4 ms·
And it's not just disability benefits. When you stop and really analyze it; Medicaid and health insurance credits, SSI, food stamps, EITC, FICA, progressive inc
by zaroth 12y ago
And it's not just disability benefits. When you stop and really analyze it; Medicaid and health insurance credits, SSI, food stamps, EITC, FICA, progressive income tax rates, refundable tax credits, phased-out tax deductions, even things like housing and energy assistance, etc.
There's easily $60,000 of services, utilities, fees, and taxes that you pay when earning $100k, that you get for free or don't have to pay if you earn $0. As @fredophile says, then you still have to add in the direct/indirect costs of going out and earning that money (e.g. childcare for starters), and you can easily gain net-zero or negative benefit all the way up to $100k of household income.
I'm sure people must have researched this extensively, and can give a properly cited cost analysis, but it's something I've been calling the 'middle class crucible'. Until you break out on the other side of $150k household income, the vast majority of your earned income is effectively running on a treadmill. E.g. On the order of 80 cents of each dollar you earn.
Every progressive (means-tested) social support program or tax rate, by definition, is a penalty for working. These programs have grown so big, and phase-out so aggressively in the income curve, it's an incredible trap / attack against the middle class.
- jameshart 12y agoThat actually sounds like you might be able to back that up - would be interesting to see the actual stats. But I think you're missing a certain qualitative difference though - the services the 100K-income household is getting for their 60k are significantly better than the services the 0-income household is being given. Obviously they're probably spending money on better food than the food stamps would cover, they're likely living in better conditions in a better neighborhood, and their health insurance probably gives them more choices than they would have on medicaid.
- zaroth 12y agoThere's definitely a qualitative argument. Certainly that's what you see if you turn on any ad-supported media, and you're inundated with that "quality of life" everyone is selling to the middle-class. But for example, you can pay ~$1000/mo for a family of 4 for "Silver" health insurance and earning > $63k you would have to pay the full amount. Credits pay for almost the entire cost (aka $12,000 of tax-free income from the Fed) if your household income is $33k. So under just one program (ACA), $30k of incremental work disqualifies you from $12k of assistance. And that's for the same exact plan/service. Then you get below $33k household income and instead of paying thousands for a Silver plan with a $6,000 family deductible, you pay basically nothing and have no deductible for Medicaid / Medi-Cal. That's effectively a $24,000 / year value for a family of 4. [1] In both cases, you can argue about access to top-specialists for chronic care, but certainly access to acute care coverage is equivalent (i.e. hospitals can't base their ER services based on ability to pay). In many ways Medicaid is better because deductibles are a hell of a lot lower than $13,500 Bronze / $6,000 Silver. By the way, Whole Foods takes food stamps. So that's another example where you get straight up cash for not working. Up to $8,400 / year, cash on a debit card, which phases out as household income goes to ~$30k / year (plus allowed deductions) for a family of 4. [2] If you have a qualifying disability and have to make the choice of giving up work and going on DI, assuming you have the work history credits, it's another up to $31,000 / year of income (not entirely tax-free though). [3] That's over $60k right there, and there are many more programs to account. It would add up to well over $100k except you can't fully stack all of the programs, e.g. CA SDI payments count against SSDI payments. I was thinking about making a "how much do you lose by working" micro-site as an excuse to play with D3 and interactive visualization, targeted to residents of California, but the whole thing was too infuriating I haven't mustered the motivation to do it. [1] - http://www.coveredca.com/shopandcompare/#incomeGuidelines http://www.coveredca.com/shopandcompare/#incomeGuidelines [2] - http://www.stanworks.com/community-reports/other-services/content.php?nav=food-stamps/food-stamps-faq.htm http://www.stanworks.com/community-reports/other-services/co... [3] - http://www.disabilitysecrets.com/how-much-in-ssd.html http://www.disabilitysecrets.com/how-much-in-ssd.html
- chipotle_coyote 12y agoWhile this is interesting, I'm not sure what point we should really be taking away from it. That government assistance is so good it's a motivator not to work? It's easy to play with numbers and make it look like you're "losing money" by working, but it's somewhat disingenuous. For instance, in practice that "$30K of incremental work" is statistically very likely to involve a job with a company that provides health care for their employees and dependents. Furthermore, your description of the way food stamps work is correct but elides how that "phase out" works. Under current CalFresh guidelines[1], a household of 4 grossing $30K a year would get $98 a month. If they grossed $24K a year that would go up to $218 a month -- an extra $1440 a year, when you work it out, which is to say much less than what they'd net by just making another $6000 a year. [1]: http://foodstampguide.org/calculating-the-grant-how-much-do-you-get/ http://foodstampguide.org/calculating-the-grant-how-much-do-... In practice, I'd suggest that most of these calculations are going to work out in roughly the same way: yes, you're "losing out" on government assistance by making more money, but the benefits you accrue from actually making more money more than offset that.
