9 ms·
My Adventures with “4K” 2160p and Linux
- patcheudor 12y agoHats off for trying this in Linux. I gave up on that path a long time ago and am running nine monitors with a Windows 8.1 base OS, utilizing DisplayLink USB docs in combination with the DVI out on my main doc to drive the 2560x1600 30" display (the yellow one) with all others running at 1920x1200 from DisplayLink. I then run Linux in a VM, all from a laptop whith 32GB of ram and three built in SSD's giving me a bit more than 2TB of storage. Interestingly there appears to be an eight monitor limit total when using DisplayLink for the OS so the ninth monitor is driven from its own DisplayLink doc which I've directly hardware associated with a VM. Of course because the host OS doesn't know about that monitor I also need a second mouse so I can access it. Here's the latest photo of my setup: http://defaultstore.com/mydesk.jpg http://defaultstore.com/mydesk.jpg
- bithush 12y agoWow. That is a pretty crazy setup. I would worry about neck problems with the position of the top row. How long have you worked with this setup? Also what make/model/spec is the laptop you run it all from?
- patcheudor 12y agoIt's taken a few years to build up to this. To mitigate neck pain I: 1) Have set my chair so that it rocks as far back as possible with little force. 2) Sit directly across from the gym and try to visit it twice a day for at least two 15 minute HIIT cardio / body weight workout. I do lots of pull-ups, archers, and have been working up to the iron cross. 3) Only use the upper deck monitors for security reviews where I need "eyes on" resulting actions. I don't use them on a daily basis.
- hansjorg 12y agoI guess just using multiple workspaces doesn't work for you?
- atrus 12y agoNot when you're trying to monitor a lot of data. Even on my dual monitor setup, One monitor has 4 terminal windows for informational purposes. It would take longer to move to another workspace than to just simply take a quick glance to the left.
- patcheudor 12y agoExactly! Over the years more than a few people have called me crazy for having a setup like this because at the end of the day they try to picture themselves using this sort of solution. The fact is, if you aren't trying to keep track of a large number of things as near real time as you can, nine monitors is absolutely absurd. In the past you'd only find this type of setup on a stock brokers desk; however, when you consider what's required from even a moderately scoped pen-test, going to this point makes a lot of sense from a time perspective. I've greatly reduced the amount of duplicate work because I can see the entire result of an action in real time while sparing myself from switching between tasks to work on code & exploits.
- dustin999 12y agoHonest question, do you feel a little ridiculous with that setup? I'm a coder and have 2x24" monitors, and found that to be borderline ridiculous with neck strain, thus the reason I'm going 27". But unless you're running security at a place of business or something with 50 security cams, I can't imagine what you're doing that requires a wall of monitors?
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- patcheudor 12y agoOur philosophy in the office is that alt-tab is for suckers. While my setup is the most over the top we have three other people with five monitors or more. We are all security researchers and find the configuration saves a bunch of time in reviews. As an example, I can associate a MitM proxy like the Burpsuite or Fiddler 2 with the server side application which might communicate to web clients as well as to additional web services behind the scenes. That takes up one monitor, typically the one at the far top left. Under that monitor I can then associate another MitM proxy with the client. I can then run the client from my laptop display. If I'm working on a fat client, on the 30" I'll then run Wireshark which will effectively be watching the client. On another monitor I can run sysinternal tools. What remains I use for writing code necessary for the review, running additional tools like Metasploit, e-mail, chat, and research. I arrange my workspace for the task at hand. On a daily basis do I use all nine? No. Interestingly enough, with this sort of setup it's pretty easy to visually see what's happening when going after an application. Before going to the monitor extreme I'd constantly alt-tab between my monitoring & exploit tools with every action. Now I can run an action and see the results within one workspace. Of course there is a massive downside. It makes competing in CTFs a pain in the butt as I can't drag that setup with me to physical events.
- jmgrosen 12y agoA bit off-topic, but what CTF team do you play on?
