15 ms·
24-Bit vs. 16-Bit Audio Test – Part II: Results and Conclusions
- taeric 12y agoMore people really need to watch this video. http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml http://xiph.org/video/vid2.shtml
- imaginenore 12y agoWow, that video is awesome. It definitely corrected a few misconceptions I had in my head.
- ehPReth 12y agoThat video player is amazing! What is it?
- Hytosys 12y agoSeems to just be a browser-native <video> tag with an overlay that pretty simply controls the quality/time/subtitles. The logic for the controls is at video.js[1] and the logic for the subtitles is at subtitles.js[2] (check the `playSubtitles` function for VTT[3] decoding). All of the sources (the videos for each quality, and the VTT files for each subtitles track) are specified as HTML attributes in vid2.shtml, the linked page. In short, it was seemingly made in-house. [1] http://xiph.org/video/video.js http://xiph.org/video/video.js [2] http://xiph.org/video/subtitles.js http://xiph.org/video/subtitles.js [3] http://dev.w3.org/html5/webvtt/ http://dev.w3.org/html5/webvtt/
- drcode 12y agoWow, I haven't learned that much in 20 minutes in years! Too bad this new found wisdom has such limited application for anything I'm actively involved with.
- logicallee 12y agoWhat technologies do you work with, and of these, what would you enjoy a ten minute enlightenment on?
- Demiurge 12y agoI learned more from this about digital/analogue conversion than from my EE class that covered this topic!
- thunderbong 12y agoWow! Just amazing! I can't believe the amount of confusing science this video dispelled for me. This should be seen by everybody who think they know what a digital signal is.
- lisper 12y agoIs it just me, or is anyone else hearing something that sounds like wind noise over the narration? (It goes away when he plays sample sounds, and other audio on my system sounds normal.)
- vanderZwan 12y agoYou mean the "noisy fan" (as Monty calls it) of the signal generator?
- lisper 12y agoOh, is that what that is? Makes sense. Thanks.
- iLoch 12y agoI watched the full 20 minutes and have absolutely no idea what he was talking about for most of it. I did have that misconception about the stepping in digital signals though - so I did learn something!
- nitrogen 12y agoTry watching his other videos; I think there's one that is more introductory.
- agumonkey 12y agoxiph.org is like a MOOC without the name, spectacular pedagogical quality.
- robert_tweed 12y agoThis is such an awesome video. I really hope there's a follow-up at some point, because as someone with a decent amount of experience with computer graphics, but only a fairly general understanding of sampling theorem, the stuff that would naturally come next is what most interests me, namely: - What happens when you start combining waves together to create more complex signals? This is pretty important, since any real instrument produces hundreds of harmonics with complex attack and decay properties, so decomposition of the fundamental frequencies won't be as accurate as with toy examples. - Following on from that: the effects of aliasing. It definitely exists and I have a very good understanding of aliasing with respect to computer graphics, but what effect does aliasing really have on an audio signal? In CG it's something that's talked about all the time and there are tons of papers about it, but it seems (from the outside at least) that audio guys only ever talk about aliasing in very hand-wavy terms. - Although we can't hear sounds (much) above 20KHz, we can detect artefacts such as "beats" produced when harmonics are slightly mismatched. Is is possible to show that such information either isn't lost, or that what is lost is either below the noise floor or outside the audible frequency range? This particular one is a fairly common complaint made by audiophiles about 44KHz/Nyquist, so it would be nice to see it addressed head-on. FWIW, I'm a bit of an audiophile myself, but not one of those people who thinks they can hear a difference between 192kbps MP3 and uncompressed, let alone 16/44 vs 24/192. Generally the noise floor in the original recording is too high to tell the difference, even if you could hear a difference in artificially constructed pathological cases. But I am interested in really understanding what information is lost, what isn't, and why that may or may not make any difference. In other words, what are those pathological cases? This video is a really good start and clears up a lot, but in some ways it only scratches the surface.