- zaroth 12y agochipotle_coyote, you give the perfect example (actually it's close to the worst case part of the curve). A family of 4 making $24k/year, working their ass off to increase their income 25% to $30k/year. But at the end of the year, what happened? Gross Increase in Income: $6,000 - FICA: ($ 918) - Fed Income Tax: ($ 900) - State Income Tax: ($ 500) - Reduced Food Stamps: ($1,440) - Reduced EITC: ($1,260) [21% phase out after $23,260] - Reduced ACA: ($ ???) [Just about to lose Medi-Cal] That's just top of my head. There are other programs I'm definitely forgetting or don't know about. There's at least $5,000 of additional taxes you pay, and credits you lose, for earning that $6,000. If I had all the numbers, I'm sure said hypothetical family is worse off earning the extra $6,000. They literally now have less money to spend on food every week. Think about how broken this is. At the point in the curve where adding $6,000 in family income could actually be life-changing, the government claws back at least 83% of it?! Fucking A... (sorry, this really makes me mad). > "$30K of incremental work" is statistically very likely to involve a job with a company that provides health care I count benefits as part of income. So if part of the increased payroll expense is actually spent by the employer paying for a private health plan (with a high deductible and cost sharing with the employee) that's a huge net-loss for the family versus getting cash income from the employer and keeping their free health care from Medi-Cal. (It makes zero difference to the employer, ACA penalties aside, either way it's a fully deductible business expense) Edit: I see you gave two examples, $24k vs $30k, and lets say $30k vs $60k. If we do a detailed realistic budget accounting for all costs, credits, programs, etc. you will find "earning $60k" you actually have less money to spend than "earning $30k". You will be net-negative if you have any significant health care expenses at all. It's completely counter-intuitive, and in fact, borderline insane.
- Domenic_S 12y agoIn California, Medicaid + MediCal is substantially better than most private insurance, at least for elder care.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> In California, Medicaid + MediCal is substantially better than most private insurance Medi-Cal is the name of California's Medicaid program, so "Medicaid + Medi-Cal" is just counting the same program twice. Which, if you could actually benefit that way, would probably be fairly generous, but the state actually makes a significant effort to prevent that. Did you intend to say Medicare + Medi-Cal, perhaps?
- Domenic_S 12y agoIndeed I did. Thanks.
- maratd 12y ago> Obviously they're probably spending money on better food than the food stamps would cover The inverse is usually true. Good food doesn't cost much, it's the garbage food that's expensive. You can easily afford fresh fruits/vegies/meat with food stamps. > they're likely living in better conditions in a better neighborhood You can get public housing in Manhattan. Granted it's public housing, but hey, location location location. > and their health insurance probably gives them more choices than they would have on medicaid. This is state specific. For New Jersey, it is absolutely the best health insurance to have. You can't even buy the sort of stuff they will cover with almost zero out of pocket.
- pc2g4d 12y agoThis sounds crazy to me. Maybe you're living in a place with a really high cost of living? What's included in "services, utilities, fees, and taxes that you pay when earning $100k" ?
- zaroth 12y agoIt's completely bonkers when you lay it all out there. On $100k of family of 4 household income... it's a combination of actively paying taxes, and missing out on credits; Payroll taxes* = $ 15,300 Federal income taxes = $ 6,500 CA income taxes = $ 4,000 ACA Subsidy = $ 12,000 Food Stamps = $ 8,000 EITC = $ 5,000 Disability = up to $30,000 if applicable Energy credits = ??? Housing credits = ??? Waived fees = ??? Some of these are refundable credits or progressive credits which you lose by earning too much, so it's a direct cost of working. Every progressive subsidy is mathematically equivalent to a progressive tax. The $12,000 ACA "tax credit" is actually a $12,000 progressive tax. It's the single largest tax hike against the middle class... possibly ever? This doesn't even get into the property tax side of the equation, since we're talking direct cost of working, not cost of owning things like houses, and cars. But that's part of the overall conversation of the war on the middle class. [Edit] There are even property tax circuit breakers where you get credits on property tax for earning less, so that should be in the above table. That's separate from housing credits such as means-tested rent control. Then you can start to pay for the personal costs of actually going out and earning that income.... everything from child care, to transportation, to business clothes, etc. And then that's still not even counting opportunity costs, e.g. I'm too busy at work, now I have to pay for a plumber, contractor, mechanic, landscaper, take-out dinner, etc. versus doing it on my own time. Think, all the things you could do for yourself in 2,080 hours per year... * Don't be fooled by the employer hiding half the cost from you.
