6 ms·
Something similar happens when riding motorcycles. At first you're cautious because you don't know how to evaluate the risks. Then you move into a peak of overc
by barrkel 12y ago
Something similar happens when riding motorcycles. At first you're cautious because you don't know how to evaluate the risks. Then you move into a peak of overconfidence where the usual risks are known; but this is the most dangerous period. It's only after a while at this level, perhaps after a few scares or accidents, that a new appreciation for unusual risks starts to come in. You start to become less optimistic, and consider what could go wrong, not just what's likely to go wrong. You start actively seeking reasons for the traffic around you to do the unexpected.
Mature evaluation of risks increases the weighting given to tail events, black swans etc., particularly if the outcome is severe. Teaching this perspective ought to be effective in keeping it in mind for the teacher too.
- jbrooksuk 12y agoMy Dad - who used to drive an Ambulance then Fire Engines (for about 20 years) - taught me to drive and use something called "Defensive Driving Techniques". Where most people look at one or two cars ahead and hopefully the one behind, my Dad taught me to look at every car that I can see, using every gap, window, mirror etc to be aware of my surroundings. Look at people, bus stops, crossings, shops in towns etc. He also suggested that rather than just looking at a car, you look at the position of the car, who's driving, the age, have I seen them drive weirdly yet? This way you can build up a much better mental model of how they're going to react to something. This has saved me numerous times where I've judged what a car will do just by how they're placed in the road, even if they look like they may do something else to a normal driver. It's a technique that I've shown to my girlfriend and it's changed her driving (for the better) and what I'll be teaching my kids when the time comes.
- umairsiddique 12y agoThat's how you drive in third world countries.
- sk5t 12y agoIt's the right way to drive anywhere hundreds of barely-trained primates are distractedly operating heavy equipment at high speed...
- CraigJPerry 12y agoThat's a kind of brute force approach. It seems sub optimal but I don't know how to reason about it. Should I say that observing every vehicle across the median on the oncoming carriageway is inefficient? Well I can't say that because occasionally some small cargo or even a wheel falls off and bounds across to the oncoming lane - something you definitely want to see coming. Perhaps taking a zonal approach is as effective and certainly less taxing on the driver. Scan each zone, some zones get scanned more frequently, and look for anything unusual.
- Jtsummers 12y agoDefensive driving is really just a specific application of situational awareness [0]. With practice and experience you'll go from just maintaining visibility and space for reaction time to actually remembering where drivers are that have been blocked from your view by other vehicles. You never really track every vehicle and pedestrian, but you do make note of particular ones and the rest get lumped into groups based on their behavior. You'll learn to anticipate the car that's going to make a left turn in front of you by taking your foot off the throttle earlier instead of braking at the last second. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Situation_awareness http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Situation_awareness
- gretful 12y agoyou're talking about chunking: at first you try to remember everything, then as you gain experience you learn you can abstract certain items away to a general model of them (chunk) without having to remember the specifics of each individual item.
- jerf 12y ago"That's a kind of brute force approach. It seems sub optimal but I don't know how to reason about it." Well, what else are you doing while driving? For the most part, whatever your answer is to that question, stop it. (Reasonable exceptions apply; conversation with another in the car isn't too big a deal, of course.) Now that you're just driving and not doing anything else, you might as well be active about it and be on the lookout for long-tail risks, since really long-tail risks are all you ever have to worry about. Driving is fairly safe and almost everything that ever happens bad is long-tail in the first place or we wouldn't drive.
- 1123581321 12y agoI use that technique, and during a period in which I commuted, my meditations on cars taught me to use the same principles of thorough research and prediction to analyze stocks, which worked out well. It can also apply to understanding a room of people or a crowd. Those are all situations where overconfidence can be worse than overcaution. I think defensive driving is a good way to introduce that kind of prudence to people who would otherwise not pay close attention to things because piloting an auto is frightening at first so makes a person receptive to whatever makes them safer and gives them confidence.
- frogpelt 12y agoI've heard Defensive Driving described as driving with the assumption that someone else is going to do something wrong, and to be in a position to defend yourself from that eventuality. The opposite is to drive Offensively (ha ha) which I guess is to assume that every other car will do the right thing and it's okay if I take a few risks.
- jbrooksuk 12y agoI wouldn't say that at all since you're not assuming people are going to do something wrong per-se, you're more willing to accept that a situation that looks normal is going to turn out differently and be aware of how you can avoid any driver who's going to do that stupid thing.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Raphmedia 12y agoI drive with the assumption that everyone else is drunk. Most friday night around here, it is true. In the morning, I drive with the assumption that everyone is half blind and too aged to drive. I work next to an eye clinic, so this is also true. Drive like everyone else is a fool and you should make it back home safe.
- ahjones 12y agoI learnt these techniques from the IAM [0] in the UK. Their manual is Roadcraft - the Police Driver's Handbook [1] which introduces techniques which I've found incredibly valuable. [0]: http://www.iam.org.uk/ http://www.iam.org.uk/ [1]: http://www.amazon.com/Roadcraft-Police-Drivers-Handbook-Foundation-ebook/dp/B00O8SQ446/ http://www.amazon.com/Roadcraft-Police-Drivers-Handbook-Foun...