- rspeer 12y agoI can point you to a follow-up on one of those: An example on Wikipedia [1] lets you hear the effect of aliasing on a sawtooth wave. When audio is aliased, the high harmonics will wrap around the Nyquist frequency and come back as audible, inharmonic tones. Aliased audio really sounds quite bad, in a way that would make any listener say "oh god make that horrible noise stop". This is probably why it's easier to recognize the effects of aliasing in video than in audio -- you're not hearing much aliased audio. Aliased video is fairly common and seen as acceptable in some contexts, while anyone who produces aliased audio is going to fix their mistake before inflicting it on listeners. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing#Online_audio_example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aliasing#Online_audio_example
- gfody 12y agoThe argument for mainstream 24bit dynamic range shouldn't be for higher fidelity reproduction for audiophiles. It should be for enabling more sophistication in our playback devices. In the YouTube era not every recording is perfectly mastered by audio engineers to fill the available range. And I could be listening on high end home theater equipment or the tiny speaker in my smart phone.
- laxatives 12y agoWhat about 24 bit enables "more sophistication in our playback devices". Doesn't sufficiently high fidelity mean you can already listen on your high end equipment?
- gfody 12y agoIt would allow our playback devices to correct poor quality source material without introducing distortions or clipping. All the same reasons why 24bit is preferred in the studio. Basically studio-quality post processing would be possible on any mainstream content resulting in higher fidelity ultimately. Also, if you consider mashup style content where people are producing derivatives based on already mastered material it would generally increase the quality of that material.
- q_no 12y agoThanks for sharing! I really enjoyed the video, though I didn't understand everything (english is not my mothertongue).
- falfour 12y agoThat was an awesome video, resulting in some follow up questions. Is it correct to say that lowering the bits increased the ground noise level, then why, (basically is quantization on the amplitude of the wave??)? If lowering the number bits still produces the same output wave as input wave what and where is the lower limit that changes the sound? Finally how is this 24 bit 16 bit related to my 128kbps mp3s?
- aidenn0 12y agoWith proper dithering, lowering the bits raises the noise floor. This is because dithering is approximately equal to changing the quantization error from something regular to something random. If you don't dither, then the quantization error will likely be something harmonic rather than the hiss you hear in that video. This is much more noticeable[1]. Lowering the number of bits produces the same wave, but with more error. Dithering ensures that the error is random noise, which is why you hear "tape hiss" in that video as the bits gets lowered. With a tone frequency chosen to maximize the harmonic quantization error and no dithering you would start to hear it. Lastly, 24 and 16 bit are largely unrelated to mp3s. In practice, mp3s are decoded to 16 bit audio, but they don't store the audio as PCM, but (roughly) rather as frequency/amplitude pairs which could in theory be decoded at any sample size. In any event, the absolute magnitude of error introduced by encoding a 128kbps mp3 is way, way, way larger than 16 bit quantization error, and the goal of the mp3 encoder is to find a way that is as inaudible as possible. MP3 is an old format at this point, so it does have audible defects in some types of music at even the maximum bitrate (certain percussive instruments are an issue). Vorbis and AAC work in some ways similar to mp3 but are strict improvements (though for the love of music, don't use the FAAC decoder, it's generally considered horrible). 1: Still not noticeable at 16-bit audio, as a similar test to the one in the article was done with no dithering on the 24 -> 16 bit conversion. at somewhere between 12 to 14 bits it would start to be discernible.
- falfour 12y agoAhh, a lots been cleared up but I don't understand "Lowering the number of bits produces the same wave, but with more error" If the wave is the same how can there be more error? and is quantization error caused by quantizing the steps in amplitude?
- gcb0 12y agocaveat: xiph works mainly promoting digital codecs. so... there is a reason they like you to think DAC (digital to analog converter) is a moot problem.
- woah 12y agoWhy are there so few women in the audiophile community? Do female audiophiles face the same adversities as women in tech?
- wyager 12y ago> Do female audiophiles face the same adversities as women in tech? How would that work? There isn't even any opportunity to be excluded from being an audiophile. It's the exact same thing that accounts for a lot of the discrepancy between men and women in professional tech: the fact that men, on average, like gadgets more than women.
- lentil_soup 12y agoI really doubt men like gadgets more than women per se, it's a social/cultural/education thing that leads them to move away from those interests.