- danans 12y ago- The $15,300 in payroll tax is over and above your 100k. If you are going too call that a tax on you, then you need to call your income $115,300 for the purposes of the % calculation. - You can't subtract the opportunity cost of not working from your income when you make $115k, because you've made the decision to work and earn that salary. - The EITC is for people who work (hence the "earned" part). If you chose to go exclusively on govt assistance, your max EITC is $11 for a family of 4: http://www.irs.gov/uac/Newsroom/Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-Do-I-Qualify http://www.irs.gov/uac/Newsroom/Earned-Income-Tax-Credit-Do-... - I don't doubt that there is a measurable amount of disability insurance abuse, but the fact remains that you probably have a disability that prevents you from doing child care. The poor still often have to pay for childcare. In any case, the average annual benefit for a family of 4 comes to about $24k, not $30k: http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfacts/stat_snapshot/ http://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/quickfacts/stat_snapshot/ Subtracting the opportunity cost of not working from vs working at 115300k muddies the comparison. It's more sensible to compare the two scenarios separately: 115300-15300(payroll tax)-6500(fed tax)-4000(CA tax)-8000(foodstamp equivalent food cost)-2600(typical employee cost for PPO-health program)= 78900 vs. 12000(ACA)+8000(food stamps)+11(per EITC comment above)+24000(per disability citation above) = 44011 Even this comparison isn't apples to apples. In the $100k figure, are you accounting for the employer paid portion of health-insurance (and the lower rates that those in a employer-negotiated plan pay?), any tax-free employer retirement plan contributions, and other pre-tax benefits (DCAP, flex-spending account, employee health insurance contributions?). If you own a home, are you accounting for the mortgage interest and property tax deduction? I do agree with one sliver of your argument: making financial progress on $100k income is challenging for a family of 4 in VERY high cost-of-living places such as the Bay Area, where that remaining 79k easily gets eaten up by childcare, housing, food, transportation, etc. Is the standard of living on the $115k salary equivalent to that of a family of 4 on govt assistance? I don't know, but I doubt it, and I would bet on the latter's standard of living being significantly worse. Neither situation is easy street. EDIT: wording. EDIT2: formatting
- camgunz 12y agoI'd also really like to see some numbers, because I don't believe that 60% of a $100k/yr. income is lost to "services, utilities, fees, and taxes that you pay when earning $100k, that you get for free or don't have to pay if you earn $0". Is your list "Medicaid and health insurance credits, SSI, food stamps, EITC, FICA..." things that you have to pay, or benefits you get if your income is $0/yr.? For example, you wouldn't get EITC if you had no income, but you wouldn't get food stamps if you had $100k/yr. I would argue that it's poor framing to compare a hypothetical family with $0/yr. income to one with $100k/yr. income. You bring up childcare as an example, but when you look at a family making, say, $35k/yr., they're largely unqualified for assistance but childcare is almost certainly out of reach for them. $100k/yr. families are paying for childcare, paying tons of taxes, and buying amazing Christmas gifts. Because only 20% of Americans even make >= $100k/yr., I don't think you can rightly call them middle class. I'm not sure we should really be concerned for those at that income level, I think it's more imperative to start looking at people working full time but still making < $35k/yr. Is there an upper-middle class treadmill? Yeah sure, I'm not even sure what your argument is, that you're not getting rich? Regardless, a treadmill is much better than the alternatives. You imply that until you make $150k/yr., you may as well make $0/yr. This is really just untrue; probably (depending on number of children) it's untrue until you get down around $20k/yr., which is where you start getting into living wage argument territory. Finally, I'm with you on progressive taxation. Tax tiers make no sense; we need a (simple) tax function. Problem solved.
- zaroth 12y agoSee below for a table. Also, please note, $100k household income != $100k individual income. Although if one parent works and the other stays home to take care of the kids... > Is your list "Medicaid and health insurance credits, SSI, food stamps, EITC, FICA..." things that you have to pay, or benefits you get if your income is $0/yr.? For example, you wouldn't get EITC if you had no income, but you wouldn't get food stamps if you had $100k/yr. I edited in; they don't all fully stack or else it would hit well over $100k. So it's a very complicated calculation (why we need a nice D3 app to show how everything interacts!). For EITC, I think it's fair to count the full $5k which you could get by working just a little, against the cost of working 'too much'. I have not done the math necessary to find the global maxima of public support. Frankly, I'm not sure it's a great idea to make that calculation too easy for everyone to figure out, lest we all start optimizing for it!! Conversely, there are many points in the curve where you are below Net-$0. $63k household income for a family of 4 is probably the global-minima, where you're way below Net-$0. The cost of working is much worse if, for example, you have a qualifying disability but are not vegetative and know how to code. You then have to choose, just stop working and get $30k, or don't go quietly into the night and forgo the entire $30k of SSDI.