- mabbo 12y agoEven beyond that, there's an overall 'field' of cars for me. Peripheral vision gets an overall sense of all cars in the proverbial neighborhood, and looks for scary patterns. Little things that seem harmless (and maybe are) put me on edge and make me guard my brake. My wife didn't understand at first, but after 12 years of driving with zero accidents, it becomes apparent that it works.
- jessaustin 12y ago...look at every car that I can see, using every gap, window, mirror etc to be aware of my surroundings. Look at people, bus stops, crossings, shops in towns etc. In my experience a shortcut to this level of awareness is to regularly cycle in commuting traffic. Not only does one notice much more, but one also notices the classes of things that it's actually impossible to notice from an autocage. (Examples: what most drivers are doing in addition to driving, where pedestrians are hiding, how a line of traffic moves through signals in fits and starts, etc.)
- jbrooksuk 12y agoI cycled 150 miles for charity once, you soon pick up on extra things - having been knocked before.
- draven 12y agoWhen I got my motorcycle license I was told that the probability of an accident happening increases a lot after 6 months / 3000 km (~2000 miles) due to the recently gained confidence. I have no idea if those stats are even remotely correct but it made sense at the time.
- lazyant 12y agoI think the idea applies to cars as well, fwii the worst year for car accidents is the 2nd year after getting a licence (1st year being the worst), at least in some countries (can't remember where this is from)
- angersock 12y agoI've noticed that some curve in software engineering and systems administration, at least from people who are trying to be serious. At first, everything is new and scary, so they'll ask for help with even basic things, and maybe keep meticulous notes or comments about what they're doing. Later, after they've gotten more and more comfortable, they'll stop keeping good notes and asking for help. Finally, after being bitten in the ass a few times, they'll start to regard all computer systems as being in active conspiracy to make their life and their code miserable, and at last they'll finally have the correct mindset to get quality work done.
- Fuzzwah 12y agoI came to make a similar comment regarding my hobby; skydiving. I've been falling out of planes for over 20 years, and have seen the equipment progress in design and function such that people don't die due to the same things which used to claim skydivers. However the yearly rate of death remains about the same. The dark joke is that as the sport has gotten safer people have had to come up with new, more stupid ways to die. Smarter people than me point to the theory of risk homeostasis. Basically, you accept a level of risk of an activity, if the safety of this act increases you'll find new ways to make it as risky as it was previously. https://www.google.com/search?q=risk+homeostasis https://www.google.com/search?q=risk+homeostasis In skydiving this is jumping smaller and smaller canopies (aka parachutes), swooping, base jumping, big way formations, aggressive angle flying, etc.
- pointernil 12y agoNot as dramatic as skydiving but when paragliding we had the saying: "There are old pilots and then there are brave pilots." ;)
- sliverstorm 12y agoThe original form I heard that one: There are old pilots and there are bold pilots. There are no old, bold pilots.
- pointernil 12y agoYup that's it. I was remembering AND translating ;) Thanks
- RyJones 12y agoAlso true for private pilots. People between 40 and 100 hours are pretty good, but from 100+ there is a rise in overconfidence. More people need to read the "I learned about flying from that" series of books, which is a collection of columns.
- liquidcool 12y agoWhat about the overall risk on a motorcycle? I have two friends who were killed on motorcycles. Both were experienced, in neither case was it their fault, and I'm not sure if they could have avoided it. Seems unlikely. But what I do know is that if they were driving their cars, they would be alive today. I find people often correctly evaluate the risk of failure (low), but completely ignore the potential cost (your life) . I'm guessing they also have a different model for calculating reward, but it seems mostly an error in calculating risk and cost. BTW, these were IT guys in their 30s, not teenagers.
- chadgeidel 12y agoCertainly riding a motorcycle is risky. Lots of things people do for fun have very large downsides (death or otherwise). Some of us feel the risk is worth the reward. I totally understand if you don't agree. In terms of experience - I see a LOT of experienced motorcycle riders that have "1 year of experience 10 times". I'm not saying that I'm a better rider than other experienced riders, however motorcycle riding is something that requires constant discipline (moreso than other forms of transportation that people generally do). edit: Please don't take this comment as any indication of your friends experience. I'm speaking in generalities.
- ggreer 12y agoJust how dangerous do motorcycles have to be before the fun isn't worth the risk? Twice as dangerous as cars? 5 times? Maybe 10x? Surely not 20 times more dangerous? From Wikipedia's article on Motorcycle Safety: Per vehicle mile traveled, motorcyclists' risk of a fatal crash is 35 times greater than a passenger car. Motorcycles are insanely dangerous. There are 23 fatalities per 100 million miles ridden in the US. If you ride 4,000 miles a year for 40 years, that gives you just over a 4% chance of dying. Compare to a 0.1% chance for doing the same in a car. And that's just the risk of death. It doesn't include risk of paralysis, brain damage, or losing a limb. Even if you are a perfect rider, half of all fatal motorcycle accidents are collisions with cars. Many of those simply cannot be avoided. People would rightly call you insane for driving a car that had 35x more fatalities than average. I fail to see how removing two wheels makes it OK. (Note: I've been riding for seven years and had no accidents. There are some good reasons for riding a motorcycle, but they don't involve recreation.)