- renaudg 12y agoNo it's not. http://www.livescience.com/22677-girls-dolls-boys-toy-trucks.html http://www.livescience.com/22677-girls-dolls-boys-toy-trucks...
- lmm 12y agoIt could simply be women having less disposable money?
- meowface 12y agoIs your second question independent or leading from the first? If the latter, then you realize that just because there is a lack of certain demographics in a group does not necessarily mean it is due to adversities, right? There could be countless reasons. As for what those reasons are, tech enthusiast communities of all sorts tend to be predominantly male. I don't think it's anything particular to audio. I agree that I was a bit surprised at how overwhelmingly male the sample was, though.
- spopejoy 12y ago
- S_A_P 12y agoI'm really glad there have been more audio related posts on HN lately. Maybe it's just my own bias, but seems that print/online media related to audio is dying off and is now limited to forums and hobbiest sites now. The few that are still around are difficult to take seriously with some of the snake oil that gets reviewed. (Carbon fiber disc stabilizers anyone?) I would love to see a serious attempt at an enthusiast "magazine" done again...
- thirdsun 12y agoI agree - audio technology, music production tools and of course music itself have always been topics of interest for me. However there's a whole jungle of misconceptions half-knowledge to browse through before you find good content. For audio production tools and other related niche topics, I can recommend createdigitalmusic.com
- retrogradeorbit 12y agoTry repeating the experiment without the dither.
- spankalee 12y agoThat would allow the subject to easily tell the difference between the two samples by looking to see which had all 0's in the 4 lowest bits.
- hackinthebochs 12y agoDithering is known to increase the perceived dynamic range of music. As an example try listening to a song in foobar in 8bit output mode then 8bit dithered.
- retrogradeorbit 12y agoThis makes no sense to me. Please explain. The difference between 24 and 16 is 8, not 4 for one. Are you saying the "16-bit" sample files actually had noise added to the least significant 4 (8?) bits? This is not dithering. Dithering is adding noise BEFORE truncation. A dithered 16 bit rendering of 24 bit audio will only be 16 bit. An undithered 16 bit rendering of 24 bit audio will also only be 16 bit.
- mng2 12y agoI think the GP is basically saying, how would you propose to run an internet survey asking anonymous audiophiles to blindly A/B (no peeking at the bits) full and truncated files? The dithering is probably the least questionable part of the methodology.
- thrownaway2424 12y agoAre you also a fan of non-oversampling DACs?
- retrogradeorbit 12y agoI'm a fan of good sounding DACs. By dithering you increase the perceived dynamic range. You change it from a listening test of the quality of the sound, to the character of the noise floor. Maybe this is why some "engineers" could tell. If you are trained in what to listen for you would know in these listening tests to completely ignore the majority of the sound and frequency range, and instead listen to the sound of the high frequency hiss on the noise floor (for instance in very quiet or completely silent sections. Just isolate a very quiet part and turn it up loud). This would be the tell tale sign of the dithering, thus 16 bit.
- xlayn 12y agoIt's all about obsesive compulsive. I count myself on that group... I bought every recommended pair of headphones promising more and more magic but one day you come to notice that it's just a sound equalizer and some people like it some way... some other. so 192kbps 44khz and mdrv6 to a 30$ player; that's it.
- gcb0 12y agonot really. headphones range a lot within the frequencies you DO hear. also, the weight vs outside sound isolation ratio varies with price. those are all observable and measurable things. speakers, they also vary on those audible frequencies, but after you are past $150 per speaker you are only dealing with quality after very loud volumes. over $3000 for a home system? just be honest with yourself and confess you are buying the prettiest furniture that match your decor.
- skelsey 12y agoYeah, if you are going to spend money, spend it on the reproduction side. A nice set of speakers will make you feel like you've never heard a song before.
- jbergens 12y agoIt's actually very easy to hear different speakers have different quality in prices much higher than $150, even at moderate sound levels. Just go to a store and try it out (especially compare a $150 speaker with a speaker for $1500).
- ChrisGranger 12y ago> speakers, they also vary on those audible frequencies, but after you are past $150 per speaker you are only dealing with quality after very loud volumes. This is simply not true, and you could determine that for yourself easily if you wanted to. There are many, many factors that affect how a loudspeaker sounds besides how loudly it's playing. $150 speakers are much better today than they were say 30 or 40 years ago, but they're still full of design compromises.