- pastProlog 12y ago> the 'middle class crucible'. Until you break out on the other side of $150k household income, the vast majority of your earned income is effectively running on a treadmill. > it's an incredible trap / attack against the middle class. If your household is not making $150k you're not middle class though. You're working class. Middle class people don't have to run on a treadmill like that (unless they want to). For about 25 years after World War II, an anomaly occurred where a young blue collar veteran could go on the GI bill, or alternatively get a unionized job at the factory, and buy a car and a house in the suburbs with a stay-at-home wife who took care of the kids whose college tuition was affordable, along with long-distance one week vacations every year, a solid pension etc. Some people even extended the term middle class to these people, which had previously meant professionals. Because they were living the lifestyle of middle class people. If anything is clear, it's the eradication over the past 40 years of the idea of extending the term middle class downward from professional households to those making less than $150k a year. This was the working class before World War II and it is the working class now. Even if nowadays it's banging out PHP code or putting Visual Basic widgets together or wiring Cisco switches together instead of going into the mines or soldering parts on an assembly line.
- hyperpape 12y agoFather of two, I have earned ~20,30,40k a year at various points in the past decade, then a good bit more. You are simply wrong. There are places below $50k where you might suffer from close to 100% marginal rates, which I view as an enormous problem, but it's not true at higher incomes. Even the 80% figure you quote sounds wrong (and of course I know I shouldn't believe you because you don't even pick a set of numbers and stick to it). Edit: I see elsewhere in the thread, it's clear that you're not really talking about income.
- zaroth 12y agoHow the CBO defines "income": Labor income includes cash wages and salaries, including amounts allocated by employees to 401(k) plans; employer-paid health insurance premiums; the employer’s share of payroll taxes for Social Security, Medicare, and federal unemployment insurance; and the share of corporate income taxes borne by workers (see Box 1)." [1] I see how bad the problem is, when we can't even agree what 'income' means. I've been mainly self-employed the last 5 years, and had years of near-$0 income, and other years, better, where I was also paying other employee W-2s and 1099s. Before that, I was W-2 from $50k up to one particularly good year where I max'd out FICA. I've also seen the process of applying for SSDI, SSI, Medi-Cal, food stamps, the whole gambit. Call me wrong, but please do me the favor of doing the math for yourself and let us follow along with your examples. I thought the $24k - $30k example was a great one. It's the reality for many Americans. I though the $100k example was also fairly straight-forward, minus the FICA confusion. I don't quite get why companies tend to hide all the payroll costs associated with a W-2 plus full benefits. If cost of an employee is $140k line item on the income statement, I tend to want them to know that, even if it's not all showing up in the direct deposit or on the paystub. I know exactly how much $0 deductible group health insurance costs in my zip code by age, and I know you can get that all for free by not working. Economically that is income you have to earn (value you have to create for the company) to make up for that loss of benefits. It doesn't come from the magical W-2 benefits fairy. All that money would be actual real income if you didn't lose your guaranteed free Medi-Cal (the best insurance money can't buy) by simply deciding to work full time. A rigorous financial analysis must count the totality of lost and forfeit benefits. I understand the inclination to bury one's head in the sand to avoid the realization that it's almost literally all-for-nothing but the enjoyment of doing good work. Once you actually get your head above water at around $100k+ of GROSS household income, and you actually see a little bit of real free cash flow, things improve rapidly. Up to that point, it's economically, almost entirely treadmill. The only reason to keep going is building experience and hopefully getting a raise till you finally crawl out of the hole. It's not too bad in the programming field, even a single breadwinner can get the family there, but statistically, most people will never emerge from the social welfare pit. [1]... "In its analyses of the distribution of income and taxes, the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) strives to measure income as broadly as possible and thus includes in income some items that people may not usually consider to be part of income. For example, CBO counts taxes paid by businesses as part of household before-tax income; because those taxes are ultimately borne by households in the form of reduced income, CBO adds them to before-tax income in order to measure more accurately what a household’s ability to consume would have been in the absence of those taxes." [2] CBO intentionally broke it's measure of government transfers after ACA, in their latest report, [because it just looked too bad otherwise] (emphasis added): "CBO recently undertook a more comprehensive analysis of the distribution of federal spending in 2006. Although that study used a similar methodology to the one used in this report, it differed in some important respects, most notably by adjusting the amount of transfer income reported in survey data to match the budgetary totals reported in the Treasury Department’s Monthly Treasury Statements. The data used in this report are not aligned to budgetary totals and, because of underreporting of transfer income in surveys, do not capture the full effects of government transfers on household income."