- 12y ago
- aschampion 12y agoNo need for a second mouse: http://synergy-project.org/ http://synergy-project.org/
- bane 12y agoSynergy is amazing. It's hard to explain to people, but as soon as they get somebody to set it up you can watch their faces the first time they move their mouse over to another machine and they go "oh"..."ooOOOHHH" and the light clicks on. They've recently moved to a paid model, but some older free versions are still around. I don't know why it's not better known.
- nbolton 12y agoStory of my life! That's why I commissioned the video. What do you think? Some think the music is a bit babyish... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJlUiQZ84Uw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vJlUiQZ84Uw
- Todd 12y agoI think the video looks great. It conveys the purpose very clearly for those who don't even know that they need something like that. Although it's not my cup of tea, I think the music is very current in this context. Nice work!
- bane 12y agoVideo is great! Still it's weird, I can even show somebody a setup with Synergy running, and until the moment they move their own mouse cursor over that hard boundary at the end of their monitor, it never seems to click...and weirdly people are kind of resistant to it. I almost think the next Tron movie needs a character named Synergy that bashes down arbitrary walls between systems to really get the idea out there ;)
- rcarmo 12y agoAlso Teleport for Mac: http://www.abyssoft.com/software/teleport/ http://www.abyssoft.com/software/teleport/ (requires a little tweaking to work with Yosemite)
- mvlad 12y agoNo. aaand No. That is the most stupid thing I've ever seen. You will (presumably in the next version of Windows) be able to use workspaces. I have 11 workspaces and I can switch to a workspace MUCH faster than you can tilt your head. I've never understood why people need more than 1 monitor. I've used two monitors and felt overly confused. It is utterly pointless and expensive to have an entire monitor dedicated to an application. By your "setup" I should have at least 20 monitors. Go figure.
- jacquesm 12y agoDon't berate someone's tools before you've looked at their application of those tools.
- ketralnis 12y agoI'd go further and say don't berate someone's tools full stop. They're not making you use it. They're not making you pay for it. Why do you care at all? What does it have to do with you? Why do you think they want your opinion at all?
- Chronic29 12y agoBy that logic, we should look not criticize what others are doing, even if it is unethical or dangerous. Oh, that man is using a knife to kill himself? Well it's his tool after all...
- bane 12y agoAmazingly, some people don't get confused when confronted with two different things going on in two different places.
- leoc 12y agoAlt-tabbery and workspace swapping are more likely to generate mental confusion and delay than having things simultaneously visible side by side, surely.
- deeviant 12y ago
- utku_karatas2 12y agoAaaand this is why I switched to first a tiling WM, and then to OSX for its intuitive 4 finger swipe workspaces. Till that switch I was a multi monitor junkie, but after 3 monitors it starts getting bad for your neck, bad for your eyes (with all those monitor backlights burning your retinas) and you also need humongous desk setups. Nowadays it's just one big monitor and 4 finger swipes.
- stinos 12y agoI work both on triple monitor and single monitor+workspace setups and still prefer the triple monitor for a single reason: you cannot put workspaces next to each other and get an overview of multiple windows at the same time.. Just saying it might work for you, but it's by no means a proper replacement for all of us
- DeanCollinsNY 12y agothat's what I was thinking, I often throw a frame onto the left or right monitor.....having a single monitor would mean I'm adjusting positions all the time?
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> you cannot put workspaces next to each other and get an overview of multiple windows at the same time While I personally prefer a single-monitor no-workspace setup, there do exist several window managers that let you independently choose workspaces for different monitors rather than having each workspace specify a layout for all monitors. For instance, the window manager "awesome" uses tags (primarily 1-9) for windows, and lets you say "this monitor should display 1, and this one should show 2-3".