- shmerl 12y agoThis was posted here before, but it's a great article if anyone still didn't read it yet: https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/neil-young.html
- ChrisGranger 12y agoAs I said in the other recent 24-bit audio thread, any improvement in sound quality offered by using 24-bit will be inaudible for the vast majority of listeners, the extra low-level detail of the increased dynamic range lost in the noise floor of a typical room.
- steven2012 12y agoYou mean it's inaudible for ALL the listeners. There is no subset of listeners that would be able to tell the difference between 24-bit and 16-bit listener with any type of statistical significance.
- ChrisGranger 12y agoDownvoted for saying "vast majority" instead of ALL? Sigh. For ALL the listeners in this specific test? Yes, almost certainly. Naturally, just randomly picking a song, even one that subjectively sounds really good, and listening to 16-bit or 24-bit versions of it at moderate volume in a typical room will absolutely prevent anyone from choosing correctly with any statistical significance. The OP's test was doomed to fail from the outset. That doesn't mean it's impossible to detect any difference under any circumstances.
- hvidgaard 12y ago16bit gives you an effective dynamic range of 120dB - noone, and I challenge to to prove me wrong, can detect differences beyond that. To quote from the last articel, that is enough to record the difference between a jackhammer and a mosquito in the same room.
- retrogradeorbit 12y ago> that is enough to record the difference between a jackhammer and a mosquito in the same room. That is utterly laughable. Stated like someone who has never actually tried to record sounds with large dynamic range. But I suppose it's how you define "record". So if a mosquito is 40dBA, and a jackhammer is 130dBA, that's a difference of 90dB. Now I don't know of any preamp that has such a low noise floor, but assuming one existed, if we set the gain staging such that the jackhammer is 0dBFS, then the mosquito is peaking at -90dBFS. Thats 6dB above null, or ONE BIT. So your "recording" of the mosquito is one bit flipping on and off. Quite the recording! Statements like these are what make recording engineers roll their eyes and think here we go again. > 16bit gives you an effective dynamic range of 120dB 16 bit gives you 96dB of dynamic range. And less than that of usable dynamic range. You may say "effectively" as is, once dithered, but then you're accepting that the recording is done at a higher bit depth and then dithered down, thus refuting the original statement that 16 bits is enough dynamic range to record said sounds.
- TheOtherHobbes 12y agoSlight problem - DXD is not PCM. It's downsampled DSD, which isn't a true PCM format and is of debatable value in a bit-depth test. DSD uses single-bit delta-sigma modulation at a very high sample rate. You have to downconvert it before you can hear it, and this adds noise/dither/distortion. One of the problems with DSD is that it's not entirely clear what useful bit-depth you're left with after downsampling, because there are theoretical reasons for criticising one-bit sampling. See e.g. http://sjeng.org/ftp/SACD.pdf http://sjeng.org/ftp/SACD.pdf A useful test would start with high quality unmastered and unprocessed 24-bit PCM recordings and A/B them with 16-bit downconversions. (Remember, even orchestral recordings are mixed in a studio and the individual stems usually have some dynamic processing and gain riding, even if it's not as obvious as dance music pumping.) I'd expect a test like this to use a bit meter like Bitter to confirm there's useful information in the lower bits, and not just rely on a vague estimate of the dynamic range. http://www.stillwellaudio.com/plugins/bitter/ http://www.stillwellaudio.com/plugins/bitter/ Ironically, all of the reviews of the Bozza track say that the BluRay audio version sounds cleaner than the SACD source used here. (I have no idea if this is true. But if someone has both and wants to do a blind A/B, that would be interesting.) It's also worth mentioning there are easy-to-find test tones you can use to check how clean your audio hardware is at extreme sample rates. They're not directly relevant to bit-depth tests, but they're a good torture test for audio. http://www.audiocheck.net/testtones_highdefinitionaudio.php http://www.audiocheck.net/testtones_highdefinitionaudio.php
- hvidgaard 12y agoIt doesn't make sense that it is unmastered. We want to test the difference of a properly made 24 bit output downsampled to 16 bit and the original. There is difference between 16, 24, and 32 bit recordings, but it just so happens that 16 bits are enough to give an effective 120dB dynamic range, if you use proper dithering. If you do not want to use dithering "because it's not pure", you still have 96dB of dynamic range. So with dithering 16 bit allow you to represent a mosquito and a jackhammer in the same room. And even without (and that isn't a good idea, as the noise now consist of harmonic distortion which is a lot easier to hear than dithered noise) I really doubt anyone can tell the difference, 96dB is still quite a bit.
