21 ms·
When I was a fifteen year old "internet marketer" I was able to create 60,000 google accounts from residential IP's, despite google's CAPTCHA system. As a fifte
by chatmasta 12y ago
When I was a fifteen year old "internet marketer" I was able to create 60,000 google accounts from residential IP's, despite google's CAPTCHA system. As a fifteen year old kid, that's when I knew google is not an invincible company.
The trick was that google's backend registration logic did not validate the referrer of the signup form, or that the submitting IP address matched the one that downloaded the CAPTCHA. So I cloned the form on my own server, loaded it in an invisible iFrame with all fields filled except the CAPTCHA. Then I served the CAPTCHA to the user, who solved it and clicked "submit". Then the entire hidden form in the iframe submitted and registered a google account with the visitor's IP.
I was surprised that worked, because it was a huge vulnerability. Nowadays I would go for the bug bounty, but back then I tried to sell it for $5k -- unfortunately nobody believed I could do it and I couldn't prove it without revealing the method, so I ended up unable to take advantage of the code.
I did have about 60k accounts from random page views on blogspot blogs, but I never did anything with them. Perhaps that was the only time my inability to finish projects ironically saved me from some trouble. :)
- timboslice 12y agoI remember seeing you post something about this back in the day (maybe on WF?) good times :-P
- neo_optimus 12y agoWhat is (was?) WF?
- us0r 12y agoWickedFire
- chii 12y agoheh, you could've made some distributed service using google appengine, and take full advantage of the free tier ;)
- chatmasta 12y agohmmmmm a litecoin miner perhaps?
- cinquemb 12y agoYou probably wouldn't have got in much trouble, just a c&d and probably asked to fork over some money from your profits and sign a contract with google that youll never do it again (And "your" account on google disabled"). ;) At least thats what happend with me and my friend when we mined about 1/10th of users from facebook, and crowdsourced a bunch of info from people, made it public, (we had an psudeoanonmyous no login messaging feature where people would literally share informaion that would make people question what privacy is when n-1 people are divulging everything about you) from searching names. If I wasn't a US citizen, id probably do it better now that i know more of what im up against. Maybe the landscape might be more open in the US in the future. People moan on and on about facebook and companies like them as if they are all powerfull (they can seem that way if you play by their rules and submit to their jurisdiction for pragmatic reasons), but challenging those assumptions and leveraging user behaviors, and arbitraging legalities, one can probably crack some pretty big holes...