- worklogin 12y agoTruly, if this works for you, then all the best. But we have lots of people at my organization programming, analyzing big data, and troubleshooting operations, and never have I ever heard or seen anyone wish for more than four monitors (two is the standard). I feel the physical issues, the problems with space (if everyone wanted that) and the capital investment all point to the use of workspaces. This setup makes me think of this, which has been a joke in our circle for some time. http://www.criticalcommons.org/Members/ccManager/clips/swordfishtechno3dhackingdrama.mp4/thumbnailImage http://www.criticalcommons.org/Members/ccManager/clips/sword...
- bryanlarsen 12y agoIf you're looking for a ~40" QHD monitor, you no longer have to buy a TV with its attendant compromises. Check out the Philips BDM4065UC.
- pmoriarty 12y agoHow well is it supported on Linux?
- jacquesm 12y agoHDMI 1.4 should drive it at 30 Hz.
- pmoriarty 12y agoI think I'll wait, then. I need a minimum of 60 Hz for it to be bearable.
- jacquesm 12y agoThat works with that monitor but only using display port. It's more of a cabling thing than a linux thing. It also seems to support multiple interface signals side-by-side or above each other (see documentation): http://download.p4c.philips.com/files/b/bdm4065uc_61/bdm4065uc_61_dfu_eng.pdf http://download.p4c.philips.com/files/b/bdm4065uc_61/bdm4065... That might be an alternative road to getting 60 Hz at full res.
- bryanlarsen 12y agoThat's a video card question, not a monitor question. That being said, this monitor supports 60Hz operation in SST with DisplayPort 1.2 so it should work cleaner than those first generation monitors that have to pretend that a QHD monitor is two monitors to work at 60Hz.
- ck2 12y agoThat's a $1200 monitor ! Has to be something between a $300 sekei @ 30hz and $1200
- dustin999 12y ago"The myth I keep hearing is that you must go to larger fonts when scaling up to a 4K monitor. This is not exactly true. Do the math. If you double the screen resolution and at the same time you double the screen width, you have done absolutely nothing to the size of a pixel or the physical size of your fonts." Yeah but it's a 39" monitor... On your desk! Seriously, I'm all for the largest monitor and resolution and everything else, but there's a point where I'd argue it's just too much. I think a 39" monitor on your desk is crossing that line. I can't imagine the neck strain that's going to occur. Instead of selling extended warranties, they need to start selling these with chiropractic insurance. Full disclosure: I just went through several days of research on 1440p vs 4k. I went into it assuming I'd get a 4k monitor, but in the end, opted for the 1440p monitor because I refused to stick a 39" monitor on my desk, and the 28" 4k would require DPI scaling and all that mess. I'd get a 4k for gaming, assuming I had a rig that could power games at that resolution. Otherwise, I'm happy with my decision to get the Asus PB278Q 1440p monitor.
- notjackma 12y ago> I can't imagine the neck strain that's going to occur. I was wondering about this too and the impact on your eyes. For a 39" monitor it's recommended you sit over 5ft away, so the optimal desk environment for such a large monitor will be interesting. http://www.rtings.com/info/television-size-to-distance-relationship http://www.rtings.com/info/television-size-to-distance-relat...
- VLM 12y agoLess, not more. Too close and the pixels are going to be "big" and too far away and the pixels are going to be invisible. For example, at 15 feet away the high res would be a waste of money for that screen size, you can't see better than 480 lines at that range. Extending my arm, I seem to be around 2.5 feet from this screen. Doing the math, higher that 4K at 40 inch screen would be visibly noticeable although its kind of borderline, so 4K should be good enough.
- woodchuck64 12y agoMaybe a large monitor should be like a large desk. You only work on what's in front of you but with a glance around you quickly see everything that needs your attention. With a small monitor or small desk, things get stacked and buried, hidden in drawers/folders etc.
- eeZi 12y agoThe real fun starts with high DPI/high resolution displays when you actually have to scale up your desktop environment. (which works reasonably well nowadays - at least with Gnome!)
- kenrikm 12y agoI ran the Seiki 4K as a monitor for about a year. Overall the quality is fine however the 30hz and mouse lag make it less then optimal for anything other then static content. Even scrolling a page is not easy on the eyes.