- 12y ago
- Derbasti 12y agoSome confidence intervals for the hypothesis would be really handy. Still, great article!
- antonios 12y ago> Furthermore, 20% used an ABX utility in the evaluation process suggesting good effort in trying to discern sonic differences. Take those results with a (large) grain of salt.
- chronial 12y agoDoesn’t matter - the respondents didn’t know which sample is which.
- stefantalpalaru 12y ago> biological gender This is getting ridiculous. Just call it "sex" already.
- kmike84 12y agoI think the conclusion ("there was no evidence that 24-bit audio could be appreciably differentiated from the same music dithered down to 16-bits") is not correct. EDIT: I'm not sure if the conclusion is correct or not, but the logic that lead to the conclusion has flaws. 50%/50% accuracy means a random guess - people can't distinguish 24-bit from 16-bit. But if accuracy is less than 50% for a large enough sample it means the difference between 24-bit and 16-bit is heard. Article said: "As a subgroup (total of 31 respondents), the self identified respondents with a "good amount" of musical background did not do well. In fact, this group of respondents consistently scored worse than the combined result." People with persumably better ears ("musicians" and "hardware reviewers") were less accurate than regular people, especially on Vivaldi. I think this means they did well. This means they heard the difference - it is not possible to be significantly less accurate than 50% without hearing a difference. They failed on deciding which one is "better", but they were able to differentiate 16-bit music from 24-bit.
- svantana 12y agoBut the article itself states that this difference was not statistically significant, and should therefore be attributed to randomness?
- kmike84 12y agoThe article does state that the difference is statistically significant: "Curiously, the musician group seemed to select the 16-bit dithered Vivaldi as the "better" sounding version (p-value 0.047)."
- ZoFreX 12y agoI'm not convinced it is, though. If you take a sample of 140 people and divide it into a dozen different cohorts, it's pretty likely that one of those groups will show a difference that would be statistically significant if observed across the whole sample.
- Steuard 12y agoHow many individual comparisons were made throughout the article? A dozen? Two? You'd expect a p-value less than 0.05 by chance about one time in 20, and indeed this p-value is just marginally below that threshold. I wouldn't view this one result as particularly significant in that context.
- Joeboy 12y agoWhat I would like to know is: Is there any individual human who can reliably distinguish between 16 and 24 bit audio? If somebody believes they can, where can I send them to establish whether it's true or not?
- throwawayaway 12y agoyou can hear the difference between summing 16 channels of 24bit audio vs. 16bit audio in a daw. 24 sounds better. then when you render it, you can't tell the difference between a 16bit dump and a 24bit dump. i think the recent aphex twin release was out on 24bit and 16bit, it would be a great test subject matter for the foobar abx plugin. with all types of music, you can train your ear to listen for what mp3 hiccups on. i know nothing about classic music, but i can spot a 320kbps mp3 a mile off due to terrible sounding high hats and crashes in genres where they are prominent. disco records also suffer very badly, just something about how they were recorded. i wouldn't know what to listen for in classical.
- swift 12y agoHigh hats and crashes are exactly the thing I noticed improved when switching my music from MP3 to FLAC many years ago. The difference is very obvious to me; I really don't think it's placebo. That said, I've heard that AAC handles them much better, and that modern MP3 encoders do a better job. I haven't had a chance to do an A/B test to check that. I'd love to confirm that AAC has solved this problem, because my music collection is taking up way more space than I'd like!
