherwise. By starting your rocket engine at a higher altitude, you can improve the efficiencies by designing your rockets to lower atmospheric pressures (I don't know if this is done for the SABRE engine, but this is theoretically possible). So based on these, the main motivation for this is probably for the mass savings and efficiency. Additionally, this engine presents itself with potentials for complete reusability, which is very attractive as most current launch cost is from the unrecoverable launch vehicle itself. [1]: forum.nasaspaceflight.com/index.php?topic=9959.msg189860#msg189860
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- iwwr 12y ago>So based on these, the main motivation for this is probably for the mass savings and efficiency. They plan to invest all those savings into a single-stage-to-orbit launcher. It's appealing in a similar manner that SpaceX's stage-return strategy, but in a one-spacecraft package. High-mach aircraft will find other uses too besides orbital launchers. As for saving a 'mere' 15% at launch that can be crucial from a payload perspective in the rocket equation.
- m_mueller 12y agoStarting the rocket at 15% velocity is not the same as saving 15% of the energy though. * you have slightly reduced gravity field * you have a big win in reduced drag energy loss * these wins have an exponential effect on your fuel requirements at sea level, since less weight in additional fuel again means less fuel to transport that fuel up there etc. * On the other hand, energy is proportionate to velocity squared, so that gives you less than 15% savings if you assume no atmosphere. Looking at the wiki[1] these SABRE engines (according to manufacturer specs) will have a 7-8 times higher fuel efficiency than typical rocket engines while in atmosphere (3500 seconds vs. 450 seconds specific impulse). Since this has been peer reviewed by ESA, I'm trusting these numbers. The ascend profile of these machines will look quite a bit different than rockets, so it's hard to compare the efficiencies, but the 'rocket starting at mach 5 horicontal velocity and out of atmosphere' comparison seems to be a good intuition to me, although we still have to reduce it by the amount of fuel that has been used in order to get to that point (which will not be insignificant, even though it's 7.7 lower). We also shouldn't forget that the hybrid system has a thrust-to-weight ratio of 14 compared to 150 of SpaceX' merlin engine, which means that it will take longer for such a system to reach the same speeds, reducing its efficiency gains. The reduced weight of the whole orbiter will make up some of that though, so unless we get more publicised informations on the whole ascend path along with simulated data it's hard to tell. All I know is: When using the simplified versions in KSP these hybrid engines make a lot of sense, i.e. it's the easiest way of getting an SSTO there ;-). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SABRE_(rocket_engine)
- vilhelm_s 12y agoYou can make a SSTO even without airbreathing, this is how the VentureStar would have worked. I think there are two benefits. One is that the oxygen takes up most of the fuel mass (e.g. the first stage of a Delta IV carries 173 tons of oxygen and 30 tons of hydrogen), so getting some from the atmosphere is a big weight saving. The other is that even if the air-breathing part on works in lowest part of the atmosphere, the denser parts of the atmosphere costs a lot of fuel because the rocket has to go slow and incurs more gravity drag. For the Falcon 9, first-stage separation occurs at Mach 6, roughly the same speed that the Skylon would switch from air-breathing to liquid oxygen. But in fact, the first stage is the biggest part of the rocket.
- vlasev 12y agoLet's see. The sabre engine has a closed cycle specific impulse of 450, which gives an effective exhaust velocity of 4.4 km/s. LEO requires about 7.8 km/s velocity while mach 5 is 1.7 km/s. In one case you accelerate from 0 to 7.8 km/s an in the other from 1.7 to 7.8 (for 6.1 km/s delta-v). The first figure gives a mass ratio of 5.9 while the second one gives you ratio of 4.0. You save about 1/3 of the initial mass if you only have to burn on a closed cycle from Mach 5 upwards. In reality gravity is a tough mistress so actual rockets launching from a pad require about 9.0 km/s delta-v because they lose a substantial amount due to the gravity losses of climbing up from Earth's gravity well. This is especially true for the first few km's of altitude where the thrust-to-mass ratio is quite low. Potentially, the skylon will eliminate most of those gravity losses by effectively launching from 26km altutude at mach 5 (i'm ignoring the relatively modest fuel consumption for reaching this state - the specific impulse is about 3500). Assuming a delta-v of 9.0 km/s needed for a single stage rocket gives a mass ratio of 7.7. This means that the skylon should save about 48% of the initial mass required by a SSTO rocket launching from sea level.
- sitkack 12y agoIsn't that mass savings mostly in the 330k$ of fuel for the first stage? The economic argument is in the reusable hardware.
- weterley 12y agoThe atmosphere is thick as soup, and that's why lift and flight are possible. Conventional rockets are way too heavy to fly (in the literal sense); they just bring tons of fuel and ditch the containers in stages. SSTO instead brings little enough fuel (weight) that it can fly itself through the soupy part, which is much more efficient (by like an order of magnitude), on top of not requiring oxidizer for that phase. The longer you can stretch out the aerodynamic phase (i.e. the faster and higher you engines breathe), the less oxidizer you need to bring. If you crunch the numbers (which apparently they did), you get that the equations work out to needing an engine that will stretch the aerodynamic phase up to mach 5. If your plane can't do that, getting to orbital velocity requires you to bring too much fuel for your plane to fly in the first place, and you might as well build a conventional rocket.
- grondilu 12y agoThe short answer is that Mach 5 may be only a fifth of Mach 25, but since the rocket equation is logarithmic, this speed gain actually matters a lot. Just enough to go to orbit in a single stage, anyway. According to ReactionEngines calculus, that is.