- darshan 12y agoI've been running 3840x2160 on the 23.8" Dell UP2414Q for the past month, and I couldn't be more pleased. Well, I could if I had it running at 60 Hz rather than 30 Hz, but having twice the PPI is worth the cut in the frame rate to me without question. I'm using the open source Intel drivers and the on-die GPU of my i7-4770K, and everything works out of the box at 30 Hz. Patches to get things at 60 Hz are in the works, but it's pretty complicated because the software needs to treat the display as two separate 1920x2160 displays due to limitations in the DisplayPort spec. My desktop is where I spend the most time, yet it was the last remaining device I use where there were visible, ugly, distracting pixels everywhere. Now I never see pixels in my daily life, and reading and writing on my desktop have become significantly more pleasant. I highly recommend switching to a high-DPI monitor for anyone who spends much time on the computer (which is probably almost everyone here). Oh, most software works just fine once I manually set the DPI in KDE's system settings. Upgrading to Plasma 5, the only software I use that isn't scaled properly is Chrome. Apparently they're working on it, but I only use Chrome for Netflix, and it's not too bad having tiny browser tabs for that one use.
- jacquesm 12y ago> Now I never see pixels in my daily life Just wait for a bit and that problem will solve itself handily. And then you'll be wishing for the time when you could see pixels.
- expr- 12y agoHaving a poorer eyesight is not going to make fonts comprised of ten or so square pixels (in a direction) a bigger joy to read. Reading off a low DPI display is not only slower, but it also tires out your eyes faster.
- jacquesm 12y agoAh, but having a 30+" screen a few feet from your face and upping the font size in fact does help. It's all about the distance, not about the number of pixels or the font size. So the ideal (for me) is a large high res monitor sitting 3 or more feet away from me. The first hint you're on this path is when your arms start to be too short for reading books and when you are 100% sure that the gray squiggles on that chip used to have meaning.
- ck2 12y agoHow's that 30hz refresh rate working out for you. Noticed there was no mention of it. You want to flash the firmware from the 50" version to fix it a little bit but without hdmi 2.0, it is always going to suck.
- gwern 12y ago> Before starting this project I was wondering how happy I would be with 30Hz updates. Well, at this point I have to say that the display appears solid at that update rate with no noticeable flicker whatsoever. Maybe if I was using this setup to watch sports videos this might be an issue, but for me, I'm finding this 30 Hz update rate to be quite satisfactory for workstation duty.
- washadjeffmad 12y agoTo explain this comment, flashing the 39" model to the 50" FW enables true 1080_120 display mode, as opposed to the stock FW's frame doubling. 2160 is limited to 30Hz, but that's hardly an issue for anything but games, most of which are better played in other display modes anyway. Besides, it doesn't make sense that someone who cared enough about hires gaming to buy a GPU beefy enough to run games at >30fps in 4k wouldn't just buy an appropriate monitor as well.
- thyselius 12y agoIt's impossible to get used to the mouse pointer in 30hz. I tried hard for weeks but cant stand it.
- washadjeffmad 12y agoIf you still have the screen, the ATSC_THTF_SY14343_ST2975C_CMI_V500dk1_P01_20140707 FW improves the apparent responsiveness of movements at 2160. It's still 30Hz, but feels closer to 50. Includes other improvements as well.
- PSeitz 12y agoI have the same monitor, 4k is cool but the input lag makes it not so efficient to work with. At least I could't get used to.
- zaroth 12y agoI have a late-2010 Macbook Air with the nVidia 320M, which can handle 2560x1440 over the mini-DP. I have the Acer B326HUL which was $399 on Black Friday. Seemed like a good compromise since driving 4K would mean a new laptop. Compared to the 28" 1920x1200 monitor it replaced, I'm very pleased with the 32" 1440p.