- emn13 12y agoTry opus. I was amazed how good that sounds at ridiculously low bitrates. I'd be surprised if you can tell the difference between 80kpbs opus and FLAC (i.e. raw) files outside certainly very rare corner cases. And unlike mp3, those corner cases don't sound terrible, though that's subjective. Even at 64kbps the difference wasn't obvious without careful listening - to me, YMMV :-). If you do try it, make sure to use the 1.1 encoder (which deals with difficult samples by detecting that and upping the bitrate more aggressively than previous versions), and you might as well increase the maximum framesize the maximum (60ms) since you're not interested in low-latency applications.
- r721 12y agoDiscussion of this test at hydrogenaud.io: http://www.hydrogenaud.io/forums/index.php?showtopic=106156 http://www.hydrogenaud.io/forums/index.php?showtopic=106156
- casion 12y agoI'd like to point out the potentially non-obvious here. This is a test of delivery format. There still are benefits to using 24-bit audio in the recording and processing stages. This is in large part due to most recording systems expecting 0dbVU = -18dbFS and the subsequent processing that can bring the noise floor well into the audible range (dynamic range processors are notoriously effective at this, and heavily used in modern music). We could take a simple example of a snare drum being recorded at 16bit, being EQ'd with a +6db boost anywhere on the spectrum, then compressed with a reduction peaking around 10db (not uncommon). After brickwall limiting in the final mix, this track will easily have a noise floor (via quantization error only) > -68dbFS best case. (-96db starting. -12dbFs peaking snare, +6 + 10 to noise floor, assuming limiting with no gain reduction) -68dbFS is already audible in a critical listening scenario. With dozens (sometimes hundreds) of uncorrelated signals being subjected to similar processing, this noise floor raises well into the audible range for even a modest playback system. While I realize that delivery format is the only thing important to most people, it is important to differentiate since the article does make a point to separate out musicians, sound engineers and hardware reviewers. These are groups of people that _should_ be aware of the benefits of higher sample resolution. Since it's fairly obvious that most people in these categories are confused about their ability to discern delivery formats, it's not beneficial to confuse them even further about working formats. To be more succinct, the difference between 16bit and 24bit is largely inaudible when the source material is worked in a higher resolution format and properly converted.
- mankyd 12y ago> These are groups of people that _should_ be aware of the benefits of higher sample resolution. I don't think the author is necessarily dismissing the idea of high fidelity audio; especially for the reasons you point out. Rather, the author is claiming that if you're simply _listening_ to the playback, it won't make a bit of difference, regardless of how your ears are trained. Edit: Also note that several of the respondents were really confident that they heard a difference. This small study demonstrates that their confidence was misplaced. This, I believe, is what the author is trying to drive home.
- shmerl 12y agoThat's true. But I understood this as talking about playback, not about mastering. The article linked below makes this distinction more clearly: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8727591 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8727591
- keenerd 12y agoShoot, most people won't be able to tell 8 bit audio from 16 bit audio. Try the following: sox highres.flac --bits 8 lowres.wav dither Wave is required because flac doesn't do 8 bit and we want to be 100% certain nothing sneaky is going on. You might be able to notice a slight increase in background hiss if you are in a very quiet room.
- casion 12y agoThat background hiss IS the difference. I'm not sure what you think the difference would be otherwise, but the increase in the noise floor caused by quantization error will be the difference between the formats. I also don't know what 'lowres.wav' is (is this linked in the article?), but on classical or jazz recordings the difference is very noticeable due to the lower 'average' amplitude of the recordings. If you did this on a modern pop recording that's smashed to hell and back... then yeah, many people won't even notice the noise.
- keenerd 12y agoNo, most think that if you reduce something to 8 bits that it will sound like NES-powered voice mail being played back through a piezo buzzer. If you converted something to 8 bits and used proper dithering, no one who heard it would exclaim "You monster! That is only 8 bit audio!" Where as if you reduced something to a low bitrate mp3, people would notice immediately and call you out on it.
- casion 12y agoThat is an issue. People don't understand what bit-depth reduction sounds like. That doesn't change the fact that the hiss is the difference. That is the quantization noise floor, and the primary artifact of the conversion. Rather than try to goad people into thinking that there is no difference, it is better to educate them on what the difference actually is (or could be). From there an honest interaction can be had regarding the potential perception of these differences. Quite simply, just because some people are misinformed about what qualitative effect is occurring, that does not discount the fact that there is a qualitative effect occurring.