- nightcracker 12y ago> The myth I keep hearing is that you must go to larger fonts when scaling up to a 4K monitor. This is not exactly true. Do the math. If you double the screen resolution and at the same time you double the screen width, you have done absolutely nothing to the size of a pixel or the physical size of your fonts. What the author seems to be missing here is that if you double your screen size you will likely put the screen at further viewing distance.
- ars 12y ago> if you double your screen size you will likely put the screen at further viewing distance So don't. Why would you anyway?
- Todd 12y agoHe makes a point that he uses tiny fonts and that they work for his eyes. The photo of the screen just behind the keyboard is further evidence. I'm guessing it's at the same distance as his previous setup.
- Someone 12y agoEven if you don't, pixels near the edge of a flat display will look smaller because they are further away from your eyes. For example, for a 20 inch diagonal monitor at 10 inches distance, the corner pixels have about 0.7 times the angular extent of those in the center of the screen, or about half the solid angle. Replace that by a 40" diagonal monitor at 10", and that factor drops to about 1:sqrt(5), or 1:5 in solid angle. So, I guess you will need larger fonts, _if_ you keep your eyes in the same position on your larger monitor. There probably are publications on this in studies on airplane ergonomics.
- undersuit 12y agoIf you're running a 2x2 monitor setup do you move it further away from your face? I don't move my 2x1 further away than i would a single monitor.
- shmerl 12y agoKDE will only fully support it in Plasma 5.0. As of now it's somewhat messy and requires lot's of manual tweaks besides changing the DPI. See https://community.kde.org/KDE/High-dpi_issues https://community.kde.org/KDE/High-dpi_issues However one should be careful when getting monitors with such huge resolution since they put more requirements on the GPU. For example if you want to play games in native, it will require dual GPU at least which is a very pricey overkill otherwise. Current video cards don't cope with such resolution well yet. That besides the fact that such monitors are very expensive on their own. Also, ergonomics wise, for me personally 24-27" is a sweep spot. Anything larger than that becomes uncomfortable to use unless you place it in some distance.
- RussianCow 12y ago> For example if you want to play games in native, it will require dual GPU at least which is a very pricey overkill otherwise. Current video cards don't cope with such resolution well yet. Can't you just set the games to a lower resolution? Wouldn't that lower the GPU load?
- shmerl 12y agoYou can, but for LCD monitors non native resolution usually degrades image quality. And basically it means that for that scenario you aren't using what you paid for. So it's something to consider when buying it.
- simoncion 12y agoThe Windows version of ATI's Catalyst driver has an option that permits you to use the GPU to scale less-than-native-resolution output to an attached LCD's native resolution. It makes video games a little bit fuzzy, but works better than the built-in LCD rescalers that I've seen.
- detrino 12y agoI don't know why this was downvoted, everything you say is true.
- 12y ago
- jrockway 12y agoSo all that and it's only refreshing at 30Hz? Here's my long post about the current state of the art: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8549629 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8549629
- siliconc0w 12y agoI looked into this setup but it gets pretty ridiculous if you want to do any gaming. You want 4k @ 60hz with 4:4:4 color sampling at a reasonable <40" but it soon begins to feel like you're hunting a rare animal. With only hints and whispers strewn throughout a dark abyss of forums threads and amazon reviews. The kind of places where people put AMD driver revisions in their signatures. I don't think we're quite there yet.
- marknutter 12y agoCan you get a 4k display and use it at its full resolution for everything but gaming, and then just switch to a lower resolution for gaming when you want the higher refresh rates?
- bryanlarsen 12y agoAccording to reports, it scales 2560x1440 beautifully. 1920x1080 obviously works well, since that's an integer multiple.
- lrizzo 12y agoI have tried 4K@30Hz using HDMI on five different TVs (not monitors): Seiki 39" US, Seiki 39" UK (US and UK modes are different), Hisense 42K680, Samsung UE40HU6900DX, LG 40UB800 (the latter three are in Italy and seem available across europe). In all cases the additional display lag wrt my retina MBpro screen (measured with the small HTML/JS at the end) was huge, in the 130-230ms range, i.e. 4-7 frames. As a comparison, even the low end 1080p TVs i tried (at 60Hz) only gave 0-16ms additional lag, i.e. one frame. The problem is not 30Hz vs 60Hz, but a video pipeline which is too deep, and cannot be shortened in any of the models i tried (even the models that have a "gaming" mode disable that control when running at 4k). Note that even at 30Hz one frame is only 33ms so anything more than 66ms indicates excessive pipeline depth. Based on my measurements, I think that at the moment the chipset that do 4k (upscaler etc.) are still buggy/immature in terms of features, and probably we need to wait the next generationof silicon to get 4K TVs that can be used as monitors. I have become used to the 130ms lag but it is not pleasant. Note that the Acer Chromebook C720 ($199) can drive the screen at 4K through the HDMI port. I had no problem with FreeBSD using high end nvidia cards (GT640 and GT750), whereas lower model seem unable to use pixel clocks above 165 MHz (you need about 290 MHz to run at 4k). <!DOCTYPE html><html><head><script> Object.prototype.d = function(l) { return (this + Math.pow(10,l)).toString().substring(1, l+1) } function g(x) { return document.getElementById(x); } function clock() { var t=new Date(); g('txt').innerHTML=t.getSeconds().d(2)+'.'+t.getMilliseconds().d(3); setTimeout(clock,1); } </script></head> <body onload="clock()"> Set PC to mirror screens, take a snapshot with a camera, compare times<br/> <div id="txt" style="font-size: 120px;"></div> </body></html>
- firloop 12y agodisplaylag.html:5 Uncaught SyntaxError: Unexpected token function displaylag.html:10 Uncaught ReferenceError: clock is not defined Wasn't able to run that page you put at the end of your comment on Chrome 39.0.2171.95. Am I missing something? Here's a codepen: http://codepen.io/pen/yyOxXQ http://codepen.io/pen/yyOxXQ
- sumnulu 12y agoFixed: http://codepen.io/anon/pen/GgZXYO http://codepen.io/anon/pen/GgZXYO
- dedward 12y agoI don't mean to be "that guy"... because this is, of course, about linux running 4k. But much of the discussion seems to be around what the point is, whether it's useful, and so on. As someone who's been using one of the new 5k iMacs since it came out (so that's 5120x2880 in a 26" display)... let me add a bit, hopefully without sounding like an apple fanboy. First - running it at actual 5k, rather than at 3200 or 2560 HiDPI, is crystal clear, amazingly sharp, but too small at this size. With a 40" display it would be perfect, I imagine. At full 5k, you can fit an amazing amount of stuff on a single screen, and it's handy for certain short troubleshooting sessions - but stuff can be so small it's straining. The stuff is still crisp though, if you can manage to focus on it. The detail is there. 12 point fonts are barely readable to my 40 year old eyes unless I get closer. 3k is just fine, and 2k is what you'd expect - but both are using HiDPI rendering and you get stunningly crisp fonts and detailed images and whatnot. I wouldn't trade it for anything, even if I don't run in 5k all day long.
- lrizzo 12y agoSpeaking of screen size, having used it i confirm that 39-40" is what i find the minimum acceptable size for 4K if you are not running in HiDPI mode. It corresponds to 1080p at 20" which (which to my 50y eyes is almost below the threshold of what i can see).
- miduil 12y agoI wonder if a bigger screen will make that difference for me. I've been using an 1920x1200 24" screen and that was nice, but for the past 12 months I've been fine with my 1366x768 12.4" laptop. Tough, I'm using a tiling window manager which makes a difference compared to others I guess. (:
- vostrocity 12y agoNo one has mentioned that the author of the piece likes to leave his monitors on 24/7. I often see many monitors in offices left on overnight running a screensaver. Is there a good reason for this, or simply ignorance?
- netforay 12y agoCan some one tell me why it has to be 30Hz vs 60Hz. Why it can not be 40Hz or 50Hz?