- mark-r 12y agoPerhaps the 16-bit sample really did sound better in some cases? The lowest bits of a D/A converter are the most non-linear. By avoiding them you might get a more accurate waveform overall. This would explain the people who were confident that they knew which was which, even when they got it consistently wrong. It would depend greatly on the specific D/A converter so you'd expect it to go both ways.
- cnvogel 12y agoSorry, but no! 1.0 1.1 1.9 2.0 2.1 2.9 3.0 is still a better approximation of a linearly increasing list of numbers than 1.0 1.0 2.0 2.0 2.0 3.0 3.0 and I doubt that any 24bit DAC or ADC in existence will interpolate as bad as I did in this example. Whatever distortion due to quantisation the latter creates, the former will create less of it.
- emn13 12y agoNotably, with such a small sample size and multiple testing, it's to be expected to see small deviations in preference such as the one in the article. The article mentions p=0.28, which isn't entirely easy to interpret given that he doesn't quite explain what that p value is actually measuring (did he correct for multiple testing, for instance?), but it's certainly not a claim of any meaningful significance.
- mark-r 12y agoYour example is overly simplistic. Dithering is what allows a low bit sample to emulate a high bit one, and I don't see any evidence that you applied any; even if you did you wouldn't get a feel for how it operates with such a short sample.
- cnvogel 12y agoThe initial statement was: "lowest bits of a D/A converter are the most non-linear. By avoiding them you might get a more accurate waveform overall." You can of course apply dithering to any signal to mask quantization noise. It's just that a perfect N-bit DAC will require less dithering to mask its quantization distortion/noise than a non-perfect/not-quite-linear N-bit DAC which again will introduce less quantization distortion/noise than the (N-k) bit DAC. In fact, you could say that a N-bit DAC is just "perfect reproduction" plus a non-linearity that amounts to the step-width of 1-LSB, e.g. it's resolution. And a 24-bit DAC that unfortunately is off by 8 LSB (2^3) along its 0...2^N-1 to 0V..Uref curve is still as good or better as a 21-bit DAC (24bit-3bit) in reproducing a waveform, and still better than a 16 bit DAC. A graphical representation of this is commonly found in datasheets and called "integrated non-linearity."
- Zigurd 12y agoQuality reports on audio depend, as far as I know, entirely on conscious reporting of quality that's accessible to a test subject through introspection. By definition, this makes it easy to debunk "golden ears." Because loudness (energy) determines what we pay attention to in sound, this is why sonic detail that's low in energy compared to the total can be dropped without test subjects being able to report the missing information. And maybe this is valid. If we can't report our experiences, are they really experiences? But I find this unsatisfactory if only from the point of view of experimental design. Does the brain really throw this information away at a low level? Does our ear "compress" audition on the way to other parts of the brain? Or does our subconscious experience uncompressed music differently?
- vitoreiji 12y agoWhile the conclusion is in accordance with what I would expect, I think the study suffers a lot from not having a control group. From these results, there is no telling if participants screwed up in replay, or if they were all just guessing anyway or whatever. This should be redone with at least one sample pair where one of the samples is deliberately reduced in quality is delivered to a subset of the participants.
- mark-r 12y agoThere's a lot of great data here, and the author obviously tried to cover all of the bases. Unfortunately I'm still bothered by a couple of aspects. Firstly, the question of "can you hear a difference" is completely orthogonal to the question of "which do you think is 24 bit". By using the answer to the second question to infer an answer to the first, you're entangling them. If someone could reliably hear the difference but on half the songs they preferred 16 bit and on the other half preferred 24 bit, their own answers would cancel each other out. Secondly, all it takes is ONE PERSON who can reliably tell the difference [1] to prove that the difference is audible, even if it's only to a very small subset of the population. The test was structured to detect the abilities of a group, not a single person. I'm perfectly willing to believe that as a group, people on average can't tell a difference, but that doesn't tell me whether I can tell a difference. [1] Reliably telling the difference would mean being consistent on double-blind A/B testing, repeated enough times to achieve statistical significance.